Harvard Nominees Pty Ltd v Tiller (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 77 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Harvard Nominees Pty Ltd v Tiller (No 2) [2020] FCA 604

File number: WAD 250 of 2019
Judge: JACKSON J
Date of judgment: 11 May 2020
Catchwords:

CONSUMER LAW - misleading or deceptive conduct - express oral representations regarding involvement of party in proposed leases - certain representations found to have been made - reliance on representations - whether representations misleading or deceptive - involvement in misleading or deceptive conduct - causation of loss or damage - applicant not pursuing 'no transaction' or 'different transaction' case - whether detriment or disadvantage required - whether counterfactual required to establish causation - whether entry into contractual relations amounts to loss or damage - whether misleading or deceptive conduct had continuing operative effect - no loss or damage caused by misleading or deceptive conduct

CONSUMER LAW - misleading or deceptive conduct - non-disclosure of deeds of assignment - terms of deeds falsified letter - whether omission to disclose deeds misleading or deceptive - whether applicant would have been able to terminate leases if the deeds had been disclosed - whether respondents engaged in misleading conduct involving non-disclosure

LANDLORD AND TENANT - equitable leases - assignment of equitable interest in equitable lease - requirement of delivery of deeds - whether deeds implemented - deeds held to be legally effective - whether clause in leases prohibiting assignment applies to equitable assignment - construction of leases - clause held to prohibit assignment in equity

CONTRACT - prohibition on assignment - whether fundamental breach or repudiation - application of general contractual principles to leases - privity of estate between lessor and lessees not displaced by equitable assignment - breach not going to root of contract - fundamental breach or repudiation not established - application dismissed

Legislation:

Acts Interpretation Act 1901 (Cth) s 15AC

Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) sch 2 (Australian Consumer Law) ss 2, 13, 14, 18, 236, 237, 243

Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) s 139B

Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) ss 50, 59, 81, 87, 135, 140, 142

Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) ss 52, 75B, 82, 87

Fair Trading Act 2010 (WA) s 111

Land Act 1933 (WA) ss 143, 151

Property Law Act 1969 (WA) s 9

Transfer of Land Act 1893 (WA) ss 58, 68, 82

Second Explanatory Memorandum, Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Bill (No 2) 2010 (Cth)

Cases cited:

Abigroup Contractors Pty Ltd v Sydney Catchment Authority (No 3) [2006] NSWCA 282; (2006) 67 NSWLR 341

ACE Insurance Limited v Trifunovski [2013] FCAFC 3; (2013) 209 FCR 146

Addenbrooke Pty Limited v Duncan(No 2) [2017] FCAFC 76; (2017) 348 ALR 1

Air Great Lakes Pty Ltd v KS Easter (Holdings) Pty Ltd (1985) 2 NSWLR 309

Akron Securities Ltd v Iliffe (1997) 41 NSWLR 353

Amaca Pty Ltd v Booth [2011] HCA 53; (2011) 246 CLR 36

Associated Newspapers Ltd v Bancks (1951) 83 CLR 322

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Cornerstone Investment Aust Pty…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Harvard Nominees Pty Ltd v Tiller (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] FCA 604
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Harvard Nominees Pty Ltd v Tiller, the plaintiff, Harvard Nominees Pty Ltd, brought an action against five defendants, including John and Allen Caratti and their respective companies, as well as Mr and Mrs Tiller, for alleged misleading or deceptive conduct in relation to certain farming leases. The defendants denied the allegations and counterclaimed for relief in relation to the leases. The case was heard by the Federal Court of Australia, which was required to decide several legal issues related to the alleged misleading or deceptive conduct, the validity of the leases, and the assignment of equitable interests.

The court found that certain oral representations made by Mr Caratti to Mr Tiller regarding his involvement in the proposed leases were misleading or deceptive, and that Mr Tiller had relied on those representations. However, the court held that Harvard had not suffered any loss or damage as a result of the misleading or deceptive conduct, and therefore could not recover any damages. The court also found that the deeds of assignment were legally effective, and that the clause in the leases prohibiting assignment did not apply to the equitable assignment. Finally, the court held that the privity of estate between the lessor and lessees was not displaced by the equitable assignment, and that there was no fundamental breach or repudiation of the leases.

In conclusion, the court dismissed Harvard's claim against all five respondents, and directed the parties to provide submissions as to costs. The defendants were found not to have engaged in any misleading or deceptive conduct that caused loss or damage to Harvard, and the leases were held to be valid and enforceable. The equitable assignment of the leases was also found to be legally effective, and there was no fundamental breach or repudiation of the leases.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

I gave a broad description of the pleaded issues in Harvard Nominees Pty Ltd v Tiller [2019] FCA 1672, but there have been substantial amendments since, then so it is convenient to give a full description here.Background John Caratti is a central figure in the relevant events. I will refer to him as 'Mr Caratti', except when it is necessary to avoid confusion between him and other members of his family. According to the Further Further Amended Statement of Claim filed on 3 December 2019 (SOC), Mr Caratti and other entities in which he had an interest leased farming properties in the Esperance and Yilgarn districts to Mr Nicoletti and his wife. That included the Farms, which from about 1994 were leased to the Nicolettis via a sub‑lease from Mammoth. Harvard claims that various disputes arose about arrears of rent and other defaults. Harvard says that in or about November 2016, Mr Nicoletti told Mr Caratti that he and his wife wanted to cease farming in Esperance. It also alleges that Mr Tiller told Mr Caratti that Mr and Mrs Tiller wanted to take over operating the Farms. It is said that Mr Caratti told both Mr Nicoletti and Mr Tiller that he would agree to lease the Farms to Mr and Mrs Tiller if all arrears of rent were satisfied. It is also alleged that Mr Caratti told them, and it was the fact, that he did not want to deal with Mr Nicoletti again in relation to the Farms as he was dissatisfied with the manner in which Mr Nicoletti had addressed (or not) the alleged defaults. Mr and Mrs Tiller became sub‑lessees of the Farms from Mammoth for a five year term commencing on 1 March 2017 under an instrument I will call the Tiller Lease. On 18 January 2019, Mammoth issued a default notice to them for non-payment of rates. Harvard alleges that on or about 22 January 2019, Mr Tiller told Mr Caratti that Mrs Tiller had asked for a divorce.The alleged conversations on 31 January 2019 On or about 31 January 2019 two conversations between Mr Caratti and Mr Tiller are claimed to have taken place, with the second of these being the occasion on which the first alleged instance of misleading or deceptive conduct occurred. It is pleaded that in the first conversation on that day, Mr Tiller told Mr Caratti that (SOC para 10):(a)he had formed a new company called Dimension Agriculture Pty Ltd (being the Second Respondent);(b)he wished to surrender the Tiller Lease and enter into a new lease of the Farms with himself and [Dimension] as lessee, in place of [Mrs Tiller], on the same terms;(c)the partnership between [Mr and Mrs Tiller] would need to be dissolved and all the assets in the partnership assigned to [Dimension];(d)[Mrs Tiller] had said she would sign a surrender of the Tiller Lease as part of implementing the divorce arrangements;(e)because the latest season had seen a bumper crop and good market prices for grain, he would be able to pay off all outstanding arrears and debts owed by the Tiller partnership to [Harvard] and Mammoth in return for [Harvard] and Mammoth agreeing to surrender the Tiller Lease and entering into a new lease with [Dimension].

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Counsel for the respondents submitted that to the extent that it was a discretionary decision whether to admit the evidence, the discretion should be exercised against doing so because, he said, Mr May's evidence in the witness box differed in material respects from Mr Caratti's evidence about what he said and 'we should [not] be saddled with two sets of evidence … from the same witness' (ts 392). I take this to be a submission that the court should exercise its discretion under s 135 of the Evidence Act to refuse to admit the evidence because its probative value is substantially outweighed by the danger that it might be misleading or confusing or (perhaps) cause or result in undue waste of time. But I do not consider that the two different accounts of what Mr May said are likely to result in either of those outcomes. There will be no impediment to reconciling the two different accounts, or choosing between them, in the usual way.A chronological account of the evidence In Butcher v Lachlan Elder Realty Pty Limited [2004] HCA 60; (2004) 218 CLR 592 at [102] and [109], McHugh J observed that s 52 of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) (TPA), the predecessor to s 18 of the ACL, required the court to examine the impugned conduct as a whole in the light of the relevant surrounding facts and circumstances, not in isolated parts. His Honour was in dissent but not on this principle: see also the majority (Gleeson CJ, Hayne and Heydon JJ) at [74]: 'in cases under s 52, read in the light of the particular structure and goals of the Act, everything must depend on an appropriately detailed examination of the specific circumstances of the case'. See also Campbell v Backoffice Investments Pty Ltd [2009] HCA 25; (2009) 238 CLR 304 at [102] (Gummow, Hayne, Heydon and Kiefel JJ). It is convenient before making specific findings about the key factual issues to place the factual disputes in the context of the relevant course of events as a whole. That includes the documents which, with one exception, were admitted into evidence by consent. Where the testimony adduced by the parties on key issues is contradictory, I will describe the competing versions of events but defer findings until the subsequent sections of these reasons.The history of lease dealings between the Nicolettis and Caratti interests There is an extensive history of lease dealings between the Nicolettis and companies associated with them, and John and Allen Caratti and companies associated with them. Mr Caratti's evidence was that he has known Mr Nicoletti for 30 years (ts 119). Mr Nicoletti's evidence was that he has farmed properties owned by the Caratti family since around 1999 (Mr Nicoletti first witness statement dated 11 November 2019 (Nicoletti I), para 21). That is borne out by the numerous leases and extensions of lease in evidence; and it is not necessary to go into detail about them. Mr Nicoletti gave evidence that his dealings with the Caratti family have always been through Allen Caratti (Nicoletti I, para 19). That statement is too wide and unqualified to be accepted in its entirety, but John Caratti did accept in his evidence‑in‑chief that Allen Caratti was largely responsible for the management of the Nicolettis' leases up until about 2012 (Mr Caratti's responsive witness statement dated 27 November 2019 (Caratti II), para 40). He said that he (John Caratti) took a more proactive role after that, although in cross‑examination, he said that Allen only stopped managing farms on behalf of Mammoth in 2015 or 2016 (ts 126). When asked whether he accepted that Mr Nicoletti dealt with Allen Caratti in relation to the management of the farms he was leasing, Mr Caratti said that 'Allen and Nicoletti were bonded together' (ts 128). I accept that until 2016, Mr Nicoletti had few if any direct dealings with John Caratti over the leases. As will be seen, by late 2016 John Caratti was taking steps to assert more active control over the leasing arrangements for the Farms. It is not necessary to make a finding as to precisely when in 2016 he began to have dealings with Mr Nicoletti about those matters.

Decision

Reasons for decision

One more issue should be noted as it was raised at trial, although there was limited argument and hardly any evidence about it. The respondents submitted that if damages for the loss of the rent for the first year of the Fowler Lease were to be assessed, that should be done on the basis that it was a loss of opportunity. While a lease had been signed, it had not commenced, and the new tenants had not gone into possession. The respondents submitted that Harvard should have pleaded how the loss of opportunity was to be discounted to take account of the possibility that it might not have eventuated: see for example Graham & Linda Huddy Nominees Pty Ltd v Byrne [2016] QSC 221 at [50]. Harvard did not, however, approach the case on this basis. Its loss was particularised, in effect, as 100% of the difference between a year's rent under the New Leases and the first year's rent under the Fowler Lease. In view of the findings I have made, it is not necessary to decide which of these approaches to the assessment of damages in this case is correct.Conclusion Harvard's claim will be dismissed as against all five respondents. I will make directions for the parties to provide submissions as to costs.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.