INPEX Operations Australia Pty Ltd v AkzoNobel NV (No 3)

Link copied
Case Copied 52 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

INPEX Operations Australia Pty Ltd v AkzoNobel NV (No 3) [2024] FCA 1221

File numbers: WAD 162 of 2021
Judgment of: BANKS-SMITH J
Date of judgment: 22 October 2024
Catchwords: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE - whether applicants should be permitted to cross-examine deponents of affidavits relating to discovery regime - discovery proceeded according to categories - relevant previously undiscovered documents produced during 11-week liability trial - trial steps still pending - continuing obligations of parties and lawyers in relation to discovery - whether leave required to cross-examine deponents - leave not required - cross‑examination permitted having regard to particular circumstances
Legislation:

Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) Schedule 2 (Australian Consumer Law) s 18

Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) s 27

Federal Court Act of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) ss 37M, 37N

Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) rr 20.14, 20.15, 20.21, 20.22

Cases cited:

Clifton (Liquidator) v Kerry J Investment Pty Ltd trading as Clenergy [2020] FCAFC 5

Dale v Clayton Utz (a firm) [2012] VSC 577

Guy Carpenter & Company Pty Ltd v Grove (No 2) [2011] FCA 1190

INPEX Operations Australia Pty Ltd v AkzoNobel NV [2023] FCA 382

IO Group Inc v Prestige Club Australasia Pty Ltd [2008] FCA 1147

Kuhl v Zurich Financial Services Australia Ltd [2011] HCA 11; (2011) 243 CLR 361

Lantrak Holdings Pty Ltd v Yammine [2023] FCAFC 156

Mango Boulevard Pty Ltd v Spencer [2008] QCA 274

Marsden v Amalgamated Television Services Pty Ltd [2000] NSWSC 66

Olympic Airways SA v Spiros Alysandratos & Consolidated Travel (Vic) Pty Ltd (unreported, Supreme Court of Victoria, 26 May 1997)

Procter v Kalivis [2009] FCA 1518

Re Summit Hotel Bondi Beach Pty Ltd [2023] NSWSC 295

Selvaratnam v St George - A Division of Westpac Banking Corporation (No 2) [2021] FCA 486

Sivwright v St Ives Group Pty Ltd (No 3) [2024] FCA 833

Talacko v Talacko (No 2) [2009] VSC 444; (2009) 25 VR 613

Voxson Pty Ltd v Telstra Corporation Limited (No 10) [2018] FCA 376

Watson v Kriticos (Further Discovery and Adjournment) [2023] FCA 793

Wu v Avin Operations Pty Ltd (No 3) [2006] FCA 1321

Division: General Division
Registry: Western Australia
National Practice Area: Commercial and Corporations
Sub-area: Regulator and Consumer Protection
Number of paragraphs: 117
Date of hearing: 16 October 2024
Counsel for the Applicants: Mr JJ Gleeson KC, Ms G Crafti SC and Ms EE Bateman
Solicitor for the Applicants: Corrs Chambers Westgarth
Counsel for the Respondents: Mr BW Walker SC and Mr N Kirby
Solicitor for the Respondents: Clayton Utz
Counsel for the Cross‑Claimants: Mr BW Walker SC and Mr N Kirby
Solicitor for the Cross‑Claimants: Clayton Utz
Counsel for the First and Second Cross-Respondents: Mr JJ Gleeson KC, Ms G Crafti SC and Ms EE Bateman
Solicitor for the First and Second Cross-Respondents: Corrs Chambers Westgarth
Counsel for the Third Cross‑Respondent: The third cross-respondent did not appear

ORDERS

WAD 162 of 2021
BETWEEN:

INPEX OPERATIONS AUSTRALIA PTY LTD

First Applicant

ICHTHYS…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read INPEX Operations Australia Pty Ltd v AkzoNobel NV (No 3) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] FCA 1221
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case INPEX Operations Australia Pty Ltd v AkzoNobel NV (No 3) concerns an application by INPEX to cross-examine the deponents of affidavits filed by ANIP in relation to the discovery process in the ongoing litigation over the degradation of the Intertherm 228 protective coating product used in the Ichthys LNG Gas Field Onshore Project. The primary issue before the court was whether INPEX should be permitted to cross-examine the deponents of affidavits filed by ANIP, given that the discovery process had proceeded according to categories, and relevant previously undiscovered documents had been produced during the 11-week liability trial. The court had to determine whether leave was required for such cross-examination and, if so, whether it should be granted given the unique circumstances of the case.

The court reasoned that, although cross-examination of affidavit deponents is generally not permitted during the interlocutory discovery phase, there are exceptions where it is necessary to ensure a fair trial. The court noted that the discovery process in this case had been extensive and ongoing, with numerous requests and contested categories that had evolved over several years. The late discovery of relevant documents and the differing interpretations of the discovery categories by the parties highlighted the need for clarity and fairness in the discovery process. The court concluded that cross-examination was necessary to test the explanations provided by the deponents and to ensure that all pleaded issues between the parties were tried fairly. The court emphasized that its decision was not based on any assumption of inappropriate conduct by the deponents but rather on the need to prevent any party from gaining a forensic advantage through inadequate disclosure or ambiguous explanations.

The court granted INPEX's application to cross-examine the deponents of the affidavits, noting that such cross-examination would be tightly controlled and limited to the issues raised in the application. The court ordered that cross-examination of Mr Timothy Donisi, Dr Sarah McCague, and Ms Marni Lancaster would be permitted and scheduled the hearing for 30 October 2024. The parties were directed to confer and approach chambers to address the timing of the hearing and any other practical matters. Costs were reserved for further determination.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The applicant is permitted to cross-examine each of:

(a) Mr Timothy Donisi, deponent of affidavits dated 16 January 2024,

27 March 2024 and 28 August 2024;

(b) Dr Sarah McCague, deponent of affidavits dated 15 January 2024 and 18 April 2024; and

(c) Ms Marni Lancaster, deponent of affidavits dated 12 June 2024 and 16 August 2024.

2. Subject to further order, a hearing for the purpose of the cross-examination is listed for 30 October 2024.

3. The parties to confer and approach Chambers in relation to the timing of the hearing and any other practical matters that arise.

4. Costs reserved.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

This application relates to whether INPEX should be permitted to cross‑examine deponents of affidavits relating to discovery. Whilst I have decided to allow the application, its circumstances are unusual.Background This action, referred to as the INPEX action, is being heard concurrently with WAD 448 of 2017, referred to as the JKC action. In accordance with an ongoing convention in the proceedings, I will refer to the parties as INPEX, JKC and ANIP. ANIP is the respondent in both actions. Each of INPEX and JKC pursue ANIP in relation to the supply and use of a protective coating product known as Intertherm 228 (I228) on piping and equipment used in the Ichthys LNG Gas Field Onshore Project at Bladin Point, Darwin. The I228 has degraded. The cost of rectification is said to be in the billions of dollars. Which party should bear that cost is in issue. It is not necessary to set out any further details in these reasons, as there are a number of interlocutory judgments in the respective proceedings that already do so. Some will be referred to below. In terms of the trial architecture, the questions of liability and quantum are to be determined by a liability trial (which proceeded over the course of some 11 weeks from 17 June 2024), a reference of specified quantum issues to a referee which is to proceed in November 2024, and a hearing to consider the adoption of the referee's report scheduled for May 2025. Judgment on liability and quantum will not be delivered until sometime after the adoption hearing. Although the liability trial is largely complete, at the date of the hearing of this application there remain some discrete matters to be addressed on a small number of allocated hearing days in October 2024 and November 2024, including potential further oral closing submissions and evidence from a further witness. Further written closing submissions remain to be filed. The parties continued to request and produce documents during the trial. Issues with discovery were raised during the course of the trial. Relevantly, a number of affidavits were filed on behalf of ANIP during the trial that purported to respond to some of those issues. The intention to cross-examine the deponents was anticipated during the trial. Senior counsel for INPEX made its position expressly clear during oral closing submissions and there were discussions at that time about programming this hearing and the filing of respective submissions. This context is important. This is not a standard pre-trial self‑contained interlocutory application, where time may permit various options to be explored ahead of trial. It is brought during the closing stages of a long and complex liability trial and in relation to continuing disclosure obligations.Discovery regime There has been mutual non-standard discovery in this action and the JKC action by way of exchange of lengthy Redfern schedules that incorporate categories, with rulings made by the Court as required. Having regard to r 20.15 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth), it was agreed by the parties that the criteria in r 20.14 apply to the discovery to be given by the parties. The formal discovery process, insofar as the JKC action is concerned, commenced by at least November 2018, with the first orders addressing contested categories made on 18 January 2019. There were two subsequent Redfern schedules provided. The Court made a number of other detailed rulings and discovery orders. The formal discovery regime in the INPEX action commenced by at least February 2022 with the exchange of Redfern schedules. Orders for discovery by categories were made in May 2022. Rulings and orders on contested categories were made in May 2023 by reference to an INPEX Combined Redfern Schedule (INPEX Operations Australia Pty Ltd v AkzoNobel NV [2023] FCA 382).

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

If affidavits are filed, they are of course open to scrutiny. Further, when a deponent of an affidavit provides it, they know or should know there is a risk that they will be cross-examined, even if, for whatever reason, they do not consider that prospect to be likely.Evidence relates to interlocutory discovery processes Further, I consider it is artificial to proceed on the basis that there was some freestanding interlocutory process for discovery that at some point was concluded, leaving the parties to proceed with their trial preparation. A simple model such as this might represent the manner in which smaller disputes or disputes pre-electronic records might have proceeded. That is not this case. The Redfern schedule process, rolling requests for discovery, applications for further discovery and further contested requests for production continued over the course of many years. Indeed, such contested requests and responses have continued in parallel to the running of the trial. The parties did not bring a separate interlocutory application every time there was a discovery issue, but rather continued to respond and react and seek Court assistance from time to time. All parties have been on notice of their ongoing obligations of discovery. Therefore, I do not approach this task on the basis that the deponents' affidavits were filed in response to interlocutory applications that were forensically exhausted. Nor was it suggested that the deponents were trial witnesses (by either INPEX or ANIP). Rather, the deponents have provided evidence in relation to discovery. Having provided it, they may be cross-examined. Any cross-examination would be undertaken in the context of discovery being an interlocutory process, rather than a trial, and would be controlled. It does not follow that the deponents' evidence will be irrelevant when it comes to questions of inferences that might be drawn from discovery processes. How such evidence is deployed remains to be seen, as Mr Gleeson has foreshadowed. But that is not the central point of this application. The central point of this application, to adopt what was said in MangoBoulevard, is to ensure that all the pleaded issues between the parties are tried fairly. And to adopt what was said in Olympic Airways, an injustice might be done if documents of relevance to the proceeding do exist but are not discovered. The Court will be assisted in guarding against the risk of such injustice by permitting cross-examination. A party cannot be permitted to gain a forensic advantage by failing to give proper disclosure, nor by giving ambiguous, incomplete or artificially-confined explanations for any such failure or the absence or destruction of documents without the capacity for the explanations to be tested. Cross‑examination is the manner by which such explanations might be tested.Mr Donisi INPEX seeks to cross-examine Mr Donisi on his affidavits in relation to questions they expose about the manner in which Clayton Utz, together with Deloitte, searched for, organised and reviewed certain documents, particularly in the context of discovery by categories and search terms. The questions arise primarily by reference to the examples of the Ward Letter and the PCLR report, but relate more generally to the late discovery referred to at [25]-[33] above.

Decision

Reasons for decision

I observe that Ms Lancaster does not address the non-availability of Ms Muller's email mailbox in her evidence. This is not surprising as this email mailbox was not covered by the court order pursuant to which her affidavit was filed. I note this because although INPEX has raised the issue relating to Ms Muller, it is not clear whether INPEX assumes it might therefore cross‑examine Ms Lancaster about it. This can be addressed should it arise in due course. Otherwise, I also observe that no submissions were made in relation to Lancaster 2 (which addressed separate discovery) and I proceed on the basis that the issues upon which INPEX seek to cross‑examine Ms Lancaster are those that arise from Lancaster 1.Conclusion My decision to permit cross-examination is not premised on any view or assumption as to any inappropriate conduct by the deponents of the affidavits. I have not formed such views or made any such assumptions. Indeed, there are indications that aspects of the process have been undertaken conscientiously and (unsurprisingly) involved the allocation of enormous resources, in terms of people and time. What I am concerned about is ensuring that INPEX is able to fairly put its case and fairly address ANIP's defence. Accordingly, there will be orders that permit each of Mr Donisi, Dr McCague and Ms Lancaster to be cross-examined.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

I note these by way of example. Mr Donisi is not a trial witness. Cross-examination relating to an interlocutory process (such as discovery) is more strictly controlled than during a trial and, where permitted, tends to be limited to the issues of the application: Marsden v Amalgamated Television Services Pty Ltd [2000] NSWSC 66 (Levine J). Permitting cross‑examination would not provide an opportunity for free-range cross-examination on any matter in issue. Mr Gleeson acknowledged this to be the position.Consideration Collecting all of these matters and having regard to the centrality of attribution and the PDS/cure to the outcome of this high stakes proceeding, questions properly arise from Mr Donisi's affidavits which persuade me that there are reasonable grounds for being fairly certain that there are other relevant documents. The respective responses to the Ward letter are telling. It is apparent that Corrs and Clayton Utz (or their respective clients) have taken a different approach to the interpretation or scope of certain discovery categories. This reveals that ANIP apparently does not consider that it has any overarching obligation to disclose documents that it accepts are relevant following the January 2024 amendment unless such documents fall within its interpretation of the previously determined categories. It also exposes a significant issue that exists more generally with discovery by categories. In this context Mr Walker referred to the 'lamented abolition of Peruvian Guano' and I am sure he is not alone in that view. Categories can be counterproductive, and as this experience indicates, important documents relevant to facts in issue may be shielded from production through ambiguous or uncertain drafting or a lack of knowledge as to the type of documents that may exist and should be requested. No doubt standard discovery may also serve to obscure relevant documents in an avalanche of data. It is unsurprising that in a dispute of this scope the parties considered that the most efficient method by which to proceed was by categories. However, that approach brings with it the need to revise, refine and reconsider, particularly as issues evolve or pleadings are amended. Further, it is inevitable that in these reasons I would refer to the recognised obligations of parties and their lawyers having regard to s 37M and s 37N of the Federal Court Act of Australia Act 1976 (Cth). Such obligations also inform the approach to discovery. If this application were not being considered virtually at the end of the liability trial, in light of Donisi 3 and Donisi 4 I might have directed the parties to reconsider the categories in line with the final pleaded positions and to also reconsider if there were additional search terms that should be applied across different repositories of documents. I might have made detailed orders about further and better discovery and the provision of further specific affidavits. However, I am concerned, having regard to the numerous lengthy exchanges of correspondence in evidence on such matters between the parties' solicitors both prior to and during the trial, that such a course would now have very little prospect of efficiently resolving the questions raised by ANIP's discovery.