FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Emerald Ocean Distributors Pty Ltd [2006] FCA 244
TRADE PRACTICES – misleading and deceptive conduct – certain Slendertone products as existed in 2000 – orders following delivery of reasons for judgement – findings of fact appropriately in orders – no basis to include declarations not going to offending conduct – appropriateness of injunctions in absence of undertakings – inactivity of business not outweigh public interest in orders – limited possible effect on third party not preclude corrective orders
Acts Interpretation Act 1901 (Cth) s 8
Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) ss 51A, 80A, 83, 86C, 86C(2)(b), 86C(4), 87, 87(1A)
Federal Court Act 1976 (Cth) s 21Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v 4WD Systems Pty Ltd (2003) 200 ALR 491
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Australian Safeway Stores Pty Limited (No 2) [2003] FCAFC 163
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Danoz Direct Pty Ltd (2003) 60 IPR 296
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Dell Computers Pty Ltd (2002) ATPR 41-878
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Emerald Ocean Distributors Pty Ltd [2004] FCA 303
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Emerald Ocean Distributors Pty Ltd [2005] FCA 1703
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Hartwich [2002] FCA 273
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Health Partners Inc (1997) 151 ALR 662
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v International Technology Holdings Pty Ltd (1997) 37 IPR 573
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Real Estate Institute of WA Inc (1999) 95 FCR 114
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v The Tasmanian Salmonid Growers Association Ltd [2003] FCA 788
Hospital Contribution Fund of Australia Ltd v Switzerland Australia Health Fund Pty Ltd (1987) 78 ALR 483
Medibank Private Ltd v Cassidy (2002) 124 FCR 40
Mundine v Layton Taylor Promotions Pty Ltd (1981) ATPR 40-211
Trade Practices Commission v Santos Limited [1993] ATPR 41-221AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION AND CONSUMER COMMISSION v EMERALD OCEAN DISTRIBUTORS PTY LTD, SLENDERTONE HEALTH AND BEAUTY PTY LTD and SEAN O’DONOGHUE
WAD 118 of 2000NICHOLSON J
17 MARCH 2006
PERTH
IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY
WAD 118 OF 2000
BETWEEN:
AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION AND CONSUMER COMMISSION
APPLICANTAND:
AND:
AND:
EMERALD OCEAN DISTRIBUTORS PTY LTD
(ACN 074 316 304)
FIRST RESPONDENTSLENDERTONE HEALTH AND BEAUTY PTY LTD
(ACN 059 362 542)
SECOND RESPONDENTSEAN O'DONOGHUE
THIRD RESPONDENTEMERALD OCEAN DISTRIBUTORS PTY LTD
(ACN 074 316 304)
FIRST CROSS-CLAIMANTSLENDERTONE HEALTH AND BEAUTY PTY LTD
(ACN 059 362 542)
SECOND CROSS-CLAIMANTSEAN O'DONOGHUE
THIRD CROSS-CLAIMANTBIO-MEDICAL RESEARCH LIMITED
CROSS-RESPONDENTJUDGE:
NICHOLSON J
DATE OF ORDER:
17 MARCH 2006
WHERE MADE:
PERTH
THE COURT ORDERS THAT:
FOR THE PURPOSE OF s 83 OF THE TRADE PRACTICES ACT 1974 (CTH), THE COURT MAKES THE FOLLOWING FINDINGS OF FACT AGAINST THE FIRST, SECOND AND THIRD RESPONDENTS:
1.The first and second respondents (‘Emerald Ocean’ and ‘Slendertone’ respectively), acting through their common sole director, secretary and member, the third respondent (‘Mr O’Donoghue’), were engaged in…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Emerald Oce... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2006] FCA 244
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court was tasked with determining the appropriate scope and form of the declarations and injunctions sought by the ACCC, as well as the costs to be borne by the parties. The legal issues included whether the declarations should be unqualified given the court's findings, and whether the injunctions were necessary given the cessation of the business activities that led to the ACCC's action. The respondents argued that the orders should reflect the court's findings that some representations were not misleading, and that the injunctions were unnecessary as the business activities had ceased.
The court held that the purpose of the orders was to resolve the legal controversy at hand, and since the court had already found that certain representations were misleading, it was appropriate for the declarations to be unqualified. The court also found that the injunctions were necessary to prevent future misleading conduct. The court accepted the ACCC's proposed orders and rejected the respondents' contentions regarding the form of the orders. The court further ruled that the respondents were to pay the majority of the ACCC's costs, while the cross-claimants were to bear their own costs unless a special costs order was sought.
Orders
Orders of the court
8. Each of Emerald Ocean and Slendertone themselves, and their respective servants or agents, in trade or commerce, in connection with the supply or promotion of the Slendertone Products, or any of them, be restrained for a period of 3 years from representing that the Slendertone Products, or any of them, have the following or similar performance characteristics, uses or benefits without also specifying with equal prominence that, ‘To obtain full benefit or result from the use of this product it must be used in conjunction with a healthy diet and regular exercise’:
(a) tone any part of a user’s body without exercise;
(b) tighten the user’s stomach or improve the strength of the user’s abdominal muscles;
(c) shape and lift the user’s body;
(d) reduce the user’s waist measurements;
(e) improve the user’s posture; or
(f) toning or tightening the user’s thighs.
9. Each of Emerald Ocean and Slendertone themselves, and their respective servants or agents, in trade or commerce, in connection with the supply or promotion of the Slendertone Products, or any of them, be restrained for a period of 3 years from representing that the Slendertone Products or any of them have the following or similar performance characteristics, uses or benefits:
(a) giving the user in 40 minutes per day the equivalent of 300 general exercises;
(b) contracting and relaxing the user’s muscles in 40 minutes use in a manner equivalent to the user performing sit-ups;
(c) giving the user strong visible abdominal muscles in 3 weeks;
(d) giving the benefit of performing 180 sit-ups in just 30 minutes;
(e) gaining a perfectly toned figure without exercise;
(f) completely removing, smoothing away, banishing, dispersing or effectively treating cellulite or ‘orange peel’ skin;
(g) shaping the user’s muscles;
(h) giving a user of the product the benefit of a work-out without having to exercise;
(i) making the user toned within 3-4 weeks;
(j) markedly reducing the user’s body measurements in only 3 weeks;
(k) giving the user the benefit of performing 180 sit-ups in just 30 minutes; or
(l) achieves results in approximately 8 weeks.
10. Mr O’Donoghue, for a period of 3 years, whether by himself, his servants or agents or otherwise howsoever, be restrained from aiding, abetting, counselling or procuring or being in any way directly or indirectly knowingly concerned in or a party to conduct, by Emerald Ocean, Slendertone or any other corporation, of the same or substantially similar nature to the conduct described in paragraphs 8 and 9 above.
11. Emerald Ocean, Slendertone and Mr O’Donoghue at their own expense shall:
(a) within 28 days of the date of this order, cause to be published an advertisement in terms of Sch A to these orders, in the following publications;
(i) Women’s Health magazine;
(ii) Ultrafit magazine;
(iii) The Australian newspaper; and
(iv) The West Australian newspaper
and Emerald Ocean, Slendertone and Mr O’Donoghue shall use their best endeavours to ensure that such advertisements:
(v) are within the first 10 pages of the magazines and the first 20 pages of the newspapers;
(vi) are of a size not less than 120 mm x 80 mm;
(vii) are in a text which is in a type not less than 10 points; and
(viii) include the logo of Slendertone as appearing in Sch A.
(b) within 14 days of the date of this order, cause to be published on the Slendertone website for a period of 14 days the consumer notice in the form at Sch B to these orders and use their best endeavours to ensure that such notice:
(i) shall appear immediately upon access by a consumer to the homepage of the website http://www.slendertone.com.au;
(ii) shall be not less than 50 per cent of the size of the computer screen;
(iii) shall have a bold type heading in at least 18 point type and the body of the notice shall be in a type not less than 12 points, Times New Roman font and right and left justified; and
(iv) shall include the logo of Slendertone at the top as appearing in Sch B.
12. Mr O’Donoghue attend, within 60 days of the date of this order, trade practices training covering ss 52 and 53 of the Act, in accordance with the requirements set out below, for the purpose of ensuring that he does not engage in conduct in contravention of ss 52 and 53 of the Act, or similar or related conduct:
(a) the training is to be administered by a suitably qualified, compliance professional or legal practitioner with expertise in trade practices law; and
(b) Mr O’Donoghue shall provide a written statement or certificate from the trade practices professional who conducts the training to the applicant within 14 days of completion of the training, verifying that such training has occurred.
13. Emerald Ocean, Slendertone and Mr O’Donoghue jointly or severally pay 90 per cent of the applicant’s costs of the proceedings (including any reserved costs) in an amount to be agreed or, if not agreed, to be taxed.
14. (a) The cross-claim be dismissed.
(b) Unless the cross-respondent does within 14 days of today make an application for any special costs order, the first, second and third cross-claimants do jointly and severally pay the cross-respondent’s costs of the proceedings (including any reserved costs) in an amount to be taxed if not agreed.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Established by: NICHOLSON J
As to the primary ground of the respondents’ contention, I agree with the applicant’s submissions.DECLARATIONS SOUGHT This refers to proposed orders 3-7. The respondents accept that they cannot argue against these proposed orders where they relate to specific findings made in relation to the specific express representations found to have been made by them. However, the respondents contend that the orders should be shaped to take into account the reasons and the fact that the applicant has been unsuccessful in a number of claims. In particular it is said where the Court has ruled that the statements of the respondents have been found to be false and/or misleading or deceptive as a result of the ‘absolute’ nature of the representation, the orders should be shaped to reflect that fact. Also it is contended that regard should be had in the orders to the fact that the Court has found at [132]-[143] that the relevant technology supports representations which are qualified. The applicant responds to this by referring to the wide discretion for the Court to make binding declarations of right pursuant to s 21 of the Federal Court Act 1976 (Cth); Trade Practices Commission v Santos Limited [1993] ATPR 41-221 and other matters pertaining to the Court’s power. In relation to the absolute nature of the statements, the applicant also submits in reply that the nature of the statements of whether the technology supports representations that are qualified is a consideration to be taken into account by the Court in resolving the legal controversy as to whether the representations were in fact false, misleading or deceptive. This, it is said, has been resolved by the Court because it was held that the absolute statements were false or misleading or deceptive. Accordingly it is said it is appropriate for the Court to make the declarations in support of those findings without qualification. I agree with the applicant’s submissions that the purpose to be served by the exercise of the Court’s discretion to make orders is to solve the legal controversy at hand. That is, orders fall to be made in circumstances where the findings require orders to be made because the conduct has been found to have given rise to liability. Where orders are not required, because no contravention has been found, there is no requirement to craft an order recording the result. Additionally, there is no competing draft from the respondents to provide persuasion towards the form of order which they seek. Therefore the applicant’s proposed orders 3-7 should be accepted.INJUNCTIONS SOUGHT This refers to proposed orders 8-11. The respondents submit the injunctions sought are unnecessary and ought not to be made. This is based on the fact that the business which gave rise to the applicant’s action has been terminated by the current action and there is no prospect of there being any revival in respect of the particular products. It is said that the relevant principles are those in Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v 4WD Systems Pty Ltd (2003) 200 ALR 491 at [211]-[219].