Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Woolworths Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 47 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Woolworths Limited [2016] FCA 44

File number: NSD 941 of 2014
Judge: EDELMAN J
Date of judgment: 5 February 2016
Catchwords:

CONSUMER LAW – pecuniary penalties – relevant matters – assessment of comparative cases – effect of incommensurability – relevance of previous acknowledgment of likely similar contravention – relevance of payment of compensation by contravening party – whether payment of compensation is only relevant to whether the contravening party is contrite

CONSUMER LAW – pecuniary penalties – s 224(4)(b) Australian Consumer Law – meaning of the “same conduct” – effect of the course of conduct principle

Legislation:

Australian Consumer Law (Schedule 2 of the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth)) ss 18, 29, 29(1)(a), 29(1)(g), 33, 87B, 131, 131(1), 131(2), 131(4), 131(5), 224(2), 224(3), 224(4)(b), 246(2)(a), 246(2)(b), 1330

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 21

Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) ss 52, 53(eb)

Cases cited:

ACCC v Cotton On Kids Pty Ltd [2012] FCA 1428

ACCC v George Weston Foods Ltd (2000) ATPR 41-763; [2000] FCA 690

Australian Competition & Consumer Commission v Econovite Pty Ltd [2003] FCA 964

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v ABB Transmission and Distribution Ltd (No 2) [2002] FCA 559; (2002) 190 ALR 169

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Apple Pty Ltd [2012] FCA 646

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Coles Supermarkets Australia Pty Limited [2015] FCA 330

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Reebok Australia Pty Ltd [2015] FCA 83

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Singtel Optus Pty Ltd (No 4) [2011] FCA 761; (2011) 282 ALR 246

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Sontax Australia (1988) Pty Ltd [2011] FCA 1202

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v TPG Internet Pty Ltd [2013] HCA 54; (2013) 250 CLR 640

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Woolworths Ltd [2002] FCA 1001; (2002) ASAL 55-085

Commonwealth of Australia v Director, Fair Work Building Industry Inspectorate [2015] HCA 46

Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union v Cahill [2010] FCAFC 39; (2010) 269 ALR 1

Forster v Jododex Aust Pty Ltd [1972] HCA 61; (1972) 127 CLR 421

ICI Australia Operations Pty Ltd v Trade Practices Commission (1992) 38 FCR 248

NW Frozen Foods Pty Ltd v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission [1996] FCA 1134; (1996) 71 FCR 285

Pearce v The Queen [1998] HCA 57; (1998) 194 CLR 610

Ryan v The Queen [2001] HCA 21; (2001) 206 CLR 267

Singtel Optus Pty Ltd v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission [2012] FCAFC 20; (2012) 287 ALR 249

Thewlis v The Queen [2008] NSWCCA 176; (2008) 186 A Crim R 279

Trade Practices Commission v CSR Ltd [1991] ATPR 41-076

Weininger v The Queen [2003] HCA 14; (2003) 212 CLR 629

McGregor H, McGregor on Damages (19th ed, Sweet & Maxwell, 2014) 13 [2-001]

Chapman B “Law, Incommensurability, and Conceptually Sequenced Argument” (1998) 146 Uni Penn Law Rev 1487

Sunstein…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Woolworths... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] FCA 44
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Woolworths Limited, the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) brought an action against Woolworths Limited, alleging multiple breaches of the Australian Consumer Law (ACL). The ACCC claimed that Woolworths engaged in misleading or deceptive conduct in relation to the safety of its products, specifically the Abode 3 Litre Stainless Steel Deep Fryer, Woolworths Select Drain Cleaner, Safety Matches, Padded Flop Chair, and Folding Stool. Additionally, Woolworths was alleged to have failed to recall unsafe products within a reasonable time, contravening section 131 of the ACL.

The primary legal issues addressed by the court were the assessment of pecuniary penalties for the contraventions, the relevance of previous acknowledgments of likely contraventions, and the effect of the course of conduct principle in determining the penalties. The court also considered whether the payment of compensation by Woolworths was relevant to the assessment of penalties.

The court found that the proposed penalty of $2.2 million by Woolworths was insufficient given the seriousness of the contraventions, particularly those involving the Select Drain Cleaner and Deep Fryer, which posed serious health risks to consumers. However, the court also determined that a penalty of $4 million exceeded the appropriate amount considering the mitigating factors and the statutory maximum penalty for a single contravention. The court imposed a total penalty of $3.057 million, broken down into specific amounts for different courses of conduct and contraventions, and ordered Woolworths to implement a dedicated product safety compliance program to prevent future breaches. The court further ordered Woolworths to publish recall information on its website and smartphone application and to pay the ACCC’s costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

THE COURT DECLARES THAT:

1. Between 4 June 2012 and 4 July 2012, by continuing to offer the Abode 3 Litre Stainless Steel Deep Fryer, Model DF30BW (the Deep Fryer) for retail sale after it became aware that the side handles of the Deep Fryer may detach when the Deep Fryer was lifted, leading to a consequential hazard comprising oil spills and possible burn injuries if the appliance was moved while containing hot oil, by its silence and by refraining from:

(a) withdrawing the Deep Fryer from sale at its Big W stores; and

(b) recalling the Deep Fryer from its Big W stores;

once a reasonable period of time in which it could have identified, assessed and responded to this safety hazard had elapsed, Woolworths engaged in conduct (the Deep Fryer Silence Conduct) that was:

(c) misleading or deceptive, or likely to mislead or deceive; and

(d) liable to mislead the public as to the suitability of the Deep Fryer for its purpose,

because:

(e) the side handles of the Deep Fryer may (and did on one known occasion prior to 4 June 2012) detach when the Deep Fryer was lifted, leading to a consequential hazard comprising oil spills and possible burn injuries if the appliance was moved while containing hot oil;

(f) Woolworths had knowledge of the matters stated in subparagraph (e) above; and

by the Deep Fryer Silence Conduct, Woolworths:

(g) engaged in conduct, in trade or commerce, which was misleading or deceptive, or likely to mislead or deceive, in contravention of section 18 of the ACL; and

(h) engaged in conduct, in trade or commerce, that was liable to mislead the public as to the suitability of the Deep Fryer for its purpose, in contravention of section 33 of the ACL

(the Deep Fryer Contravention).

2. Between in or about 25 August 2013 and in or about 20 March 2014, Woolworths, in offering the house brand consumer good Woolworths Select Drain Cleaner 1L (Select Drain Cleaner) for retail sale to consumers, with a cap that bore the text, “Close tightly while pushing down turn”, accompanied by two arrows directing an anti-clockwise motion, expressly and impliedly represented that the Select Drain Cleaner could only, within the ordinary range of uses of the product, be opened by applying downward pressure to the cap while turning it (the Select Drain Cleaner Opening Representation), which representation was:

(a) misleading and deceptive, or likely to mislead or deceive; and

(b) a false or misleading representation that the Select Drain Cleaner was of a particular standard or quality and had certain performance characteristics; and

(c) liable to mislead the public as to the suitability for its purpose of the Select Drain Cleaner,

because the cap on the Select Drain Cleaner:

(d) was ineffective, in that it did not lock securely on the bottle; and

(e) could be opened or open without the application of downward pressure to the cap while turning it,

and thereby, Woolworths:

(f) engaged in conduct, in trade or commerce, which was misleading or deceptive, or likely to mislead or deceive, in contravention of section 18 of the ACL; and

(g) made a false or misleading representation, in trade or commerce, in connection with the supply or possible supply of house brand home ware products, that the Select Drain Cleaner was of a particular standard or quality and had certain performance characteristics, in contravention of sections 29(1)(a) and 29(1)(g) of the ACL; and

(h) engaged in conduct, in trade or commerce, that was liable to mislead the public as to the suitability for its purpose of the Select Drain Cleaner, in contravention of section 33 of the ACL

(the First Select Drain Cleaner Contravention).

3. Between 24 February 2014 and 20 March 2014, by continuing to offer the Select Drain Cleaner for retail sale after it became aware that the Select Drain Cleaner was unsafe when deployed during ordinary or reasonably foreseeable uses of the product, because the cap on the Select Drain Cleaner was ineffective, in that it did not lock securely on the bottle and could be opened without applying downward pressure to the cap while turning it, by its silence and by refraining from:

(a) withdrawing the Select Drain Cleaner from Woolworths, Safeway, Food For Less, and Flemings stores; and

(b) recalling the Select Drain Cleaner from its Woolworths, Safeway, Food For Less, and Flemings stores,

once a reasonable period of time in which it could have identified, assessed and responded to this safety hazard had elapsed, Woolworths engaged in conduct (the Select Drain Cleaner Silence Conduct) that was:

(c) misleading or deceptive, or likely to mislead or deceive; and

(d) liable to mislead the public as to the suitability of the Select Drain Cleaner for its purpose

because:

(e) when deployed during ordinary or reasonably foreseeable uses of the product, the cap on the Select Drain Cleaner:

(i) was ineffective, in that it did not lock securely on the bottle;

(ii) could be opened without applying downward pressure to the cap while turning it, which hazard in fact materialised; and

(f) Woolworths had knowledge of the matters stated in subparagraphs 3(e) above, and

by the Select Drain Cleaner Silence Conduct, Woolworths:

(g) engaged in conduct, in trade or commerce, which was misleading or deceptive, or likely to mislead or deceive, in contravention of section 18 of the ACL; and

(h) engaged in conduct, in trade or commerce, that was liable to mislead the public as to the suitability of the Select Drain Cleaner for its purpose, in contravention of section 33 of the ACL

(the Second Select Drain Cleaner Contravention).

4. Between 6 June 2012 and 28 June 2012, by continuing to offer the house brand 10 x 45 Homebrand Safety Matches (the Safety Matches) for retail sale after it became aware that the Safety Matches were unsafe when deployed during ordinary or reasonably foreseeable uses of the product because the Safety Matches suffered the defect that, in some instances, the head of the match may break or give off sparks upon ignition, and if that defect occurred the product may fail resulting in possible injury or property damage, including by causing the box of matches to ignite, by its silence and by refraining from:

(a) withdrawing the Safety Matches from Woolworths supermarket stores;

once a reasonable period of time in which it could have identified, assessed and responded to this safety hazard had elapsed, Woolworths engaged in conduct (the Safety Matches Silence Conduct) that was:

(b) misleading or deceptive, or likely to mislead or deceive; and

(c) liable to mislead the public as to the suitability of the Safety Matches for their purpose;

because:

(d) the Safety Matches suffered the defect that, in some instances, the head of the match may break or give off sparks upon ignition;

(e) if that defect occurred the product may fail resulting in possible injury or property damage, including by causing the box of matches to ignite, which defect and hazard in fact materialised;

(f) Woolworths had knowledge of the matters stated in subparagraphs (d) and (e) above; and

by engaging in the Safety Matches Silence Conduct, Woolworths:

(g) engaged in conduct, in trade or commerce, which was misleading or deceptive, or likely to mislead or deceive, in contravention of section 18 of the ACL; and

(h) engaged in conduct, in trade or commerce, that was liable to mislead the public as to the suitability of the Safety Matches for their purpose, in contravention of section 33 of the ACL

(the Safety Matches Contravention).

5. Between in or about 1 May 2012 and 31 August 2012, Woolworths, in offering the Padded Flop Chair for retail sale to consumers, made an express representation that the Padded Flop Chair was capable of bearing weights up to 115 kg, which representation was:

(a) misleading or deceptive, or likely to mislead or deceive; and

(b) a false or misleading representation that the Padded Flop Chair was of a particular standard or quality and had certain performance characteristics; and

(c) liable to mislead the public as to the suitability for its purpose of the Padded Flop Chair,

because the Padded Flop Chair was not, in all cases, capable of bearing weights of up to 115 kg and, under testing, could reliably support no more than 92 kg, and thereby, Woolworths:

(d) engaged in conduct, in trade or commerce, which was misleading or deceptive, or likely to mislead or deceive, in contravention of section 18 of the ACL; and

(e) made a false or misleading representation, in trade or commerce, in connection with the supply or possible supply of house brand home ware products, that the Padded Flop Chair was of a particular standard or quality and had certain performance characteristics, in contravention of sections 29(1)(a) and 29(1)(g) of the ACL; and

(f) engaged in conduct, in trade or commerce, that was liable to mislead the public as to the suitability for its purpose of the Padded Flop Chair, in contravention of section 33 of the ACL

(the Padded Flop Chair Contravention).

6. Between 31 August 2012 and 22 July 2013, Woolworths, in offering the Folding Stool for retail sale to consumers, made an express representation that the Folding Stool was capable of bearing weights up to 100 kg, which representation was:

(a) misleading or deceptive, or likely to mislead or deceive; and

(b) a false or misleading representation that the Folding Stool was of a particular standard or quality and had certain performance characteristics; and

(c) liable to mislead the public as to the suitability for its purpose of the Folding Stool,

because the Folding Stool was not capable of bearing weights of up to 100 kg and, under testing, could reliably support no more than 90 kg, and thereby, Woolworths:

(d) engaged in conduct, in trade or commerce, which was misleading or deceptive, or likely to mislead or deceive, in contravention of section 18 of the ACL; and

(e) made a false or misleading representation, in trade or commerce, in connection with the supply or possible supply of house brand home ware products, that the Folding Stool was of a particular standard or quality and had certain performance characteristics, in contravention of sections 29(1)(a) and 29(1)(g) of the ACL; and

(f) engaged in conduct, in trade or commerce, that was liable to mislead the public as to the suitability for its purpose of the Folding Stool, in contravention of section 33 of the ACL

(the Folding Stool Contravention).

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

7. In respect of the misleading or deceptive conduct Woolworths pay to the Commonwealth of Australia within 30 days a pecuniary penalty of $3,000,000 based on the following courses of conduct:

(a) the Deep Fryer contraventions $ 600,000

(b) the two Select Drain Cleaner courses of contraventions: $1,400,000

(c) the Safety Matches contraventions $ 400,000

(d) the Flop Chair contraventions $ 300,000

(e) the Folding Stool contraventions $ 300,000

8. In respect of the eight section 131 contraventions Woolworths pay to the Commonwealth of Australia within 30 days a pecuniary penalty of $57,000:

(a) the Deep Fryer s 131 contravention $ 10,000

(b) the Select Drain cleaner s 131 contravention $ 5,000

(c) the other six s 131 contraventions $ 42,000

9. Woolworths within 30 days prominently publish on the Internet homepage of Woolworths supermarkets, Big W, Masters Home Improvement and Ezibuy a link to an internet page in the form and terms set out in Annexure A.

10. Woolworths within 30 days or otherwise agreed with the ACCC prominently publish on the Woolworths supermarket Smartphone Application:

(a) details of products currently recalled by Woolworths and products recalled in the past 12 months; and

(b) a link to the Recalls Australia website.

11. Woolworths:

(a) implement the upgraded dedicated product safety compliance program in accordance with the requirements set out in Annexure B for the employees and other persons engaged in Woolworths’ business, being a program designed to minimise its risk of future breaches of sections 18, 29 and 33 of the ACL in relation to the safety of its products and of section 131 of the ACL (the Program), which would be provided to the ACCC within 3 months of the Orders being made;

(b) continue to develop and implement for a period of 3 years from the date of these orders the Program; and

(c) provide, at its own expense, a copy of any documents requested by the ACCC evidencing Woolworth’s implementation of the Program, including the documents referred to in clauses 4, 6, 12 of Annexure B.

12. Woolworths pay to the ACCC within 14 days of the date of this order the ACCC’s costs of the proceeding in the sum of $50,000.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involved Woolworths Limited, an Australian retail giant, facing allegations of consumer law breaches by the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC). The primary allegations centered on Woolworths' conduct in relation to several of its products sold to consumers. The first issue involved the Abode 3 Litre Stainless Steel Deep Fryer, Model DF30BW, which Woolworths continued to sell despite knowing that the side handles could detach, posing a burn injury risk. The second issue pertained to the Woolworths Select Drain Cleaner 1L, where Woolworths represented the product could only be opened with a specific motion, though the cap was ineffective and could open without the required motion, posing a safety risk. Another allegation involved Woolworths continuing to sell the Select Drain Cleaner after becoming aware of its unsafe cap. The fourth issue was regarding 10 x 45 Homebrand Safety Matches that Woolworths sold despite knowing that the matches could ignite the box due to a defect. The fifth and sixth issues involved misrepresentations about the weight-bearing capacity of the Padded Flop Chair and the Folding Stool, respectively. These misrepresentations misled consumers about the products' safety and performance.

The case came before the court following an investigation and enforcement action by the ACCC against Woolworths. The ACCC alleged that Woolworths contravened consumer protection laws by engaging in misleading or deceptive conduct and making false or misleading representations about the safety and performance of its products. The case involved multiple hearings, submissions, and evidence from both parties. The court considered submissions on the appropriate quantum of penalties and orders to be imposed on Woolworths for the contraventions found.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Although I consider that the undertaking is relevant, its weight is also limited, although less so than in relation to the advertorial. It was more recent in time and it involved an acknowledgement of a likely contravention concerning a representation which related to consumer safety. But it was a single representation, there was no positive finding of any contravention, and the conduct in this case was not a breach of the undertaking.Conclusions and ordersPecuniary penalties As Finkelstein J explained in Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v ABB Transmission and Distribution Ltd (No 2) [2002] FCA 559; (2002) 190 ALR 169, 179-180 [38], there are different approaches which have been taken to the award of penalties. In some cases a separate penalty has been imposed for each contravention. In others a single global penalty has been imposed for all contraventions (eg Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Coles Supermarkets Australia Pty Limited [2015] FCA 330 [85]). The contraventions in this case involved different conduct and different events. But they overlapped in significant respects. In particular, the most serious contravening conduct by Woolworths stemmed from the same systemic conduct in a broad sense. As Woolworths described that conduct it involved misrepresentations about the characteristics of some of its products, refraining from withdrawing products within a reasonable time, and refraining from recalling unsafe products within a reasonable time. In this case, following the acceptance in Commonwealth of Australia v Director, Fair Work Building Industry Inspectorate [2015] HCA 46 that parties to civil penalty cases can make submissions about the quantum of a penalty, Woolworths submitted that an appropriate total penalty would be $2.2 million. The ACCC submitted that an appropriate total penalty would be $4 million. The $2.2 million proposed by Woolworths is insufficient. Even taking into account the significant mitigating factors which I have described, such a penalty is insufficient in the context of the seriousness of the contraventions, particularly when one takes into account the contraventions in relation to products such as the Select Drain Cleaner and Deep Fryer, where the misleading of the public about suitability for purpose and delays in withdrawing and recalling the products seriously endangered the health of consumers during the period of contraventions. Nevertheless, in the circumstances I have described, including the mitigating factors involved and the maximum statutory penalty for a single contravention of $1.1 million, a penalty of $4 million exceeds the amount that I consider should be awarded. Overall, the appropriate penalties should be as follows. In imposing these penalties I have taken into account considerations of totality:(1)In respect of the misleading or deceptive conduct: $3,000,000 based on the following courses of conduct:(a) the Deep Fryer contraventions $ 600,000(b) the two Select Drain Cleaner courses of contraventions: $1,400,000(c) the Safety Matches contraventions $ 400,000(d) the Flop Chair contraventions $ 300,000(e) the Folding Stool contraventions $ 300,000(2) In respect of the eight section 131 contraventions: $57,000(a) the Deep Fryer s 131 contravention $ 10,000(b) the Select Drain cleaner s 131 contravention $ 5,000(c) the other six s 131 contraventions $ 42,000

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered various factors in determining the appropriate penalties for Woolworths' misleading or deceptive conduct. It examined the seriousness of the contraventions, the health risks posed to consumers, and the systemic nature of Woolworths' conduct. The court noted that different approaches to penalty awards had been taken in previous cases, with some imposing separate penalties for each contravention and others imposing a single global penalty. In this case, the court found that the contraventions involved different conduct and events but overlapped in significant respects. The court also considered the mitigating factors presented by Woolworths, such as the absence of any positive finding of contravention and the absence of consumer harm due to the implementation of a recall program.

The court concluded that the $2.2 million proposed by Woolworths was insufficient to reflect the seriousness of the contraventions, particularly in light of the health risks posed to consumers by the misleading representations about the suitability for purpose of certain products. However, the court also noted that the maximum statutory penalty for a single contravention was $1.1 million, and a penalty of $4 million would exceed the amount that should be awarded in the circumstances. Therefore, the court determined that an appropriate total penalty would be $3,077,000, broken down as follows: $600,000 for the Deep Fryer contraventions, $1,400,000 for the two Select Drain Cleaner contraventions, $400,000 for the Safety Matches contraventions, $300,000 for the Flop Chair contraventions, and $300,000 for the Folding Stool contraventions. The court also imposed a penalty of $57,000 for the eight section 131 contraventions.

In addition to the pecuniary penalties, the court ordered Woolworths to take certain measures to ensure compliance with consumer protection laws in the future. These measures included prominently publishing links to recall information on the internet homepage and smartphone application, implementing an upgraded dedicated product safety compliance program, and providing evidence of the program's implementation to the ACCC.

The court's reasoning was based on the principles of consumer protection under the Australian Consumer Law and the need to deter and punish misleading or deceptive conduct. The court relied on previous cases to determine the appropriate approach to penalty awards and the relevant considerations in assessing the seriousness of the contraventions. The ratio decidendi of the decision is that the court should consider the totality of the conduct, the health risks posed to consumers, and the systemic nature of the contraventions when determining the appropriate penalty for misleading or deceptive conduct. The court also considered mitigating factors, such as the absence of consumer harm and the absence of a positive finding of contravention, in determining the appropriate penalty.