Court of Appeal
New South Wales
Case Title: Tonto Home Loans Australia Pty Ltd v Tavares; FirstMac Ltd v Di Benedetto; FirstMac Ltd v O'Donnell Medium Neutral Citation: [2011] NSWCA 389 Hearing Date(s): 1- 4 August 2011 Decision Date: 21 December 2011 Jurisdiction: Before: Bathurst CJ at 1
Allsop P at 2
Campbell JA at 303Decision: (1) As to appeal number 2009/00298570 (formerly 40454 of 2009) being the Tavares and Rowe appeal:
(a) Allow the appeal in part.
(b) Set aside order 2(b) made by the Supreme Court on 26 February 2010 (as set out in [448] of the primary judge's reasons) and in lieu thereof order that the mortgagee Tonto Home Loans Australia Pty Ltd deliver up to Jose De Carvalho E Rego Tavares and Kim Lee-Anne Rowe a registrable discharge of mortgage, but only on condition that Mr Tavares and Ms Rowe pay or have paid to the mortgagee or at its direction the sums referred to in order 4 made by the Supreme Court on 26 February 2010.
(c) The appellant pay the respondents' costs of the appeal.
(2) As to appeal number 2009/00298571 (previously 40455 of 2009) being the Di Benedetto appeal:
(a) Allow the appeal in part.
(b) Set aside order 2(b) made by the Supreme Court on 26 February 2010 (as set out in [447] of the primary judge's reasons) and in lieu thereof order that the mortgagee, Permanent Trustee Company Limited ("Permanent"), or to the extent that it has acceded to that company's rights, FirstMac Limited, deliver up to Lawrence Di Benedetto and Maria Di Benedetto a registrable discharge of mortgage.
(c) The appellant pay the respondents' costs of the appeal.
(3) As to appeal number 2009/00298572 (previously 40456 of 2009) being the O'Donnell appeal:
(a) Allow the appeal in part.
(b) Set aside orders 2 and 5 made by the Supreme Court on 26 February 2010 (as set out in [446] of the primary judge's reasons) and in lieu thereof order:
(i) The loan agreement dated 10 January 2003 and made between Permanent as lender, or to the extent that it has acceded to that company's rights, FirstMac Limited, and Gillian O'Donnell and John Robert O'Donnell as borrowers be varied to reduce the principal loan from $500,000 to $125,000 such variation to take effect from 1 August 2005, with the effect that thereafter the responsibility for payment of interest and principal be referable to a principal sum of $125,000.
(ii) The security provided by registered mortgage numbered 9386484P between Mr and Mrs O'Donnell and Permanent, or to the extent that it has acceded to Permanent's rights, FirstMac Limited, be limited in effect accordingly such that upon payment of the sum or sums sufficient to repay said loan as varied the O'Donnells be entitled to receipt of a registrable discharge of mortgage.
(iii) The plaintiff pay 75 per cent of the defendants'/cross-claimants' costs of the proceedings.
(c) The appellant pay 75 per cent of the respondents' costs of the appeal.
[Note: The…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Tonto Home Loans Australia Pty Ltd v Tavares and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2011] NSWCA 389
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The Court of Appeal was required to determine whether the loan contracts were unjust within the meaning of the Contracts Review Act 1980 (NSW), considering the circumstances including the fraudulent conduct of third parties and the lenders' lack of knowledge. It also considered whether the relationship between mortgage originators and sub-introducers constituted agency, and whether the lenders' conduct, or that of the mortgage originators, could be characterised as unconscionable under the Australian Securities and Investments Commission Act 2001 (Cth).
The Court held that low-documentation lending, while carrying inherent risks, is not inherently unjust. The primary safeguard against such risks lies in the lender's rigorous application of lending guidelines. In this instance, the lending guidelines were not followed, which was a significant factor in the assessment of injustice. The Court found that the concept of agency did not extend to the relationship between mortgage originators and sub-introducers, as the latter did not act on behalf of or represent the former. Furthermore, unconscionable conduct was not made out against the lenders as they lacked knowledge of the third-party fraud.
The Court allowed the appeals in part. For the Tavares and Rowe appeal, the order was varied to require the borrowers to pay the sums previously ordered before a discharge of mortgage would be provided. For the Di Benedetto appeal, a discharge of mortgage was ordered. In the O'Donnell appeal, the loan agreement was varied to reduce the principal amount, and the security was limited accordingly, with specific cost orders made in favour of the plaintiffs in that matter.
Orders
Orders of the court
(1) As to appeal number 2009/00298570 (formerly 40454 of 2009) being the Tavares and Rowe appeal:
(a) Allow the appeal in part.
(b) Set aside order 2(b) made by the Supreme Court on 26 February 2010 (as set out in [448] of the primary judge's reasons) and in lieu thereof order that the mortgagee Tonto Home Loans Australia Pty Ltd deliver up to Jose De Carvalho E Rego Tavares and Kim Lee-Anne Rowe a registrable discharge of mortgage, but only on condition that Mr Tavares and Ms Rowe pay or have paid to the mortgagee or at its direction the sums referred to in order 4 made by the Supreme Court on 26 February 2010.
(c) The appellant pay the respondents' costs of the appeal.
(2) As to appeal number 2009/00298571 (previously 40455 of 2009) being the Di Benedetto appeal:
(a) Allow the appeal in part.
(b) Set aside order 2(b) made by the Supreme Court on 26 February 2010 (as set out in [447] of the primary judge's reasons) and in lieu thereof order that the mortgagee, Permanent Trustee Company Limited ("Permanent"), or to the extent that it has acceded to that company's rights, FirstMac Limited, deliver up to Lawrence Di Benedetto and Maria Di Benedetto a registrable discharge of mortgage.
(c) The appellant pay the respondents' costs of the appeal.
(3) As to appeal number 2009/00298572 (previously 40456 of 2009) being the O'Donnell appeal:
(a) Allow the appeal in part.
(b) Set aside orders 2 and 5 made by the Supreme Court on 26 February 2010 (as set out in [446] of the primary judge's reasons) and in lieu thereof order:
(i) The loan agreement dated 10 January 2003 and made between Permanent as lender, or to the extent that it has acceded to that company's rights, FirstMac Limited, and Gillian O'Donnell and John Robert O'Donnell as borrowers be varied to reduce the principal loan from $500,000 to $125,000 such variation to take effect from 1 August 2005, with the effect that thereafter the responsibility for payment of interest and principal be referable to a principal sum of $125,000.
(ii) The security provided by registered mortgage numbered 9386484P between Mr and Mrs O'Donnell and Permanent, or to the extent that it has acceded to Permanent's rights, FirstMac Limited, be limited in effect accordingly such that upon payment of the sum or sums sufficient to repay said loan as varied the O'Donnells be entitled to receipt of a registrable discharge of mortgage.
(iii) The plaintiff pay 75 per cent of the defendants'/cross-claimants' costs of the proceedings.
(c) The appellant pay 75 per cent of the respondents' costs of the appeal.
[Note: The Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 provide (Rule 36.11) that unless the Court otherwise orders, a judgment or order is taken to be entered when it is recorded in the Court's computerised court record system. Setting aside and variation of judgments or orders is dealt with by Rules 36.15, 36.16, 36.17 and 36.18. Parties should in particular note the time limit of fourteen days in Rule 36.16.]
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi