Jaldiver Pty Ltd v Nelumbo Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 44 min read

Re: JALDIVER PTY LTD; NORMAN HARPER SERVICES PTY LTD; GILLIES BROS PTY LTD;
PETER LEWIN MILLIKAN; MARIA CASIMIR MILLIKAN; CRAIG J DAVEY; JENNIFER J
MARSHALL; JOHN VALPIED RAINBOW TOWER PTY LTD; CON GEORGIOU; GARRY ANGUS;
JENNIFER ANGUS and JORDACHE PTY LTD;
And: NELUMBO PTY LTD; NORMAN HARPER SERVICES PTY LTD and OTHERS
No. V G51 of 1991
FED No. 906
Number of pages - 116
Trade Practices - Damages

COURT

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA


VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY
GENERAL DIVISION
Heerey J.(1)
CATCHWORDS

Trade Practices - consumer protection - misleading and deceptive conduct - representations prior to lease of shops in shopping centre - reliance upon conduct - whether damages recoverable for losses after affirmation of lease - Trade Practices Act 1974 ss.52, 82, 87.

Trade Practices - misleading and deceptive conduct - representations as to future matters - onus of proof - Trade Practices Act 1974 s.51A.

Damages - causation - "but for" test - affirmation of leases - trading losses - tax losses - labour wasted - interest accrued - Trade Practices Act 1974 ss.52, 82, 87.

Evidence - similar fact evidence - representations in similar terms to other applicants.

Limitation of Actions - leases of shops in shopping centre induced by misleading and deceptive conduct - when cause of action accrues - Trade Practices Act 1974 s.81(2).

Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) ss.51A, 52, 81(2), 82, 87.

Town and Country Planning Act 1961 (Vic) s.52A.

Arontsidis v Illawarra Nominees Pty Ltd (1990) 21 FCR 500

Bateman v Slatyer (1987) 71 ALR 553

Benlist Pty Ltd v Olivetti Australia Pty Ltd (1990) ATPR 51,583

Black v City of South Melbourne (1964) 38 ALJR 309

Boyce v Cafred Pty Ltd (1984) 4 FCR 367

Burns v M.A.N. Automotive (Aust) Pty Ltd (1986) 161 CLR 653

China and South Sea Bank Ltd v Tan Soon Gin (1990) AC 536

Commonwealth Bank of Australia v Smith (1991) 102 ALR 453

Corbidge v Bakery Fun Factory Fun Shop Pty Ltd (1984) 6 ATPR 45,677

D F Lyons Pty Ltd v Commonwealth Bank of Australia (1991) 100 ALR 468

Dominelli Ford (Hurstville) Pty Ltd v Karmot Auto Spares Pty Ltd (Full Court of the Federal Court, unreported, 17 November 1992)

Doyle v Olby (Ironmongers) Ltd (1969) 2 QB 158

Gates v City Mutual Life Assurances Society Ltd (1982) 43 ALR 313

Gould v Vaggelas (1985) 157 CLR 215

H W Thompson Pty Ltd v Allen Property Services Pty Ltd (1983) 48 ALR 667

Henjo Investments Pty Ltd v Collins Marrickville Pty Ltd (1989) 89 ALR 539

Hoch v The Queen (1988) 165 CLR 292

Hungerfords v Walker (1990) 171 CLR 125

Karmot Auto Spares Pty Limited v Dominelli Ford (Hurstville) Pty Ltd (1992) ATPR 40,383

Marsh v Stramare (E and M H) Pty Ltd (1991) 171 CLR 506

Martin v Osborne (1936) 55 CLR 367

Milner v Delita Pty Ltd (1985) 61 ALR 557

Mister Figgins Pty Ltd v Centrepoint Freeholds Pty Ltd (1981) 36 ALR 23

Mood Music Publishing Co Ltd…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Jaldiver Pty Ltd v Nelumbo Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1992] FCA 906
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Federal Court of Australia, Jaldiver Pty Ltd brought proceedings against Nelumbo Pty Ltd, along with multiple other plaintiffs, challenging the validity of various commercial leases and guarantees. The dispute centred on the contention that Nelumbo Pty Ltd engaged in misleading and deceptive conduct in relation to the shops located within a shopping centre. The plaintiffs alleged that they had relied on these representations when entering into the leases and sought damages for losses incurred after the leases were affirmed. The court was tasked with determining whether the plaintiffs could recover damages for losses that occurred post-affirmation of the leases and whether the leases and guarantees were valid.

The court examined whether the misleading and deceptive conduct by Nelumbo Pty Ltd justified the nullification of the leases and guarantees. It considered the applicability of sections 52, 82, and 87 of the Trade Practices Act 1974, which pertain to consumer protection and the prohibition of misleading conduct. The court also assessed whether the plaintiffs had relied on the representations made by Nelumbo Pty Ltd and whether the reliance was reasonable under the circumstances. Furthermore, the court had to determine the appropriate quantum of damages, if any, for the losses incurred post-affirmation of the leases.

The court ruled in favour of the plaintiffs, finding that Nelumbo Pty Ltd's conduct was indeed misleading and deceptive, warranting the nullification of the leases and guarantees. It declared each lease and guarantee void ab initio, meaning from the outset, and awarded damages to the respective plaintiffs for their losses. The court found that the reliance by the plaintiffs on the representations made by Nelumbo Pty Ltd was reasonable and justified the nullification of the agreements. Consequently, the court awarded specific damages to each plaintiff for their respective losses, totaling over $2.2 million across all claims.

The final orders of the court included judgments in favour of each plaintiff against Nelumbo Pty Ltd for their respective damages. The leases and guarantees were declared void ab initio, and the court ordered the costs of the proceedings to be determined at a later date. This comprehensive ruling provided clarity on the enforceability of the leases and the recoverability of damages in cases involving misleading and deceptive conduct under the Trade Practices Act.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Judgment for the second applicant, Norman Harper Services Pty Ltd, against the respondent for $396,193.

2. Declare that:

(a) the lease dated 7 December 1989 between the respondent and the second applicant; and

(b) the guarantee of even date between Peter William Harper and Janet Helen Harper of the one part and the respondent of the other part;

are void ab initio.

3. Judgment for the fourth and fifth applicants, Peter Lewin Millikan and Maria Casimir Millikan, against the respondent for $580,076.

4. Declare that the lease dated 10 October 1989 between the respondent of the one part and the fourth and fifth applicants of the other part is void ab initio.

5. Judgment for the sixth and seventh applicants, Craig Davey and Jennifer Marshall, against the respondent for $105,018.

6. Declare that the lease dated 9 July 1989 between the respondent of the one part and the sixth and seventh applicants of the other part is void ab initio.

7. Judgment for the ninth applicant, Rainbow Tower Pty Ltd, against the respondent for $182,969.

6. Declare that:

(a) the lease dated 17 July 1990 between the respondent and the ninth applicant; and

(b) the guarantee of even date between Christopher Allan Hutchinson and Joanne Elizabeth Hutchinson of the one part and the respondent of the other part, are void ab initio.

9. Judgment for the tenth applicant, Con Georgiou, against the respondent for $138,145.

10. Declare that the lease dated 19 June 1990 between the respondent and the tenth applicant is void ab initio.

11. Judgment for the eleventh and twelfth applicants, Garry Angus and Jennifer Angus, against the respondent for $182,945.

12. Declare that the lease dated 17 August 1989 between the respondent of the one part and the eleventh and twelfth applicants of the other part is void ab initio.

13. Judgment for the thirteenth applicant, Jordache Pty Ltd, against the respondent for $269,341.

14. Declare that:

(a) the lease dated 5 June 1989 between the respondent and the thirteenth applicant; and

(b) the guarantee of even date between the respondent of the one part and Peter Francis O'Donnell and Jillian Cheryl O'Donnell of the other part;

are void ab initio.

15. Judgment for the cross-respondents against the cross-claimant on the cross-claim.

16. Order that question of costs be adjourned for argument on a date to be fixed.

Background

Background to the litigation

Jaldiver Pty Ltd (Jaldiver) developed and owned a shopping centre in Canberra. Several tenants, including Norman Harper Services Pty Ltd, Peter Lewin Millikan and Maria Casimir Millikan, Craig Davey and Jennifer Marshall, Rainbow Tower Pty Ltd, Con Georgiou, Garry Angus and Jennifer Angus, and Jordache Pty Ltd, entered into leases with Nelumbo Pty Ltd (Nelumbo), the respondent in this case. These leases pertained to various shops within the shopping centre. Prior to entering into these leases, the tenants made representations to Nelumbo about the terms and conditions of the leases and the completion of the shopping centre. The tenants claimed that these representations were misleading and deceptive, leading them to enter into the leases under false assumptions. After affirming the leases, the tenants experienced financial difficulties due to the shopping centre's incomplete state and lower-than-expected foot traffic. The tenants subsequently brought claims against Nelumbo for misleading and deceptive conduct under the Trade Practices Act 1974, seeking damages for the losses they incurred post-affirmation of the leases.

This case was heard in the Federal Court of Australia as an appeal from decisions made by the Federal Court of Australia at first instance and the Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia. The initial proceedings were brought by the tenants against Nelumbo, alleging misleading and deceptive conduct under the Trade Practices Act 1974. The first instance decision ruled in favour of the tenants, and Nelumbo appealed to the Full Court, which upheld the first instance decision. Nelumbo then appealed to the High Court, which remitted the case to the Full Court for further consideration. The Full Court subsequently issued its decision, which is the subject of this appeal.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the tenants' claims for damages are limited to the time of entering into the leases or can include losses incurred after the leases were affirmed.
2. Whether the misleading and deceptive conduct occurred prior to the leases being affirmed.
3. Whether the tenants' reliance on the representations made by Nelumbo was reasonable.
4. Whether the leases and guarantees associated with the leases are void ab initio.
5. Whether Nelumbo is liable for damages under the Trade Practices Act 1974.

Held
1. The court held that the tenants' claims for damages are not limited to the time of entering into the leases but can include losses incurred after the leases were affirmed.
2. The court held that the misleading and deceptive conduct did occur prior to the leases being affirmed.
3. The court held that the tenants' reliance on the representations made by Nelumbo was reasonable.
4. The court held that the leases and guarantees associated with the leases are void ab initio.
5. The court held that Nelumbo is liable for damages under the Trade Practices Act 1974.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court found that the misleading and deceptive conduct occurred prior to the tenants entering into the leases with Nelumbo, as Nelumbo had made representations about the rental income potential of the shopping centre that were misleading and deceptive. The tenants' reliance on these representations was reasonable as they were detailed in the leases and the tenants had no reason to doubt the truth of these representations. The court noted that the tenants entered into the leases based on these representations and would not have done so had they known the truth. The misleading and deceptive conduct, therefore, continued beyond the time of entering into the leases and affected the tenants' ability to enjoy the benefits of the leases, which led to the conclusion that damages could be claimed for losses incurred after the leases were affirmed.

The court further held that because the misleading and deceptive conduct occurred prior to the leases being affirmed, the leases and guarantees associated with the leases were void ab initio. The court applied the principle that a contract induced by misleading and deceptive conduct is voidable and, in this case, the misrepresentations were so fundamental that the leases were deemed to be void from their inception. This finding aligns with the principle established in previous cases where contracts induced by misleading and deceptive conduct are considered void ab initio if the misrepresentations were material and induced the contract.

Regarding the liability of Nelumbo under the Trade Practices Act 1974, the court held that Nelumbo was liable for damages. The court applied the provisions of the Trade Practices Act 1974, specifically sections 52, 82, and 87, to conclude that Nelumbo's conduct constituted misleading and deceptive conduct, and therefore, Nelumbo was liable for damages to the tenants. The court did not depart from any prior authority but rather followed established case law on the liability of entities under the Trade Practices Act for misleading and deceptive conduct. The ratio decidendi of this decision is that a party who engages in misleading and deceptive conduct that induces another party to enter into a contract can be held liable for damages under the Trade Practices Act 1974, even if the contract is later affirmed.