Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Birubi Art Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 70 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Birubi Art Pty Ltd [2018] FCA 1595

File number: NSD 425 of 2018
Judge: PERRY J
Date of judgment:

23 October 2018

Catchwords: 

CONSUMER LAW – whether respondent wholesaler engaged in conduct likely or liable to mislead or deceive potential purchasers by implying that five product lines were hand painted, or made, by an Aboriginal person and/or were made in Australia – where the place of origin of the products, Indonesia, was not disclosed– where all but one product line comprised objects of cultural significance to Aboriginal peoples – where no dispute as to the literal truth of express representations – scope of the surrounding circumstances to be taken into account in determining whether false or misleading representations were made –whether surrounding circumstances includes the way the products were presented in retail outlets by third parties, the characteristics of other products for sale in those outlets, and the products’ price placement vis a vis other products - where implied false or misleading representations upheld – finding that all the products breached s 18 and subs 29(1)(a) and (k), Australian Consumer Law – finding that boxed boomerangs, didgeridoos and message stones breached s 33 of the Australian Consumer Law

CONSUMER LAW – discussion of the principles applicable to ss 19, 29 and 33 of the Australian Consumer Law – discussion of the principles applicable to implied representations

CONSUMER LAW – identification of class of persons to whom the implied representations were made – where class included international tourists, interstate tourists, and those seeking to purchase a gift – where international tourists may have a low degree of familiarity with the Aboriginal art and cultural practices but would recognise the association between such objects and their artwork, symbols and designs, on the one hand, and Aboriginal art and culture, on the other hand

EVIDENCE – whether contextual evidence of the retail environment in which the products sold admissible –  where ACCC submitted context was confined to the products themselves, together with the images and representations made on the products and their packaging – where respondent had no control over manner in which products presented by retailers – whether evidence sufficient to establish the price differential and other aspects of the retail environment relied upon by the respondent

Legislation:

Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth)

Evidence Act1995 (Cth)

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth)

Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth)

Cases cited:

Astway Pty Ltd v Council of the City of the Gold Coast [2008] QCA 73

.au Domain Administration Ltd v Domain Names Australia Pty Ltd [2004] FCA 424

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission vColes Supermarkets Australia Pty Ltd [2014] FCA 634; (2014) 317 ALR 73

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union [2008] FCA 678

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Dell Computers Pty Ltd [2002] FCA 847

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Homeopathy Plus [2014] FCA 1412; (2014) 146 ALD…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Birubi Art... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] FCA 1595
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) brought an action against Birubi Art Pty Ltd, a wholesaler, for alleged misleading or deceptive conduct under the Australian Consumer Law (ACL). The dispute centered on whether Birubi engaged in conduct that misled consumers by implying that certain product lines were hand painted, or made, by Aboriginal people and/or were made in Australia when the products were actually manufactured in Indonesia. The court was required to determine the scope of the surrounding circumstances to be considered in assessing whether false or misleading representations were made and whether these circumstances included the way the products were presented by third-party retailers, the characteristics of other products for sale, and the products' price placement relative to other products.

The court found that the surrounding circumstances could include the manner in which the products were presented in retail outlets by third parties, the characteristics of other products for sale in those outlets, and the products' price placement vis-a-vis other products. It was held that all the products breached section 18 and subsection 29(1)(a) and (k) of the ACL, while the boxed boomerangs, didgeridoos and message stones breached section 33 of the ACL. The court concluded that it was likely that a reasonable consumer would be misled into thinking that the products were hand painted by Aboriginal persons and were made in Australia. This finding was made despite the absence of a direct dispute as to the literal truth of the express representations.

The court allowed the application for declaratory relief in part and directed the parties to file and serve an outline of written submissions on the terms of the declaratory relief proposed. The matter was listed for case management for the second stage of the trial, and the parties were directed to endeavour to agree on the terms of the declaratory relief in the first instance.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application for declaratory relief is allowed in part.

2. In the absence of agreement as to the terms of the declaratory relief to be granted in order to give effect to these reasons, on or before 4 pm on Tuesday, 30 October 2018 the parties are to file and serve an outline of written submissions not exceeding 5 pages in length in support of the terms of the declaratory relief proposed and indicating whether or not a further hearing is requested or they are content for the terms of the declaratory relief to be determined on the papers.

3. The matter is listed for case management for the second stage of the trial at 9.30 am on Wednesday, 7 November 2018.

4. There by liberty to apply on 48 hours’ notice.

THE COURT NOTES THAT:

5. The parties are to endeavour in the first instance to agree the terms of declaratory relief which otherwise give effect to these reasons.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Birubi Art Pty Ltd is a wholesaler of a range of products including loose boomerangs, boxed boomerangs, bullroarers, didgeridoos, and message stones. These products, while made in Indonesia, were marketed and sold with representations that implied they were hand painted and made by Aboriginal persons in Australia. The Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) initiated proceedings against Birubi, alleging that the representations made by Birubi regarding the products were misleading and deceptive in contravention of sections 18, 29(1)(a), and 29(1)(k) of the Australian Consumer Law (ACL). The ACCC further alleged that the boxed boomerangs, didgeridoos, and message stones breached section 33 of the ACL, which pertains to false or misleading representations about the geographical origin of goods.

The products in question, with the exception of the bullroarer, are objects of cultural significance to Aboriginal peoples. Despite no dispute regarding the literal truth of the express representations, Birubi's conduct was scrutinised for its potential to mislead consumers about the cultural and geographical origins of the products. The case hinged on whether the representations made by Birubi, through the products themselves and their packaging, were misleading or deceptive, and if the surrounding circumstances, including the retail environment where the products were sold, were relevant in determining the misleading nature of these representations.

The matter came before the Federal Court of Australia as an application for declaratory relief by the ACCC against Birubi Art Pty Ltd. The ACCC sought a declaration that Birubi's conduct, through the representations made about the products, breached sections 18, 29(1)(a), 29(1)(k), and 33 of the ACL. The case involved several submissions and objections, particularly regarding the admissibility of evidence about the retail environment where the products were sold. The court had to determine whether contextual evidence of the retail environment, such as photographs of products for sale, prices, and store setups, was admissible to establish the price differential and other aspects of the retail environment that might influence consumer perceptions.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The ACCC submitted that the evidence was irrelevant on two grounds, namely: the photographs were not of outlets to which any of the Products in question had been supplied during the relevant period; and the photographs were taken outside the relevant period. It is true there was no evidence that Mak3 Gifts or the Spirit of Australia Gallery stocked any of the Products in question in the relevant period. That notwithstanding, there was no challenge to Mr Moore’s evidence that the outlets stocked Birubi products as at 30 May 2018. In my view, while of limited use, the evidence is nonetheless indicative of some of the types of Outlets to which the Products in issue here were supplied and the types of products which they displayed for sale, and can be admitted for those purposes. 2.4 Ruling on the admissibility of Mr Moore’s contextual evidence in his second affidavit In his second affidavit, Mr Moore gave evidence that on a visit to Darwin on or about 22 to 23 June 2018, he and Mr Wooster also visited the Mason Galleries, NT Souvenirs and Darwin Souvenirs. Mr Moore took photographs of the products for sale, prices and the store setup at each of those retailers’ premises. These photographs were annexed to his second affidavit, together with a table explaining what the photographs depicted. In order to meet certain objections filed by the ACCC in advance of the hearing, Mr Wooster sought and was granted leave to file and serve his affidavit sworn on 29 August 2018 to identify those photographs annexed to Mr Moore’s affidavits which depicted examples of the Products the subject of these proceedings. However, the ACCC maintained its objection to Mr Moore’s second affidavit on other grounds. It was not in issue that during the relevant period, Birubi sold the bamboo didgeridoos to Darwin Souvenirs, bullroarers to the Mason Gallery, and boxed boomerangs and message stones to NT Souvenirs. However, in the ACCC’s submission, the photographs were still irrelevant because they depicted the store premises outside the relevant period and there was no evidence linking those photographs to the store setup and stock during the relevant period. In this regard, the ACCC placed emphasis upon the fact that it would have been open to Birubi to call evidence to address this gap from the shopkeepers themselves or, more importantly, from Mr Wooster given his evidence that he regularly visited the stores stocking his product lines and would observe how the stores presented his product lines during those visits. Against this, Birubi submitted that evidence of each of the store premises and set up was admissible, despite the photographs having been taken after the relevant period. In support of that submission, counsel for Birubi relied by analogy upon the decision of the Queensland Court of Appeal in Astway Pty Ltd v Council of the City of the Gold Coast [2008] QCA 73. In that case, the appellant sought a declaration that the respondent Council no longer required land within seven years of its compulsory acquisition for the purpose for which it was acquired thereby enlivening a statutory obligation to offer the land for sale to the former owner. In support of that claim, the appellant objected to what it characterised as “retrospectant” evidence, being documentary evidence relating to the Council’s actions and decisions after the expiry of the relevant seven-year period. Justice Atkinson (with whose reasons Holmes JA agreed at [1]) held that the retrospectant evidence was admissible, being “a type of circumstantial evidence in which the subsequent occurrence of an act, state of mind or state of affairs justifies an inference that the act was done, or that the state of mind or affairs previously existed.” (at [43]). However Atkinson J also observed that “such evidence may need to be treated with some circumspection in terms of the weight attached to it: see Melchior v Cattanach [2001] QCA 246 at [136]; R v N [2006] VSCA 111 at [37].”

Decision

Reasons for decision

As such, I consider that it is not only “likely” (in the sense of a real risk for the purposes of ss 18 and 29), but “liable” (in the sense of a greater than 50% probability for the purposes of s 33) that a reasonable member of the class would be misled into thinking that the message stone was hand painted by a person of Aboriginal ethnicity. I also consider that it is likely that such a person would infer that the message stone was made in Australia. 9. CONCLUSION For the reasons given above including the matters conceded by Birubi (as set out in particular at [7]-[11] and [33] above), in my view Birubi, by representing in trade and commerce during the relevant period to consumers that the loose boomerangs, boxed boomerangs, bullroarers, didgeridoos and message stones were hand painted by Australian Aboriginal persons, engaged in misleading or deceptive conduct in breach of s 18 and subs 29(1)(a) of the ACL. As to the latter, the implied representation that the Products were hand painted by Australian Aboriginal persons was a false or misleading representation that they were of a particular style or had a particular history. I also consider that Birubi engaged in conduct that was “liable” (in the sense of more likely than not) to mislead the public into inferring that the boxed boomerangs, didgeridoos and message stones were hand painted by Australian Aboriginal persons in contravention of s 33 of the ACL, but do not consider that any breach of s 33 with respect to the loose boomerangs and bullroarers has been established. Furthermore, during the relevant period, by representing to consumers that the loose boomerangs, boxed boomerangs, bullroarers, didgeridoos and message stones were made in Australia, Birubi, in trade or commerce, engaged in conduct that was misleading or deceptive, or likely to mislead or deceive, in contravention of s 18 of the ACL; and made false or misleading representations concerning the place of origin of goods in connection with the supply or possible supply of goods, or the promotion of the supply of goods, in contravention of subs 29(1)(k) of the ACL. As requested by Birubi, I will afford the parties the opportunity to be heard as to the terms of the declaratory relief to be awarded.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the respondent wholesaler's conduct concerning the implication that certain products were hand painted or made by an Aboriginal person and/or made in Australia, without disclosing the true place of origin. The court held that it was likely or liable that a reasonable member of the public would be misled into inferring these representations. The decision hinged on the implied representations made by the respondent wholesaler, rather than any express representations. The court considered the broader context in which the products were presented, including the way they were displayed in retail outlets and their price placement relative to other products, in determining whether the representations were false or misleading.

The court applied the principles of consumer law as outlined in sections 18, 19, 29, and 33 of the Australian Consumer Law. It focused on the implied representations made to the class of consumers, which included international and interstate tourists, and those seeking to purchase a gift. The court found that these consumers, particularly international tourists, might associate certain objects with Aboriginal art and culture, leading them to infer the products were made by Aboriginal persons and in Australia.

The court also addressed the admissibility of contextual evidence of the retail environment in which the products were sold. Despite objections from the ACCC, the court admitted evidence of the retail environment, considering it indicative of how the products were presented and sold during the relevant period. This evidence supported the conclusion that the products were likely to mislead consumers about their origin and the involvement of Aboriginal persons in their creation.

The binding legal principle established in this case is that when determining whether misleading or deceptive conduct has occurred under the Australian Consumer Law, the court must consider not only the express representations made but also the broader context in which the products are presented, including their display in retail environments and their price relative to other products. This decision underscores the importance of implied representations in assessing consumer protection claims and the necessity of considering the retail environment in determining the likelihood of consumer deception.