Martin v Norton Rose Fulbright Australia (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 72 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Martin v Norton Rose Fulbright Australia (No 2) [2019] FCA 96

File number: SAD 49 of 2017
Judge: CHARLESWORTH J
Date of judgment: 11 February 2019
Catchwords:

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – order for discovery – asserted non-compliance with discovery order – where no application to cross-examine deponent of an affidavit verifying a list of documents – whether there is a reasonable basis to believe there are discoverable documents in existence so as to justify orders for the discovery of specific documents

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – legal professional privilege – where legal practitioner is a partner of a law firm to whom the legal advice and services are provided – where the law firm is a party to litigation to which the advice and services relate – whether the legal practitioner lacked professional detachment from the firm and from the subject matter of the claims – role of independence in the assessment of privilege claims –Rich v Harrington [2007] FCA 1987 not followed – whether the Court should inspect documents subject to a privilege claim in circumstances where a lack of independence is alleged

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – legal professional privilege – public policy exception – communications subject to a privilege claim alleged to have been made in furtherance of a wrong involving intentional deceit or abuse of process – where allegations of wrongdoing said to displace privilege are the same allegations of wrongdoing forming the subject matter of the suit – standard of evidence necessary to displace the privilege

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – legal professional privilege – asserted waiver – whether party claiming privilege has adopted an inconsistent approach to privilege claims within its list of documents or otherwise in comparison to the party’s earlier response to a notice to produce – inconsistency not shown – no proper basis for waiver shown

Legislation:

Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) ss 5, 6, 131, Sch 2

Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) s 125

Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) ss 340, 345, 351, 352, 365, 368, 386, 370

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 37M

Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) rr 2.21, 2.22, 2.25, 2.27, 20.11, 20.12, 20.15

Partnership Act 1892 (NSW)

Desiatnik RJ, Legal Professional Privilege in Australia (3rd ed, LexisNexis Butterworths Australia, 2017)

Cases cited:

Alanco Australia Pty Ltd v Higgins (No 2) [2011] FCA 1063

Alfred Crompton Amusement Machines Ltd v Customs and Excise Commissioners (No 2) [1972] 2 QB 102

Aquila Coal Pty Ltd v Bowen Central Coal Pty Ltd [2013] QSC 82

Archer Capital 4A Pty Ltd (as trustee for the Archer Capital Trust 4A (ACN 123 463 749)) v Sage Group PLC (No 2) (2013) 306 ALR 384

Attorney-General (NT) v Kearney (1985) 158 CLR 500

Balabel v Air India [1988] Ch 317

Brookfield v Yevad Products Pty Ltd [2002] FCA 1376

Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union v BHP Coal Pty Ltd (No 2) [2011] FCA 1396

DSE (Holdings) Pty Ltd v InterTAN Inc (2003) 135 FCR 151

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Martin v Norton Rose Fulbright Australia (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] FCA 96
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Martin v Norton Rose Fulbright Australia (No 2), the Court was tasked with ruling on several issues concerning discovery, legal professional privilege, and potential waiver of privilege. Mr Martin, the applicant, sought orders for discovery of specific documents and argued that Norton Rose Fulbright Australia (NRFA) had not fully complied with a previous discovery order. Additionally, Mr Martin challenged NRFA's claims of legal professional privilege over certain documents, argued that NRFA's representatives lacked the necessary independence to claim privilege, and suggested that the public policy exception to privilege should apply due to alleged wrongdoing. The Court also considered whether there had been a waiver of privilege based on inconsistencies in NRFA's handling of document disclosure.

The central legal issues before the Court included whether there was a reasonable basis to believe that discoverable documents existed to justify orders for the discovery of specific documents, the validity of NRFA's claims of legal professional privilege given the alleged lack of independence of their representatives, the standard of evidence required to displace privilege under the public policy exception, and whether there was a proper basis for finding a waiver of privilege due to inconsistencies in document disclosure practices. The Court had to assess these issues within the framework of the common law principles governing legal professional privilege and the specific provisions of the Federal Court Rules.

In addressing these issues, the Court first determined that the applicant had not provided a persuasive argument that the documents in question fell within the scope of the existing discovery order. It further held that Mr Martin had not shown a proper basis to go behind the affidavit of Mr Cash, which verified the existence and location of documents responsive to the discovery order. Regarding privilege, the Court noted that while some factual questions overlapped with those to be determined at trial, it was necessary to make certain findings at the interlocutory stage. The Court found no cause for concern that the searches for documents were deficient and rejected the argument that NRFA's representatives lacked the necessary independence to claim privilege. The Court also determined that the public policy exception did not apply as the standard of evidence required to displace privilege had not been met. Finally, the Court found no proper basis for a waiver of privilege based on the inconsistencies argued by Mr Martin.

The Court dismissed the applicant's interlocutory application in its entirety, emphasising that the findings and conclusions were made at an interlocutory stage and based on the limited materials presented. The Court's decision underscored the importance of adhering to procedural rules and the need for clear and compelling evidence to challenge established privilege claims.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The applicant’s interlocutory application dated 19 October 2018 is dismissed.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Mr Martin’s allegations in the underlying proceeding, as understood from the pleadings and his oral submissions, are to the effect that:(1)At the time that an agreement for the conduct of the private mediation had been reached by the parties, the initiating documents in the prohibition proceeding had been faxed to the New South Wales District Registry of this Court for filing but not yet accepted for filing by the Registrar: see generally rr 2.21(1)(c), 2.22, 2.25(1) and 2.27 of the Rules.(2)At the time that the terms for the conduct of a private mediation were agreed, a partner of NRFA, Mr Cross, represented to Mr Martin’s solicitor that NRFA had put a stop to the filing of the prohibition proceeding.(3)Mr Martin agreed to participate in the private mediation on that basis.(4)The initiating documents were nonetheless accepted for filing and then served on Mr Martin. Service occurred on 23 September 2016.(5)In correspondence accompanying the served documents, Mr Cross represented that there was nothing NRFA could have done to avoid the acceptance of the documents for filing (and hence the commencement of the prohibition proceeding).(6)Mr Martin was intentionally deceived into believing that the commencement of the prohibition proceeding could not have been avoided by NRFA.(7)NRFA had not in fact put a stop to the filing of the documents, but instead had taken positive steps to secure the acceptance of the initiating documents by the Registrar, including by paying a filing fee.(8)The initiating documents were accepted for filing by the District Registrar on 22 September 2016 without a lawyer’s signature endorsed on the originating application.(9)On 22 September 2016, Mr Cross applied his signature and the date 19 September 2016 to the originating application after it had been sealed by the Court and so deliberately altered an initiating process.(10)By his email correspondence and by applying his signature and dating the document, Mr Cross intended to deceive Mr Martin into persisting with the private mediation, to gain leverage in settlement negotiations and so cause him to compromise his position in the underlying dispute.(11)Had Mr Martin known that NRFA did not put a stop to the filing of the prohibition proceeding, he would not have participated in the private mediation and he would not have withdrawn the FWC proceeding. He would instead have obtained a certificate under s 368(3)(c) of the FW Act and commenced a general protections court application in this Court.(12)The commencement and continuation of the prohibition proceeding (including NRFA’s persistence with its costs application) of itself constitutes an actionable abuse of process for which damages are payable.Evidence bearing generally on the privilege claim NRFA’s list of documents is organised in five parts. Claims for privilege are made in respect of the documents contained in Parts 3 and 4. In his verification affidavit, Mr Cash says, of those documents:6.The documents set out in part 3 are in the control of the respondent but I claim privilege from production of each of these documents on the grounds that they are:(a)confidential documents recording or evidencing confidential communications, or from which the content or substance of such communications could be inferred or revealed, between the respondent and its counsel, made for the dominant purpose of providing the respondent with professional legal services relating to this proceeding, the FWC application and/or proceeding no. NSD1610/2016; or(b)documents that are, or that would reveal the contents of, confidential documents prepared for the dominant purpose of providing the respondent with professional legal services relating to this proceeding, the FWC application and/or proceeding no. NSD1610/2016.7.The documents set out in part 4 are in the control of the respondent. Parts of some documents in part 4 are redacted. I object to producing unredacted copies of those documents on the ground that the redacted parts are privileged, and I claim privilege from production of each of these documents on the grounds that those parts:(a)record or evidence confidential communications, or from which the content or substance of such communications could be inferred or revealed, between the respondent and its counsel, made for the dominant purpose of providing the respondent with professional legal services relating to this proceeding, the FWC application and/or proceeding no. NSD1610/2016; or(b)reproduce, or would reveal the contents of, confidential documents prepared for the dominant purpose of providing the respondent with professional legal services relating to this proceeding.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The alleged waiver of privilege arising from the notice to produce procedure raises a separate issue. It is dealt with elsewhere in these reasons.Conclusion The circumstances upon which Mr Martin relied do not gain persuasive force when considered in their totality. As I have said, Mr Martin’s submissions did not assist the Court to comprehend how documents of the kind referred to in [5] to [10] fall within the scope of the discovery order. The application for orders in terms of those paragraphs must fail for that reason alone. Assuming the documents now sought do fall within the scope of the discovery order, no proper basis for going behind the affidavit of Mr Cash in respect of the existence of documents described in the order has been shown. Mr Martin did not otherwise invite the Court to make additional orders for discovery so as to obtain the documents described in [5] to [10] by that means. On such an application it would have been necessary to persuade the Court that an additional discovery order should now be made, having regard to the case management history of this proceeding and the requirements of r 20.11 of the Rules and s 37M of the FCA Act. As Mr Martin expressly disavowed any intention to apply for an order for discovery of additional documents, it is unnecessary to consider the exercise of the Court’s discretion in that regard. For the same reasons I am not satisfied that an order should be made in terms of [13] of the interlocutory application, insofar as it refers to the searches undertaken by Mr Cash as to the existence and location of documents that respond to the discovery order. I am not satisfied that there is cause for concern that the searches for documents falling within the scope of the order were deficient.PRIVILEGE Having regard to the issues to be tried, it is not surprising that a claim of privilege extends to documents that are critically relevant to the issues to be determined at trial. In some respects, the factual questions arising for consideration on this interlocutory application coincide with the factual issues to be determined at trial. The nature of Mr Martin’s challenges to the privilege claims is such that it has not been possible to determine the interlocutory application without expressing some views about the same or similar matters that are to be finally determined by a trial judge. It should be emphasised that the findings and conclusions expressed below are made at an interlocutory stage and upon the limited materials to which I was referred in the course of argument. It is necessary to begin with some general statements of principle.General principles In a pre-trial context, it is the common law test for legal professional privilege that applies: Esso Australia Resources Ltd v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (1999) 201 CLR 49 at [17] – [28] (Gleeson CJ, Gaudron and Gummow JJ), [64] (McHugh J). At common law, privilege attaches to confidential communications between a lawyer and client made for the dominant purpose of obtaining or giving legal advice or assistance, or to aid in the conduct of actual or anticipated litigation: Esso at [61]. Litigation will be anticipated when there is a real prospect of legal proceedings being commenced. It is not enough to show that proceedings are possible: State of New South Wales v Jackson [2007] NSWCA 279.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established