Hoy Mobile Pty Ltd v Allphones Retail Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 26 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Hoy Mobile Pty Ltd v Allphones Retail Pty Ltd
[2008] FCA 369

EVIDENCE – admissibility of evidence – affidavit sworn by solicitor of party and read by it as evidence in earlier interlocutory proceeding – subsequently at trial, affidavit sought to be adduced as evidence of admission by solicitor’s client – whether, for the purposes of s 87(1)(a) of Evidence Act 1995 (Cth), solicitor had authority to make admission on client’s behalf – whether representations in solicitor’s affidavit constituted an ‘admission’ – whether hearsay rule did not apply pursuant to s 81(1) of Evidence Act – whether, for purposes of definition of ‘previous representation’ in Evidence Act, earlier interlocutory proceedings were same proceedings as the trial within meaning of ‘the proceeding in which evidence of the representation is sought to be adduced’

Held:  Each representation was made with client’s authority and constituted an ‘admission’ – ‘the proceeding’ in Evidence Act definition of ‘previous representation’ is the particular hearing before the particular judge and does not extend to other hearings or phases in the conduct of a matter, including any interlocutory proceeding, in which the parties have been engaged prior to that hearing

WORDS AND PHRASES – ‘admission’, ‘previous representation’, ‘in the proceeding in which evidence of the representation is sought to be adduced’, ‘judge’

EvidenceAct 1995 (Cth), ss 3 (and Dictionary), 4, 81(1), 82(b), 87(1)(a), 88

British Thomson-Houston Co Limited v British Insulated and Helsby Cables Limited [1924] 2 Ch 160 referred to
Chief Executive Officer of Customs v Labrador Liquor Wholesale Pty Limited (2003) 216 CLR 161 referred to

Doe d. Wetherell v Bird (1835) 7 C & P 6 applied

Dovuro Pty Limited v Wilkins (2003) 215 CLR 317 cited

In the matter ofSimionato Holdings Pty Limited; Commissioner of Taxation of the Commonwealth of Australia v Simionato Holdings Pty Limited [1997] FCA 125 cited

Langley v Earl of Oxford (1836) 5 LJ Exch 166 applied

Lloyd v David Syme & Co Ltd [1986] AC 350; (1985) 3 NSWLR 728 cited

Lustre Hosiery Limited v York (1935) 54 CLR 134 referred to

Prangley v Evans (1896) 17 LR (NSW) (L) 416 applied

Richards v Morgan (1863) 4 B & S 641 applied

Sargent v ASL Developments Ltd (1974) 131 CLR 634 cited

Smith v Joyce (1954) 89 CLR 529 followed

Trade Practices Commission v TNT Management Pty Limited (1984) 56 ALR 647 cited

Phipson, The Law of Evidence (8th ed, Carswell Company, 1942)
Australian Law Reform Commission (ALRC), Report No 38, Evidence, Australian Government Publishing Service Canberra, 1987

HOY MOBILE LIMITED v ALLPHONES RETAIL PTY LIMITED
NSD 1678 OF 2006

RARES J
26 FEBRUARY 2008
SYDNEY


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

NSD 1678 OF 2006

BETWEEN:

HOY MOBILE LIMITED
Applicant

AND:

ALLPHONES RETAIL PTY LIMITED
Respondent

JUDGE:

RARES J

DATE OF ORDER:

26 FEBRUARY 2008

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The application to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hoy Mobile Pty Ltd v Allphones Retail Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] FCA 369
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Hoy Mobile Pty Ltd v Allphones Retail Pty Ltd is a case that deals with the admissibility of evidence in the form of an affidavit sworn by Bernard John Lloyd, an employee of Allphones Retail Pty Ltd. The dispute revolves around whether certain statements made in the affidavit can be considered admissions by Allphones, given that it is a corporation and cannot express opinions or have a mind of its own. The Federal Court of Australia was tasked with determining the admissibility of Lloyd's affidavit as an admission by Allphones. The central legal issue was whether the statements in Lloyd's affidavit, specifically paragraphs 7 and 8, could be treated as admissions by Allphones under sections 81 and 82 of the Evidence Act. The court considered whether the quality of Lloyd's evidence was such that it could not be treated as an admission and whether the vagueness of certain statements precluded their use as evidence.

In its reasoning, the court acknowledged that a corporation can only act through its agents, who may attribute knowledge or state of mind to the corporation based on their actions or statements. The court held that Lloyd's evidence could be treated as an admission by Allphones because it demonstrated an intention to affirm or acknowledge the existence of certain facts. The court emphasised that the admissibility of an admission does not depend on the source of the party's knowledge but on the intention to affirm or acknowledge the facts. While the vagueness of some statements might affect their weight, it did not prevent their reception into evidence as admissions. The court concluded that the challenged paragraphs in Lloyd's affidavit were capable of being admissions by Allphones, but it did not rule on the potential prejudice to Allphones at that stage. The court ordered that the application to tender Lloyd's affidavit be stood over for further hearing to allow for a more comprehensive exploration of the circumstances and potential prejudice.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application to tender the affidavit of Bernard John Lloyd sworn 5 April 2007 stand over to 9.30am on 6 March 2008 for further hearing.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Here, of course, Allphones, being a corporation, can only act by others. It can have no opinions because it has no mind, but it can have attributed to it a state of mind or knowledge based on what those whom it authorises to act on its behalf say or do: Lloyd v David Syme & Co Ltd [1986] AC 350 at 366; (1985) 3 NSWLR 728 at 736 per Lord Keith of Kinkel. For these reasons, I am of opinion that Mr Lloyd was a person whose evidence can be treated as being an admission by Allphones.WAS THE QUALITY OF MR LLOYD’S EVIDENCE INCAPABLE OF AMOUNTING TO AN ADMISSION? Next, Allphones argued that the quality of Mr Lloyd’s evidence was such that it could not be treated as being an admission of anything. It pointed to the fact that Mr Lloyd did not state his source of knowledge or belief in the affidavit. This is a complaint which does not go to the capacity of the statements to be used as evidence. It merely may go to their weight, albeit that Mr Lloyd’s evidence was put forward by Allphones to prove some of the very facts it now says should not be accepted from the same information. The question is whether the representations in pars 7 and 8 are capable of showing that before giving its notice of intention to terminate, Allphones had knowledge of the failure of Hoy Mobile to account for receipts from sales of the unlocked phones. As Allphones pointed out the introductory phrase in par 7 ‘in or around May 2006’ is somewhat vague. It also argued that pars 7 and 8 of the affidavit are vague in relation to the extent of Allphones’ knowledge and the circumstances in which it was obtained. I am of opinion that these criticisms do not prevent their reception into evidence of the representations as admissions. In Lustre Hosiery Limited v York (1935) 54 CLR 134 at 143 to 144 Rich, Dixon, Evatt and McTiernan JJ said:‘This course of authority seems consistent with the view that words or conduct amount to an admission receivable in evidence against the party if they disclose an intention to affirm or acknowledge the existence of a fact whatever be the party’s source of information or belief.In determining whether he intends to affirm or acknowledge the state of facts the party’s knowledge or source of information may be immaterial or if he states that another person has told him of it and it appears that he has additional sources of information to the like effect it may be right to understand him as implying a belief in what he repeats or again a person who fails to contradict a statement concerning matters within his own knowledge may be understood as acquiescing in the statement if the circumstances are such as to make it unlikely that he’d allow an erroneous statement to pass unchallenged But although the meaning of his words or conduct may depend upon the state of his knowledge once that meaning appears and an intention is disclosed to assert or acknowledge the state of facts its admissibility in evidence as an admission is independent of the party’s actual knowledge of the true facts. When admitted in evidence however its probative force must be determined by reference to the circumstances in which it’s made and may depend all together upon the party’s source of knowledge.If it appears that he had no knowledge or that although he had some means of knowledge he had formed no certain or considered belief and indicated nothing amounting to a personal judgment or conclusion of his own the probative force of the admission may be so small that a jury ought not be allowed to act upon it alone or in preference to opposing evidence.’

Decision

Reasons for decision

RARES J TAMBERLIN J
The parties conducted the substantial argument around pars 7 and 8. I should record that objection was taken to the reception into evidence of pars 1-17, 36-40 and 42 although no separate elaboration was made as to their character were I otherwise minded to admit pars 7 and 8.CONCLUSION For these reasons, I am of opinion that the paragraphs objected to in Mr Lloyd’s affidavit are capable of being admissions within the meaning of ss 81 and 82 of the Evidence Act. However, the circumstances in which the evidence has been tendered and any potential prejudice that might occur to Allphones in dealing with that evidence have not been fully explored or argued at this stage. I make no ruling on those matters at the present time.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: RARES J, TAMBERLIN J