Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Mandurvit Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 58 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Mandurvit Pty Ltd [2014] FCA 464

Citation: Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Mandurvit Pty Ltd [2014] FCA 464
Parties: AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION AND CONSUMER COMMISSION v MANDURVIT PTY LTD (ACN 147 626 284)
File number: WAD 183 of 2013
Judge: MCKERRACHER J
Date of judgment: 12 May 2014
Catchwords: CONSUMER LAW – penalty hearing – misleading or deceptive conduct – consumer guarantee provisions – representations concerning the existence, exclusion or effect of a warranty, guarantee, right or remedy – admitted contraventions – whether orders sought by consent appropriate in the circumstances – whether proposed pecuniary penalty within appropriate range
Legislation: Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) ss 4, 76, 131, 138
Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) Sch 2, ss 18, 29(1)(m), 54, 224, 232, 259, 260, 261, 262, 263
Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) s 191
Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 21
Judiciary Act 1993 (Cth) s 39B(1A)
Cases cited: Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v AGL Sales Pty Ltd [2013] FCA 1030
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Dimmeys Stores Pty Ltd [2011] FCA 372
Australian Competition & Consumer Commission v Econovite Pty Ltd [2003] FCA 964
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Energy Australia Pty Ltd [2014] FCA 336
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Flight Centre Limited (No 3) [2014] FCA 292
Australian Competition & Consumer Commission v Gullyside Pty Ltd [2005] FCA 1727
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Hewlett-Packard Australia Pty Ltd [2013] FCA 653
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v HP Superstore Pty Ltd [2013] FCA 1317
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Jewellery Group Pty Limited (No 2) [2013] FCA 14
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Kingisland Meatworks & Cellars Pty Ltd (2013) 99 IPR 548
Australian Competition & Consumer Commission v Liquorland (Australia) Pty Ltd (2005) ATPR 42-070
Australian Competition & Consumer Commission v Marksun Australia Pty Ltd [2011] FCA 695
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v MSY Technology Pty Ltd (No 2) (2011) 279 ALR 609
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Real Estate Institute of Western Australia Inc (1999) 161 ALR 79
Australian Competition & Consumer Commission v Real Estate Institute of Western Australia Inc (1999) 95 FCR 114
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v TPG Internet Pty Ltd (No 2) [2012] FCA 629
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v TPG Internet Pty Ltd [2013] HCA 54
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Yellow Page Marketing BV (No 2) (2011) 195 FCR 1
Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Ingleby [2013] VSCA 49
Barbaro v The Queen (2014) 88 ALJR 372
Comcare v PVYW [2013] HCA 41
Commissioner for Consumer Protection v Susilo [2014] WASC 50
Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union v Cahill (2010) 269 ALR 1
CSR Ltd v Eddy (2005) 226 CLR 1
Director of the Fair Work Building Industry Inspectorate v Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union (No 2) [2014] FCA 160
Global One Mobile Entertainment Pty Ltd v Australian Competition…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Mandurvit P... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] FCA 464
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) brought an action against Mandurvit Pty Ltd for alleged breaches of consumer law, specifically under the Australian Consumer Law (ACL). The case involved a dispute regarding statements made by Mandurvit’s sales representatives to a customer about repair fees for a camera purchased from the store. The primary issue was whether the statements constituted misleading or deceptive conduct under the ACL.

The court had to determine the appropriate civil penalty for the breaches found. The ACCC and Mandurvit submitted joint submissions on the quantum of the penalty, suggesting a figure of $10,000. The court considered several factors in arriving at this figure, including the absence of actual loss or damage to the consumer, Mandurvit's cooperation with the ACCC, the lack of prior contraventions of the ACL by Mandurvit, the company's size and financial position, and its compliance training efforts.

In deciding the penalty, the court noted that while the High Court's decision in Barbaro v The Queen provided some principles applicable to sentencing, the principles governing civil penalty submissions were distinct from criminal sentencing. The court adhered to the established approach in cases like NW Frozen Foods Pty Ltd v Australian Competition & Consumer Commission, where the court recognises the strong public interest in ordering the amount agreed upon by the parties, provided it is deemed appropriate. After considering all relevant factors, the court concluded that the agreed penalty of $10,000 was appropriate and ordered that amount as the civil penalty.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

The main issue requiring examination is the process of agreeing and recommending a civil penalty in light of recent authority. THE KEY FACTS The following facts are agreed for the purposes of s 191 of the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth). Mandurvit, trading as Harvey Norman AV/IT Superstore Mandurah, was at all material times:(a)a body corporate duly incorporated pursuant to the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth);(b)a trading corporation within the definition of ‘corporation’ in s 4 CCA;(c)capable of being sued in its corporate name;(d)engaged in trade or commerce within the meaning of s 18 and s 29(1)(m) ACL;(e)a franchisee of a subsidiary of Harvey Norman Holdings Ltd (HNHL); and(f)up to about 31 May 2013, operating as a single retail outlet or store in Mandurah, Western Australia, under the name of ‘Harvey Norman AV/IT Superstore Mandurah’, selling electronic products and after-sales services in respect of those products (Store).The Oral Statements and their circumstances On or about 8 October 2011, an identified customer purchased a Panasonic Lumix DMC‑S1 camera from Mandurvit. On or about 14 December 2011, the customer took the camera back to the Store and spoke to a sales representative of Mandurvit about a problem she was having with the camera, namely, that some photos taken with the camera had a milky appearance when viewed on her computer and the camera became warm when being used. She left the camera at the Store for repairs. The sales representative told the customer that it would take four to six weeks to repair the camera. On or about 10 February 2012, the customer attended the Store and spoke to a different sales representative of Mandurvit and enquired about the camera. In response to her enquiries, the sales representative made an oral statement to this effect (First Oral Statement):Your camera is currently with the repairer and you will need to pay $88 before they'll send it back to us ... [Panasonic] will only return it if you pay the $88. ... The $88 is a charge by Panasonic to cover postage and handling. Later on the same day, the same sales representative of Mandurvit as referred to in the preceding paragraph telephoned the customer and made an oral statement to this effect (Second Oral Statement):I have spoken to Panasonic and they will not waive the $88 fee... The Manager is away for a few weeks. I doubt the Manager would be able to do anything. It's up to Panasonic... There are two things you can do. You could phone Panasonic to see if you can get them to waive the charges, or you could lodge a complaint with the ACCC. In late March 2012, Mandurvit provided a replacement camera to the customer.The representations constituted by the Oral Statements By the First Oral Statement, Mandurvit in trade or commerce:(a)represented in effect that:(i)the customer would have, and had an obligation, to pay a fee of $88 charged by Panasonic for postage and handling before she could have the camera returned to her; and(ii)further and alternatively, Mandurvit would not, and did not have any obligation to, pay that $88 fee or return the camera to her; and(b)thereby made a representation that was false or misleading under Pt 5-4 and Pt 3-2 ACL (Consumer Guarantee Provisions) in that:(i)under the Consumer Guarantee Provisions, the customer may not have had any obligation to pay the $88 fee and it was possible that she was entitled to recover the camera without her paying such a fee; and(ii)a supplier such as Mandurvit:(A)could be obliged to pay charges, including a charge such as the fee of $88 for postage and handling, incurred in relation to the repair of goods it supplied, including the camera, where those goods were not of acceptable quality;(B)could be obliged to return the camera to the customer without her paying that fee; and(C)possibly had such obligations in relation to the camera.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

I will shortly deal with the law as it applied prior to the recent High Court decision in Barbaro v The Queen (2014) 88 ALJR 372 delivered two days before the joint submissions were filed. It is necessary, however, to say something about that decision. High Court decision in Barbaro I sought submissions from the parties as to whether the High Court decision in Barbaro should bear upon the approach this Court should take in relation to agreed penalty submissions. Those submissions have been supplied and as I am satisfied that they are both helpful and largely correct I propose to adopt them in substantial measure. (I have indicated where I would depart from the submissions.) In Barbaro the High Court dismissed two appeals from the Victorian Court of Appeal on sentences imposed on Barbaro and Zirilli who had both pleaded guilty to serious drug offences and were sentenced to life and 26 years imprisonment respectively. The appellants argued they had been denied procedural fairness as the sentencing judge refused to hear the prosecution’s submissions on the appropriate sentencing range. Her Honour imposed sentences that were higher than those recommended by the prosecution. The Court of Appeal rejected that argument as did the High Court. The High Court rejected the arguments that the prosecution is permitted or required to make any submission on sentencing ranges. It held that such submissions are not submissions of law, but merely a statement of opinion, which the sentencing judge may or may not take into account in deciding on the appropriate sentence. A refusal to hear the prosecution on the available sentencing ranges did not amount to a failure to take account of a material consideration in fixing the sentences. The ACCC and Mandurvit submit that:(a)the approach the Court should take in relation to joint submissions on the quantum of civil pecuniary penalties is relevantly distinguishable from the approach which should be taken in relation to criminal penalties and sentencing; and(b)in this case, the Court is bound to follow the approach taken by the Full Court in NW Frozen Foods Pty Ltd v Australian Competition & Consumer Commission (1996) 71 FCR 285, a decision that was further considered and affirmed in Minister for Industry, Tourism & Resources v Mobil Oil Australia Pty Ltd [2004] FCAFC 72 and has been consistently applied in a succession of subsequent cases in this Court. Under that approach: (i)the parties to proceedings under the TPA and its successor legislation may make submissions as to the quantum of pecuniary penalty that the parties agree is appropriate in the circumstances of their case; and(ii)the Court recognises that, provided that it considers the proposed amount is appropriate, there is a strong public interest in ordering that amount, even if the Court may have otherwise ordered a different amount: NW Frozen Foods (at 290-291 and 298). While the plurality judgment in Barbaro contains statements of principle that are potentially applicable beyond the facts of that case, ACCC and Mandurvit contend that those statements, which were made in the particular context concerning a specific criminal prosecutorial practice, and were not expressed to apply beyond that context, should not be applied broadly, particularly where the effect of such a reading would be to overrule well-established appeal court authority.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

There is no evidence of loss or damage to the consumer in this proceeding, arising from the contravening conduct of Mandurvit.Cooperation with the ACCC Retail stores in Australia trading under the ‘Harvey Norman’ banner do so under franchise arrangements between subsidiaries of HNHL and numerous companies unrelated to each other or to HNHL or its subsidiaries. The subsidiaries are the franchisors. Each franchisee company owns and operates a retail store. On 12 June 2013, the ACCC commenced proceedings against Mandurvit. The Proceedings were commenced by the ACCC following a period of broad discussions between the ACCC and HNHL in relation to complaints to the ACCC made by consumers about statements made by a number of sales representatives in a number of stores. The discussions were focussed on the potentially misleading nature of the statements and did not identify any particular store, including Mandurvit’s store, as being the subject of a complaint. Before commencing legal action against Mandurvit in respect of the conduct that constitutes the contraventions the subject of these proceedings, the ACCC did not inform Mandurvit or HNHL about that conduct or any other specific conduct of Mandurvit. At an early stage in these proceedings, Mandurvit (through its solicitors) proposed a settlement meeting with the ACCC following which a settlement was reached by the parties. Mandurvit’s co-operation has saved the ACCC and the Court (and ultimately the community) the cost and burden of litigating a fully contested hearing.Whether prior contravention of the ACL Mandurvit has not been previously found by a court to have contravened any provision of the ACL or to have engaged in similar conduct to that described in the statement of agreed facts.Size and Financial Position of Respondent Mandurvit operated a single retail store at Mandurah in Western Australia until it ceased trading on about 31 May 2013 and does not to intend re-commence a business of any kind. Mandurvit has had no employees since it ceased trading on about 31 May 2013. For the financial years ended 30 June 2012 and 30 June 2013 Mandurvit’s sales revenue and net profit were: The net profit figures take no account of income tax because Mandurvit carried on its business through a family trust structure (Trust). Income tax on the profits of the business was paid by beneficiaries to whom the profits were distributed each year. As at 30 June 2013, the net assets (assets less liabilities) held by Mandurvit (as trustee) were $10. Mandurvit conducted its business pursuant to a franchise agreement between it and a subsidiary of HNHL until Mandurvit ceased to trade on about 31 May 2013. Mandurvit and the Trust are not related entities of HNHL or its subsidiaries.Compliance Training Mandurvit was incorporated on 30 November 2010 and commenced business on 1 August 2011. The compliance training, in relation to the consumer law provisions of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) (TPA) now known as the CCA (Consumer Law), comprised at least the following until Mandurvit ceased trading on about 31 May 2013:(a)Staff attended a face-to-face Consumer Law training session presented by an external professional trainer engaged by a subsidiary of HNHL.(b)Staff watched a DVD received from the franchisor explaining the Consumer Law provisions.(c)A memorandum received from the franchisor (a subsidiary of HNHL) on the Consumer Law was read and discussed at Mandurvit’s regular staff meetings.(d)Consumer Law discussions were a fixed agenda item at weekly staff meetings where staff discussed their experiences with customers relating to Consumer Law.STATUTORY FRAMEWORK