Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Emma Sleep GmbH

Link copied
Case Copied 72 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Emma Sleep GmbH [2025] FCA 618

File number(s): NSD 1526 of 2023
Judgment of: HILL J
Date of judgment: 16 June 2025
Catchwords: CONSUMER LAW – misleading and deceptive conduct and false and misleading representations about goods or services under ss 18 and 29(1)(i) of the Australian Consumer Law – agreed statement of facts – liability admitted in respect of Australian subsidiary in corporate group for certain representations – whether German parent company (Emma Sleep GmbH) or Philippines related company (Bettzeit) are also liable for those representations – conduct “on behalf of ” a body corporate under s 139B(2) of the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) (CCA) – attribution of conduct of a subsidiary company to a parent company or related company – Bettzeit liable for impugned representations, both by virtue of s 139B(2)(b)(i) of the CCA and as a principal contravener – Emma Sleep GmbH not liable
Legislation:

Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth), ss 84(2), 139B(2)

Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth), Sch 2 (Australian Consumer Law), ss 18, 29(1)(i)

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), ss 198A, 198C

Evidence Act 1995 (Cth), s 140(2))

Cases cited:

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Bluescope Steel Ltd (No 5) [2022] FCA 1475

Ackers v Austcorp International Ltd [2009] FCA 432

Australian Building and Construction Commissioner v Parker [2017] FCA 564; (2017) 266 IR 340

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Cornerstone Investment Aust Pty Ltd (in liq) (No 4) [2018] FCA 1408

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Hillside (Australia New Media) Pty Ltd t/as Bet365 [2015] FCA 1007

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Olex Australia Pty Ltd [2017] FCA 222

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Productivity Partners Pty Ltd (t/as Captain Cook College) (No 3) [2021] FCA 737; (2021) 154 ACSR 472

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Yazaki Corporation (No 2) [2015] FCA 1304; (2015) 332 ALR 396

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v BHF Solutions Pty Ltd [2022] FCAFC 108; (2022) 293 FCR 330

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Big Star Energy Ltd (No 3) [2020] FCA 1442; (2020) 389 ALR 17

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v GetSwift Ltd (Liability Hearing) [2021] FCA 1384

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Hellicar [2012] HCA 17; (2012) 247 CLR 345

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v National Australia Bank Ltd (No 2) [2023] FCA 1118

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Peter Ivan Macks (No 4) [2020] SASC 209

Bennett v Elysium Noosa Pty Ltd (in liq) [2012] FCA 211; (2012) 202 FCR 72

Briggs v James Hardie & Co Pty Ltd (1989) 16 NSWLR 549

Brosnan v Katke [2012] FCA 1249

Cassidy v Saatchi & Saatchi Australia Pty Ltd [2004] FCAFC 34; (2004) 134 FCR 585

Commissioner for Fair Trading v Bowes Street Developments Pty Ltd (No 3) [2024] ACTSC 315

Consolo Ltd v Bennett [2012] FCAFC 120; (2012) 207 FCR 127

Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Emma Sleep... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] FCA 618
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case between the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) and Emma Sleep GmbH concerns allegations of misleading and deceptive conduct and false representations about goods and services under sections 18 and 29(1)(i) of the Australian Consumer Law (ACL). The parties have agreed on certain facts, including that Emma Sleep GmbH, a German company, has subsidiaries in the Philippines (Bettzeit) and Australia (Emma Sleep AU). Emma Sleep AU is the entity that made the impugned representations to Australian consumers. The German parent company, Emma Sleep GmbH, and the Philippine subsidiary, Bettzeit, are also parties to the dispute. The court must decide whether these entities are liable for the conduct of Emma Sleep AU under section 139B(2) of the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (CCA).

The legal issues centre on the attribution of the conduct of Emma Sleep AU to its parent company, Emma Sleep GmbH, and to its related company, Bettzeit. The court examines whether the representations made by Emma Sleep AU can be attributed to Bettzeit and Emma Sleep GmbH under section 139B(2) of the CCA. This section allows for the attribution of conduct to a body corporate through its agents or at the direction of its directors or employees. Additionally, the court must determine whether Bettzeit and Emma Sleep GmbH are liable as principal contraveners of the ACL.

The court found that Bettzeit was liable for the impugned representations both as a principal contravener and because its conduct could be attributed to it under section 139B(2)(b)(i) of the CCA. This conclusion was based on the close involvement of Bettzeit employees in the making of the representations by Emma Sleep AU. However, the court determined that Emma Sleep GmbH was not liable. The ACCC's case relied on the strategic guidance provided by certain executives of Emma Sleep GmbH; however, the court found that this did not amount to a "direction" that could be connected to the impugned representations. The court also highlighted that the executives of Emma Sleep GmbH generally provided strategic guidance rather than specific directions, and that any occasional specific directions were in response to queries from the country teams, not connected to the impugned representations.

In conclusion, the court found that Bettzeit was liable for the representations made by Emma Sleep AU, both as a principal contravener and through the operation of section 139B(2)(b)(i) of the CCA. Emma Sleep GmbH, on the other hand, was not found to be liable for the impugned representations. The court ordered that a case management hearing be listed to arrange for the penalty proceeding.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The matter be listed for a case management hearing on a date to be fixed.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

For the following reasons, I find that Bettzeit also contravened ss 18 and 29(1)(i) of the ACL in respect of the impugned representations, both as a principal contravener and through the operation of s 139B(2)(b)(i) of the CCA. However, I find that Emma Sleep GmbH did not contravene the ACL. The next step is to list a case management hearing to make arrangements for the penalty proceeding.B. AGREED FACTS The parties have agreed a “Statement of Agreed Facts Regarding Liability” dated 14 November 2024 (SOAF), a “Supplementary Statement of Agreed Facts Regarding Liability” dated 26 March 2025, and a “Second Supplementary Statement of Agreed Facts Regarding Liability” dated 15 May 2025 (2SSOAF). These are made for the purposes of s 191 of the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth). Respondents: Emma Sleep GmbH is a bedroom furniture supplier incorporated in Germany. Bettzeit and Emma Sleep AU are subsidiaries of Emma Sleep GmbH. Bettzeit is incorporated in the Philippines, and Emma Sleep AU is incorporated in Australia (SOAF [2]). Emma Sleep AU advertising platforms: Emma Sleep AU commenced operations in Australia in November 2019 and began to make regular sales to consumers in 2020. Emma Sleep AU advertises and supplies mattresses, bed frames, pillows and accessories to Australian consumers, primarily through its website (referred to as the “Emma Sleep Website”) (SOAF [3]). Emma Sleep AU also advertises its products to Australian consumers through online platforms, including Facebook, Instagram, and by email (SOAF [4]). Emma Sleep AU also advertises its products on third-party retailer websites (including Woolworths Everyday Market), and advertises its products to Australian consumers on television, radio, and by other offline means including emails, text messages, and physical billboards (SOAF [5]). The various media platforms on which Emma Sleep AU advertises its products to Australian consumers are referred to collectively as “the Platforms” (SOAF [6]). Emma Sleep AU’s products are also advertised on a product review website (referred to as “Top 5 Best Mattress Website”), which is registered to Emma Sleep AU. The website is operated by a different subsidiary of Emma Sleep GmbH (DIBMat GmbH), in conjunction with a group of staff known as “Country Team Australia” (SOAF [4], as amended by 2SSOAF [3]). Country Team Australia: Country Team Australia is a division or business unit of Emma Sleep AU. It is responsible for:(a)the operations of Emma Sleep AU in Australia, including business development, operations and retail/wholesale; and(b)the management of content on online Platforms (namely the Emma Sleep Website, Facebook, Instagram, email and third-party retailer websites).See SOAF [8]. Country Team Australia was responsible for developing, approving and updating the advertising of Emma Sleep AU’s products on the Platforms on behalf of Emma Sleep AU (SOAF [7]). Relationship between Emma Sleep entities: Paragraph 9 of the SOAF sets out the following facts about the relationship between the different Emma Sleep entities during at least the Relevant Period (15 June 2020 to 27 March 2023):·Employers for leadership roles: Country Team Australia was comprised by persons employed by Emma Sleep AU and Bettzeit (SOAF [9](a)). The persons occupying the position of “Team Lead” (who led Country Team Australia) were employed by Bettzeit and Emma Sleep AU (SOAF [9](b)). The persons occupying the positions of “Country Manager” or “Head of Australia” (which sat above Country Team Australia) were employed by Bettzeit, and were “responsible for steering the business operations of Emma Sleep AU” (SOAF [9](c)).·Share ownership: Emma Sleep GmbH held 99.40% of the issued share capital in Bettzeit (with the remaining 0.60% split evenly between Mr Schmoltzi, Mr Müller, and Mr Quiroga-Rivera) (SOAF [9](d)). Emma Sleep AU was a wholly-owned subsidiary of Emma Sleep GmbH (SOAF [9](j)).·Directorships: Mr Schmoltzi, Mr Müller, and Mr Quiroga-Rivera were directors of Bettzeit. Mr Quiroga-Rivera (the “Country Manager” or “Head of Australia”) held the position of Managing Director of Bettzeit (SOAF [9](e)). Mr Schmoltzi and Mr Müller were also directors of Emma Sleep GmbH, and directors of DIBMat GmbH (SOAF [9](f) and (h)).·Management: Mr Müller, Mr Schmoltzi, and senior managers of Emma Sleep GmbH, “generally provided guidance at a strategy level to Country Team Australia and the persons occupying the positions of Team Lead, Country Manager and Head of Australia with respect to the operations of Emma Sleep AU” (SOAF [9](g)). Reference is made to four email chains including Mr Schmoltzi and Mr Müller, dated 1 August 2022; 15 to 16 September 2022; 31 October to 1 November 2022; and 23 to 24 March 2022.·The directors of Emma Sleep AU “were appointed to fulfil statutory requirements for company registration, and were not involved in the day-to-day business of Emma Sleep AU” (SOAF [9](i)).

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Conclusions on Bettzeit: For the reasons set out above, I find that Bettzeit is liable for the impugned representations, because this conduct can be attributed to it under s 139B(2)(b)(i) of the CCA. I also find that Bettzeit is liable as a principal contravener, because its employees in Country Team Australia (including in one period Bettzeit’s Managing Director) were closely involved in the making of the representations by Emma Sleep AU.E.4 Position of Emma Sleep GmbH I turn now to the position of Emma Sleep GmbH. As noted, the ACCC contends that Emma Sleep GmbH is liable both as a principal, and liable by reason of s 139B(2) of the CCA because (it is said) Emma Sleep AU’s conduct was engaged in either as the agent of Emma Sleep GmbH, or at the direction of a director or employee of Emma Sleep GmbH. Emma Sleep GmbH liability under CCA s 139B(2)? Starting with s 139B(2), the ACCC’s case raises three questions:(1)Whether Emma Sleep AU’s conduct was engaged in “on behalf of” Emma Sleep GmbH;(2)If yes to (1), whether in doing so Emma Sleep AU was acting as the agent of Emma Sleep GmbH, within the scope of Emma Sleep AU’s actual or apparent authority as agent;(3)If yes to (1) but no to (2), whether:(a)in doing so Emma Sleep AU was acting at the direction of a director, employee or agent of Emma Sleep GmbH; and(b)the direction was within the scope of the actual or apparent authority of the director, employee or agent. It is convenient to focus on questions (2) and (3)(a), starting with the latter. Any direction issued to Emma Sleep AU? The most pressing question raised by the ACCC’s case against Emma Sleep GmbH is whether the impugned representations were made “at the direction of” an employee or director of Emma Sleep GmbH within s 139B(2)(b)(i) of the CCA, particularly Dr Schmoltzi or Mr Müller. It is clear that Dr Schmoltzi and Mr Müller (and others in Emma Sleep GmbH) provided detailed advice on marketing and pricing strategy for Emma Sleep AU during the Relevant Period, as revealed by the emails summarised in [73]-[76] above. However, none of the emails relied on by the ACCC amount to a “direction”, in the sense of authoritative guidance, that can be connected to the impugned representations. This is consistent with the agreed facts, which state only that these executives “generally provided guidance at a strategy level” (SOAF [9](g)). And an email from Ms Gao of Emma Sleep GmbH dated 1 November 2022 states that “country teams own this topic and execute it” (meaning the topics of pricing and discounts): see [73](3) above. This statement is directly contrary to the ACCC’s case on this point. The fact that Ms Gao is included and participates in an email discussion involving very senior executives in the Emma Sleep Group, such as Dr Schmoltzi, Mr Müller, and Mr Quiroga-Rivera, suggests that her understanding of the position can be given weight. The ACCC points to the fact that a letter from Emma Sleep GmbH dated 24 November 2023 states that Emma Sleep GmbH directors and senior managers generally do not give specific directions or instructions in relation to matters such as discounts and countdown timers, but “they may have done so from time to time during the Relevant Period in response to a query from the country team” (emphasis added): see [74](2) above. However, this guarded statement does not provide a sufficient basis for inferring that a direction was given by a director or employee of Emma Sleep GmbH in respect of the impugned representations.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Top 5 Best Mattress Website: Finally, the ACCC relies on the fact that Emma Sleep AU’s products are advertised on the Top 5 Best Mattresses Website. That website is registered to Emma Sleep, and operated by a German subsidiary of Emma Sleep GmbH (DIBMat GmbH) in conjunction with Country Team Australia.E. CONSIDERATIONE.1 Approach to fact finding It is convenient to begin with three general comments about the approach to fact finding in these proceedings. Standard of proof: The first comment concerns the appropriate standard of proof. The ACCC of course bears the burden of proof in all matters, on the balance of probabilities: Evidence Act, s 140(1). That standard of proof is informed by s 140(2) of the Evidence Act, which requires that the Court take into account (among other things) the nature of the subject-matter of the proceeding, and the gravity of the matters alleged (s 140(2)(b) and (c)). In Bluescope Steel (No5) at [178], O’Bryan J explained the effect of s 140 as follows:[T]here is only one civil standard of proof, being the balance of probabilities. However, satisfaction on the balance of probabilities is affected by the nature of the issues being determined and their gravity. Issues which have serious consequences, including particularly the imposition of civil penalties, are weighed by the Court. In reaching my findings and determining whether I am satisfied that the ACCC’s case has been proved on the balance of probabilities, I have taken into account the gravity of the matters alleged.See also Australian Building and Construction Commissioner v Parker [2017] FCA 564; (2017) 266 IR 340 at [58]-[59] (Flick J). Inferences: The second comment concerns the approach to drawing inferences. A finding may be made in the absence of direct evidence; however, the “more probable” civil standard means that it is not sufficient that the circumstances give rise to conflicting inferences of an equal degree of probability or plausibility, or that the choice between them can only be made by conjecture: Bluescope Steel (No 5) at [180], quoting Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Olex Australia Pty Ltd [2017] FCA 222 at [479] (Beach J). As with any civil proceedings, any inference must be “reasonable and definite”: Luxton v Vines [1952] HCA 19; (1952) 85 CLR 352 at 358 (Dixon, Fullagar and Kitto JJ); Director of the Fair Work Building Industry Inspectorate v McCullough [2016] FCA 1291 at [151] (Barker J); Australian Securities and Investments Commission v GetSwift Ltd (Liability Hearing) [2021] FCA 1384 at [1898] (Lee J). Jones v Dunkel: The third comment concerns the availability of the rule in Jones v Dunkel (1959) 101 CLR 298, on which the ACCC seeks to rely. This rule is available, as a matter of law, in civil penalty proceedings: see Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Big Star Energy Ltd (No 3) [2020] FCA 1442; (2020) 389 ALR 17 at [39] (Banks-Smith J); Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Macks (No 4) [2020] SASC 209 at [393] (Doyle J), and the cases cited.