Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Campbell (No 3)

Link copied
Case Copied 77 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Campbell (No 3) [2021] FCA 528  

File number: VID 612 of 2019
Judgment of: O'BRYAN J
Date of judgment: 19 May 2021
Catchwords:

CONSUMER LAW – application for remedies under the Australian Consumer Law (Schedule 2 to the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth)) – contraventions of ss 18, 29(1)(g), 36(3) and 36(4) of the Australian Consumer Law – where the respondents sold franchises to consumers representing that those franchises would be operational within 12 months, and received payments from franchisees on that basis, but in most instances did not supply a franchise within that period or at all – where the contravening conduct caused substantial loss to franchisees – where the first respondent is in liquidation and the third respondent has limited financial resources – where the parties have jointly filed statements of agreed facts and admissions – where the applicant and third respondent have agreed penalties and filed joint submissions in support of agreed penalties – where the first respondent does not oppose the orders sought by the applicant – consideration of the relevant principles to the assessment of pecuniary penalties, non-party consumer redress orders, declaratory and injunctive relief

STATUTORY INTERPRETATION – proper construction of s 227 of the Australian Consumer Law – meaning and effect of the requirement to give preference to making an order for compensation – whether orders proposed by the applicant satisfy that requirement

Legislation:

Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth) s 82(3)

Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) ss 80, 137H

Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) Schedule 2 (Australian Consumer Law) ss 4, 18, 29(1)(g), 36(3), 36(4), 224, 227, 232, 233, 239, 240(1), 240(3)

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) s 553B

Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) s 191

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 37AF(1)

Cases cited:

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v ACN 117 372 915 Pty Ltd (in liq) (formerly Advanced Medical Institute Pty Ltd) [2015] FCA 368; ATPR 42-498

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v AGL South Australia Pty Ltd [2015] FCA 399; 146 ALD 385

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Birubi Art Pty Ltd (in liq) (No 3) [2019] FCA 996; 374 ALR 776

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Campbell [2019] FCA 886

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Campbell (No 2) [2019] FCA 1487

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Clinica Internationale Pty Ltd (No 2) [2016] FCA 62

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Coles Supermarkets Australia Pty Ltd [2014] FCA 1405

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Geowash Pty Ltd (Subject to a Deed of Company Arrangement) (No 4) [2020] FCA 23; 376 ALR 701

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Pratt (No 3) (2009) 175 FCR 558

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Reebok Australia Pty Ltd [2015] FCA 83; ATPR 42-501

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v STA Travel Pty Ltd [2020] FCA 723

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v TPG Internet Pty Ltd (2013) 250 CLR…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Campbell (N... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] FCA 528
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) brought proceedings against Mr Campbell and two companies, Jump Loops and Swim Loops Holdings, alleging that they contravened various sections of the Australian Consumer Law. The primary dispute centred on the failure of the respondents to deliver operational franchises within the promised timeframe, causing significant financial loss to franchisees. The case was heard in the Federal Court of Australia, which was tasked with determining the appropriate remedies and penalties.

The court had to decide several legal issues, including the proper interpretation of the statutory requirement to give preference to making compensation orders under section 227 of the Australian Consumer Law. The court also had to consider the appropriate pecuniary penalties, consumer redress orders, and injunctive relief in light of the contravening conduct by Mr Campbell and the companies. The court needed to balance the need for deterrence and punishment with the principle of compensating affected consumers.

The court found that Mr Campbell's conduct warranted significant penalties and injunctive relief. It concluded that the injunctions proposed by the ACCC were appropriate and necessary to prevent future breaches. The court also determined that the penalties and consumer redress orders proposed by the ACCC, while significant, were necessary to achieve the objectives of deterrence and consumer protection. The court further found that the orders satisfied the statutory requirement to give preference to making compensation orders, as they included provisions for compensating affected franchisees.

In its decision, the court ordered Jump Loops to pay a pecuniary penalty of $23 million, and Mr Campbell, as the third respondent, to pay a penalty of $400,000. Additionally, Mr Campbell was required to contribute $500,000 towards a redress scheme for affected franchisees. The court imposed several injunctive orders to prevent Mr Campbell from making misleading representations about franchise timeframes and from being involved in the franchising sector for three years. The court also varied the existing freezing orders to allow for the payment of penalties and redress.

The court's decision underscored the importance of holding corporate entities and their directors accountable for misleading conduct that causes substantial consumer loss. The orders reflect a commitment to ensuring that consumers receive appropriate redress and that entities engaging in such conduct are effectively deterred from repeating their actions.

Orders

Orders of the court

Penalty

6. Pursuant to s 224 of the Australian Consumer Law, the First Respondent pay to the Commonwealth of Australia an aggregate pecuniary penalty in the sum of $23 million.

7. Pursuant to s 224 of the Australian Consumer Law, the Third Respondent pay to the Commonwealth of Australia an aggregate pecuniary penalty in the sum of $400,000.

8. The penalty in order 7 is due and payable:

(a) if the payment in order 9 below is paid within the time required by that order, by 30 June 2022; or

(b) otherwise, by the date which is 50 days after the date of these orders.

Orders to redress loss

9. Pursuant to s 239 of the Australian Consumer Law, the Third Respondent must pay to the trust account of HWL Ebsworth Lawyers by the date which is 21 days after the date of these orders, the amount of $500,000 (Funds) and must direct HWL Ebsworth Lawyers to apply the Funds solely in accordance with the requirements set out in the Appendix to these orders (Redress Scheme).

10. The Third Respondent must notify the Applicant within 24 hours of payment of the Funds pursuant to order 9.

11. Subject to, and from the date on which the Third Respondent makes, payment of the Funds pursuant to order 9 (Scheme Commencement Date), the Applicant and the Third Respondent must comply with the requirements set out in the Redress Scheme as applicable to each of them.

12. The Applicant and the Third Respondent have liberty to apply to the Court to vary the requirements of the Redress Scheme if they become impracticable to comply with.

Injunctions

13. Pursuant to s 232 of the Australian Consumer Law, the Third Respondent be restrained for a period of 5 years from the date of this order from being knowingly concerned in, or party to, the making of representations to a prospective franchisee concerning the timeframe for establishing an operational franchise in circumstances where there are not reasonable grounds for such representations.

14. Pursuant to s 232 of the Australian Consumer Law, the Third Respondent be restrained for a period of 5 years from being knowingly concerned in, or party to, the acceptance of payment or other consideration for the supply of goods or services for, or relating to, the business of a franchisor in circumstances where, at the time of acceptance, the person accepting the payment or other consideration is aware, or ought reasonably to be aware, that there are reasonable grounds for believing the goods or services would not be supplied within the period specified at or before the time the payment or other consideration is accepted or, if no period is specified, within a reasonable time.

15. For a period of 3 years from the date of these orders, the Third Respondent be restrained in Australia from being in any way, directly or indirectly, involved in carrying on business as or of a franchisor, including as an individual franchisor or as an employee, director, manager, servant, agent or representative of another person (including a corporation).

16. For the purposes of these orders, the term "franchisor" has the same meaning as those terms are defined in clause 4 of Schedule 1 of the Competition and Consumer (Industry Codes - Franchising) Regulation 2014 (Cth) as in force on 31 March 2020.

Freezing orders

17. The freezing orders made on 7 June 2019, as varied on 12 June 2019, 19 June 2019 and 28 June 2019 (the Freezing Orders), be:

(a) further varied to allow the Third Respondent to make the payment under paragraphs 7 and 9 above; and

(b) discharged from the date on which the Third Respondent makes the payment under paragraphs 7 and 9 above.

Confidentiality

18. Pursuant to s 37AF(1) of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth), in order to prevent prejudice to the proper administration of justice, the personal and company names contained in:

(a) the First and Second Annexures to the Statement of Agreed Facts and Admissions dated 6 November 2020;

(b) the Annexure to the Supplementary Statement of Agreed Facts dated 14 December 2020;

(c) the First and Second Annexures to the Statement of Agreed Facts and Admissions dated 17 December 2020; and

(d) Annexures A to D to the Judgment,

be kept confidential and:

(i) are not to be accessed by any person other than by the Court and the parties to this proceeding and their legal advisors, including HWL Ebsworth Lawyers; and

(ii) their contents are prohibited from being disclosed (save as between the parties) by publication or otherwise.

Other

19. The Applicant’s claims against the Respondents are otherwise dismissed.

20. There be no order as to costs.

21. A copy of the Judgment in this proceeding, with the seal of the Court thereon, be retained in the Court for the purposes of s 137H of the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth).

APPENDIX

Redress Scheme

1. Subject to further order of the Court, the Funds must only be paid in accordance with the terms of the Redress Scheme set out in this Appendix.

2. The persons eligible to be paid compensation from the Funds pursuant to the Redress Scheme (eligible persons) are those persons listed in Annexure D to the Judgment.

3. Within 14 days of the Scheme Commencement Date, the Third Respondent must provide the Applicant with all contact details (including mail and email addresses) known to the Third Respondent for each of the eligible persons.

4. The Applicant must:

a. within 28 days of the Scheme Commencement Date, send a notice to each of the eligible persons for which the Applicant has a last known mail address and/or email address; or

b. where the Applicant has no last known mail address and/or email address for any eligible person, within 45 days of the Scheme Commencement Date use its best endeavours to locate and contact them so as to provide them with a notice,

stating that:

c. the Court has found that the Third Respondent was knowingly concerned in, and party to, contraventions of s 29(1)(g) of the Australian Consumer Law by the First and Second Respondents and ss 36(3) and 36(4) of the Australian Consumer Law by the First Respondent;

d. the Court has ordered the Third Respondent to pay to the trust account of HWL Ebsworth Lawyers the amount of $500,000 (Funds) which is to be paid by way of partial redress to persons who have incurred loss and damage caused by the contravening conduct in the form of fees paid to the First and Second Respondents in relation to purchasing a franchise (Redress Scheme);

e. the Redress Scheme has been approved by the Court;

f. the recipient of the notice has been identified as one of the persons who incurred loss or damage caused by the contravening conduct;

g. the Funds will be insufficient to compensate fully all persons who suffered loss or damage caused by the contravening conduct and, accordingly, each person who accepts the redress will be entitled to receive a proportionate share of the Funds based on the amount of fees which each person paid for the franchise (to a maximum of the total amount of fees paid by each person);

h. the recipient of the notice may choose whether:

(i) to accept the redress, in which case they will be bound by the order, and will not be able to bring any claim, action or demand against the Third Respondent in relation to that amount of their loss or damage that has been redressed; or

(ii) not to accept the redress, in which case they will not be bound by the order and will be able to bring any claim, action or demand against the Third Respondent in relation to their loss or damage;

i. for the avoidance of doubt, accepting the redress will not prevent the recipient of the notice from proving in the liquidation of the First and Second Respondents in relation to any loss or damage beyond the amount of redress;

j. in order to accept the redress, the recipient of the notice must send to the Applicant, within 28 days of receipt of the notice, a written response which includes sufficient proof of the person's identity and banking details; and

k. redress will be paid from the Funds paid by the Third Respondent to the trust account of HWL Ebsworth Lawyers as soon as practicable and is expected to be paid to persons accepting the redress in 30 to 60 days.

5. The notice referred to in paragraph 4 will be deemed to have been received by the person to whom it was sent:

a. if the notice was sent by email, one day after the email was sent unless a message is received by the Applicant in that time that the email was undeliverable; and

b. if the notice was sent by mail, 14 days after the mail was sent by ordinary prepaid mail.

6. If the Applicant receives a message that an email sent to an eligible person was undeliverable, the Applicant will use its best endeavours to obtain a mail address for the eligible person and send a copy of the notice by mail.

7. Upon the expiry of the period within which recipients of the notice may accept the redress, the Applicant must prepare a document that:

a. lists the eligible persons who have accepted the redress (the participating persons) together with their contact and bank account details; and

b. calculates for each participating person their proportionate share of the Funds based on the amount of fees which that person paid for a franchise (to a maximum of the total amount of fees paid by that person),

and provide a copy of the document to HWL Ebsworth Lawyers.

8. Within 14 days of receiving the document referred to in paragraph 7, HWL Ebsworth Lawyers must disburse the Funds in accordance with the details contained in the document and notify the Applicant:

a. when the disbursement is complete; and

b. if any disbursement was unable to be made.

9. Within 14 days of receiving notification under paragraph 8, the Applicant must provide a notice to each participating person confirming the payment of redress and the amount of the payment.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

The two statements of agreed facts are substantially the same. There are certain facts, however, which are only relevant to, and admitted by, Mr Campbell. I have taken that into account in these reasons. The following is a summary of the primary facts agreed between the parties and admissions made by the first and third respondents.Agreed facts that are common to the partiesThe business structure From 2014 to March 2016, Swim Loops, as franchisor, conducted the Jump Swim Schools franchise business. As such, it:(a)promoted franchises to prospective franchisees and entered into franchise agreements;(b)employed all persons involved in the business;(c)leased properties for the construction of swimming pools, for the purpose of licensing the use of the properties to franchisees for the operation of Jump Swim Schools franchises; and(d)conducted all of the other operations of the business. Swim Loops has been in liquidation since 23 August 2019. In or around 2016, the Jump Swim corporate group was formed. Between March 2016 and July 2019, it conducted the Jump Swim Schools franchise business. It comprised some six corporate entities which assumed different parts of the business previously conducted by Swim Loops. The ultimate holding company was the second respondent, Swim Loops Holdings. That company was involved in the promotion of franchises to prospective franchisees and held relevant intellectual property including the brand name “JUMP! Swim Schools” and its associated logo. It has been in liquidation since 22 July 2019. The first respondent, Jump Loops, became the franchisor and also promoted the supply of franchises to prospective franchisees. It has been in liquidation since 5 July 2019. Different entities within the group employed staff and engaged contractors, leased properties and undertook construction works. At all relevant times, Mr Campbell was:(a)a director of Swim Loops (Mr Campbell was one of two directors until 10 October 2016 and after that date he was the sole director);(b)the founder, sole director and managing director of Jump Loops;(c)a director of Swim Loops Holdings (Mr Campbell was one of two directors until 14 October 2018 and after that date he was the sole director);(d)the sole director of all other companies within the Jump Swim corporate group;(e)managing director of the Jump Swim corporate group; and(f)responsible for and had knowledge of all aspects of the operation and management of the Jump Loops and Swim Loops businesses and the Jump Swim corporate group, including marketing and selling Jump Swim School franchises, overseeing prospective and operating franchises, the development process for securing and fitting out premises, and supervising staff who were also responsible for these aspects of the business.Jump Swim School franchises Jump Loops offered franchises for sale on a “turn-key” basis such that Jump Loops agreed to hand over ready-to-operate businesses pursuant to a standard form franchise agreement. Under the franchise agreement, Jump Loops agreed (among other things) to supply the premises (subject to agreement being reached on a suitable location), fitout services, training and associated rights required to operate the franchise in order to provide swimming lessons to the public.The relevant representation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

I consider that it is appropriate to make the injunctions sought by the ACCC. In respect of the first two injunctions, the conduct sought to be enjoined has a close relationship with the contraventions that have been admitted by Mr Campbell. Further, those injunctions are limited to a defined period of 5 years, which I consider to be appropriate in circumstances where Mr Campbell has not previously been found to have contravened the Australian Consumer Law. In respect of the third injunction, while the conduct to be enjoined would not of itself involve a contravention of the Australian Consumer Law, that is not a statutory requirement. In my view, Mr Campbell’s contravening conduct in his management of, and involvement in, the Jump Swim corporate group is so reprehensible that it warrants an injunction preventing him from being involved in the franchising sector for a period of 3 years. E. CONCLUSIONS In conclusion, I will make the orders sought by the ACCC (which are not contested by Jump Loops and which are agreed by Mr Campbell), subject to the modifications discussed in these reasons. The ACCC has agreed that there be no orders as to its costs on the basis that that will ensure the maximum amount possible being directed towards non-party consumer redress. Accordingly, there will be no order as to costs.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

During the relevant period, Jump Loops received total payments of at least $24 million. The payments were made under the franchise agreement in consideration for the provision of operational swim schools. All of those funds were expended in the operation of the Jump Swim corporate group.Failure to provide operational swim schools During the relevant period, Jump Loops entered into franchise agreements with at least 155 franchisees to supply operational Jump Swim Schools franchise. Jump Loops also received funds from a further 19 prospective franchisees, but there is no record of those prospective franchisees executing a franchise agreement. Of the 174 franchisees who had either entered into a franchise agreement or paid monies to Jump Loops without entering into a franchise agreement, Jump Loops had not provided an operational franchise within 12 months of sign-up to:(a)at least 9 franchisees by 30 June 2017;(b)at least 56 franchisees by 30 June 2018; and(c)at least 93 franchisees by 12 March 2019. As at the date of liquidation of Jump Loops, the state of its franchisees was as follows:(a)21 franchisees had received an operational franchise. Of those, 6 received an operational swim school within 12 months of signing up to a franchise agreement; 11 received an operational swim school only after 12 months or more had passed since signing up; and for the remaining 4 it is not known how much time passed between signing up to a franchise agreement and receipt of an operational franchise.(b)23 franchisees had not received an operational franchise but had been fully or partially refunded by Jump Loops. Of those, 21 franchisees received full refunds which totalled $755,345.43 and 2 received partial refunds which totalled $74,500.00.(c)At least 100 franchisees had signed up to a franchise agreement more than 12 months prior to the date of liquidation and had not received an operational franchise, with the average number of days spent waiting being over 700 days.(d)At least 31 franchisees had signed up to a franchise agreement less than 12 months prior to the date of liquidation and had not received an operational franchise.(e)In respect of 3 other franchisees that had not received an operational franchise, the parties are unable to identify when two of them signed a franchise agreement and the agreement was terminated in respect of the third. In a relatively small, but indeterminate, number of these cases, the franchisee had indicated to Jump Loops prior to the expiration of 12 months of entering into a franchise agreement that they were either financially unable or unwilling to proceed with their franchise and requested that the franchise agreement be terminated. Some of these requests were denied by Jump Loops.Awareness of issues relating to timing At all material times during the relevant period, Jump Loops did not have a reasonable basis for making the Representation. Jump Loops knew, including through Mr Campbell’s personal knowledge, that it was not possible to estimate accurately the length of time it would take to open a Jump Swim Schools franchise from the date of signing the franchise agreement, as the time taken to secure a site for the franchise differed for each site. Further, the time it would take to open a site from sign-up depended on the franchise location (including the rules and requirements of the relevant State or local council) and was largely reliant on approvals and other elements outside of the control of Jump Loops and Mr Campbell.