FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Mazda Australia Pty Ltd (No 3) [2024] FCA 83
ORDERS
VID 1169…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Mazda Austr... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2024] FCA 83
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
Orders
Orders of the court
Pecuniary penalties
1. Pursuant to section 224(1) of the Australian Consumer Law at Schedule 2 of the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) (ACL), Mazda is to pay to the Commonwealth of Australia forthwith the total sum of $11.5 million by way of pecuniary penalty by reason of Mazda’s contraventions of section 29(1)(m) of the ACL as declared by this court on 21 March 2022.
Compliance program
2. Pursuant to section 246(2)(b) of the ACL, Mazda at its own expense is to:
(a) within 90 days, implement the Competition and Consumer Compliance Program (Compliance Program) measures in the terms of Appendix A to this order; and
(b) maintain the Compliance Program measures referred to in order 4(a) for three years from the date on which they are implemented.
Injunctive relief
3. Pursuant to section 232 of the ACL, Mazda be restrained, whether by itself, its officers, employees, agents or otherwise, for a period of 5 years from the date of the order, from, in trade or commerce, making false or misleading representations in the course of communication with consumers, concerning the existence or effect of consumer guarantees under Part 3-2 of the ACL, and the rights or remedies available under Part 5-4 of the ACL, and whether it had reasonable grounds for forming an opinion that the consumer was not entitled to a refund or replacement vehicle at no cost to them under the consumer guarantee provisions of the ACL when it had no reasonable grounds for forming such an opinion. (For the avoidance of doubt, the word “agents” in this order does not include any Mazda dealer).
Disclosure order
4. Pursuant to section 246(2)(c) of the ACL, Mazda, at its own expense and within 14 days, is to provide a disclosure notice describing in the terms of Appendix B, the court’s findings of contravention and the effect of the court’s final orders in this proceeding by sending it by email to all Mazda dealers.
5. Within 21 days, Mazda file and serve an affidavit verifying its compliance with order 4.
Adverse publicity order
6. Pursuant to section 247 of the ACL, Mazda, at its own expense and within 14 days, publish a notice for a period of 90 days on the Mazda Support page (at https://www.mazda.com.au/owners/help-and-support/ (under the heading, “Mazda Recalls”)) of the Mazda website located at https://mazda.com.au/ in the terms of Appendix C to this order.
Non-party consumer redress
7. Pursuant to section 239 of the ACL, Mazda is to pay non-party redress as set out below:
(a) within 14 days, the ACCC is to contact each of the consumers referred to in Appendix D to this order in writing (Relevant Consumers):
(i) advising them of the making of these orders and the amount proposed to be paid to them by way of redress;
(ii) inviting their written acceptance of the redress amount within four weeks of the date of the letter; and
(iii) seeking their payment account details;
(b) within 7 days of the expiry of the four week period referred to in order 7(a)(ii), the ACCC is to contact Mazda in writing advising which of the Relevant Consumers have communicated their acceptance of the redress pursuant to order 7(a)(ii), and the total amount of redress due to be paid (Funds);
(c) within 14 days of the ACCC complying with order 7(b), Mazda is to pay the Funds to the ACCC;
(d) within 14 days of Mazda complying with order 7(c), the ACCC is to distribute to each of the Relevant Consumers who have communicated their acceptance of the redress the amount of the Funds due to be paid in accordance with Appendix D to these orders.
Costs
8. Mazda pay to the Commonwealth of Australia 70% of the ACCC’s total costs of the proceeding up to and including the date of making these orders in a lump sum in an amount to be determined by the Registrar and in accordance with such directions as the Registrar considers appropriate, such costs to be payable forthwith after fixing.
Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.
APPENDIX A
COMPETITION AND CONSUMER COMPLIANCE PROGRAM
LEVEL 4
Mazda Australia Pty Ltd (ACN 004 690 804) (Mazda) will implement the following requirements into its competition and consumer compliance program (Compliance Program):
Complaints Handling System
1. Within two months of the orders of the Federal Court of Australia dated 14 February 2024 (Commencement Date), Mazda will develop and implement procedures for identifying, classifying, storing and responding to competition and consumer law complaints (Complaints Handling System).
2. Mazda will use its best endeavours to ensure the Complaints Handling System is consistent with the Australian/New Zealand Standard AS/NZS 10002:2022 Guidelines for complaint management in organizations, as in force or existing at the Commencement Date, tailored as required to Mazda’s circumstances.
3. Mazda will ensure that staff and customers are made aware of the Complaints Handling System.
Whistleblower Protection
4. Mazda will:
4.1. ensure that it has whistleblower protection mechanisms to protect those coming forward with competition and consumer law complaints.
4.2. use its best endeavours to ensure that these mechanisms are consistent with good practice guidance identified in ASIC Regulatory Guide 270: Whistleblower policies, as in force or existing at the Commencement Date, tailored as required to Mazda’s circumstances.
Compliance Review
5. Within one year of the Compliance Program coming into effect, Mazda will, at its own expense, cause an annual review of the Compliance Program (Review) to be carried out in accordance with each of the following requirements:
5.1. Scope of Review – the Review should be broad and rigorous enough to provide Mazda and the ACCC with:
5.1.1. a verification that Mazda has in place a Compliance Program that complies with each of the requirements detailed in paragraphs 1 to 4 of this Annexure; and
5.1.2. the Compliance Reports detailed at paragraph 6 of this Annexure.
5.2. Independence of Review – Mazda will ensure that each Review is carried out by a suitably qualified, independent compliance professional with expertise in consumer law (Reviewer). The Reviewer will qualify as independent on the basis that he or she:
5.2.1. did not design or implement the Compliance Program;
5.2.2. is not a present or past staff member or director of Mazda;
5.2.3. has not acted and does not act for, and does not consult and has not consulted to, Mazda in any consumer law matters, other than performing Reviews; and
5.2.4. has no significant shareholding or other interests in Mazda.
5.3. Evidence – Mazda will use its best endeavours to ensure that each Review is conducted on the basis that the Reviewer has access to all relevant sources of information in Mazda’s possession or control, including without limitation:
5.3.1. the ability to make enquiries of any officers, employees, representatives and agents of Mazda;
5.3.2. documents relating to the review of Mazda’s customer complaint processes undertaken by Mr Michael Robins in 2022 (Risk Assessment);
5.3.3. documents relating to Mazda’s Compliance Program, including documents relevant to Mazda’s consumer law compliance policy, Complaints Handling System, and consumer law staff training and induction (Staff Training and Induction); and
5.3.4. any reports made by Mr Robins to Mazda’s Board or senior management regarding Mazda’s Compliance Program.
5.4. Following the completion of the initial Review, Mazda will ensure that subsequent Reviews are completed within two years and three years of the Compliance Program coming into effect.
Compliance Report
6. Mazda will use its best endeavours to ensure that within 30 days of the completion of a Review, the Reviewer includes the following findings of the Review in a report to Mr Robins, or any other person appointed as compliance officer of Mazda at that time (Compliance Report):
6.1. whether the Compliance Program of Mazda includes all the elements detailed in paragraphs 1 to 4 of this Annexure, and if not, what elements need to be included or further developed;
6.2. whether the Compliance Program adequately covers areas identified in the Risk Assessment, and if not, what needs to be further addressed;
6.3. whether the Staff Training and Induction is effective, and if not, what aspects need to be further developed;
6.4. whether Mazda’s Complaints Handling System is effective, and if not, what aspects need to be further developed;
6.5. whether Mazda is able to provide protections consistent with good practice guidance referred to in paragraph 4.2 of this Annexure for competition and consumer law whistleblowers, and whether staff are aware of the whistleblower protection mechanisms; and
6.6. whether there are any material deficiencies in Mazda’s Compliance Program, or whether there are or have been instances of material non-compliance with the Compliance Program (Material Failure), and if so, recommendations for rectifying the Material Failure.
Mazda’s Response to Compliance Report
7. Mazda will ensure that the Compliance Officer, within 30 days of receiving the Compliance Report:
7.1. provides the Compliance Report to Mazda’s Board or senior management; and
7.2. where a Material Failure has been identified by the Reviewer in the Compliance Report, provides a report to Mazda’s Board or senior management identifying how Mazda can implement any recommendations made by the Reviewer in the Compliance Report to rectify the Material Failure.
8. Mazda will promptly and fully implement any recommendations made by the Reviewer in the Compliance Report to address a Material Failure.
APPENDIX B
Disclosure notice to dealers
CORRECTIVE NOTICE
PUBLISHED BY ORDER OF THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
False and Misleading Statements About Consumer Rights
Following action by the ACCC, the Federal Court of Australia has declared that Mazda Australia Pty Ltd (Mazda) contravened the Australian Consumer Law (ACL) by making false representations to nine consumers:
· concerning the existence or effect of consumer guarantees and the rights or remedies available under the ACL; and
· that it had reasonable grounds for forming the opinion that those consumers who had purchased Mazda vehicles were not entitled to a refund or replacement vehicle at no cost to them under the consumer guarantee provisions of the ACL.
These representations were false. Motor vehicles purchased by Australian consumers come with consumer guarantee rights under the ACL which cannot be excluded.
On 14 February 2024, Justice O’Callaghan of the Federal Court ordered Mazda to pay a penalty of $11.5 million to the Commonwealth for making the false representations referred to above.
Authorised motor vehicle dealers are required to adhere to the consumer guarantees as to goods and services under the ACL. Consumers are entitled to remedies when there is a:
· major failure to comply with a consumer guarantee;
· minor failure to comply with a consumer guarantee that cannot be fixed within a reasonable time; or
· minor failure to comply with a consumer guarantee that can be fixed.
For further information on consumer rights in Australia, visit www.consumerlaw.gov.au and www.accc.gov.au/consumerguarantees.
For further information on the consumer guarantees as they apply to the motor vehicle industry, download the Motor Vehicle Sales and Repairs Guide at: https://www.accc.gov.au/about-us/publications/motor-vehicle-sales-and-repairs-an-industry-guide-to-the-australian-consumer-law
A link to the Federal Court judgment appears here: [hyperlink to be inserted]
APPENDIX C
CORRECTIVE NOTICE
PUBLISHED BY ORDER OF THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
False and Misleading Statements About Consumer Rights
Following action by the ACCC, the Federal Court of Australia has declared that Mazda Australia Pty Ltd (Mazda) contravened the Australian Consumer Law (ACL) by making false representations to nine consumers:
· concerning the existence or effect of consumer guarantees and the rights or remedies available under the ACL; and
· that it had reasonable grounds for forming the opinion that those consumers who had purchased Mazda vehicles were not entitled to a refund or replacement vehicle at no cost to them under the consumer guarantee provisions of the ACL.
These representations were false. Motor vehicles purchased by Australian consumers come with consumer guarantee rights under the ACL which cannot be excluded.
On 14 February 2024, Justice O’Callaghan of the Federal Court ordered Mazda to pay a penalty of $11.5 million to the Commonwealth for making the false representations referred to above.
For further information on consumer rights in Australia, visit www.consumerlaw.gov.au and www.accc.gov.au/consumerguarantees.
A link to the Federal Court judgment appears here: [hyperlink to be inserted]
APPENDIX D
Relevant Consumer
Compensation payment
RC
$5,990
CT and MT
-
SB and KB
$27,650
MG
$14,393
TK and MK
-
LC
$24,408
EG
$9,850
TOTAL
$82,291
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The extent to which the contravener has conceded liability and cooperated with the investigating authority is relevant to determining penalties and typically results in a discount off the penalty that otherwise would have been imposed. This reflects the fact that such discounts increase the likelihood of cooperation in the future by contraveners and free up the ACCC’s resources.Relevant Considerations On the question of the size of the penalties that should be imposed, the ACCC and Mazda were poles apart. The following table summarises the competing positions on the question of penalty: I now turn to deal with the various considerations relevant to the penalties to be imposed in the circumstances of this case.Maximum penalty The contraventions here occurred over an extensive period, namely between June 2017 and June 2019. At a point during that period the maximum penalty changed. Pursuant to item 2 in the table in s 224(3) of the ACL, for the period prior to 1 September 2018, the maximum penalty for a body corporate for each contravention of s 29(1)(m) of the ACL is $1.1 million. Pursuant to ss 224(3) and 224(3A), for the period from 1 September 2018 until 9 November 2023 (when maximum penalty amounts were further increased), the maximum penalty for a body corporate for each such contravention was raised from $1.1 million so as to not exceed the greater of:(a)$10 million; or(b)if the court can determine the value of the benefit that the body corporate has obtained directly or indirectly and that is reasonably attributable to the act or omission—3 times the value of that benefit; or(c)if the court cannot determine the value of that benefit — 10% of the annual turnover of the body corporate during the 12 month period ending at the end of the month in which the act or omission occurred or started to occur. Section 295 provides that the new, higher maximum penalties provided for in s 224(3A) apply only to acts or omissions that occur on or after 1 September 2018. With respect to Mazda’s contraventions on or after 1 September 2018, the ACCC submitted that s 224(3A)(a) applied and did not seek to rely on ss 224(3A)(b) or (c). The parties agreed that there were 49 contraventions of s 29(1)(m), 42 of which occurred before 1 September 2018 and seven occurring after 1 September 2018. The agreed total theoretical maximum penalty is therefore $116.2 million, as set out in the following table: The ACCC’s submissions regarding the nature and extent of the contravening conduct largely consisted of the summary of my findings in the Liability Judgment with respect to each of the consumers that has been set out at [7] to [27] above. Mazda criticised this approach on the basis that it did not “distil or seek to characterise the impugned conduct in a way that indicates where in the available penalty range the court should fix a penalty”. Mazda submitted that the following observations were relevant when considering the nature and extent of the contraventions:(a)While breaches involving misleading or deceptive conduct by their very nature are serious, s 29(1)(m) can be breached in a variety of ways: inadvertently, deliberately, honestly or dishonestly. Merely referring to a breach of the provision is therefore insufficient to properly characterise the nature of the contravention for the purpose of determining the appropriate penalty. (b)there was no finding that s 29(1)(m) was breached deliberately, nor any allegation that Mazda had acted in bad faith or dishonestly (Liability Judgment [147]);(c)the number of consumers (ie nine) affected by the conduct was discrete, and very low in the scheme of the number of Mazda vehicles in operation in Australia at any one time, estimated in the evidence of Mr Robins to be approximately 1 million. Nor was there any “system” or “pattern” case brought against Mazda (or any finding to that effect (Liability Judgment [8]-[9])).(d)In the Liability Judgment, I rejected the contentions that:(i)Mazda did not take consumers’ safety concerns seriously (Liability Judgment [276]; [509]; [855]; [955]); and(ii)Mazda placed unfair or unreasonable commercial pressure on consumers to accept offers; and(e)As to duration, the extent of the contraventions for each course of conduct varied from nine days to five months.