Singtel Optus Pty Ltd v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 42 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Singtel Optus Pty Ltd v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission [2012] FCAFC 20

Citation: Singtel Optus Pty Ltd v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission [2012] FCAFC 20
Appeal from: Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Singtel Optus Pty Ltd (No. 4) [2011] FCA 761
Parties: SINGTEL OPTUS PTY LTD (ACN 052 833 208) v AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION AND CONSUMER COMMISSION
File number: NSD 1245 of 2011
Judges: KEANE CJ, FINN & GILMOUR JJ
Date of judgment: 7 March 2012
Date of corrigendum: 7 June 2012
Catchwords: TRADE PRACTICES – Misleading and deceptive conduct –Enforcement and Remedies - Penalties
Legislation: Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth)
Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth)
Cases cited: ACCC v MSY Technology Pty Ltd (No 2) (2011) 279 ALR 609 cited
ACCC v Singtel Optus Pty Ltd [2011] FCA 87 referred to
ACCC v Telstra Corporation Ltd (2010) 188 FCR 238 cited
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Singtel Optus Pty Ltd(No. 1) [2010] FCA 1177 referred to
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Singtel Optus Pty Ltd (No. 2) [2010] FCA 1200 referred to
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Singtel Optus Pty Ltd (No. 3) [2010] FCA 1272 referred to
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Singtel Optus Pty Ltd (No. 4) [2011] FCA 761 referred to
House v The King (1936) 55 CLR 499 cited
Markarian v The Queen (2005) 228 CLR 357 referred to
Queen v Tait (1979) 46 FLR 386 cited
Trade Practices Commission v Optus Communications Pty Ltd and Anor (1996) 64 FCR 326 referred to
Date of hearing: 14 February 2012
Place: Sydney
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 72
Counsel for the Appellant: Mr J Gleeson SC with Ms D Bampton
Solicitor for the Appellant: Minter Ellison
Counsel for the Respondent: Mr N Williams SC with Mr D Tynan
Solicitor for the Respondent: Australian Government Solicitor

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Singtel Optus Pty Ltd v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission [2012] FCAFC 20 

CORRIGENDUM

1.In paragraph 58 of the Reasons for Judgment, in the first sentence, the reference to “s 76E(2)(c)” should read “s 76E(2)(a)”

I certify that the preceding one (1) numbered paragraph is a true copy of the Corrigendum to the Reasons for Judgment herein of the Honourable Keane CJ, Finn & Gilmour JJ.

Associate:

Dated:       7 June 2012


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

NSD 1245 of 2011

ON APPEAL FROM THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
BETWEEN:

SINGTEL OPTUS PTY LTD (ACN 052 833 208)
Appellant

AND:

AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION AND CONSUMER COMMISSION
Respondent

JUDGES:

KEANE CJ, FINN & GILMOUR JJ

DATE OF ORDER:

7 MARCH 2012

WHERE MADE:

PERTH (HEARD IN SYDNEY)

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1. The appeal be allowed and the penalty set aside.

2.In lieu thereof, that Optus pay to the Commonwealth a penalty of $3,610,000.

Note:Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Singtel Optus Pty Ltd v Australian Competition and Consumer... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] FCAFC 20
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Singtel Optus Pty Ltd appealed against a penalty imposed by the primary judge in the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Singtel Optus Pty Ltd (No. 4) [2011] FCA 761 judgment. The primary judge had found that Optus had contravened s 55A of the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) by engaging in misleading and deceptive conduct through various advertisements. The Australian Competition and Consumer Commission sought a civil penalty for each contravention, with the primary judge finding 11 contraventions and imposing a total penalty of $5.26 million. Optus appealed against the penalty, arguing that the primary judge's discretionary judgment was affected by error of fact or principle. Optus contended that the primary judge misunderstood the facts of the case, particularly regarding the awareness of Optus' in-house legal personnel of the enforceable undertaking, and therefore erred in concluding that Optus had failed to take compliance seriously. Optus also argued that the primary judge erred in treating each advertisement as a separate contravention and not giving due weight to the lack of harm caused to consumers.

The Court considered whether the primary judge's discretionary judgment was affected by error of fact or principle. In doing so, the Court noted that it would not interfere with the sentence imposed merely because it was of the view that the sentence was insufficient or excessive. The Court would only interfere if it was shown that the sentencing judge was in error in acting on a wrong principle or in misunderstanding or wrongly assessing some salient feature of the evidence. The Court found that the primary judge's conclusions regarding the lack of awareness and understanding of the enforceable undertaking within Optus' legal department were not supported by the evidence. The Court also found that the primary judge erred in treating each advertisement as a separate contravention and not giving due weight to the lack of harm caused to consumers. Accordingly, the Court allowed the appeal and set aside the penalty, ordering that Optus pay a penalty of $3,610,000 to the Commonwealth.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal be allowed and the penalty set aside.

2. In lieu thereof, that Optus pay to the Commonwealth a penalty of $3,610,000.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

His Honour’s findings in the corrective orders judgment were not challenged by Optus in its appeal to this Court in respect of the penalty imposed by the primary judge.THE PENALTY JUDGMENT In the judgment as to penalty, Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Singtel Optus Pty Ltd (No. 4) [2011] FCA 761 (the penalty judgment), his Honour observed, in the case of the three television commercials, that the disclaimer as to speed limiting of the broadband internet service was “essentially invisible”. In the case of the print advertisements, the flyers and the billboard, it was ineffective: [18], [21] and [26]. Optus had previously been found by the Court to have engaged in similar conduct: Trade Practices Commission v Optus Communications Pty Ltd and Anor (1996) 64 FCR 326 (per Tamberlin J) and ACCC v Singtel Optus Pty Ltd [2011] FCA 87 (per North J). In the latter case, North J determined that the expression “Unlimited broadband” was misleading. References that qualified that headline representations were in “very small print” or worse. The advertisements ran at various dates in April – July 2010. In the penalty judgment, the primary judge held that the contemporaneity of the conduct dealt with in North J’s decision was a “substantial exacerbation”: [52]. Section 55A of the Act proscribes conduct which is “liable to mislead the public as to … the quantity of any services”. It is contained in Div 1 Pt V of the Act. As a result, the contravention of the section engaged the Court’s power to order a civil penalty under s 76E of the Act. The ACCC sought the imposition of such a penalty. Under s 76E(3) of the Act, the maximum penalty for each contravention was $1.1 million. The primary judge proceeded on the footing that there had been 11 contraventions, one for each advertisement in each medium. On that footing the maximum total penalty might have been $12.1 million. In assessing the penalty, the primary judge took as his starting point the maximum penalty of $12.1 million, “which it would [only] be appropriate to apply in the worst case” and adopting the “instinctive synthesis” approach discussed in Markarian v The Queen (2005) 228 CLR 357, fixed upon a total penalty of $5.26 million to “capture the total wrong-doing implicit in the contraventions” (at [80]). His Honour broke down the penalties imposed in relation to each advertisement in each medium at [79]: In fixing the penalty the primary judge expressed special concern that Optus was subject to an enforceable undertaking under s 87B of the Act in which Optus agreed to desist from making headline representations in advertisements that contravened the Act. His Honour regarded Optus’ failure to comply with the undertaking as an indication that Optus did not take seriously its obligation to comply with the Act. On that basis, his Honour concluded, condign punishment was warranted. THE APPEAL Optus appeals to this Court against the penalty judgment, arguing that the primary judge’s discretion miscarried in various ways. First, his Honour is said to have erred in finding as a fact that Optus’ in-house legal Counsel responsible for approving the “Think Bigger” and “Supersonic” plans were unaware of the undertaking, that there was a lack of understanding of the undertaking within Optus’ legal department, and that Optus did not take compliance with its obligations under the undertaking seriously. Optus argues that this factual error infects the process of “instinctive synthesis” by which his Honour arrived at the penalty he ultimately imposed. Secondly, Optus argues that the primary judge erred in regarding each advertisement as a single contravention and failing to group together advertisements which displayed the same vice. Thirdly, Optus argues that his Honour did not give due weight to his finding that little loss or damage had been suffered by consumers due to the contravening conduct. Fourthly, the primary judge is said to have erred in proceeding on the basis that considerations of general and specific deterrence justified stripping Optus of a substantial portion of the profits it could expect to earn from the plans in question.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

His Honour proceeded to fix the penalty on the footing that there were 11 separate contraventions. He said at [77]:I do not think the vice in each advertisement was the same. The deceptions were not identical and the breadth of exposure for each advertisement differed. The television commercials were, in terms of deception, much worse than the other elements in the campaign. The flyers and newspaper advertisements were less, although still, serious. The billboard even less so. On the other hand, the Think Bigger internet commercial was by far the most persistent format. Less serious was the Supersonic internet commercial, by reason, in part, of its duration. I conclude therefore that each advertisement represented a distinct item of conduct separate from, and different to, the others. It would not be consistent with the overall seriousness of the matter to treat this as but a single contravention just as it would be manifestly excessive to proceed on the basis that each individual instantiation of the commercials was itself a contravention. Consistently with what I regard as the objective seriousness of the matter I approach the question of penalty on the basis that there were 11 contraventions, one for each advertisement in each media.CONSIDERATION The penalty under challenge was imposed in the exercise of the discretion vested by the Act in the primary judge. The first question is not whether this Court considers that the penalty is excessive but whether the discretionary judgment of the primary judge is affected by error of fact or principle: see House v The King (1936) 55 CLR 499 at 505, [42]. In The Queen v Tait (1979) 46 FLR 386 at 388 Brennan, Deane and Gallop JJ explained that:[A]n appellate court does not interfere with the sentence imposed merely because it is of the view that that sentence is insufficient or excessive. It interferes only if it be shown that the sentencing judge was in error in acting on a wrong principle or in misunderstanding or in wrongly assessing some salient feature of the evidence. The error may appear in what the sentencing judge said in the proceedings, or the sentence itself may be so excessive or inadequate to manifest such error. Factual error? Optus contends that the primary judge misunderstood the facts of the case in finding that Optus’ in-house legal personnel Mr Derber and Ms Booth, were not aware of the undertaking. This finding led to the conclusions that there was a “lack of basic understanding of the undertaking within the legal department” and that Optus had “failed to take compliance seriously”. Optus emphasises that it was this conclusion that his Honour spoke of as calling for condign punishment. Optus argues that these findings were not available on the evidence, and, indeed, were not sought by the ACCC at trial. In challenging these findings, Optus tendered an affidavit of Charles Alexander, Optus’ solicitor on the account, as additional evidence on appeal. The ACCC did not object to the reception of this evidence.