Construction, Forestry and Maritime Employees Union v Richard Crookes Constructions Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 25 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Construction, Forestry and Maritime Employees Union v Richard Crookes Constructions Pty Ltd [2024] FCA 437

File number(s): NSD 959 of 2022
Judgment of: RAPER J
Date of judgment: 30 April 2024
Catchwords:

INDUSTRIAL LAW - the respondent was the principal contractor on a construction site – the applicant’s employee attended the site to investigate suspected work health and safety contraventions – where the employee held a permit to enter sites under s 117 of the Work Health and Safety Act 2011 (NSW) and ss 501 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) – the respondent unduly delayed entry – the applicant alleged one contravention of s 501 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) – the contravention was admitted by the respondent

INDUSTRIAL LAW – consideration of the principles for fixing appropriate pecuniary penalties – consideration of whether to endorse the agreed penalty – consideration of the absence of evidence regarding remediation – declaratory relief granted

Legislation:

Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) s 191

Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) ss 481, 494, 494(1), 494(2)(a)(i), 494(3), 501, 512, 546

Fair Work Regulations 2009 (Cth) r 3.25

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 21

Work Health and Safety Act (NSW) ss 117, 118, 134

Cases cited:

Australian Building and Construction Commissioner v Construction, Forestry, Maritime, Mining and Energy Union (Doubletree Hilton Case) [2021] FCA 1468

Australian Building and Construction Commissioner v Pattinson [2022] HCA 13; 274 CLR 450

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v TPG Internet Pty Ltd [2013] HCA 54; 250 CLR 640

Brocx v Hughes [2010] WASCA 57; 41 WAR 84

Commissioner of the NDIS Quality and Safeguards Commission v Australian Foundation for Disability [2023] FCA 629

Commonwealth v Director, Fair Work Building Industry Inspectorate (Agreed Penalties Case) [2015] HCA 46; 258 CLR 482

Communications, Electrical, Electronic, Energy, Information, Postal, Plumbing and Allied Services Union of Australia v Richard Crookes Constructions Pty Ltd [2022] FCA 1142

Construction, Forestry, Maritime and Energy Union v Richard Crookes Constructions Pty Limited [2022] FCA 992

Minister for Industry, Tourism & Resources v Mobil Oil Australia Pty Ltd [2004] FCAFC 72; 54 ACSR 395

Singtel Optus Pty Ltd v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission [2012] FCAFC 20; 287 ALR 249

Trade Practices Commission v Allied Mills Industries Pty Ltd (1981) 60 FLR 38

Volkswagen Aktiengesellschaft v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission [2021] FCAFC 49; 284 FCR 24

Division: Fair Work Division
Registry: New South Wales
National Practice Area: Employment and Industrial Relations
Number of paragraphs: 55
Date of hearing: 23 April 2024
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr R Reitano
Solicitors for the Applicant: Taylor & Scott Lawyers
Counsel for the Respondent: Mr J Darams SC
Solicitors for the Respondent: Lander & Rogers

ORDERS

NSD 959 of 2022
BETWEEN:

CONSTRUCTION, FORESTRY AND MARITIME EMPLOYEES UNION

Applicant

AND:

RICHARD CROOKES CONSTRUCTIONS PTY LTD

Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

RAPER J

DATE OF ORDER:

30 APRIL 2024

THE COURT DECLARES THAT:

1.Richard Crookes

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Construction, Forestry and Maritime Employees Union v Richar... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] FCA 437
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Construction, Forestry and Maritime Employees Union v Richard Crookes Constructions Pty Ltd involved a dispute between the CFMEU and Crookes, with the latter being a principal contractor on a construction site. The CFMEU alleged that one of its employees, Mr Rielly, was unduly delayed from entering the site to investigate suspected work health and safety contraventions. Mr Rielly held permits to enter the site under relevant sections of the Work Health and Safety Act 2011 (NSW) and the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth). Crookes admitted to the contravention of s 501 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) for unduly delaying Mr Rielly's entry to the site. The court was required to decide the principles for fixing appropriate pecuniary penalties, endorse the agreed penalty, and consider the absence of evidence regarding remediation.

The court considered the principles for fixing appropriate pecuniary penalties, emphasising the need to scrutinise the material presented to ensure that the agreed penalty was appropriate. The court recognised that while there was considerable scope for parties to agree on facts and consequences, the court must still be sufficiently persuaded of the accuracy of the parties' agreement. The court also acknowledged the desirability of bringing litigation to a conclusion as soon as possible, but noted that this consideration could not override the statutory directive to impose a penalty that was determined to be appropriate.

The court accepted the agreed penalty of $25,000, which equated to almost 40% of the possible maximum penalty, and granted the declaratory relief requested by the CFMEU. The court emphasised that while a regulator's interests in achieving its statutory objectives of general and specific deterrence may be different from those of a union, the statutory directive to impose an appropriate penalty still applied.

In summary, the court accepted the agreed penalty of $25,000 and granted the declaratory relief requested by the CFMEU. The court emphasised the importance of scrutinising the material presented to ensure that the agreed penalty was appropriate, while also recognising the desirability of bringing litigation to a conclusion as soon as possible.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Pursuant to s 546 of the FW Act Crookes pay a pecuniary penalty to the Construction, Forestry and Maritime Employees Union, in the sum of $25,000 for the contravention of s 501 of the FW Act which is the subject of the declaration above, within 28 days of the date of this order.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Crookes has admitted that it contravened s 501 of the FW Act at Armidale site on 8 April 2020, which was described in the SOAF in the following way:In the circumstances Mr Davie unduly delayed entry onto the Site by Mr Rielly, who was entitled to enter the Site in accordance with Part 3-4 of the FW Act. By operation of s 793 of the FW Act, Mr Davie’s conduct referred to above is taken to have been that of [Crookes] so that [Crookes] contravened s 501 of the Act in that it unduly delayed entry onto the Site by Mr Reilly who was entitled to enter the Site in accordance with Part 3-4 of the FW Act.Agreed facts It is worthwhile briefly describing the factual context as agreed between the parties. This proceeding concerns an attempt on 8 April 2020 by a CFMEU official, Mr Rielly, to enter the Armidale Secondary College site occupied by Crookes, located at 182 Butler Street in Armidale (the site). Mr Rielly (holder of entry permits issued under ss 512 of the FW Act and 134 of the WHS Act) says that he received several phone calls and text messages from CFMEU members on or around 6 April 2020, in which he was told about workers at the site having difficulty accessing the areas where they had to do work as a result of rain and poor drainage. After receiving these calls, Mr Rielly says he called Mr Cleary (a CFMEU delegate working at the site for a crane company engaged by Crookes) and says that Mr Cleary told him about further concerns held by him and other workers, including with respect to: (a)the blocking of access ways;(b)poor communication between workers with gyprocking workers who had limited English skills;(c)directions to operate cranes and drive Franna cranes in wet conditions;(d)workers working in wet conditions generally;(e)workers working alongside moving plant machinery with poor visibility in wet conditions; and (f)concerns about emergency egress. On 7 April 2020, Mr Rielly and Mr Davie, a project manager employed by Crookes, had a telephone conversation during which Mr Rielly provided details of the concerns that had been raised with him (that involved suspected contraventions of the WHS Act at the site). Mr Rielly then told Mr Davie that he would attend the site and exercise his right of entry to investigate the suspected contraventions the following day. On 8 April 2020, Mr Rielly arrived at the site and entered through an open panel of temporary fencing, through which he had seen workers entering and exiting the site. Soon after entering, between 9:00 am and 9:30 am, he was approached by Mr Davie, and told him that he was there to inquire into suspected contraventions of the WHS Act involving the matters discussed over the phone and roofers working on roofs without edge protection. He showed Mr Davie his FW Act permit and WHS Act permit and asked to sign in. Mr Davie did not respond, and returned to the site office, where he spoke into a phone and said: “Yeah, we’ve got trespassers on site”. Mr Davie then had the following exchange with Mr Reilly:Rielly We've come to sign in, is there a sign in area? There used to be an area to sign in right here. We've come in to do it. That's the tape, that's the pen, where is it mate? Can we sign in please? No? Can I sign in please? Because we're permit holders under the Act, if you hinder, obstruct or delay a union official. We're asking to sign in. Is that the sign in area? Can me and Paul sign in? Thankyou'Davie So, you 're not signing to go on site.Rielly Why am I not signing in to go on the site?Davie You 're not coming on the site.Rielly I'll show you my permit right now, right that's my permits right there. You can see those, you want to see them? You'll take the number down? We'll give you a notice, right here, a suspected breach. I've written it out already, because I knew what we were coming on site for, EWPs and other access ways. I'm happy to give you that now, Joel? If we could follow the process please? We're trying to get on the site. Otherwise, Paul, having walked in, there was roofers on the roof, with no edge protection. Paul's going to deal with that right now. I'm asking you: can you please allow us to sign in? Yes, or no?Davie You 're not signing in to go on site.Rielly You've already breached the rules of the site, you've walked out on the construction site with no hard hat on. ..Davie Yeah..Rielly ... no glasses on ...Davie Yeah ...Rielly ... because the last time I was here ...Davie ... because you were trespassing.Rielly Because we were trespassing?Davie You were trespassing Rielly And you think that breaching your own safety protocols is adequate if people are trespassing is that right?And now you've had your mate bring you your hard hat and your vest and you want to go out to site.You're not allowing us to sign in?Davie You're not going out to site RiellyIs that your statement, you're not allowing us?Davie Yeah, that's my statementRiellyAll right, okay no worries.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

A court considering an agreed penalty “must scrutinise the material presented to it carefully and satisfy itself that it was sufficient to determine whether the agreed penalty [is] appropriate”: Minister for Industry, Tourism & Resources v Mobil Oil Australia Pty Ltd [2004] FCAFC 72 at [78]. Consideration The parties agreed upon a penalty of $25,000, which equates almost 40% of the possible maximum penalty. The High Court recognised in the Agreed Penalties case at [57] that there is very considerable scope for the parties to agree on the facts and upon the consequences by which the court may make orders on the terms provided by the parties if the court is persuaded that the course is appropriate, stating at [58]:….Subject to the court being sufficiently persuaded of the accuracy of the parties’ agreement as to facts and consequences, and that the penalty which the parties propose is an appropriate remedy in the circumstances thus revealed, it is consistent with principle and, for the reasons identified in Allied Mills, highly desirable in practice for the court to accept the parties’ proposal and therefore impose the proposed penalty. (citation omitted) As to why this course is “highly desirable” the High Court drew on the reasons identified by Sheppard J in Trade Practices Commission v Allied Mills Industries Pty Ltd (1981) 60 FLR 38 at 41–42, which included that:All things being equal, it is always important to bring litigation or any part of it to a conclusion as soon as possible. It is in the public interest that litigation should finish. That is specially so in a case such as this where the potential liability for each for further costs is most substantial. Similarly, Volkswagen Aktiengesellschaft v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission [2021] FCAFC 49; 284 FCR 24 at [126], citing the above extracted portion of the Agreed Penalties case, articulated the desirability of the Court accepting a proposed agreed penalty which it is persuaded is an agreed penalty, as derived “primarily from a public policy consideration; the promotion of predictability of outcome in civil penalty proceedings” (by encouraging corporations to acknowledge contraventions and assist in avoiding lengthy and complex litigation) but noting “that this public policy consideration is but one of the relevant considerations to which the Court must have regard and, more significantly, it cannot override the statutory directive for the Court to impose a penalty that is determined to be appropriate”. I note that a regulator was a party in both the Agreed Penalties Case and in Volkswagen and there are aspects of their reasoning applicable only to that circumstance. Here, the position of the CFMEU is not analogous to that of a regulator: It is a registered organisation, with certain statutory powers, but which arise not by reason of it being a public body acting in the public interest, but rather to further the interests of its members. While “a regulator in a civil penalty proceeding is not disinterested” (Agreed Penalties case at [60]), a regulator’s interests are in achieving its statutory objectives of general and specific deterrence, a union is not so constrained. As a consequence, it is not necessarily correct to assume that a penalty agreed between a union and a contravener reflects an equivalent “considered estimation of the penalty necessary to achieve deterrence and the risks and expense of the litigation had it not been settled”: Agreed Penalties case at [60].