Martin v Norton Rose Fulbright Australia (No 11)

Link copied
Case Copied 48 min read

Federal Court of Australia

Martin v Norton Rose Fulbright Australia (No 11) [2020] FCA 1641  

File numbers: SAD 49 of 2017
NSD 1610 of 2016
Judgment of: KERR J
Date of judgment: 16 November 2020
Catchwords:

TORTS – tort of deceit – where national firm of legal practitioners in dispute with a person who was formerly a “Fixed Profit Share Partner” of the firm but claimed to have been a “Clayton’s partner” who had in truth been an employee of the partnership intentionally misled its opponent’s legal representatives regarding the circumstances of the filing of a proceeding in the Federal Court of Australia seeking to prevent the Fair Work Commission from dealing with a general protections application involving dismissal under the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (Fair Work Act) – where firm’s opponent relied on those misrepresentations and suffered damage as a result in the form of various legal costs incurred – tort of deceit established – damages, including aggravated and exemplary damages, awarded

CONSUMER LAW – claim that certain representations made in the course of discussions between legal representatives regarding the institution of a proceeding in the Federal Court of Australia were made “in trade or commerce” and were relevantly misleading and deceptive contrary to Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) Sch 2 Australian Consumer Law s 18 – representations found not have been made in trade or commerce – claim dismissed

TORTS – tort of abuse of process – where national firm of legal practitioners instituted a proceeding in the Federal Court of Australia seeking to prevent the Fair Work Commission from dealing with a general protections application under the Fair Work Act advanced by a person who was a former “Fixed Profit Share Partner” of the firm but claimed to have been a “Clayton’s partner” who had in truth been an employee of the partnership – proceeding alleged to have been an abuse of process – proceeding found to have been without merit – consideration of Hewitt v Topero Nominees Pty Ltd [2013] FWCFB 6321; 238 IR 42 and Coles Supply Chain Pty Ltd v Milford [2020] FCAFC 152 – firm found to have instituted the proceeding not for the purpose of obtaining to any substantial extent relief within the scope of the remedy it ostensibly sought, but rather as a vehicle to prevent its opponent from accessing the judicial power of the Commonwealth by preventing him from obtaining from the Fair Work Commission a certificate pursuant to s 368(3) of the Fair Work Act as he required in order to litigate his claims in the Federal Court of Australia pursuant to s 370 of that Act – where firm’s opponent suffered damage as a result in the form of various legal costs incurred – tort of abuse of process established – damages awarded

COSTS – costs of proceeding instituted by national firm of legal practitioners to prevent the Fair Work Commission from dealing with a general protections application involving dismissal under the Fair…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Martin v Norton Rose Fulbright Australia (No 11) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] FCA 1641
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Martin v Norton Rose Fulbright Australia (No 11), the plaintiff, Mr. Martin, a former employee of Norton Rose Fulbright Australia (NRFA), brought claims against the firm for deceit, misleading and deceptive conduct under the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth), and abuse of process. The plaintiff alleged that NRFA intentionally misled his legal representatives regarding the circumstances of a proceeding filed in the Federal Court seeking to prevent the Fair Work Commission from dealing with a general protections application involving his dismissal. Additionally, he alleged that certain representations made in discussions between legal representatives were misleading and deceptive, and that the proceeding was an abuse of process. The case was heard in the Federal Court of Australia.

The legal issues before the court were whether NRFA had committed the tort of deceit, whether certain representations made in the course of discussions between legal representatives were misleading and deceptive, and whether the proceeding instituted by NRFA constituted an abuse of process. The court had to determine whether NRFA intentionally misled the plaintiff's legal representatives, whether certain representations made in discussions between legal representatives were misleading and deceptive, and whether the proceeding instituted by NRFA was an abuse of process.

The court found that NRFA had indeed committed the tort of deceit by intentionally misleading the plaintiff's legal representatives regarding the circumstances of the proceeding. The court also found that the proceeding instituted by NRFA constituted an abuse of process, as it was instituted not for the purpose of obtaining relief, but rather as a vehicle to prevent the plaintiff from accessing the judicial power of the Commonwealth. The court awarded damages, including aggravated and exemplary damages, for both the tort of deceit and the abuse of process. The court found that the representations made in discussions between legal representatives were not made in trade or commerce, and therefore did not constitute misleading and deceptive conduct. The court also found that the proceeding was instituted without reasonable cause and ordered that NRFA pay the plaintiff's costs on an indemnity basis.

The court made several orders in the case. First, it ordered that NRFA pay the plaintiff's costs in the proceedings, subject to a reduction of $500.00 to adjust for damages awarded to the respondent in a related proceeding. Second, it ordered that the constitution of NRFA, as filed in the proceedings, be suppressed and kept confidential for ten years from the making of the order, to prevent prejudice to the proper administration of justice. Third, it directed the Registrar to refer the papers in the proceeding, along with the court's reasons, to the Legal Services Commissioner of New South Wales for consideration.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Subject to a reduction of $500.00 to adjust for damages awarded to the Respondent in SAD49/2017, the Applicant pay the Respondent’s costs in these proceedings on a solicitor client basis as agreed or in default of agreement as taxed.

2. Pursuant to ss 37AF and 37AG(1)(a) of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) and in order to prevent prejudice to the proper administration of justice, the constitution of Norton Rose Fulbright Australia as filed in these proceedings, subject to further order, be suppressed and kept confidential for ten years from the making of this order.

3. The Registrar be directed to refer the papers in this proceeding with my reasons to the Legal Services Commissioner of New South Wales for such consideration as the Commissioner sees fit.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

The critical issues in dispute in these proceedings largely concern events that occurred during a relatively confined period: Monday 19 September 2016 to Friday 23 September 2016 inclusive. BACKGROUND However, first it is appropriate to provide context and background to what is in dispute. On 12 January 2013 Mr Martin, admitted to practice as a lawyer, commenced employment in the Perth Office of Norton Rose Fulbright Australia (NRFA). NRFA is an Australian law firm with a national presence and international connections. On 12 March 2015, NRFA offered Mr Martin a position as a “Fixed Profit Share Partner”. It is uncontentious that on 1 May 2015, Mr Martin became a Fixed Profit Share Partner. Whether his change of status caused him thereupon to have ceased to be an employee of NRFA is discussed later in these reasons. On 15 July 2016, following a deterioration of Mr Martin’s relationship with NRFA its managing partner Mr Wayne Spanner sent an email to Mr Martin terminating or purporting to terminate his position as a “Fixed Profit Share Partner” with immediate effect. On 5 August 2016 Mr Martin, then represented by Harmers Workplace Lawyers (Harmers), filed a general protections application in the Fair Work Commission (FWC) against NRFA and against certain individuals within the firm (Wayne Spanner; Cameron Harvey; Dylan McKimmie and Chris McLeod). On 8 August 2016, NRFA instructed Mr David Cross (an equity partner within that firm) to act for it in relation to Mr Martin’s FWC application. On 9 August 2016, the FWC issued a Notice of Listing requiring the attendance of the parties at a telephone conciliation conference on 20 September 2016 at 2:15pm. On 12 August 2016, NRFA’s response to the FWC application fell due. NRFA did not file its response. On 22 August 2016, NRFA notified Harmers that it intended to commence Federal Court proceedings seeking a writ of prohibition to prevent the FWC from further dealing with Mr Martin’s application on jurisdictional grounds. Correspondence subsequently passed between the parties with a view to arranging a mediation of the dispute. The disputed events then occurred. Within the period from 19 to 23 September 2016, NRFA commenced an action in the Federal Court of Australia (proceeding NSD1610/2016, described by Mr Martin as the Prohibition Proceeding). That action named the “President and Members of the FWC” as the First Respondents, and Mr Martin as the Second Respondent. The originating application identified the relief sought as follows: On the grounds stated in the statement of claim, the Applicants apply for the following relief under section 39B of the Judiciary Act 1903. 1.Pursuant to section 21 of the Federal Court Act of Australia 1976 (the Act), a declaration that the Fair Work Commission does not have jurisdiction under Part 3-1 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) to deal with the ‘General Protections Application Involving Dismissal’ dated 5 August 2016 filed by the Second Respondent (FWC Application). 2.Pursuant to section 23 of the Act, an order in the nature of prohibition against the First Respondents restraining them from dealing with, or otherwise purporting to exercise jurisdiction over the Applicants in respect of, the FWC Application. 3.An order that the Second Respondent pay the Applicants’ costs of these proceedings on an indemnity basis.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Mr Martin filed no such application. Accordingly, I have had no regard to the reply submissions that he had earlier purported to file. The evidence In most instances, what was adduced or not adduced as evidence requires no further explication. Much of the evidence before the Court is in the form of emails, the provenance of which is not in dispute. However, there is some evidence that requires explanation with respect to its admission or where it appears in the Court file. That is because late in the trial Mr Martin, having become represented by counsel and instructing solicitors, applied to tender three hard copy bundles of materials. The documents in those three bundles were, by consent, admitted into evidence on the understanding that they would later be electronically filed by Mr Martin’s then solicitors as exhibits A5, A6, and A8 respectively. Unfortunately, Mr Martin’s then representatives subsequently electronically filed a single “tender bundle” titled “Index of Documents tendered by the Applicant”. That bundle included a considerable number of documents, primarily emails, sorted in chronological order. There was nothing to indicate which of those documents had been admitted as part of exhibits A5, A6 or A8 respectively. NRFA’s representatives - understandably - raised concern on its behalf that there might be discrepancies between the materials that had been tendered in Court without objection as exhibits A5, A6 and A8 and the single bundle of non-disaggregated materials later filed on Mr Martin’s behalf. Correspondence on this point ensued between the parties and with the Court. On 27 May 2020, I convened a case management hearing to resolve the issue. The parties agreed to a way forward with respect to the exhibits. They agreed on the terms in which exhibits A5, A6 and A8 should have been, and would be, filed. They also agreed that Mr Martin should be granted leave to file a further bundle of documents as had been inadvertently omitted from what had been tendered as Ex A9. Relevantly, I made the following orders: 1.Mr Martin have leave to file as evidence in his case in the trial of matters SAD49/2017 and NSD1610/2016 Exhibits A5, A6 and A8 in paginated electronic form, being respectively those documents the parties agree were tendered in Court in bundles but without their being included on the electronic court file, no later than 4:00pm on Friday 29 May 2020.2.Pursuant to r 1.34 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth), the Court dispenses with any provision of the Rules as would prevent Mr Martin also filing as evidence in his case in the trial of matters SAD49/2017 and NSD1610/2016 Exhibit A9, being a paginated bundle of seven documents as identified by the parties during the case management hearing held on Wednesday 27 May 2020, and as they agreed should be received as evidence in those proceedings, no later than 4:00pm on Friday 29 May 2020. The Court noted that:1.Norton Rose Fulbright Australia’s legal representative appearing at the case management hearing undertook on that firm’s behalf that it will provide Mr Martin’s legal representatives with the agreed versions of Exhibits A5, A6, A8 and A9 in paginated electronic form in sufficient time to permit Mr Martin’s legal representatives to file those documents with the Court, as provided for by Orders 1 and 2.2.The parties agree that the Court will disregard any documents other than Exhibits A5, A6, A8 and A9 as have been earlier filed in purported compliance with Mr Martin’s obligation to electronically file those documents tendered on his behalf in Court.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established