Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Oakmoore Pty Ltd (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 60 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Oakmoore Pty Ltd (No 2) [2018] FCA 1170

File number: QUD 478 of 2016
Judge: GLEESON J
Date of judgment: 13 August 2018
Catchwords:

COMPETITION – collusive arrangement – exclusive dealing – second respondent admitted to contraventions of s 47 of the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) – sixth respondent admitted to being directly and knowingly concerned in third respondent’s contraventions within meaning of s 75B(1)(c) of the Act – enforcement and remedies – application for agreed declarations, pecuniary penalties, non-punitive orders, and disqualification order – whether proposed declarations, penalties and orders appropriate – consideration of principles – proposed declarations and orders made and penalties imposed

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – application for confidentiality orders protecting financial information pursuant to s 37AF of the Federal Court Act 1976 (Cth) on basis of “commercial sensitivity” – consideration of principles – application refused where information not of continuing commercial significance

Legislation:

Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) ss 47, 76, 86C, 86E

Federal Court Act 1976 (Cth) ss 21, 37AE, 37AF, 37AG, 37AJ

Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) ss 47, 76, 86C, 86E)

Cases cited:

Ainsworth v Criminal Justice Commission [1992] HCA 10; (1992) 175 CLR 564

Australian Building and Construction Commissioner v Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union [2017] FCAFC 113; (2017) 254 FCR 68

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v ABB Transmission and Distribution Ltd (No 2) [2002] FCA 559; (2002) 190 ALR 169

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Acquire Learning & Careers Pty Ltd [2017] FCA 602

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Cascade Coal (No 1) [2015] FCA 607

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Cement Australia Pty Ltd [2017] FCAFC 159; (2017) ATPR 42-557

Australian Competition and Consumer Commissionv Chrisco Hampers Australia Limited (No 2) [2016] FCA 144

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Colgate-Palmolive Pty Ltd (No 2) [2016] FCA 528

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union [2006] FCA 1730; (2007) ATPR 42-140

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Econovite Pty Ltd [2003] FCA 964

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Flight Centre Limited (No 3) [2014] FCA 292; (2014) 234 FCR 325

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v MSY Technology Pty Ltd [2012] FCAFC 56; (2012) 201 FCR 378

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Oakmoore Pty Ltd [2018] FCA 1169

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Singapore Airlines Cargo Pte Ltd [2012] FCA 1395

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v TPG Internet Pty Ltd [2013] HCA 54; (2013) 250 CLR 640

Betfair Pty Ltd v Racing New South Wales (No 5) [2009] FCA 1011

BMW Australia Limited v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission [2004] FCAFC 167; (2004) 207 ALR 452

Cahyadi v The Queen [2007] NSWCCA 1; (2007) 168 A Crim R 41

Clean Energy Regulator v MT Solar Pty Ltd [2013] FCA 205

Comcare v Transpacific Industries Pty Ltd [2015] FCA 500

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Oakmoore Pt... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] FCA 1170
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case between the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission and Oakmoore Pty Ltd (No 2) involved an examination of alleged collusive arrangements and exclusive dealing in violation of the Competition and Consumer Act 2010. The court was required to decide on the appropriateness of proposed declarations, pecuniary penalties, non-punitive orders, and a disqualification order. The respondents admitted to various contraventions of the Act, and the Commission sought enforcement and remedies, including confidentiality orders for certain financial information. The legal issues primarily centred on whether the proposed declarations, penalties, and orders were appropriate, considering the principles of consistency and the nature of the contraventions.

The court considered the principles of equality before the law and the consistency in the application of legal principles to determine the appropriate penalties. It noted that while similar contraventions should generally incur similar penalties, the circumstances of each case could differ significantly. The court acknowledged that prior cases could guide matters of principle but could not dictate penalties for different circumstances. The court also evaluated the respondents' cooperation with the investigation and proceedings as a mitigating factor, which often resulted in reduced penalties. After careful consideration, the court decided that the proposed declarations and orders were appropriate, and penalties were imposed accordingly.

The court denied the application for confidentiality orders regarding certain financial information, determining that the information was not of continuing commercial significance. The court ordered Palram Australia to pay a pecuniary penalty of $3,500,000, establish a compliance training program, and contribute to the ACCC's costs. Additionally, Ms Horesh was disqualified from managing corporations for three years. The proceedings against Palram Industries were dismissed, with the company bearing its own costs. These orders reflect the court's balanced approach to enforcement, considering both the need for deterrence and the specific circumstances of the case.

Orders

Orders of the court

Pecuniary Penalty

3. Palram Australia pay to the Commonwealth of Australia a pecuniary penalty in the amount of $3,500,000 in respect of the contraventions referred to in declarations 1.1 and 2 above, within 90 days of the date of this order.

Competition Law Compliance Training Program

4. Within three months of the date of this order, Palram Australia will establish a compliance program, for employees and other persons involved in its business, including directors, to ensure their awareness of the responsibilities and obligations under Part IV of the CCA, that complies with each of the requirements specified in annexure A to these orders.

Disqualification order

5. Pursuant to s 86E(1) of the CCA, that Ms Horesh be disqualified from managing corporations for a period of three years from the date of these orders.

Costs

6. Palram Australia make a contribution to the ACCC’s costs in the amount of $250,000, to be paid within 30 days of the date of these orders.

Proceedings against Palram Industries

7. The proceedings against the fourth respondent (“Palram Industries”) be dismissed, with Palram Industries bearing its own costs of and incidental to the proceeding.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The information in respect of which the orders were sought was:(1)Palram Australia’s annual revenue for each of 2010, 2011 and 2012 stated in Table 1 of the statement of agreed facts and paras 29.2, 29.3.2, 30.2, 30.3.2 and 66 of the joint submissions (“revenue information”);(2)the proportion of Palram Australia’s revenue during the period December 2010 to February 2013 derived from the sale of polycarb stated in para 14 of the statement of agreed facts and para 66 of the joint submissions (“revenue percentage information”);(3)the amount of the fixed monthly allowance received by Ms Horesh as member of Kibbutz Ramat Yohanan (“Kibbutz”) stated in para 18.3 of the statement of agreed facts (“Kibbutz allowance information”);(4)Palram Australia’s estimate of the proportion of total sales of polycarb in the distribution market (as defined at para 35 of the statement of agreed facts) during the period December 2010 to February 2013 comprised of its sales stated in para 36 of the statement of agreed facts and para 68 of the joint submissions (“sales percentage information”);(5)the approximate value of the polycarb purchased by Palram Australia from EGR:(a)during the period between December 2010 and January 2012, stated in para 68 of the statement of agreed facts; and(b)during the period between February 2012 and February 2013, stated in para 82 of the statement of agreed facts (“value information”).Ms Birnbaum-David’s evidence In support of the application, the Palram parties relied upon an affidavit of Ms Ravit Birnbaum-David, chief legal officer of Palram Industries and in-house legal counsel for Palram Australia, affirmed 4 March 2018. At the Court’s request, the ACCC made submissions concerning the application. The ACCC contended that the proposed orders should be refused because the evidence did not satisfy the requisite standard for the making of an order pursuant to s 37AF. The ACCC objected to the admissibility of portions of Ms Birnbaum-David’s evidence as inadmissible opinion evidence, questioning her relevant knowledge and experience. I allowed the evidence but permitted cross-examination. In her affidavit, Ms Birnbaum-David gave reasons why, in her opinion, disclosure of the information over which protection was sought (apart from the Kibbutz allowance information) would be likely to provide a commercial and competitive advantage to industry participants, including Palram Australia’s competitors, customers and potential customers to the commercial and competitive disadvantage of Palram Australia.Revenue information and revenue percentage information Concerning the revenue information, Ms Birnbaum-David stated relevantly:12.The Revenue Information relates to the period 2010 to 2012. In my experience, experienced industry participants are aware of the rates of growth experienced in the industry over time and of significant developments in the industry, such as particular companies winning or losing significant customer contracts. With this awareness, in my view, experienced industry participants, including Palram Australia’s competitors, customers and potential customers, will likely be able to determine Palram Australia’s approximate current annual revenue by reference to the Revenue Information.13.Disclosure of the Revenue Information to industry participants, including Palram Australia’s competitors, customers and potential customers, will thereby:(a)make available to these participants detailed (otherwise confidential) commercial information about Palram Australia’s size, financial performance and operations;(b)likely enable these participants to calculate Palram Australia’s approximate profitability;(c)(together with the Revenue Percentage Information) enable these participants to calculate Palram Australia’s market share, this information being confidential and commercially sensitive for the reasons outlined in paragraphs 18 to 20 below, given that the value of total sales in the Distribution Market (as defined in paragraph 35 of the Statement of Agreed Facts) during the same period is stated in paragraph 36 of the Statement of Agreed Facts and in paragraph 68 of the Joint Submissions;(d)likely enable these participants to estimate the value of Palram Australia’s key customer contracts, including by comparing changes in Palram Australia’s revenue during the period 2010 to 2012 against facts set out in the Statement of Agreed Facts concerning Palram Australia winning a tender process to supply a major (ongoing) retailer customer in late 2010;(e)possibly enable these participants to estimate the prices charged by Palram Australia to the key customers referred to in paragraph 13(d) above, for example, if the industry participants are able to estimate the volume of sales made to those customers; and(f)thereby provide a commercial and competitive advantage to these participants (to Palram Australia’s commercial and competitive disadvantage), by making available to them otherwise confidential, commercial information which they will be able to use in the course of their dealings with Palram Australia and each other.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Accordingly, I do not accept that the approximate amounts paid by Palram Industries to EGR are currently relevant information about Palram Australia’s cost basis, or that the information could confer a commercial or competitive advantage on other industry participants. Conclusions concerning revenue information, revenue percentage information, sales percentage information and value information For the reasons give above, I am not satisfied that the information is of continuing commercial significance. If I am wrong, I am not satisfied that disclosure of the information is likely to cause a significant commercial and competitive disadvantage to Palram Industries. Accordingly, I am not satisfied that a non-publication order in respect of this information is necessary to prevent prejudice to the proper administration of justice.Kibbutz allowance information The basis of the application to restrict access to this information was the personal and private nature of the information and the fact that it will not otherwise be disclosed. Having regard to the authorities set out above, these matters do not warrant a conclusion that a non-publication order in respect of this information is necessary to prevent prejudice to the proper administration of justice.ReliefDeclarations The Court has a wide discretionary power to make declarations under s 21(1) of the Federal Court Act: see Forster v Jododex Australia Pty Ltd [1972] HCA 61; (1972) 127 CLR 421 at 437-438 per Gibbs J (“Forster”); Ainsworth v Criminal Justice Commission [1992] HCA 10; (1992) 175 CLR 564 at 581-582 per Mason CJ, Dawson, Toohey and Gaudron JJ; and Tobacco Institute of Australia Ltd v Australian Federation of Consumer Organisations Inc (No 2) [1993] FCA 105; (1993) 41 FCR 89 at 99. In Forster, at 437-438 (quoting Russian Commercial and Industrial Bank v British Bank for Foreign Trade Ltd [1921] 2 AC 438 at 448 per Dunedin LJ), Gibbs J stated that before making a declaration three requirements should be satisfied:(1)the question must be a real and not a hypothetical or theoretical one;(2)the applicant must have a real interest in raising it; and(3)there must be a proper contradictor. Each of these requirements is satisfied in this case. The proposed declarations relate to conduct that contravenes the CCA and the matters in issue have been identified and particularised by the parties with precision: Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v MSY Technology Pty Ltd [2012] FCAFC 56; (2012) 201 FCR 378 at [35]. It is in the public interest for the ACCC to seek to have the proposed declarations made and for the proposed declarations to be made: Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union [2006] FCA 1730; (2007) ATPR 42-140 at [6] (“ACCC v CFMEU”). There is a significant legal controversy in this case which is being resolved, and the ACCC, as the public regulator under the CCA, has a genuine interest in seeking the declaratory relief.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Since in or about January 2016, Palram Australia has:(1)had a compliance policy and ethical code of conduct in relation to the CCA, with which employees are required to comply; and(2)conducted regular annual internal CCA compliance training.Co-operation Palram Australia and Ms Horesh have provided appreciable co-operation to the ACCC, including by:(1)engaging with and providing certain documents and extensive submissions voluntarily to the ACCC during the course of the ACCC’s investigation and following the commencement of proceedings;(2)engaging from an early stage in good faith discussions with the ACCC about resolving the proceedings;(3)assisting in the preparation of the statement of agreed facts;(4)consenting to the proposed orders; and(5)assisting in preparing and agreeing to the joint submissions regarding the alleged contraventions. Co-operation with authorities in the course of investigations and subsequent proceedings is a mitigating factor that has in almost all previous cases resulted in a reduction of the penalty that would otherwise be imposed. A reduction on this account reflects the fact that such co-operation:(1)is usually evidence of contrition and an acceptance of responsibility;(2)increases the likelihood of co-operation in a way that furthers the object of the legislation;(3)frees up the regulator’s resources, thereby increasing the likelihood that other contravenors will be detected and brought to justice; and(4)reflects a willingness to facilitate the course of justice: Clean Energy Regulator v MT Solar Pty Ltd [2013] FCA 205 (“MT Solar”) at [118] citing NW Frozen Foods at 293-294; Minister for Industry, Tourism and Resources v Mobil Oil Australia Pty Ltd [2004] FCAFC 72; [2004] ATPR 41-993 at [55]; and Mornington Inn Pty Ltd v Jordan [2008] FCAFC 70; (2008) 168 FCR 383 at [73]-[74] (“Mornington Inn”).Comparable decisions In The Queen v Pham [2015] HCA 39; (2015) 256 CLR 550 at [28], the plurality considered the use of comparable cases in the context of criminal sentencing proceedings and emphasised that the consistency that is sought is consistency in the application of the relevant legal principles. Prior cases do not set a “tariff” to be applied for particular types of contraventions, nor do they confine the Court’s discretion: Comcare v Transpacific Industries Pty Ltd [2015] FCA 500; (2015) 146 ALD 637 at [269]. In NW Frozen Foods at 295:(1)it was noted that “[a] hallmark of justice is equality before the law, and, other things being equal, corporations guilty of similar contraventions should incur similar penalties”;(2)but, that in the context of the CCA, “other things are rarely equal”; and(3)that “[c]ases are authorities for matters of principle; but the penalty found to be appropriate, as a matter of fact, in the circumstances of one case cannot dictate the appropriate penalty in the different circumstances of another case”. The ACCC and Palram Australia have not been able to identify any strictly comparable decisions. The Full Court has recognised that referring to penalties imposed in other cases involving vastly different circumstances can be of limited assistance: Optus v ACCC at [60].“Course of conduct” principle