Crystal Auburn Pty Ltd v IL Wollermann Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 78 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Crystal Auburn Pty Ltd v I L Wöllermann Pty Ltd [2004] FCA 821

DAMAGES – misleading and deceptive conduct - entitlement to damages under the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) - purchase of business - entry into lease - entry into hire purchase agreement - quantification of damages by measuring difference between the price paid for the business and its true value - expert valuations provided - effect of affirmation on entitlement to damages - subsequent conduct of plaintiffs - whether issue estoppel applies to the assessment - capital contributions - rental payments - whether plaintiff entitled to indemnity on cross‑claim for unpaid rental - unrewarded labour - relocation costs - compensation for anxiety stress and upset - opportunity cost of capital - valuation fee, conveyancing costs, lease preparation and stamp duty - interest on financing.

Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth): ss 52, 75B, 87(2)(a)

Crystal Auburn Pty Ltd v IL Wöllerman Pty Ltd [2000] FCA 913
Crystal Auburn Pty Ltd v IL Wöllerman Pty Ltd [2001] FCA 735
Marks v GIO Australia Holdings Ltd (1998) 196 CLR 494 discussed
Henville v Walker (2001) 206 CLR 459 referred to
I & L Securities Pty Ltd v HTW Valuers (Brisbane) Pty Ltd (2002) 210 CLR 109 referred to
Netaf Pty Ltd v Bikane Pty Ltd (1990) 26 FCR 305 considered
Argy v Blunts & Lane Cove Real Estate Pty Ltd (1990) 26 FCR 112 cited
Gould v Vaggelas (1985) 157 CLR 215 discussed
Potts v Miller (1940) 64 CLR 282 referred to
Jaldiver Pty Ltd v Nelumbo Pty Ltd [1992] FCA 906 cited
Henjo Investments Pty Ltd v Collins Marrickville Pty Ltd (No 2) (1989) 40 FCR 76 referred to
McAllister v Richmond Brewing Co (NSW) Pty Ltd (1942) 42 SR (NSW) 187 considered
Alati v Kruger (1955) 94 CLR 216 followed
Thayananthan v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs [2003] FCA 1054 referred to
Blair v Curran (1939) 62 CLR 464 discussed
O’Neill v Medical Benefits Fund of Australia (2002) 122 FCR 455 cited
JLW (Vic) Pty Ltd v Tsiloglou [1994] 1 VR 237 cited
Radferry Pty Ltd v Starborne Holdings Pty Ltd [1998] FCA 1689 cited
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Top Snack Foods Pty Ltd (1999) 21 ATPR ¶41‑708 cited
Maridakis v Kouvaris (1975) 5 ALR 197 at 199 referred to
Karacominakis v Big Country Developments Pty Ltd [2001] ANZ Conv R 577; [2000] NSWCA 313 referred to
Karedis Enterprises Ltd & Greenfriars Pty Ltd v Rita Antonious and Michael Antonious (1995) 17 ATPR ¶41‑427 applied
Jacara Pty Ltd v Perpetual Trustees WA Ltd (2000) 185 ALR 463 cited
Pine River Pty Ltd v Scorda [2001] WASC 105 considered

AV & MS Adamson, Valuation of Company Shares and Businesses (7th edn), LBC, Sydney, 1986
Australian Property Institute, Professional Practice 2002, API, Canberra, 2001
W Lonergan, The Valuation of Businesses, Shares and Other Equity, Longman Professional, Melbourne, 1992

CRYSTAL AUBURN PTY LTD, MARK CHARLES SIBERAS and KINGSLEY WILLIAM DAVIES…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Crystal Auburn Pty Ltd v IL Wollermann Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2004] FCA 821
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Crystal Auburn Pty Ltd v IL Wollermann Pty Ltd involved a dispute between two companies, with Crystal Auburn (the plaintiff) seeking damages from IL Wollermann (the defendant) for breaches of contract and misrepresentation. The matter was heard in the Supreme Court of Victoria. The primary issue before the court was the valuation of the plaintiff's business, Valespring, and whether it was profitable in the years 1994 to 1997. This valuation was crucial as it impacted the amount of damages that the plaintiff was entitled to claim from the defendant.

The court had to decide whether the financial information provided by the plaintiff was reliable and if it accurately reflected the profitability of Valespring. The plaintiff's expert, Mr Wight, based his valuation on the tax returns prepared by Valespring, which were found to be incorrect by the court. The court had to determine how to adjust these figures to arrive at a true reflection of the business's profitability. The defendant's expert, Mr Laurie, provided evidence regarding the capital expenditure of the business, which the plaintiff's expert had not considered. The court had to assess the credibility and relevance of this evidence.

The court found that the tax returns, while incorrect, could be adjusted to provide a more accurate picture of the business's financial situation. The court accepted Mr Wight's methodology for adjusting the tax returns to account for unrecorded income and capital expenditure. The court determined that Valespring was not profitable in any of the financial years 1994 to 1997. This conclusion was based on the adjusted figures and the deductions made for rent and salaries. The court's reasoning was that the business's expenses, including capital expenditure, exceeded its income, resulting in losses.

The final orders of the court were that the plaintiff was entitled to damages based on the losses incurred by Valespring in the financial years 1994 to 1997. The exact amount of damages was to be calculated based on the losses determined by the court. The court also ruled on the admissibility of the evidence provided by the experts, finding that both experts were qualified and their opinions relevant to the issues before the court.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Each of the experts satisfied me that he held qualifications and experience relevant to the opinion proffered. With respect to Mr Laurie’s opinion, I ruled that it was relevant and admissible insofar as the opinion related to what was involved in the dismantling of the plant and equipment, and the costs involved. Evidence on the profitability of the business· Mr Wight’s valuation Mr Wight first considered which of the two conflicting sources of financial information to base his valuation upon – the Business Profile or the tax returns prepared by Valespring for the years ended 1994 to 1997. In his first judgment, Sundberg J found that the attendance figures in the Business Profile for the years 1994 to 1996 were unreliable and those for the ended 30 June 1997 were false. Sundberg J also found that the tax returns were incorrect as they did not accurately record the income and expenses of the business. Shortly before the first hearing, in an unsuccessful attempt to defeat the applicants’ attempt to establish the falsity of the attendance figures provided to them by reference to the low income recorded in Valespring’s tax returns, Mr Laurie asserted that the business received large amounts of cash not reflected in its tax returns. Nevertheless, Sundberg J found that for 1996‑1997 the total gross income in Valespring’s tax return was understated by $228,400: finding (q). The implication of finding (q) was that the expenses in the Valespring tax return for 1996‑1997 were understated by $228,400. Although Sundberg J made no findings regarding the expenses in the Business Profile, Mr Wight was of the opinion that it could not be relied on as the figures in it were less than the amounts recorded in the tax returns for corresponding years. Mr Wight decided that of the two sources it was appropriate to use the tax returns. Mr Wight found that if it were assumed that the amount of unrecorded income for the year ended 1997 gave rise to an equivalent amount of unrecorded expenses, the understated expenses of $228,400 did not affect the value of net profit before tax. However, this was not the case if the unrecorded outgoings were of a capital nature of which Mr Laurie had given evidence in the second trial. The capital expenditure was said to have comprised $10,000 to $15,000 each year on shopping centre promotions involving “Mr Wobbie” plus $40,500 in 1994 on installation and maintenance of the Splash Down attraction, and in 1997 $16,000 on the relocation of an aeroplane and $14,000 on a new sewer line. On this evidence, Mr Wight determined it reasonable to estimate $40,000 in capital expenditure in each of the years 1994 to 1997. On this analysis, Mr Wight found that by adding back this sum for each of those years the net profit before tax resulted in profits. However, Mr Wight’s next step was to calculate maintainable earnings based on “earnings before depreciation, interest and tax” and by making deductions of $150,000 for rent and $30,000 (and 10% on‑costs) as annual full time salary each for Mr and Mrs Laurie. Once the maintainable earnings were determined Mr Wight concluded that there were losses for the period as follows: $154,406 loss for the year ended 30 June 1997; $143,682 loss for the year ended 30 June 1996; $125,138 loss for the year ended 30 June 1995; $87,744 loss for the year ended 30 June 1994. Mr Wight’s opinion was that the business was not profitable in any of the financial years 1994‑1997. I note that on these calculations even if Mr Wight had used a rental figure of $75,000, as the respondents’ contended, there would still have been a loss.

Decision

Reasons for decision

GOLDBERG J

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: GOLDBERG J

Full text does not contain this section.