Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Chubb Security Australia Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 68 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Chubb Security Australia Pty Limited [2004] FCA 1750

TRADE PRACTICES – reasonable grounds for believing that the defendant was not able to supply contracted services – offences – s 58(b) and s 75AZL(3) of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) – twenty-six charges – plea of guilty – agreed facts – provision of mobile security services – previous civil proceedings for failing to provide contracted services – systemic failure – failure to carry out review measures and audits – failure to provide services – compliance systems not operating effectively – failure to provide services - contracted services provided by franchisees, licensees and sub-contractors – offences occurred over prolonged time period– payments of rebates to clients – dismissal of senior managers – early plea – full cooperation – audits – compliance procedures introduced – buying-back of franchises – introduction of electronic verification system – applicable penalty - deterrence – rehabilitation – future compliance – parity – totality principle – s 4K(3) of the Crimes Act 1914 (Cth) – grouping of contracts under s 79(2) of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) – ‘at or about the same time’

WORDS AND PHRASES –  ‘at or about the same time’

Crimes Act 1914 (Cth) s 4K, s 16A(1), s 16A(2)
Criminal Code Act 1995 (Cth) s 6.1(1)
Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth), s 58(b), s 75AZL, s 75AZL(3), s 75AZL(4), s 79(1), s 79(2)

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Allans Music Group Pty Ltd  [2002] FCA 1552
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Australian Safeway Stores Pty Ltd (1997) 75 FCR 238
Australian Competition and Consumer Commissionv Commercial and General Publications Pty Ltd (No 2) (2002) ATPR 41-905
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Dimmeys Stores Pty Ltd (2001) ATPR 41-811
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Hartwich [2002] FCA 273
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Nissan Motor Co (Aust) Pty Ltd (1998) ATPR 41-660
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v The Vales Wine Co Pty Ltd   (1996) ATPR 41-528
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Universal Music Australia Pty Ltd (No 2) (2002) 201 ALR 618
Cameron v The Queen (2002) 209 CLR 339
Camilleri’s Stock Feeds Pty Ltd v Environment Protection Authority (1993) 32 NSWLR 683
Crossan v Commons (1985) ATPR 40-542
Dawson v World Travel Headquarters Pty Ltd (1981) 53 FLR 455
Director of Public Prosecutions (Cth) v Said Khodor El Karhani (1990) 21 NSWLR 370
Ducret v Colourshot Pty Ltd (1981) 35 ALR 503
Ducretv Nissan Motor Co (Australia) Pty Ltd (1979) ATPR 40-111
Eva v Mazda Motors (Sales) Pty Ltd (1977) ATPR 40-020
Kovacevic v Mills (2000) 174 ALR 77
Mill v The Queen (1988) 166 CLR 59
The Queen v Browne [1999] VSC 282
Siganto v The Queen (1998) 194 CLR 656
Thompson v Magnamail (No 1) (1977) ATPR 40-032
Trade Practices Commission v Advance Bank Australia Limited (1993) ATPR 41-229
Trade Practices Commission…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Chubb Secur... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2004] FCA 1750
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) filed charges against Chubb Security Australia Pty Ltd for failing to provide promised security services on certain mobile security control runs in the ACT, NSW, and Tasmania. Chubb pleaded guilty to the charges, which involved the company entering into agreements with customers for security patrols and alarm responses while having reasonable grounds to believe it could not supply the contracted services. The court accepted the agreed facts and evidence presented by both parties.

The primary legal issue the court had to decide was the appropriate penalty for Chubb’s breaches of the Australian Consumer Law. Chubb’s counsel submitted that the offences were mid-range in seriousness and suggested a penalty of between 25 and 75 per cent of the maximum penalty for each charge. The court considered the seriousness of the conduct, the need for deterrence, Chubb’s lack of intention to commit the offences, its early plea of guilty, and its co-operation with the ACCC investigation, including the payment of rebates to affected customers and the implementation of changes to its procedures and compliance programs.

After weighing these factors, the court determined that each offence warranted a penalty of 20 per cent of the maximum penalty. For the offences under section 58(b), this resulted in a penalty of $190,000 for the summons dated 3 June 2004 and $20,000 for the summons dated 24 June 2004. For the offences under section 75AZL(3), the penalty was $1,300,000. This resulted in a total penalty of $1.51 million, taking into account the totality and parity principles. The court also reserved the question of costs.

Chubb’s failure to deliver promised services was systemic and arose from inadequate compliance systems, documentation, and audits. However, the court acknowledged Chubb’s early plea of guilty, co-operation with the ACCC, and efforts to address the underlying issues. The court concluded that while the breaches were serious, the lack of significant commercial benefit and deliberate intent warranted a reduction in the penalty.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The parties forward to my associate draft orders to give effect to these reasons.

2. The question of costs be reserved.

Background

Background to the litigation

Chubb pleads guilty to each of the charges. While that plea was formally entered only at the substantive hearing, Chubb indicated at the first directions hearing that it would plead guilty.THE AGREED FACTS The matter has proceeded on the basis of agreed facts. While all of those facts are relevant and have been taken into account, I shall refer to them only as necessary for the purposes of these reasons. The charges are concerned with the failure by Chubb to provide promised services on certain mobile security control runs in the Australian Capital Territory (‘ACT’), in New South Wales (‘NSW’) and Tasmania. The nature of the promised service and of the default in provision of those services has been set out in [8]-[10] of the agreed facts:‘8.A security patrol involves a uniformed officer, in a Chubb marked patrol vehicle, calling upon a client’s premises for an agreed number of times to perform particular services, such as checking that doors, gates and fire exits are secure, and checking perimeter fences for unauthorised entry. In the course of performing these patrols, Chubb’s officers may be called upon to respond to a client’s alarm to ascertain the cause of the alarm. This is the meaning of an “alarm response”.9.Each of the charges alleges that the defendant accepted consideration from a particular customer, namely payment or the promise of payment for security patrols and alarm responses in relation to the customer’s property. At the time of acceptance of such consideration in each case there were reasonable grounds for the defendant believing that it would not be able to supply the contracted services during the period specified in the agreement.10.The central allegation against the defendant is that at the time it entered into each of the agreements the subject of the charges, the relevant security run to which the new client would be added, which provided security services for other clients, was already unserviceable. That is, the security officer or officers assigned by the defendant were already unable to perform all of their contracted for services for clients within the time allocated for the run. Based on the defendant’s systems and records there were reasonable grounds of which the defendant’s personnel (and through them the defendant itself) were aware, for believing that the new clients could not be supplied by the defendant with the services contracted for.’The defendant Chubb has operated as a supplier of security services since 9 September 1988 and is a subsidiary of Chubb Limited, a global provider of security services. Chubb is Australia’s largest provider of security patrols and alarm responses. During the hearing, it was stated that Chubb has approximately 30 per cent of the market. The next competitor has about 5 per cent of the market. At the relevant times, Chubb’s mobile security patrol services were provided through subcontracting businesses, licensees and franchisees that were independently owned and operated. During the charge period Chubb was servicing approximately 9,000-9500 mobile patrol clients across Australia.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

As conceded by Chubb, this means that the security patrol officers assigned to each of the affected runs could not perform all of the contracted services in the time allotted for the runs.THE EVIDENCE OF MR CHAMBERLAIN Mr Chamberlain is the President of Chubb Australasia and has been in that position since March 2004. As such, he is responsible for the overall operation of the Chubb group of companies in Australia and New Zealand, including the defendant, Chubb. He is a director of Chubb and of its holding company, Chubb Security Holdings Australia Pty Ltd, which is a subsidiary of Chubb Limited. Mr Chamberlain gave evidence by affidavit and was cross-examined as to the background of Chubb’s operations and the steps that Chubb has taken before and since notification by the ACCC of the complaints that led to the filing of the summonses. That evidence, which was not objected to, has added to the factual matrix set out in the agreed facts. I have taken all of Mr Chamberlain’s evidence into account and extract the relevant parts below. Mobile security patrol services involve a patrol officer attending a client site and performing certain security services. The relationship between Chubb and its clients is governed by a written contract in a standard form. The services provided may include:(a)External and internal property security checks, for example checking aspects of a client’s premises such as doors, windows, gates and lighting(b) Staff escorts(c) Machinery operation checks(d) Staff welfare checks(e) Alarm response(f) Business opening and closing security Prior to the early to mid 1990s, all contracted services were carried out by patrol officers employed by Chubb or sub-contractors of Chubb. In the early to mid 1990s, CMS introduced license arrangements whereby some runs were serviced by the patrol officers employed by CMS licensees. CMS’s business model for the provision of mobile security patrol services changed again in 2000 when CMS introduced a franchise system, in addition to having existing licensees and sub-contractors. Each franchise arrangement provided the franchisee with a right to receive a share of revenue derived from mobile security patrol clients in a particular fixed geographical area, in return for the franchisee providing mobile security patrol services to those clients on behalf of CMS. Franchisees would typically operate three runs each. In all cases Chubb entered into the contract with the client for the supply of the contracted services. As a consequence of both the separation of the operation and sales and marketing functions within CMS and the outsourcing of patrol officer functions to licensees or franchisees, the effectiveness of the co-ordination between the persons responsible for the sale of mobile security patrol services and the persons responsible for the provision of those services was reduced. Prior to becoming aware that the ACCC was investigating Chubb’s provision of mobile security patrol services, Chubb had already identified a number of steps to be taken to increase the level of understanding and importance of compliance issues.

Decision

Reasons for decision

BENNETT J
Mr Fagan submits that the offences are ‘in the mid range of seriousness’, acknowledging that there would be more serious and less serious contraventions. He submits that the appropriate range is between 25 and 75 per cent of the penalty for each charge.CONCLUSIONS ON PENALTY Giving effect to the grouping of charges, there are now three offences which each attract a maximum penalty of $200,000 each; seven offences which each attract a maximum penalty of $220,000 and 12 offences which each attract a maximum penalty of $1,100,000. Taking into account all of the matters in s 16A(2) of the Crimes Act each offence, on its own should, in my view, attract a penalty of 20% of the maximum. In coming to that figure I have determined that what might be called the negative aspects of the offence, such as the seriousness of the conduct and the necessary deterrence, including the fact that Chubb had previously been made aware of its shortcomings in delivering promised services in the civil proceedings, attract a penalty of 40% of the maximum. I have discounted that to take account of what might be described as the positive aspects of Chubb’s response, such as lack of intention, the plea of guilty, co-operation and rehabilitation as described. I also take account of the moneys and effort that Chubb has expended in effecting a comprehensive change to its procedures and compliance programs and the commitment that comprehends to effecting future compliance. This would mean a penalty for the s 58(b) offences of $428,500 ($384,000 for the summons of 3 June 2004 and $44,000 for the summons of 24 June 2004) and, for the s 75AZL(3) offences, $2,640,000. This would result in a total penalty of $3,068, 500. In applying s 4K(4) of the Crimes Act to each summons and giving effect to the totality principle and the parity principle, I am of the view that it is appropriate to reduce that penalty. The offences, both as to number and as to time, arose out of a failure in Chubb’s procedures and systems. This was a failure to comply with the very systems that were in place to prevent the behaviour that occurred. This systemic failure does not avoid the fact that there were a large number of offences but it is a factor to be taken into consideration in reducing the penalty to be applied in respect of that total number. It is also the case that the financial benefit to Chubb, the consideration for each contract, was not large and that there was no deliberate intent on the part of Chubb to fail in the delivery of security services. This is not a case where a corporation has weighed the commercial benefit of the offences against the risk of prosecution. I am of the opinion that the appropriate penalties are: for the s 58(b) offences set out in the summons of 3 June 2004, $190,000; for the s 58(b) offences set out in the summons of 24 June 2004, $20,000; for the s 75AZL(3) offences, $1,300,000. This results in a total penalty of $1.51 million. I have been asked to reserve the question of costs and I do so.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: BENNETT J

In addition, during the Charge Period, Chubb’s operating procedures documentation purported to call for audits of the serviceability of all runs on a six monthly basis (for metropolitan locations) or annually (in the country). The nominated audit procedures included physical testing of serviceability by an audit officer who was to complete each run in order to verify that the assigned patrol officer carried out the services contracted for. Chubb’s co-operation Chubb did not contest the charges and advised the ACCC at an early stage of its preparedness to plead guilty. From the commencement of an investigation by the ACCC in 2002, Chubb co-operated with the ACCC investigation and responded by conducting its own internal investigation into allegations that had been made by the ACCC. As a result of the investigation, Chubb ascertained that its compliance systems, as outlined above, were not operating effectively. In particular, documentation of the performance of patrols and service calls was not being properly completed or checked. Shift reports were being falsified. This ought to have been apparent to management earlier, even as it occurred, through the review and analysis of reports and through audit procedures. The fact that runs were not serviceable was not always addressed, although some customers were being provided with credits on their accounts for missed calls in accordance with the contract. The crediting of customers’ accounts for missed calls was inadequate however and did not cover all instances where customers were not receiving the contracted services. In December 2002, Chubb acknowledged that the allegations in respect of some runs in Sydney and the ACT were correct. Chubb also acknowledged similar issues in relation to some runs in Tasmania and the Gosford region. Chubb now admits that, because some runs in those particular geographic locations were not serviceable, some mobile patrol customers did not receive contracted services. Chubb also admits that contracts were entered into with customers for mobile security patrol services to be provided in these geographic locations when Chubb had reasonable grounds for believing that it would not be able to supply the contracted services. The investigations conducted by Chubb revealed that a large number of runs were unserviceable. Some clients on these runs were not receiving the services that Chubb had contracted to provide. Chubb has taken disciplinary action against a number of senior managers within the organisation for their failure adequately to perform their compliance roles. Chubb has paid total rebates of $632,092.33 (excluding GST) to customers on the runs the subject of the charges. Chubb has cooperated fully with the ACCC investigation by providing all relevant information and documentation requested. Chubb also provided the ACCC with details of non-serviceable runs in Gosford and Tasmania where the ACCC had not investigated or received complaints. Chubb’s early plea and co-operation, including the provision of documents, is of considerable utility in view of the time and expense which would have been involved in gathering all necessary evidence for a trial of the charges and in conducting the trial itself.THE CHARGES LAID UNDER s 58(b) AND s 75AZL(3) OF THE ACT