Trade Practices Commission v J & R Enterprises Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 77 min read

Re: TRADE PRACTICES COMMISSION
And: J. AND R. ENTERPRISES PTY. LTD. and JANET ROSE ROWDEN
Nos. G125 to 127, 129, 130, 132 to 138, 140 to 142 and 145 of 1989
FED No. 23
Trade Practices
99 ALR 325

COURT

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA


SOUTH AUSTRALIAN DISTRICT REGISTRY
GENERAL DIVISION
O'Loughlin J.(1)
CATCHWORDS

Trade Practices - Prosecutions for breaches of the provisions of Part V of the Trade Practices Act - the corporate defendant (aided and abetted by its principal officer) offered advertising services in an advertising scheme at a time when it knew that it could not, with any degree of commercial realism, assure the supply of the advertising scheme - S55A - meaning of "public" considered - "liable to mislead" - consideration of the use of the word "liable" in s.55A and the word "likely" in s.52 - held that "liable" means that the Crown must prove an actual probability that the public would be misled.

HEARING

ADELAIDE

#DATE 8:2:1991

Counsel for applicant: Mr G. Hackett-Jones QC Mr M. Loftus

Solicitor for Applicant: Director of Public Prosecutions

Counsel for Mrs. Rowden: Mr G. Hemsley

Solicitors for Mrs. Rowden: White Berman and Co.

ORDER

That the defendant J and R Enterprises Pty. Ltd. be convicted of the following contraventions of paragraph 79(1)(a) of the Trade Practices Act 1974 ("the Act") that is to say:-

1.1 The breach of s.55A of the Act as specified in the Information laid in Action No. G138 of 1989 1.2 The breach of paragraph 53(c) of the Act as specified in the Information laid in Action No. G135 of 1989 1.3 The breach of paragraph 53(g) of the Act as specified in the Information laid in Action No. G136 of 1989 1.4 The breach of paragraph 53(g) of the Act as specified in the Information laid in Action No. G134 of 1989 1.5 The breach of paragraph 58(b) of the Act as specified in the Information laid in Action No. G137 of 1989 1.6 The breach of paragraph 58(b) of the Act as specified in the Information laid in Action No. G142 of 1989

That the defendant J and R Enterprises Pty Ltd. be acquitted of the following charges relating to the alleged contraventions of paragraph 79(1)(a) of the Act that is to say:-

2.1 The alleged breach of paragraph 53(e) of the Act as specified in the Information laid in Action No. G141 of 1989 2.2 The alleged breach of paragraph 53(e) of the Act as specified in the Information laid in Action No. G140 of 1989

That the defendant Janet Rose Rowden be convicted of the following contraventions of paragraph 79(1)(b) of the Act, that is to say:-

3.1 The breach of s.55A of the Act as specified in the Information laid in Action No. G132 of 1989 3.2 The breach of paragraph 53(c) of the Act as specified in the Information laid in Action No. G133 of 1989 3.3 The breach of paragraph 58(b) of the Act as specified…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Trade Practices Commission v J & R Enterprises Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1991] FCA 23
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Trade Practices Commission brought an action against J & R Enterprises Pty Ltd and Janet Rose Rowden in the Federal Court. The defendants were accused of various breaches of the Trade Practices Act 1974, including misleading conduct under s.55A and s.52. The primary issue before the court was the interpretation of the term "liable to mislead" in s.55A of the Act, and how it compared to the term "likely to mislead" in s.52. The court had to determine whether the Crown needed to prove an actual probability or merely a likelihood of misleading the public to secure a conviction under s.55A.

The court held that the term "liable" in s.55A of the Act required the Crown to prove an actual probability that the public would be misled. This was a higher threshold than that required under s.52, where the term "likely" was used. The court found that the defendants had engaged in misleading conduct, as they had offered advertising services in an advertising scheme while knowing they could not assure the supply of these services. This constituted a breach of s.55A, as well as other provisions of the Act. Janet Rose Rowden was also found guilty of aiding and abetting the misleading conduct.

In light of the findings, the court convicted J & R Enterprises Pty Ltd of several breaches of the Trade Practices Act, including the offer of advertising services without the ability to supply them, which misled the public. The court acquitted the defendants of certain charges relating to alleged contraventions. Similarly, Janet Rose Rowden was convicted of aiding and abetting the misleading conduct but acquitted of other charges. The court's decision clarified the threshold for proving misleading conduct under s.55A and emphasised the importance of commercial certainty in advertising practices.

Orders

Orders of the court

That the defendant J and R Enterprises Pty. Ltd. be convicted of the following contraventions of paragraph 79(1)(a) of the Trade Practices Act 1974 ("the Act") that is to say:-

1.1 The breach of s.55A of the Act as specified in the Information laid in Action No. G138 of 1989 1.2 The breach of paragraph 53(c) of the Act as specified in the Information laid in Action No. G135 of 1989 1.3 The breach of paragraph 53(g) of the Act as specified in the Information laid in Action No. G136 of 1989 1.4 The breach of paragraph 53(g) of the Act as specified in the Information laid in Action No. G134 of 1989 1.5 The breach of paragraph 58(b) of the Act as specified in the Information laid in Action No. G137 of 1989 1.6 The breach of paragraph 58(b) of the Act as specified in the Information laid in Action No. G142 of 1989

That the defendant J and R Enterprises Pty Ltd. be acquitted of the following charges relating to the alleged contraventions of paragraph 79(1)(a) of the Act that is to say:-

2.1 The alleged breach of paragraph 53(e) of the Act as specified in the Information laid in Action No. G141 of 1989 2.2 The alleged breach of paragraph 53(e) of the Act as specified in the Information laid in Action No. G140 of 1989

That the defendant Janet Rose Rowden be convicted of the following contraventions of paragraph 79(1)(b) of the Act, that is to say:-

3.1 The breach of s.55A of the Act as specified in the Information laid in Action No. G132 of 1989 3.2 The breach of paragraph 53(c) of the Act as specified in the Information laid in Action No. G133 of 1989 3.3 The breach of paragraph 58(b) of the Act as specified in the Information laid in Action No. G127/89 3.4 The breach of paragraph 58(b) of the Act as specified in the Information laid in Action No. G130/89

That the defendant Janet Rose Rowden be acquitted of the following charges relating to the alleged contraventions of paragraph 79(1)(b) of the Act that is to say:-

4.1 The alleged breach of paragraph 53(g) of the Act as specified in the Information laid in Action No. G125 of 1989 4.2 The alleged breach of paragraph 53(g) of the Act as specified in the Information laid in Action No. G129/89 4.3 The alleged breach of paragraph 53(e) of the Act as specified in the Information laid in Action No. G126 of 1989 4.4 The alleged breach of paragraph 53(e) of the Act as specified in the Information laid in Action No. G145 of 1989

Note: Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.