Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Multimedia International Services Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 73 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Multimedia International Services Pty Ltd [2016] FCA 439

File number: QUD 1086 of 2015
Judge: EDELMAN J
Date of judgment: 29 April 2016
Catchwords: CONSUMER LAW – pecuniary penalties – unconscionable conduct contrary to s 21 of the Australian Consumer Law – relevance to mitigation of loss of profits arising from publicity concerning the contraventions
Legislation:

Australian Consumer Law (Schedule 2 to the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth)) ss 4, 18, 21, 21(1), 21(4)(c), 29, 29(1)(g), 36, 36(3), 87B, 155, 224, 224(1), 224(2), 224(3), 224(4)(b), 246, 246(2)(b)

Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) ss 58(b), 75AZL(3)

Cases cited:

Australian Communications and Media Authority v TPG Internet Pty Ltd [2014] FCA 382

Australian Competition & Consumer Commission v AirAsia Berhad Company [2012] FCA 1413

Australian Competition & Consumer Commission v Commercial and General Publications Pty Ltd [2002] FCA 900

Australian Competition & Consumer Commission v Lux Distributors (No 2) [2015] FCA 903

Australian Competition & Consumer Commission v Marksun Australia Pty Ltd [2011] FCA 695

Australian Competition & Consumer Commission v South East Melbourne Cleaning [2015] FCA 257

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v ACN 135 183 372 (in liquidation) (formerly known as Energy Watch Pty Ltd) [2012] FCA 749

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v AGL South Australia Pty Ltd [2015] FCA 399

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Breast Check Pty Ltd (No 2) [2014] FCA 1068

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Chopra [2015] FCA 539

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Chubb Security Australia Pty Ltd [2004] FCA 1750

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Lux Distributors Pty Ltd [2013] FCAFC 90

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Origin Energy Limited [2015] FCA 55

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Reckitt Benckiser (Australia) Pty Ltd (No 7) [2016] FCA 424

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Reebok Australia Pty Ltd [2015] FCA 83

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Scoopon Pty Ltd [2014] FCA 820

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Sontax Australia (1988) Pty Ltd [2011] FCA 1202

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Titan Marketing Pty Ltd [2014] FCA 913

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Woolworths Limited [2016] FCA 44

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Zen Telecom Pty Ltd [2014] FCA 1049

Australian Ophthalmic Supplies Pty Ltd v McAlary-Smith [2008] FCAFC 8; (2008) 165 FCR 550

Director of Fair Work Building Industry Inspectorate v Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union [2015] FCA 1213

Director of the Fair Work Building Industry Inspectorate v Bragdon (No 2) [2015] FCA 998

Eva v Southern Motors Box Hill Pty Ltd [1977] FCA 2; (1977) 30 FLR 213

R v Richards (1980) 2 Cr App R (S) 119

R v Wright (No 2) [1968] VR 174

Ryan v R [2001] HCA 21; (2001) 206 CLR 267

Trade Practices Commission v CSR Ltd [1991] ATPR 41-076

Trade Practices Commission v Cue Design Pty Ltd (1996) 85 A Crim R 500

Date of hearing: 27 April…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Multimedia... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] FCA 439
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Federal Court, the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) brought proceedings against Multimedia International Services Pty Ltd for contraventions of various sections of the Australian Consumer Law (ACL). The primary legal issues revolved around the determination of appropriate pecuniary penalties for the contraventions and the factors that should be considered in setting these penalties, including general deterrence and the need to balance the need for punishment against mitigating factors such as contrition and cooperation. The court also had to consider whether the loss of profit due to adverse publicity could be considered as a mitigating factor.

The court meticulously evaluated the submissions from both parties regarding the appropriate level of penalties. The ACCC argued for a higher penalty, while Multimedia argued for a lower amount, citing its cooperation and contrition as mitigating factors. The court acknowledged Multimedia's genuine contrition and cooperation but found that these factors did not warrant a reduction as low as Multimedia proposed. The court ultimately determined that a penalty of $230,000 was appropriate, reflecting a balance between the need for general deterrence and the mitigating factors presented.

In addition to the penalty, the court ordered Multimedia to establish and maintain an Australian Consumer Law compliance program, which included specific requirements such as appointing a compliance officer, conducting regular staff training, and implementing a complaints handling system. The court also mandated that Multimedia provide annual reports to the ACCC on the effectiveness of its compliance program.

Orders

Orders of the court

4. Pursuant to s 224 of the Australian Consumer Law Multimedia pay to the Commonwealth of Australia, in respect of the contraventions of ss 21, 29(1)(g) and 36(3) of the Australian Consumer Law referred to in paragraphs 1 to 3 above, pecuniary penalties in the amount of $230,000.

5. Pursuant to s 246 of the Australian Consumer Law, Multimedia shall at its own expense:

5.1 establish, within 90 days from the date of this order (Commencement Date), an Australian Consumer Law compliance program which meets the requirements set out in Annexure A to this order; and

5.2 maintain the compliance program for 3 years from the Commencement Date.

6. Multimedia pay the Applicant’s costs of and incidental to the liability aspect of these proceedings fixed in the amount of $35,000 within 30 days of the date of this order.

7.

ANNEXURE A

Requirements for Australian Consumer Law Compliance Program

Multimedia International Services Pty Ltd (Multimedia) will establish an Australian Consumer Law Compliance Program (Compliance Program) that complies with each of the following requirements:

Appointments

1. On or before the Commencement Date (as defined in paragraph 5 of the Court order), Multimedia will appoint a director or a senior manager of the business as a compliance officer, with responsibility for ensuring the Compliance Program is effectively designed, implemented and maintained (Compliance Officer).

2. On or before the Commencement Date, Multimedia will appoint a suitably qualified, internal or external, compliance professional with expertise in competition and consumer law (Compliance Advisor).

3. Multimedia will instruct the Compliance Advisor to conduct a competition and consumer law risk assessment within 3 months of being appointed as the Compliance Advisor (Risk Assessment).

4. Multimedia will use its best endeavours to ensure that the Risk Assessment covers the following matters, to be recorded in a written report (Risk Assessment Report):

4.1 identifies the areas where Multimedia is at risk of breaching ss 18, 21, 29 and 36 of Schedule 2 (Australian Consumer Law) to the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) (CCA);

4.2 assesses the likelihood of these risks occurring;

4.3 identifies where there may be gaps in Multimedia’s existing procedures for managing these risks; and

4.4 provides recommendations for any action to be taken by Multimedia having regard to the above assessment.

Compliance Policy

5. Multimedia will, within 30 days of the Commencement Date, issue a policy statement outlining Multimedia’s commitment to compliance with the CCA (Compliance Policy).

6. Multimedia will ensure the Compliance Policy:

6.1 contains a statement of commitment to compliance with the CCA;

6.2 contains a requirement for all staff to report any Compliance Program related issues and CCA compliance concerns to the Compliance Officer; and

6.3 contains a clear statement that Multimedia will take action internally against any persons who are knowingly or recklessly concerned in a contravention of the CCA and will not indemnify them in the event of any court proceedings in respect of that contravention.

Complaints Handling System

7. Multimedia will ensure the Compliance Program includes a competition and consumer law complaints handling system capable of identifying, classifying, storing and responding to competition and consumer law complaints (Complaints Handling System).

Staff Training

8. Multimedia will ensure that the Compliance Program includes a requirement for regular (at least once a year) training for all employees of Multimedia whose duties could result in them being concerned with conduct that may contravene ss 18, 21, 29 and 36 of the Australian Consumer Law.

9. Multimedia will ensure that the staff training is conducted by a suitably qualified compliance professional or legal practitioner with expertise in competition and consumer law.

10. Multimedia will ensure that the Compliance Program includes a requirement that awareness of competition and consumer compliance issues forms part of the induction of all new directors, officers and employees whose duties could result in them being concerned with conduct that may contravene ss 18, 21, 29 and 36 of the Australian Consumer Law.

Reports to Board of Senior Management

11. Multimedia will ensure that the Compliance Officer reports to the Board and/or senior management every 3 months on the continuing effectiveness of the Compliance Program.

Compliance Review

12. Multimedia will, at its own expense, cause an annual review of the Compliance Program (the Review) to be carried out in accordance with each of the following requirements:

12.1 Scope of Review - the Review should be broad and rigorous enough to provide Multimedia and the ACCC with:

12.1.1 a verification that Multimedia has in place a Compliance Program that complies with each of the requirements detailed in paragraphs 1-12 above; and

12.1.2 the Compliance Reports detailed at paragraph 13 below.

12.2 Independent Reviewer - Multimedia will ensure that each Review is carried out by a suitably qualified, independent compliance professional with expertise in competition and consumer law (the Reviewer). The Reviewer will qualify as independent on the basis that he or she:

12.2.1 did not design or implement the Compliance Program;

12.2.2 is not a present or past staff member or director of Multimedia;

12.2.3 has not acted and does not act for, and does not consult and has not consulted to, Multimedia in any competition and consumer law matters, other than performing Reviews pursuant to the Court Order; and

12.2.4 has no significant shareholding or other interests in Multimedia.

12.3 Evidence - Multimedia will use its best endeavours to ensure that each Review is conducted on the basis that the Reviewer has access to all relevant sources of information in Multimedia’s possession or control, including without limitation:

12.3.1 the ability to make enquiries of any officers, employees, representatives, and agents of Multimedia;

12.3.2 documents relating to the Risk Assessment, including the Risk Assessment Report;

12.3.3 documents relating to Multimedia’s Compliance Program, including documents relevant to Multimedia’s Compliance Policy, Complaints Handling System, Staff Training and induction program; and

12.3.4 any reports made by the Compliance Officer to the Board or senior management regarding Multimedia’s Compliance Program.

12.4 Multimedia will ensure that a Review is completed within one year of the Commencement Date, and that a subsequent Review is completed within each year for 3 years.

Compliance Reports

13. Multimedia will use its best endeavours to ensure that within 30 days of a Review, the Reviewer includes the following findings of the Review in a report to Multimedia (Compliance Report):

13.1 whether the Compliance Program of Multimedia includes all the elements detailed in paragraphs 1-12 above and if not, what elements need to be included or further developed;

13.2 whether the Compliance Program adequately covers the parties and areas identified in the Risk Assessment, and if not, what needs to be further addressed;

13.3 whether the staff training and induction is effective, and if not, what aspects need to be further developed;

13.4 whether Multimedia’s Complaints Handling System is effective, and if not, what aspects need to be further developed;

13.5 whether there are any material deficiencies in Multimedia’s Compliance Program, or whether there are or have been instances of material non-compliance with the Compliance Program (Material Failure), and if so, recommendations for rectifying the Material Failure/s1.

1“Material failure” means a failure that is non-trivial and which is ongoing or continued for a significant period of time, to (i) incorporate a requirement of the Court Order in the design of the Compliance Program, for example, if a Complaints Handling System did not provide an mechanism for responding to complaints; or (ii) comply with a fundamental obligation in the implementation of the Compliance Program, for example if no staff training has been conducted within the Annual Review period.

Multimedia’s response to Compliance Reports

14. Multimedia will ensure that the Compliance Officer, within 14 days of receiving the Compliance Report:

14.1 provides the Compliance Report to the Board or relevant governing body;

14.2 where a Material Failure has been identified by the Reviewer in the Compliance Report, provides a report to the Board or relevant governing body identifying how Multimedia can implement any recommendations made by the Reviewer in the Compliance Report to rectify the Material Failure;

15. Multimedia will implement promptly and with due diligence any recommendations made by the Reviewer in the Compliance Report to address a Material Failure.

Reporting Material Failures to the ACCC

16. Where a Material Failure has been identified by the Reviewer in the Compliance Report, Multimedia will:

16.1 provide a copy of the Compliance Report to the ACCC within 30 days of the Board or relevant governing body receiving the Compliance Report; and

16.2 inform the ACCC of any steps that have been taken to implement the recommendations made by the Reviewer in the Compliance Report; or

16.3 otherwise outline the steps Multimedia proposes to take to implement the recommendations and will then inform the ACCC once those steps have been implemented.

Provision of Compliance Program documents to the ACCC

17. Multimedia will maintain a record of and store all documents relating to and constituting the Compliance Program for a period not less than 3 years.

18. If requested by the ACCC during the period of 3 years following the Commencement Date Multimedia will, at its own expense, cause to be produced and provided to the ACCC copies of all documents constituting the Compliance Program, including:

18.1 the Compliance Policy;

18.2 the Risk Assessment Report;

18.3 an outline of the Complaints Handling System;

18.4 Staff Training materials and induction materials;

18.5 all Compliance Reports that have been completed at the time of the request;

18.6 copies of the reports to the Board and/or senior management referred to in paragraphs 12 and 14.

ACCC Recommendations

19. Multimedia will implement promptly and with due diligence any recommendations that the ACCC may make that the ACCC deems reasonably necessary to ensure that Multimedia maintains and continues to implement the Compliance Program in accordance with the requirements of the Court Order.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

There are few cases concerning penalties for contravention of s 36(3), or its predecessor provision in the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) ss 58(b) or 75AZL(3) (which attracted a penalty five times lower before 2002). Penalties for a contravention of s 36(3) are also likely to vary greatly. In circumstances involving a related breach of s 36(4), albeit involving an individual (with a maximum penalty five times lower), penalties have been imposed which range from $10,000 for each contravention (see Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Chopra [2015] FCA 539). In relation to corporations, the circumstances can even vary within individual cases such as where the period of contraventions spans different penalties regimes. In one case, Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Chubb Security Australia Pty Ltd [2004] FCA 1750, Bennett J imposed penalties for a large number of contraventions involving similar provisions but spanning periods of time with different maximum penalties. Her Honour imposed penalties of 20% of the maximum penalty at the relevant time but discounted that amount to reach a conclusion in relation to the penalties with the same maximum as the current legislation of around $90,000 per contravention.Conclusion on penalties Multimedia submitted that I should impose a single penalty of $85,000. That submission was based, in part, upon the assumption that there were either two or three courses of conduct. Even then, Multimedia did not explain how it had arrived at this penalty for each of the courses of conduct. Having regard to the need for general deterrence, a penalty of $85,000 is well below that which I consider to be appropriate in all the circumstances of this case for all of the contraventions. In contrast, the ACCC submitted that total penalties of $355,000 should be imposed, in the following way for the contraventions of the Australian Consumer Law:(1)$175,000 for the contravention with respect to Bethanie’s;(2)$40,000 for the course of conduct giving rise to the contraventions of s 29(1)(g) with respect to Corben Chiropractic;(3)$60,000 for the course of conduct giving rise to the contraventions of s 36(3) for Corben Chiropractic;(4)$40,000 for the contravention of s 29(1)(g) with respect to Color Studio; and(5)$40,000 for the contravention of s 36(3) with respect to Color Studio. As I have explained, the ACCC was correct to treat each of the matters above as involving a separate course of conduct. However, having regard to all of the circumstances including the extent of all the mitigating factors, I consider that an overall penalty of $355,000 exceeds the appropriate award. The total overall penalty that I consider appropriate is $230,000. The appropriate penalties are as follows:(1)$110,000 for the contravention with respect to Bethanie’s;(2)$25,000 for the course of conduct giving rise to the contraventions of s 29(1)(g) with respect to Corben Chiropractic;(3)$40,000 for the course of conduct giving rise to the contraventions of s 36(3) for Corben Chiropractic;(4)$25,000 for the contravention of s 29(1)(g) with respect to Color Studio; and(5)$30,000 for the contravention of s 36(3) with respect to Color Studio.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Multimedia’s direct profit is unlikely to be any more than this. As I have explained, I do not accept that all of these amounts were paid to Multimedia’s sales representatives. Some was withheld from their commission. But the ultimate direct benefit to Multimedia from these contraventions was very small.Cooperation and contrition Multimedia, through its legal representatives, and through Mr Corsbie, has expressed contrition for its contraventions. As I have explained, I accept that Mr Corsbie’s contrition is genuine and that it was respectful. Multimedia also relied upon a number of other matters as demonstration of its contrition. One matter was its refunding of the money paid by the customers involved in the contraventions, as well as two others about whom no finding of contravention was made. I take into account the refunds as evidence of contrition (and also as ameliorating the customers’ losses and Multimedia’s gains). But, as evidence of contrition, it is significant that the refunds of those three small businesses with which this litigation is concerned came only after this litigation had been commenced and after a lengthy delay for those businesses and, in the case of Bethanie’s, after a debt collector affiliated with Multimedia had been engaged. More significant both as evidence of contrition, and as a factor to be considered in its own right, is the considerable cooperation that Multimedia provided to the ACCC in these proceedings. Multimedia settled these proceedings, admitted liability, and agreed to all remedies proposed except the amount of penalty and possibly costs of the penalty hearing. The settlement of the proceedings might have come after some preparation had been completed but the ACCC also did not press some allegations of contravention. Multimedia admitted many of the facts which were the subject of this proceeding and accepted responsibility for all the contraventions. It undertook to pay a substantial penalty although, as I explain below, the penalty falls some way below that which I consider to be appropriate. As I have explained. Multimedia also gave a substantial undertaking under s 87B of the Competition and Consumer Act. Its cooperation was substantial and is very significant. At one point in written submissions, the ACCC suggested that a discount for cooperation of 5% should be given. Senior counsel quite properly withdrew that submission. If the discount for cooperation in this case were to be quantified it would be considerably larger than 5%. But the proper approach is not for a numerical amount to be assigned to any factor. It is the process of instinctive synthesis that I have described.Consequential loss of profit by reason of adverse publicity Multimedia submitted that adverse publicity surrounding its conduct led to a significant decline in customers and a loss of profit. The ACCC submitted that, as a matter of principle, this was not a mitigating factor and that, in any event, the evidence before the Court did not establish any causal effect between adverse publicity and any decline in customers or loss of profit.