Chopsonion Pty Ltd (Controllers Appointed) v Watts Meat Machinery Pty Ltd (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 76 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Chopsonion Pty Ltd (Controllers Appointed) v Watts Meat Machinery Pty Ltd (No 2) [2025] FCA 4

File numbers: SAD 109 of 2020
SAD 76 of 2022
Judgment of: O'SULLIVAN J
Date of judgment: 15 January 2025
Catchwords:

SAD 109 of 2020

CORPORATIONS — breach of director’s/officer’s duties — one shadow director/shadow officer — one registered director and officer of the first applicant — where directors not a party to the proceedings — where directors breached duty to act in good faith, in the best interest of corporation and for a proper purpose — duty not to misuse position — ss 181(1) and 182(1) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (Act) — whether directors breached their fiduciary duties to the first applicant — where directors obtained funding for corporation using false documentation — where directors improperly gained an advantage for related entities — where directors used their position to cause detriment to the company by exposing it to a liability for funding in excess of that which was required using documents they knew to be false — contraventions established — compensation ordered

CORPORATIONS — accessorial liability — whether second respondent was knowingly involved in contraventions of ss 181(1) and 182(1) within the meaning of s 79 of the Act — whether second respondent knowingly assisted the directors in their breaches of fiduciary duties — dishonest and fraudulent design — liability established

CONSUMER LAW — whether the first and second respondents engaged in conduct that was misleading or deceptive in contravention of s 18 of Australian Consumer Law (ACL) — whether directors engaged in conduct contrary to s 18 of the ACL — where applicants allege respondents made false or misleading representations by preparing and providing false documentation to the directors/officers of the first applicant for the provision of those documents to the applicant lenders through a mortgage manager — funding for the acquisition of abattoir equipment — where majority of representations found to be made — where lenders and the mortgage manager relied on the false documentation in deciding to provide funding to the first applicant and were misled — liability established

CONSUMER LAW — whether the directors/officers of the first applicant engaged in conduct contrary to s 18 of the ACL — attribution of director’s/officer’s knowledge to the first applicant — fraud exception — whether first and second respondents were involved in the contravening conduct of the directors within the meaning of s 2 of the ACL — whether second respondent had actual knowledge of the essential facts constituting the contravention — liability established

TORTS — deceit — false or misleading representations — where claim in deceit arises out of same facts as claim for misleading or deceptive conduct — where lenders relied on representations — liability established

LIMITATION OF ACTIONS — whether applicants’ causes of action under s 18 of the ACL are statute barred – where applicants claim for an extension of time pursuant to s 48 of the Limitation…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Chopsonion Pty Ltd (Controllers Appointed) v Watts Meat Mach... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] FCA 4
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Chopsonion Pty Ltd (Controllers Appointed) v Watts Meat Machinery Pty Ltd (No 2), the applicants, Chopsonion and the lenders, brought claims against Mr Watts, WMM, Rolton and Mr Smith. The applicants sought damages for breaches of fiduciary and statutory duties, misleading and deceptive conduct, deceit, negligence, and estoppel. The proceedings were divided into Watts and Rolton proceedings. The Watts proceedings included claims for damages arising from breaches of fiduciary and statutory duties, misleading and deceptive conduct, and deceit. The Rolton proceedings involved claims of misleading and deceptive conduct, negligence, and deceit, in relation to the valuation of abattoir equipment. The applicants also sought extensions of time to bring their claims under the ACL.

The primary issues before the court were whether the applicants could establish the various causes of action against the respondents, and if so, whether the applicants were entitled to extensions of time to bring their claims. The court had to determine if the directors breached their fiduciary and statutory duties, engaged in misleading or deceptive conduct, and if the respondents were involved in those contraventions. Additionally, the court needed to decide if the applicants' claims were statute-barred and if estoppel applied to prevent the applicants from bringing the proceedings.

The court found that Mr and Ms Sharpe breached their fiduciary and statutory duties to Chopsonion. They used their positions to obtain funding for the company through false documentation and for their personal gain. Mr Watts and WMM were involved in those breaches. The directors' conduct was also misleading and deceptive, and the respondents were involved in those contraventions. The applicants' causes of action were not statute-barred, and estoppel did not apply. The applicants were entitled to damages for each cause of action, and the lenders were entitled to an extension of time to bring their claims. The respondents' liability for the applicants' claims was established, and the respondents were ordered to pay damages. The court will hear the parties as to the form of orders sought consequent upon the Court’s reasons.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The Court will hear the parties as to the form of orders sought consequent upon the Court’s reasons.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

In Warner v Hung, in the matter of Bellpac Pty Ltd (Receivers and Managers Appointed) (In Liquidation) (No 2) [2011] FCA 1123; 297 ALR 56, at [48] Emmett J said:Under s 140(2) of the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) (the Evidence Act), the Court must, in deciding whether it is satisfied that a case has been proved to the requisite standard, take into account:§ the nature of the cause of action or defence;§ the nature of the subject matter of the proceeding; and§ the gravity of the matters alleged.When proof of any fac is required, the Court must feel an actual persuasion of the occurrence or existence of that fact before it can be found. Mere mechanical comparison of probabilities, independent of any belief in reality, cannot justify the finding of a fact. Actual persuasion is achieved where the affirmative of an allegation is made out to the reasonable satisfaction of the Court. However, reasonable satisfaction is not a state of mind that is attained or established independently of the nature and consequences of the fact to be proved. The seriousness of an allegation made, the inherent unlikelihood of an occurrence of a given description, and the gravity of the consequences flowing from a particular finding are considerations that must affect whether the fact has been proved to the reasonable satisfaction of the Court. Reasonable satisfaction should not be produced by inexact proofs, indefinite testimony or indirect inferences (see Briginshaw v Briginshaw (1938) 60 CLR 336 at 361-2). This matter raises serious issues against Mr Watts, Ms Watts, Mr Sharpe, Ms Sharpe and Mr Smith. It is for those reasons that I make any findings of fact involving adverse findings against Mr Watts, Ms Watts, Mr Sharpe, Ms Sharpe and Mr Smith keeping in mind the principles in Briginshaw [1938] HCA 34.Applicants’ witnesses The applicants called five witnesses.Richard Walter Cumming Willson Mr Willson’s evidence-in-chief was given by way of a single affidavit sworn 16 September 2022. He gave limited oral evidence following the grant of leave to do so. Mr Willson is a Director of Red Dog, is married to the sixth applicant, Ms Willson, and is the Secretary of the fourth applicant, Willson Nominees. Mr Willson gave evidence on his own behalf and on behalf of Red Dog and Willson Nominees. Ms Willson did not give evidence but her interests and the interests of Mr Willson coincide. Mr Willson, Ms Willson, Red Dog and Willson Nominees provided funds to PFM for lending to Chopsonion, however Mr Willson had no specific involvement in the transaction with Chopsonion. Mr Willson’s evidence when tested in cross-examination was vague. It became apparent during cross-examination that his affidavit had been prepared for him, albeit on his instructions, and whereas he had read it and agreed with its contents prior to swearing the affidavit, he was unable to recall independently the detail of a number of matters to which he had deposed, including in some cases the topics themselves. Nonetheless, I considered Mr Willson to be doing his best to assist the Court in giving his evidence but was hampered by his general inability to recall specific matters of detail. I am not critical of that inability after a period of nearly eight years between the initial events and the date he swore his affidavit. However, given that his affidavit had been prepared for him, it was apparent that he had accepted a number of the propositions in the affidavit without critical thinking. To that limited extent, I have some concerns about his reliability as a witness and accordingly, I approach his evidence with some caution.Jeffrey John Cannan

Decision

Reasons for decision

Chopsonion is entitled to damages in the same amount as for the other causes of action brought by Chopsonion.CONCLUSION In the Watts proceedings, the applicants have succeeded in each of their causes of action against Mr Watts and WMM. They are entitled to damages, including interest to be calculated. In the Rolton proceedings, the applicants have failed to establish any cause of action such that the proceedings must be dismissed. I will hear the parties as to the orders they seek in view of these reasons.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the Watts proceedings as against Mr Watts and WMM, Chopsonion plead the following causes of action:(a)On the basis of breaches by Mr and Ms Sharpe of their statutory duties owed to Chopsonion pursuant to ss 181 and 182 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), involvement of Mr Watts, and through him WMM, within the meaning of s 79 of the Corporations Act;(b)On the basis of breaches by Mr and Ms Sharpe of fiduciary duties they each owed to Chopsonion, knowing assistance by Mr Watts, and through him WMM, in those breaches;(c)Misleading and deceptive conduct or conduct likely to mislead and deceive contrary to s 18 of the Australian Consumer Law set out in Schedule 2 to the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth); (d)Involvement within the meaning of s 2 of the ACL in the misleading and deceptive conduct of Mr and Ms Sharpe contrary to s 18 of the ACL; and(e)Involvement with the meaning of s 2 of the ACL in the misleading and deceptive conduct of Rolton contrary to s 18 of the ACL. In the Watts proceedings, as against WMM and Mr Watts, the Lenders plead the following causes of actions:(a)Misleading and deceptive conduct;(b)Involvement in the misleading and deceptive conduct of Mr and Ms Sharpe;(c)Involvement in the misleading and deceptive conduct of Rolton; and(d)Deceit. In the Rolton proceedings, as against Rolton and Mr Smith, Chopsonion pleads:(a)In providing the Rolton valuation and/or the Modified Rolton valuation, Rolton has engaged in conduct which was misleading and deceptive; and(b)As against Mr Smith, involvement in Rolton’s misleading and deceptive conduct within the meaning of s 2 of the ACL. In the Rolton proceedings, as against Rolton and Mr Smith, the Lenders plead the following causes of actions:(a)Negligence;(b)Misleading and deceptive conduct; and(c)Deceit. In each case where the applicants claim for either misleading and deceptive conduct or in deceit, insofar as is required, the applicants claim an extension of time within which to bring proceedings under the ACL pursuant to s 48 of the Limitation of Actions Act 1936 (SA).ISSUES The following liability issues arise as against WMM and Mr Watts in the Watts proceedings:(i)Are the applicants estopped from bringing the Watts proceedings?(ii)Was Ms Sharpe a director and/or officer of Chopsonion within the meaning of s 9AC(1)(b) and/or s 9AD(1)(b) of the Corporations Act?(iii)Did Mr and/or Ms Sharpe breach their statutory duties to Chopsonion?(iv)If so, was Mr Watts, and through him WMM, involved in the breach of those statutory duties within the meaning of s 79 of the Corporations Act?(v)Did Mr and/or Ms Sharpe owe fiduciary duties to Chopsonion, and if so, did they breach them? (vi)If so, was Mr Watts, and through him WMM, knowingly involved in the breach of those fiduciary duties?(vii)Did Mr Watts, and through him WMM, engage in conduct contrary to s 18 of the ACL?(viii)Did Mr Sharpe and/or Ms Sharpe engage in conduct contrary to s 18 of the ACL?(ix)Was Mr Watts, and through him WMM, involved in the contravening conduct of Mr Sharpe and/or Ms Sharpe within the meaning of s 2 of the ACL?(x)Was Mr Watts, and through him WMM, involved within the meaning of s 2 of the ACL in conduct by Rolton contrary to s 18 of the ACL? and(xi)Are the Lenders entitled to an extension of time within which to bring a claim under s 18 of the ACL?(xii)Did Mr Watts, and through him WMM, commit the Tort of deceit? and(xiii)Are the Lenders entitled to an extension of time within which to bring a claim in deceit?