Background
Background to the litigation
As is common in matters such as the present, a Statement of Agreed Facts was filed in the proceeding. Those agreed facts are relevantly as follows:“STATEMENT OF AGREED FACTS1. This Statement of Agreed Facts is made by the parties in these proceedings for the purposes of section 191 of the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth). A. ADMITTED CONTRAVENTIONS2. On the basis of the facts set out below, the First Respondent admits to contravening the following civil remedy provisions of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (FW Act) with respect to the employments of David van Heuzen (Mr van Heuzen) and Mr Joseph Melit (Mr Melit) (collectively, the Employees) in the period from 30 September 2013 to 30 June 2015, or part thereof:a) section 44 of the FW Act by: i) failing to pay Mr Melit personal leave pursuant to section 99 of the FW Act; ii) failing to pay the Employees for their absences on a public holiday as required by section 116 of the FW Act; b) section 45 of the FW Act by: i) failing to pay Mr Melit weekly as required by clause 31.3 of the Building and Construction General On-Site Award 2010 (Building Award) ii) failing to pay the Employees the minimum rate of pay required by clause 19.7(b) of the Building Award and the allowances prescribed in clause 19.7(e) of the Building Award; iii) failing to pay the Employees their Fares and Travel Patterns Allowances as required by clause 25.12 and 25.2 of the Building Award; iv) failing to pay the Employees overtime as required by clause 36.2 of the Building Award; v) failing to pay the Employees Saturday penalty rates as required by clause 37.1 of the Building Award; vi) failing to pay Mr van Huezen annual leave as required by clause 38.2(a) of the Building Award; vii) failing to pay Mr van Huezen annual leave loading as required by clause38.2(b) of the Building Award; and (c) section 340(1)(a)(ii) of the FW Act by taking adverse action against Mr Melit because Mr Melit exercised a workplace right, namely taking personal leave; (d) section 535 of the FW Act by failing to keep for seven (7) years records of the kind prescribed by the FW Regulations in relation to Mr Melit; (e) section 536 of the FW Act by failing to provide Mr Melit with payslips as required in the period February 2014 to June 2015. (Admitted Contraventions)3. The Second Respondent admits that he was involved in the Admitted Contraventions pursuant to section 550(1) of the FW Act.4. The First Respondent further admits that it failed to provide Mr Melit's safety net contractual entitlement to be paid ordinary wages for ordinary hours in the period from 13 February 2015 to 4 May 2015.B. THE PARTIESThe Applicant5. The Applicant is, and was at all times material to this proceeding:(a) a statutory appointee of the Commonwealth appointed by the Governor General by written instrument pursuant to section 687(1) of the FW Act;(b) a Fair Work Inspector pursuant to section 701 of the FW Act;(c) a person with standing to bring these proceedings, in accordance with section 539(2) of the FW Act; and(d) a person with standing under section 541 of the FW Act to apply for orders on behalf of employees in respect of contraventions of safety net contractual entitlements.The First Respondent6. The First Respondent is, and was at all times material to this proceeding:(a) a company incorporated under the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth);(b) able to be sued in and by its corporate name;(c) a constitutional corporation within the meaning of section 12 of the FW Act; and(d) a national system employer within the meaning of section 14 of the FW Act.7. At all material times, the First Respondent carried on a building and construction business in Queensland (Business).The Second Respondent8. The Second Respondent is, and was at all material times:(a) the sole director of the First Respondent;(b) the sole shareholder of the First Respondent;(c) the operative and controlling mind of the First Respondent;(d) responsible for the overall operation, management and control of the Business; and(e) responsible for ensuring that the First Respondent complied with its legal obligations under the FW Act.9. By reason of section 793 of the FW Act and the matters set out in paragraph 8 above, the conduct engaged in by the Second Respondent on behalf of the First Respondent is taken to have been engaged in by the First Respondent for the purpose of the FW Act.C. EMPLOYMENT OF THE EMPLOYEESDavid van Heuzen10. Mr van Heuzen commenced employment with the Second Respondent at 17 years of age and worked for the Second Respondent from~28 May 2012 to about 29 September 2013.11. Mr van Heuzen was employed by the First Respondent from 30 September 2013 to 15 January 2015 (van Heuzen Period).12. At all material times, Mr van Heuzen worked for the First Respondent pursuant to a contract of training registered with the Queensland Department of Education, Training and Employment (DETE) (van Heuzen Training Contract) which included the following terms:(a) Title and level of qualification: Certificate Ill in Carpentry;(b) Commencement date: 28 May 2012;(c) Nominal term of Training Contract: 48 months;(d) Highest completed school level: year 12 or equivalent;(e) Type of employment arrangement: federal award;(f) Name of Award: Building Award;(g) Number of hours of employment and training per week: 38 hours; and(h) Full-time or part-time apprenticeship: full-time.Joseph Melit13. Mr Melit commenced employment with the First Respondent at 17 years of age and worked for the First Respondent from 11 February 2014 to 30 June 2015 (Melit Period).14. At all material times, Mr Melit worked for the First Respondent pursuant to a contract of training registered with the DETE (Melit Training Contract) which included the following terms:(a) Title and level of qualification: Certificate Ill in Carpentry;(b) Commencement date: 4 February 2014;(c) Nominal term of Training Contract: 48 months;(d) Highest completed school level: year 12 or equivalent;(e) Type of employment arrangement: federal award;(f) Name of Award: Building Award;(g) Number of hours of employment and training per week: 38 hours; and(h) Full-time or part-time apprenticeship: full-time.Hours of work15. The usual hours of work for the Employees were:(a) six days per week;(b) Monday to Thursday, from between 6:00 and 6:30 am to between 3:00 and 6:00 pm;(c) Friday, from between 6:00 and 6:30 am to between 2:30 and 5:00 pm;(d) Saturday, from approximately 6:30 am to between 12:00 and 5:00 pm;(e) breaking for 30 minutes each day on which work continued in excess of five hours.16. At all material times, the Employees completed and submitted timecards to the First Respondent containing the following details:(a) time period and week number;(b) day of the week;(c) job name or street address;(d) description of work carried out;(e) start, lunch and finish times; and(f) daily and weekly total hours.Periods of non-payment17. Mr van Heuzen performed work for the First Respondent in the following weeks for which he received no payment at all from the First Respondent:(a) week commencing'8 December 2014;(b) week commencing 15 December 2014; and(c) week commencing 12 January 2015.18. Mr Melit performed work for the First Respondent in the following weeks for which he received no payment at all from the First Respondent:(a) week commencing 8 September 2014; ·(b) week commencing 2 February 2015;(c) week commencing 9 February 2015;(d) week commencing 18 May 2015;(e) week commencing 25 May 2015;(f) week commencing 1 June 2015;(g) week commencing 8 June 2015;(h) week commencing 15 June 2015;(i) week commencing 22 June 2015; and(j) week commencing 29 June 2015,(Melit Period of Non-payment).D. THE LEGISLATION AND APPLICABLE INDUSTRIAL INSTRUMENTS19. At all relevant times, the First Respondent was required to comply with the FW Act in respect of the employment of the Employees.20. At all relevant times:(a) the First Respondent was bound by the Building Award; and(b) the Building Award applied to the First Respondent and the Employees.21. By reason of the matters set out in paragraphs 12 and 14, the Employees were entitled to be classified as "apprentices".22. By reason of the matters set out in paragraphs 1 to 12 above, Mr van Heuzen was entitled to the following classifications during the following periods:(a) Stage 1 apprentice from 28 May 2012 to 27 May 2013;(b) Stage 2 apprentice from 28 May 2013 to 27 May 2014; and(c) Stage 3 apprentice from 28 May 2014 to 15 January 2015.23. By reason of the matters set out in paragraphs 13 and 14 above, Mr Melit was entitled to the following classifications during the following periods:(a) Stage 1 apprentice from 11 February 2014 to 10 February 2015;(b) Stage 2 apprentice from 11 February 2015 to 30 June 2015.E. ADMITTED CONTRAVENTIONSFailure to pay wages on a weekly basis - Mr Melit24. The First Respondent was required by clause 31.3 of the Building Award to pay Mr Melit not later than the end of ordinary hours of work on Thursday of each week.25. During the Melit Period of Non-payment, Mr Melit performed work for the First Respondent.26. For each of the weeks in the Melit Period of Non-Payment, the First Respondent failed to pay Mr Melit not later than the end of ordinary hours of work on Thursday of each week, or at all.27. By reason of the matters set out at paragraphs 24 to 26, the First Respondent contravened section 45 of the FW Act by failing to pay Mr Melit weekly as required by clause 31.3 of the Building Award or at all.Failure to pay ordinary wage for ordinary hours worked - Mr Melit and Mr van Heuzen28. At all material times, the First Respondent was required by clause 19.7(b) of the Building Award to pay the Employees a minimum rate of pay, in addition to the allowances prescribed in clause 19.7(e) of the Building Award, as part of the ordinary weekly wage for all purposes (Ordinary Wages).29. During the Melit Period:(a) Mr Melit performed hours of work, for which he was entitled to be paid Ordinary Wages, which are set out in columns C and D of Schedule 1;(b) the First Respondent was required to pay Mr Melit amounts on account of Ordinary Wages which are set out in column E of Schedule 1; and(c) the First Respondent only paid Mr Melit amounts for Ordinary Wages which are set out in column F of Schedule 1, resulting in an underpayment of $4,477.85 as set out in column G of Schedule 1.30. During the van Heuzen Period:(a) Mr van Heuzen performed hours of work, for which he was entitled to be paid Ordinary Wages, whi9h are set out in columns C and D of Schedule 2;(b) the First Respondent was required to pay Mr van Heuzen amounts on account of Ordinary Wages which are set out in column E of Schedule 2; and(c) the First Respondent only paid Mr van Heuzen amounts for Ordinary Wages which are set out in column F of Schedule 1, resulting in an underpayment of $2,179.74 as set out in column G of Schedule 2.31. By reason of the matters set out at paragraphs 28 to 30 above, the First Respondent contravened section 45 of the FW Act by failing to pay the Employees the minimum rate of pay as required by clause 19.7(b) of the Building Award and the allowances prescribed in clause 19.7(e) of the Building Award.Failure to pay personal leave entitlements - Mr Melit32. By reason of the matter set out at paragraph 14(h) above, Mr Melit accrued 10 days of paid personal/carer's leave for each year of service with the First Respondent in accordance with section 96(2) of the FW Act.33. As at 11 February 2015, Mr Melit had accrued 10 days' personal/carer's leave.34. The First Respondent was required by section 99 of the FW Act to pay Mr Melit for periods of personal leave taken at Mr Melit's base rate of pay for the ordinary hours of work for that period.35. On 11 and 12 February 2015:(a) Mr Melit took 16 ordinary hours "of personal leave for which he was entitled to be paid the base rate of pay which is set out in column C of Schedule 1;(b) the First Respondent was required to pay Mr Melit an amount on account of paid personal leave which is set out in column E of Schedule 1;(c) the First Respondent did not pay Mr Melit any amount on account of paid personal leave, resulting in an underpayment of $204.16 as set out in column G of Schedule 1.36. By reason of the matters set out in paragraphs 32 to 35 above, the First Respondent contravened section 44(1) of the FW Act by failing to pay Mr Melit personal leave pursuant to section 99 of the FW Act.Taking adverse action against Mr Melit37. Section 340(1)(a)(ii) of the FW Act prohibited the First Respondent from taking adverse action against Mr Melit because Mr Melit had exercised a workplace right.38. Mr Melit had a workplace right pursuant to section 341(1)(a) of the FW Act in that he was entitled to a benefit under a workplace law to take paid personal leave pursuant to section 97 of the FW Act.39. On 11 and 12 February 2015, Mr Melit exercised his workplace right to take paid personal leave.40. The First Respondent took adverse action against Mr Melit within the meaning of section 342(1) in that the First Respondent injured Mr Melit in his employment and/or the First Respondent altered the position of Mr Melit to Mr Melit’s prejudice, in that the First Respondent failed or refused to provide Mr Melit with 38 hours' work per week between 13 February 2015 and 4 May 2015 in accordance with the Melit Training Contract.41. The First Respondent took the adverse action set out in paragraph 40 above because Mr Melit exercised a workplace right as set out in paragraph 39 above.42. By reason of the matters set out in paragraphs 37 to 41 above, Mr Melit suffered loss in the amount of $6,220.80 by not receiving his ordinary wages for his ordinary hours from 13 February 2015 to 4 May 2015 as set out in columns C, D and E of Schedule 1.43. By reason of the matters set out in paragraphs 37 to 41 above, the First Respondent contravened 340( 1 )( a)(ii) of the FW Act by taking adverse action against Mr Melit.Failing to pay Safety Net Contractual Entitlement- Mr Melit44. Further to the contravention set out at paragraph 43 above, Mr Melit had an entitlement to be paid his ordinary wages for his ordinary hours from 13 February 2015 to 4 May 2015 which was a safety net contractual entitlement pursuant to section 542(1) of the FW Act.45. By reason of the matters set out in paragraph 44 above, and by acting as set out in paragraph 40 above, namely failing or refusing to provide Mr Melit with 38 hours' work per week between 13 February 2015 and 4 May 2015 in accordance with the Melit Training Contract, the First Respondent failed to provide Mr Melit's safety net contractual entitlement to payment for his full time hours of work of 38 hours per week.46. By reason of the failure admitted in paragraph 45 above, the First Respondent underpaid Mr Melit $6,220.80 as set out in columns C to G in Schedule 1.Failing to make and keep employee records - Mr Melit47. Pursuant to section 5'35 of !he FW Act, the First Respondent was required to keep for seven (7) years records of the kind prescribed in Chapter 3, Part 3-6, Division 3, Subdivision 1 of the Fair Work Regulations 2009 (FW Regulations) in relation to each of its employees.48. The First Respondent failed to keep for seven (7) years any records of the kind prescribed by regulations 3.31 to 3.34, 3.36 to 3.37 and 3.40 of the FW Regulations in relation to Mr Melit.49. By reason of the matters set out in paragraphs 47-to 48 above, the First Respondent contravened section 535 of the FW Act by failing to keep for seven (7) years records of the kind prescribed by the FW Regulations in relation to Mr Melit.Failing to give pay slips - Mr Melit50. Pursuant to section 536 of the FW Act, the First Respondent was required to give Mr Melit a pay slip within one working day of paying an amount in relation to the performance of work.51. During the Melit Period, Mr Melit was paid amounts in relation to the performance of work for the First Respondent.52. The First Respondent failed to provide to Mr Melit any payslips during the Melit Period.53. By reason of the matters set out in paragraphs 50 to 52 above, the First Respondent contravened section 536 of the FW Act by failing to provide Mr Melit with any payslips during the Melit Period.Failing to pay fares and travel patterns allowance - Mr Melit and Mr van Heuzen54. At all material times, the First Respondent was required by clause 25.12 of the Building Award to pay the Employees a proportion of the allowances prescribed in clause 25.2 of the Building Award.55. The First Respondent was required by clause 25.2 of the Building Award to pay an employee an allowance of $17.01 from 30 September 2013 to 30 June 2014 and $17.43 from 1 July 2014 to 30 June 2015 for each day worked on construction work at a construction site located:(a) within a radius of 50 kilometres of the GPO in a capital city of a State or Territory; or(b) within a radius of 50 kilometres of the principal post office in a regional city or town in a State or Territory(Fares and Travel Patterns Allowance).56. During the Melit Period:(a) Mr Melit worked various days on construction sites located within the radiuses set out at paragraphs 55(a) and 55(b) above, for which he was entitled to be paid the Fares and Travel Patterns Allowance, as set out in columns C, D and E of Schedule 1;(b) the First Respondent was required to pay Mr Melit amounts on account of the Fares and Travel Patterns Allowance which are set out in column E of Schedule 1;(c) the First Respondent only paid Mr Melit the amounts on account of the Fares and Travel Patterns Allowance which are set out in column F of Schedule 1, resulting in an underpayment of $1,224.06as set out in column G of Schedule 1.57. During the van Heuzen Period:(a) Mr van Heuzen worked various days on construction sites located within the radius set out at paragraph 55(a) above, for which he was entitled to be paid the Fares and Travel Patterns Allowance, as set out in columns C and D of Schedule 2;(b) the First Respondent was required to pay Mr van Heuzen amounts on account of the Fares and Travel Patterns Allowance which are set out in column E of Schedule 2;(c) the First Respondent only paid Mr van Heuzen the amounts on account of the Fares and Travel Patterns Allowance which are set out in column F of Schedule 1, resulting in an underpayment of $543.35 as set out in column G of Schedule 1.58. For reason of the matters set out in paragraphs 54 to 57 above, the First Respondent contravened section 45 of the FW Act by failing to pay the Employees their Fares and Travel Patterns Allowances as required by clauses 25.2 and 25.12 of the Building Award.Failing to pay wages for absence on public holiday - Mr Melit and Mr van Heuzen59. Pursuant to section 116 of the FW Act, if an Employee is absent from their employment on a day that is a public holiday, the First Respondent is required to pay the Employee his base rate of pay for the Employee's ordinary hours of work on that day. 60. During the Melit Period:(a) Mr Melit was absent from his employment on the public holiday of 8 June 2015, and was entitled to be paid his base rate of pay for his ordinary hours of work, as set out in columns C and D of Schedule 1;(b) the First Respondent was required to pay Mr Melit an amount on account of the public holiday as set out in column E of Schedule 1; and(c) the First Respondent did not pay Mr Melit any amount on account of the public holiday as set out in column F in Schedule 1, resulting in an underpayment of $102.08 as set out in column G of Schedule 1.61. During the Mr van Heuzen Period,(a) Mr van Heuzen was absent from his employment on the following public holidays and was entitled to be paid his base rate of pay for his ordinary hours of work, as set out in columns C and D of Schedule 2:(i) 9 June 2014;(ii) 25 December 2014;(iii) 26 December 2014; and(iv) 1 January 2015;(b) the First Respondent was required to pay Mr van Heuzen amounts on account of the public holidays as set out in column E of Schedule 2; and(c) the First Respondent paid Mr van Heuzen amounts on account of the public holidays set out in column F of Schedule 2, resulting in an underpayment of $327 .80 as set out in column G of Schedule 2.62. By reason of the matters set out in paragraphs 59 to 61 above, the First Respondent contravened section 44(1) of the FW Act by failing to pay the Employees for their absences on a public holiday pursuant to section 116 of the FW Act.Failing to pay overtime - Mr Melit and Mr van Heuzen63. At all material times·, the First Respondent was required by clause 36.2 of the Building Award to pay the Employees overtime at the rate of time and a half for the first two hours and at double time thereafter for all time worked beyond the Employees' ordinary time of work, Monday to Friday.64. The Employees' ordinary hours of work were the first eight hours worked each day on Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday and Thursday (irrespective of start time), and the first 6 hours worked on Friday.65. The Employees' overtime rate is calculated on the basis of the Employees' ordinary wages pursuant to clause 19.7(e) of the Building Award.66. During the Melit Period:(a) Mr Melit performed overtime hours of work for which he was entitled to be paid at the rate of time and a half, and overtime hours of work for which he was entitled to be paid at the rate of double time, as set out in columns C and D of Schedule 1;(b) the First Respondent was required to pay Mr Melit amounts on account of overtime which are set out in column E of Schedule 1;(c) the First Respondent only paid Mr Melit amounts on account of overtime which are set out in column F of Schedule 1, resulting in an underpayment of $8,237.23 as set out in column G of Schedule 1.67. During the van Heuzen Period:(a) Mr van Heuzen performed overtime hours of work for which he was entitled to be paid at the rate of time and a half, and overtime hours of work for which he was entitled to be paid at the rate of double time, as set out in columns C and D of Schedule 2;(b) the First Respondent was required to pay Mr van Heuzen amounts on account of overtime which are set out in column E of Schedule 2;(c) the First Respondent only paid Mr van Heuzen amounts on account of overtime which are set out in column F of Schedule 1, resulting in an underpayment of $895.32 as set out in column G of Schedule 2.68. By reason of the matters set out in paragraphs 63 to 67 above, the First Respondent contravened .section 45 of the FW Act by failing to pay the Employees overtime as required by clause 36.2 of the Building Award.Failing to pay Saturday penalty rates - Mr Melit and Mr van Heuzen69. At all material times, the First Respondent was required by clause 37.1 of the Building Award to pay the Employees at the rate of time and a half for the first two hours and double time thereafter for work on a Saturday, provided that all time worked on Saturday after 12 noon was paid at the rate of double time.70. The Employees' Saturday penalty rate is calculated on the basis of the Employees' ordinary wages pursuant to clause 19.7(e) of the Building Award.71. During the Melit Period:(a) Mr Melit performed work on Saturdays for which he was entitled to be paid at the rate of time and a half, and work on Saturdays for which he was entitled to be paid at the rate of double time, as set out in columns C and D of Schedule 1;(b) the First Respondent was required to pay Mr Melit amounts on account of Saturday penalty rates which are set out in column E of Schedule 1;(c) the First Respondent only paid Mr Melit amounts on account of Saturday penalty rates which are set out in column F of Schedule 1, resulting in an underpayment of $4,453.49 as set out in column G of Schedule 1.72. During the van Heuzen Period:(a) Mr van Heuzen performed work on Saturdays for which he was entitled to be paid at the rate of time and a half, and work on Saturdays for which he was entitled to be paid at the rate of double time, as set out in columns C and D of Schedule 2;(b) the First Respondent was required to pay Mr van Heuzen amounts on account of Saturday penalty rates which are set out in column E of Schedule 2;(c) the First Respondent only paid Mr van Heuzen amounts on account of Saturday penalty rates which are set out in column F of Schedule 1, resulting in an underpayment of $1,439.95 as set out in column G of Schedule 2.73. By reason of the matters set out in paragraphs 69 to 72 above, the First Respondent contravened section 45 of the FW Act by failing to pay the Employees Saturday penalty rates as required by clause 37.1 of the Building Award.Failing to pay annual leave - Mr van Heuzen74. The First Respondent was required by clause 38.2(a) of the Building Award to pay Mr van Heuzen, ,when he took a period of paid annual leave, the amount that he would have received for working ordinary hours if he had not been on leave.75. The amount that Mr van Heuzen would have received for working ordinary hours, had he not been on leave, is his ordinary wages pursuant to clause 19.7(e) of the Building Award.76. In the period from 18 December 2014 to 11 January 2015, Mr van Heuzen took 14 days' annual leave (van Heuzen Annual Leave), as set out in columns C and D of Schedule 2, for which the First Respondent:(a) was required to pay Mr van Heuzen the amount set out in column E of Schedule 2; and(b) did not pay Mr van Heuzen any amount on account of these hours of annual leave taken, resulting in the underpayment of $1,737.34 as set out in column G of Schedule 1.77. By reason of the matters set out in paragraphs 74 to 76, the First Respondent contravened section 45 of the FW Act by failing to pay to Mr van Heuzen annual leave as required by clause 38.2(a) of the Building Award.Failing to pay annual leave loading - Mr van Heuzen78. During the van Heuzen Annual Leave, the First Respondent was required by clause 38.2(b) of the Building Award to pay Mr van Heuzen, an annual leave loading of 17.5% as set out in columns C and D of Schedule 2.79. During the van Heuzen Annual Leave the First Respondent,(a) was required to pay Mr van Heuzen an amount on account of annual leave loading which is set out in column E of Schedule 2; and(b) did not pay Mr van Heuzen any amount on account of annual leave loading, resulting in an underpayment of $304.03 as set out in column G of Schedule 1.80. By reason of the matters set out in paragraphs 78 to 79, the First Respondent contravened section 45 of the FW Act by failing to pay to Mr van Heuzen annual leave loading as required by clause 38.2(b) of the Building Award.F. TOTAL UNDERPAYMENT81. By reason of the matters admitted at paragraphs 24 to 80 above, the First Respondent underpaid the Employees a total amount of $32,347.20, being:(a) $24, 919.67 owing to Mr Melit; and (b)$7, 427.53 owing to Mr van Heuzen G. RECTIFICATION82. The First Respondent rectified the underpayments in full on:(a) 8 March 2017 in respect of Mr Melit; and(b) 9 March 2017 in respect of Mr van Heuzen.H. ACCESSORIAL LIABILITY OF THE SECOND RESPONDENT83. The parties repeat and rely on paragraphs 5 to 81 above.84. At all relevant times, the Second Respondent:(a) was aware of the Melit Training Contract and is referred to by name in the Melit Training Contract;(b) was aware of the van Heuzen Training Contract and is the person who signed the van Heuzen Training Contract;(c) was aware that the First Respondent was required to comply with the FW Act and industrial instruments;(d) was aware that the First Respondent was required to pay the Employees in accordance with the Building Award;(e) knew the duties and hours of work for each of the Employees;(f) knew the periods of leave taken by each of the Employees;(g) knew the amounts paid by the First Respondent to each of the Employees;(h) was solely responsible for paying the Employees;(i) was solely responsible for allocating work to the Employees; and(j) knew that at least some payslips were not provided to Mr Melit.85. The Second Respondent was the person with whom the Applicant dealt during the course of the investigation in relation to the Employees.86. By reason of the matters set out in paragraphs 83 to 85 above, the Second Respondent admits that, by way of his acts and omissions, he was:(a) involved in (within the meaning of section 550 of the FW Act) each of the contraventions admitted by the First Respondent above; and(b) taken to have himself committed each of the contraventions admitted by the First Respondent.