FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Zen Telecom Pty Ltd [2014] FCA 1049
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Zen Telecom... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2014] FCA 1049
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The Court exercised its discretion in approving the consent orders and considered the relevant facts and factors. It found that the proposed declarations and other orders constituted an appropriate sanction for the admitted contraventions and would ensure Zen Telecom understood it should not engage in such conduct in the future. The orders were also intended to send a message of general deterrence to the community. The Court referred to relevant authorities in exercising its discretion and was satisfied that the orders conformed with legal principle.
Orders
Orders of the court
Injunctions
1. Zen Telecom be restrained for a period of three (3) years from the date of this order, whether by itself or its servants or agents or otherwise howsoever from making a representation, expressly or impliedly, that any telemarketing call from or on behalf of Zen Telecom is a call made on behalf of:
(a) Telstra or a company associated with Telstra; or
(b) any other telecommunications company,
unless Zen Telecom has authority from that company to make telemarketing calls on its behalf.
2. Zen Telecom be restrained, for a period of three (3) years from the date of this order, whether by itself or by its servants or agents or otherwise howsoever, from negotiating by telephone an unsolicited consumer agreement (as defined in the ACL) to supply telecommunications services to a consumer unless it provides to the consumer all agreement documents (within the meaning of s 78(2) of the ACL) within five business days of the making of the agreement or such further time as agreed with the consumer.
3. Zen Telecom be restrained, for a period of three (3) years from the date of this order, whether by itself or by its servants or agents or otherwise howsoever, from entering into an unsolicited consumer agreement (as defined in the ACL) to supply telecommunications services to a consumer unless the agreement document (within the meaning of s 78(2) of the ACL) given to the consumer in relation to the agreement:
(a) on its front page includes a notice that:
(i) conspicuously and prominently informs the consumer of their rights to terminate the agreement;
(ii) conspicuously and prominently sets out the following information:
(A) the text "Important Notice to the Consumer";
(B) the text "You have a right to cancel this agreement within 10 business days from and including the day after you signed or received this agreement";
(C) the text "Details about your additional rights to cancel this agreement are set out in the information attached to this agreement";
(b) is accompanied by a notice that can be used by the consumer to terminate the agreement;
(c) conspicuously and prominently informs the consumer of Zen Telecom’s business address (not being a post box); and
(d) informs the consumer of the prohibition on Zen Telecom supplying telecommunications services under the agreement during the period of 10 business days starting at the start of the first business day after the day on which the agreement document relating to the agreement was given to them.
4. Zen Telecom be restrained, for a period of three (3) years from the date of this order, whether by itself or by its servants or agents or otherwise howsoever, from supplying pursuant to an unsolicited consumer agreement (as defined in the ACL) negotiated by telephone, telecommunications services to consumers within a period of 10 business days starting at the start of the first business day after the day on which the agreement document relating to the agreement was given to them.
Pecuniary Penalties
5. Zen Telecom pay to the Commonwealth of Australia a total pecuniary penalty of $225,000 in respect of the acts or omissions relating to Zen Telecom’s contraventions of ss 29(1)(g) and (h), 78, 79 and 86 of the ACL and the pecuniary penalty be paid in the following twelve instalments:
(a) $18,750 within 1 month of the date of this order;
(b) $18,750 within 2 months of the date of this order;
(c) $18,750 within 3 months of the date of this order;
(d) $18,750 within 4 months of the date of this order;
(e) $18,750 within 5 months of the date of this order;
(f) $18,750 within 6 months of the date of this order;
(g) $18,750 within 7 months of the date of this order;
(h) $18,750 within 8 months of the date of this order;
(i) $18,750 within 9 months of the date of this order;
(j) $18,750 within 10 months of the date of this order;
(k) $18,750 within 11 months of the date of this order; and
(l) $18,750 within one year of the date of this order.
Non-punitive Orders
Compliance Program
6. Zen Telecom will at its own expense:
(a) establish, within three months of the date of this order, a Competition and Consumer Law Compliance Program (Compliance Program) which meets the requirements set out in Annexure A and maintain the Compliance Program for three years from the date on which it is established; or
(b) if it already maintains an existing Compliance Program:
(i) within three months of the date of this order, review the existing Compliance Program and make any amendments necessary to ensure that it meets the requirements set out in Annexure A; and
(ii) maintain this program for at least three years from the date on which the amendments referred to in order (6)(b)(i) are made.
Corrective Advertising
7. Zen Telecom will:
(a) within 28 days of the date of this order, take all reasonable steps to cause to be published, at its own expense, a corrective notice to be published in a weekday edition of each of The Courier Mail (Queensland), Sydney Morning Herald (New South Wales), Herald Sun (Victoria), Mercury (Tasmania), The Advertiser (South Australia), The West Australian (Western Australia) and Northern Territory News (Northern Territory) newspapers, which is in the form and terms of Annexure B to this application, and take all reasonable steps to ensure that the corrective notice:
(i) is placed within the first 10 pages of the newspaper;
(ii) is of the following height and width dimensions for each newspaper:
(A) The Courier Mail – 15.6cm x 12.9cm;
(B) Sydney Morning Herald – 18.6cm x 12.9cm;
(C) Herald Sun – 13.9cm x 12.9cm;
(D) Mercury – 15cm x 9.6cm;
(E) The Advertiser – 15.6cm x 12.9cm;
(F) The West Australian – no less than one quarter of a page; and
(G) Northern Territory News 9 x 17.5;
(iii) has a banner font of sans serif 12 point bold;
(iv) has a headline font of 12 point bold;
(v) has a body text font of no less than 11 point;
(vi) has the applicant’s and Commonwealth logos of at least 25 millimetres in height and centred; and
(vii) has a baseline text of at least 8 point and centred;
(b) within 28 days of the date of this order, publish or cause to be published a corrective notice in the form and terms of Annexure B, on each of its websites, and use all reasonable steps to ensure that the website corrective notice:
(i) is accessible by a prominent one-click link displayed in the top third of the homepage of each Zen Telecom website entitled “Corrective Notice - Breaches of the Australian Consumer Law” and satisfies the following specifications:
(A) the words “CORRECTIVE NOTICE - BREACHES OF THE AUSTRALIAN CONSUMER LAW” are to be in uppercase, 18 point, bold, black, sans serif font on a white background, centred and in a black bordered box;
(B) the words “Click here for further information” are to be 14 point, black, sans serif font on a white background and centred below the words “CORRECTIVE NOTICE - BREACHES OF THE AUSTRALIAN CONSUMER LAW” in the same bordered box;
(C) the bordered box is to be at least 255 pixels wide by 60 pixels high; and
(D) the bordered box and its contents, including white space, is to operate in the form of a one-click hyperlink to the website notice;
(ii) is substantially the same as the notice in Annexure B including font and formatting, and:
(A) has a headline font of no less than 12 point, bold, black, sans serif font on a white background;
(B) has a body text font of no less than 12 point, bold, black, sans serif font on a white background;
(C) is of at least 540 pixels wide by 500 pixels high;
(D) has a black border that is 3 pixels wide;
(E) Zen Telecom’s, applicant’s and Commonwealth logos are to be in colour, centred, and at least 25 millimetres high;
(F) is to be displayed on a stand-alone webpage that is coded in standard “HTML” format;
(G) is not displayed as a “pop-up” or “pop-under” window; and
(H) is maintained for a period of no less than 90 days from the date of this order;
(c) prior to the publication of the corrective notices in accordance with orders (7)(a) and (7)(b):
(i) establish an email address by which consumers who are responding to the corrective notices can contact Zen Telecom;
(ii) establish a 1800 telephone number by which consumers who are responding to the corrective notices can contact Zen Telecom;
(iii) appoint a contact officer to deal with any telephone calls and correspondence received by Zen Telecom in response to the corrective notices; and
(d) maintain the email address, 1800 telephone number and contact officer for a period that is not less than 120 days from the date of this order;
(e) provide to the applicant within 60 days of the date of this order a copy of the corrective notices published in accordance with orders (7)(a) and (7)(b);
(f) provide to the applicant between 120 and 140 days after the date of this order a letter signed by the proper officer of Zen Telecom setting out the following in relation to any consumer who contacted Zen Telecom in response to the corrective notices referred to in this order:
(i) the consumer’s name and address;
(ii) the date upon which the consumer contacted Zen Telecom;
(iii) the reason the consumer gave for contacting Zen Telecom;
(iv) the date of the consumer entering into an agreement with Zen Telecom;
(v) whether the consumer purported to exercise their cooling off rights; and
(vi) the details of Zen Telecom’s actions in response to being contacted by that consumer, including whether or not the agreement was terminated, and if not, the reason why not.
Costs
8. Zen Telecom pay to the applicant a contribution towards its costs of, and incidental to, these proceedings in the amount of $25,000 and the costs be paid in the following twelve instalments:
(a) $2,083.33 within 1 month of the date of this order;
(b) $2,083.33 within 2 months of the date of this order;
(c) $2,083.33 within 3 months of the date of this order;
(d) $2,083.33 within 4 months of the date of this order;
(e) $2,083.33 within 5 months of the date of this order;
(f) $2,083.33 within 6 months of the date of this order;
(g) $2,083.33 within 7 months of the date of this order;
(h) $2,083.33 within 8 months of the date of this order;
(i) $2,083.33 within 9 months of the date of this order;
(j) $2,083.33 within 10 months of the date of this order;
(k) $2,083.33 within 11 months of the date of this order; and
(l) $2,083.33 within one year of the date of this order
Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In deciding whether the consent orders conform with legal principle, the parties say that the Court is entitled to treat the consent of Zen Telecom as an admission of all facts necessary or appropriate to the granting of relief. See Thomson Australian Holdings Proprietary Limited v Trade Practices Commission (1981) 148 CLR 150 at 164.Declarations The Court has a wide discretion to make declarations under s 21 of the Federal Court of Australia Act. See Forster v Jododex [1972] HCA 61; (1972) 127 CLR 421 at 437‑8. The parties submit that in the circumstances of this case, it is appropriate for the Court to indicate its disapproval of Zen Telecom’s conduct by making the declarations sought. They say the proposed declarations sufficiently identify how and why the impugned conduct contravenes the ACL. Further, they contend that it is in the public interest for the ACCC to have the declarations made and Zen Telecom is the proper contradictor in this case. As the joint submissions indicate, these declarations serve to record the Court’s disapproval of the contravening conduct, deter other corporations from engaging in such conduct, vindicate the ACCC’s claim that Zen Telecom contravened the ACL, assist the ACCC to carry out its duties, and inform consumers of the dangers arising from the contravening conduct. The parties submit that Zen Telecom has admitted that it contravened important consumer protection provisions and has done so in the field of telecommunications, an area of commerce which has proved especially prone to breaches of consumer protections. The parties draw on Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Dataline.Net.Au Pty Ltd [2007] FCAFC 146; (2007) 161 FCR 513 at [92] and say that it is open to the Court to make declarations based on admissions, as distinct from evidence, and in any event, the statement of agreed facts and admissions provides such evidence.Injunctions The parties submit that the Court should order injunctions for three (3) years to restrain Zen Telecom from engaging in certain conduct, namely:1.making a representation, expressly or impliedly, that any telemarketing call from or on behalf of Zen Telecom is a call made on behalf of Telstra or any other telecommunications company, unless it has authority from that company to make the telemarketing calls on its behalf;2.negotiating by telephone an unsolicited consumer agreement to supply telecommunications services unless it provides to a consumer all agreement documents within five business days of the making of the agreement;3.entering into an unsolicited consumer agreement to supply telecommunications services, unless the agreement document given to the consumer includes all relevant information required by the ACL;4.supplying, pursuant to an unsolicited consumer agreement negotiated by telephone, telecommunications services to consumers within a period of 10 business days starting at the first business day after the agreement documents were given to them.