FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Reebok Australia Pty Ltd [2015] FCA 83
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Reebok Aust... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2015] FCA 83
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues before the Court were whether the proposed orders were appropriate given the admitted contraventions and whether the pecuniary penalty was within the appropriate range. The Court examined the nature of the misleading representations concerning the nature, characteristics, and suitability of purpose of EasyTone shoes, and whether these representations were false or misleading. Additionally, the Court assessed the adequacy of the response by Reebok Australia to the Federal Trade Commission's (FTC) settlement and the appropriateness of the proposed non-punitive relief and compliance measures.
The Court found that the admitted conduct, which spanned approximately 18 months and involved supplying 16,448 pairs of EasyTone shoes across Australia, was deliberate and widespread. Reebok Australia had made specific claims regarding the toning and strengthening benefits of the shoes without reasonable grounds to support these claims. The Court accepted that the total pecuniary penalty of $350,000 was appropriate, considering the totality of the contraventions and the inadequacy of Reebok Australia's response to the FTC's settlement. The Court also approved the non-punitive relief for non-party consumers, the establishment of a compliance program, and the publication orders as suitable measures to address the contraventions and prevent future occurrences.
In conclusion, the Court granted the orders as requested by the parties, including injunctions preventing future misleading conduct, a pecuniary penalty of $350,000, a compliance program, corrective advertising, redress for affected consumers, and a contribution to the ACCC's costs. The detailed orders included specific requirements for the compliance program, the format and content of the corrective notices, and the process for consumer redress.
Orders
Orders of the court
Injunctions
8. Reebok Australia be restrained for a period of three years from the date of these orders, whether by itself or its servants or agents or otherwise howsoever, in trade or commerce in Australia, from supplying footwear to retailers with any words, images or pictures that state or convey that use of the footwear offered for sale will improve toning and/or strengthening beyond any improvement which may result from using a traditional footwear of that kind unless Reebok Australia has first obtained written evidence from an expert substantiating that there is a sound scientific basis for making such statements.
Non-punitive Orders
Compliance Program
9. Reebok Australia will at its own expense:
9.1. establish, within three months of the date of this order, a Competition and Consumer Law Compliance Program (Compliance Program) which meets the requirements set out in Annexure A and maintain the Compliance Program for 3 years from the date on which it is established; or
9.2. if it already maintains an existing Compliance Program:
9.2.1. within 3 months of the date of this order, review the existing Compliance Program and make any amendments necessary to ensure that it meets the requirements set out in Annexure A; and
9.2.2. maintain this program for at least 3 years from the date on which the amendments referred to in paragraph 9.2.1 are made.
Corrective Advertising
10. Reebok Australia will:
10.1. within 28 days of the date of order take all reasonable steps to cause to be published, at its own expense, a corrective notice in the Saturday edition of The Australian newspaper, which is in the form and terms of Annexure B (Newspaper Notice), and take reasonable steps to ensure that the notice:
10.1.1. is placed within the first 10 pages of the newspaper;
10.1.2. is at least 28 centimetres by 5 columns in size and / or of a size no less than one quarter of a page in the newspaper;
10.1.3. has a banner font of sans serif 12 point bold;
10.1.4. has a headline font of 12 point bold;
10.1.5. has a body text font of no less than 11 point;
10.1.6. has the Applicant’s (ACCC) and Commonwealth logos of at least 25 millimetres in height and centred;
10.1.7. has a baseline text of at least 8 point and centred;
10.2. within 28 days of the date of order, publish or cause to be published a corrective notice in the form and terms of Annexure B, on its website www.reebok.com/en-au/ (Website Notice), and use all reasonable steps to ensure that the notice:
10.2.1. is accessible by a prominent one-click link displayed in the top third of the homepage of Reebok Australia’s website entitled “Corrective Notice - Breaches of the Australian Consumer Law” and satisfies the following specifications:
10.2.1.1. the words “CORRECTIVE NOTICE - BREACHES OF THE AUSTRALIAN CONSUMER LAW” are to be in uppercase, 18 point, bold, black, sans serif font on a white background, centred and in a black bordered box;
10.2.1.2. the words “Click here for further information” are to be 14 point, black, sans serif font on a white background and centred below the words “CORRECTIVE NOTICE - BREACHES OF THE AUSTRALIAN CONSUMER LAW” in the same bordered box;
10.2.1.3. the bordered box is to be at least 255 pixels wide by 60 pixels high; and
10.2.1.4. the bordered box and its contents, including white space, is to operate in the form of a one-click hyperlink to the website notice; and
10.2.2. is to be substantially the same as the notice in Annexure B, including font and formatting, and:
10.2.2.1. has a headline font of no less than 12 point, bold, black, sans serif font on a white background;
10.2.2.2. has a body text font of no less than 12 point, bold, black, sans serif font on a white background;
10.2.2.3. is of at least 540 pixels wide by 500 pixels high;
10.2.2.4. has a black border that is 3 pixels wide;
10.2.2.5. Reebok Australia’s, ACCC’s and Commonwealth logos are to be in colour, centred, and at least 25 millimetres high;
10.2.2.6. is to be displayed on a stand-alone webpage that is coded in standard “HTML” format; and
10.2.2.7. is not displayed as a “pop-up” or “pop-under” window; and
10.2.2.8. is maintained for a period of no less than 90 days from the date of order.
Non-party Consumer Redress
11. Reebok Australia will at its own expense:
11.1. within 14 days of the date of this order and prior to the publication of the Newspaper Notice and Website Notice:
11.1.1. establish an email address by which consumers who are responding to the Newspaper Notice or Website Notice can contact Reebok Australia;
11.1.2. establish a 1800 telephone number by which consumers who are responding to the Newspaper Notice or Website Notice can contact Reebok Australia; and
11.1.3. appoint a representative or representatives of Reebok Australia (Contact Officer) to deal with any correspondence received by Reebok Australia in response to the Newspaper Notice or Website Notice;
11.2. maintain the email address, telephone number and Contact Officer for a period that is not less than 150 days from the date of the date of this order; and
11.3. for each consumer who contacts Reebok Australia within four months of the date of publication of the Newspaper Notice or Website Notice and in response to the Newspaper Notice or Website Notice claims to have suffered loss or damage due to Reebok Australia’s contraventions:
11.3.1. assess whether the consumer has provided sufficient proof of purchase of EasyTone shoes from an authorised retailer of Reebok Australia during the period September 2011 and February 2013, such assessment to be made within 14 days of the claim; and
11.3.2. if it is determined that the consumer has a valid claim pursuant to paragraph 11.3.1 above, pay to the consumer $35 for each pair of EasyTone shoes purchased, such payment to be made within 14 days of the date of determination of a valid claim
(Consumer Redress Process).
12. Reebok Australia will at its own expense:
12.1. within 180 days of the date of this order, cause a review of the Consumer Redress Process to take place (Consumer Redress Process Review);
12.2. ensure that the Consumer Redress Process Review is conducted with access to all relevant sources of information in Reebok Australia’s possession or control, including without limitation Reebok Australia’s records of the communications with customers who have responded to the Newspaper Notice or Website Notice;
12.3. ensure that the findings of the Consumer Redress Process Review are set out in a report to be provided to the ACCC (Consumer Redress Process Review Report), which will provide particular and specific information regarding the scope of the Consumer Redress Process Review and, at a minimum, report on the following:
12.3.1. the number of consumers who contacted Reebok Australia through the Consumer Redress Process;
12.3.2. the number of consumers who are given redress; and
12.3.3. the number of consumers who were denied redress and reasons why any such consumers were denied redress; and
12.4. Reebok Australia will cause the Consumer Redress Process Review Report to be provided to the ACCC on a confidential basis within 14 days of completion of the Consumer Redress Process Review.
Costs
13. Reebok Australia pay to the ACCC a contribution towards its costs of, and incidental to, these proceedings in the amount of $45,000 within 60 days.
Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Toning, Strengthening and Percentage Representations were made in circumstances where wearing EasyTone shoes would not result in an increase in the toning or strengthening of the wearer's buttocks, thighs/hamstrings and calves by, or by up to, the specific percentage amounts represented compared to that which would result from wearing a traditional walking shoe and Reebok Australia had no reasonable grounds for making the Toning, Strengthening and Percentage Representations. Other considerations Whether conduct deliberate and period over which conduct extended The admitted conduct occurred over approximately 18 months from September 2011 to February 2013 and was spread across all of Australia. Reebok Australia supplied 16,448 pairs of EasyTone shoes to retailers for sale to consumers following the FTC Settlement and up to 3 May 2012, including the supply of 223 pairs to retailers in Queensland, 694 pairs to retailers in New South Wales, 591 pairs to retailers in Victoria, 18 pairs to retailers in Tasmania, 75 pairs to retailers in South Australia, 14,791 pairs to retailers in Western Australia, 13 pairs to retailers in the Northern Territory and 43 pairs to retailers in the Australian Capital Territory. Reebok Australia made credence claims regarding the EasyTone shoes for consumers to rely on when deciding to purchase the shoes in circumstances where the consumers were unable to readily verify those claims. The statements made in the EasyTone Shoe Box Promotional Material and EasyTone In-Store Promotional Material were developed by Reebok International and Reebok Australia had not conducted testing to substantiate the claims. The tests relied upon by Reebok International to substantiate the Toning, Strengthening and Percentage Representations made on advertising or promotional material measured muscle activation at a point in time and were insufficient to substantiate such claims and representations. Issues concerning the accuracy of the Toning, Strengthening and Percentage Representations regarding the EasyTone shoes were brought to Reebok Australia's attention as follows: (a)in February 2011, Reebok Australia was made aware of issues concerning the 28 November 2011 Claim; (b)on or about 17 September 2011, Reebok Australia was made aware of the FTC Investigation; (c)on 28 September 2011, Reebok Australia was made aware of the FTC Settlement; and (d)on 29 September 2011, Reebok Australia was made aware that the claims made by Reebok International in the USA related to the Toning, Strengthening and Percentage Representations. Additionally, the ACCC first raised concerns with Reebok Australia on 29 August 2012 about the conduct. Contraventions in relation to the EasyTone Shoe Box Promotional Material continued until February 2013 whilst Reebok Australia undertook voluntary over-stickering and removal of the EasyTone Shoe Box Promotional Material. Contraventions in relation to the EasyTone In-Store Promotional Material continued until about December 2012. Further, Reebok Australia responded to ACCC correspondence and compulsory investigative notices, but Reebok Australia continued to deny liability up until May 2014.