Productivity Partners Pty Ltd v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 77 min read

HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA

GAGELER CJ,
GORDON, EDELMAN, STEWARD, GLEESON, JAGOT AND BEECH‑JONES JJ

Matter No S118/2023

PRODUCTIVITY PARTNERS PTY LTD (TRADING
AS CAPTAIN COOK COLLEGE) & ANOR  APPELLANTS

AND

AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION AND CONSUMER
COMMISSION & ANOR  RESPONDENTS

Matter No S116/2023

BLAKE WILLS  APPELLANT

AND

AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION AND CONSUMER
COMMISSION & ORS  RESPONDENTS

Productivity Partners Pty Ltd v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission
Wills v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission

[2024] HCA 27

Date of Hearing: 7 & 8 February 2024
Date of Judgment: 14 August 2024

S118/2023 & S116/2023

ORDER

In each matter:

Appeal dismissed with costs.

On appeal from the Federal Court of Australia

Representation

J C Giles SC with R B Davies for the appellants in S118/2023 and the second and third respondents in S116/2023 (instructed by MinterEllison)

M R Hodge KC with C E Bannan for the appellant in S116/2023 and the second respondent in S118/2023 (instructed by HWL Ebsworth Lawyers)

S P Donaghue KC, Solicitor-General of the Commonwealth, and O Bigos KC with S A C Patterson and L G Moretti for the first respondent in both matters (instructed by Johnson Winter Slattery)

Notice:  This copy of the Court's Reasons for Judgment is subject to formal revision prior to publication in the Commonwealth Law Reports.

  1. These appeals concern the application of the proscription against unconscionable conduct in s 21 of the Australian Consumer Law[1] ("the ACL") to a corporation offering and providing online vocational education and training ("VET") funded through a Commonwealth scheme known as the Vocational Education and Training Fee Higher Education Loan Program ("the VFH scheme"). Through the VFH scheme, the Commonwealth assisted people to fund their VET by paying an eligible person's tuition fees ("VET fees") directly to a registered training organisation which was a "VET provider" on the basis that the person would incur a debt to the Commonwealth, in the amount of the VET fees plus a 20% "loan fee" ("VFH debt"), which the person would be required to repay to the Commonwealth over time through the tax system once the person earned above a specified threshold.

    [1]Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth), s 131(1) and Sch 2 ("ACL").

  2. Productivity Partners Pty Ltd trading as Captain Cook College ("the College") was a VET provider that offered, relevantly, online VET courses. Site Group International Ltd ("Site") acquired the College in 2014. Blake Wills was the Chief Operating Officer of Site and, between November 2015 and January 2016, acting Chief Executive Officer ("CEO") of the College.

  3. The Australian Competition and Consumer Commission ("the ACCC") alleged that the College engaged in a system of conduct, or a pattern of behaviour, in respect of persons who enrolled in the College's online courses that was, in all the circumstances, unconscionable in contravention of s 21 of the ACL. The principally relevant conduct was that, during the period from 7 September 2015 to 18 December 2015 (called "the impugned enrolment period"), the College changed its process for enrolment by removing two system controls which…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Productivity Partners Pty Ltd v Australian Competition and C... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] HCA 27
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Productivity Partners Pty Ltd (the College) and Mr Wills appealed to the High Court of Australia following a decision of the Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia. The dispute concerned allegations that the College had engaged in unconscionable conduct in contravention of section 21 of the Australian Consumer Law (ACL) by altering its vocational education and training (VET) enrolment process. Mr Wills, as Chief Operating Officer and acting Chief Executive Officer of the College's parent company, was alleged to be knowingly concerned in or party to this contravention, making him liable for pecuniary penalties under section 224 of the ACL.

The High Court was required to determine whether the College had engaged in unconscionable conduct by removing safeguards in its enrolment process, thereby facilitating the enrolment of unsuitable or unknowing individuals to claim VET fees from the Commonwealth. A further issue was whether Mr Wills possessed the requisite knowledge to be considered "knowingly concerned in" or "party to" the College's contravention, thereby establishing his accessorial liability.

The Court upheld the findings of the lower courts. It was established that the College's actions constituted unconscionable conduct because it deliberately removed enrolment safeguards, knowing that this would lead to more students remaining enrolled beyond the census date, allowing the College to claim VET fees and incur debts for those students. This conduct was found to be a "sharp practice" driven by financial gain, preying on the vulnerability of students and disregarding their interests. Regarding Mr Wills' liability, the Court affirmed that to be "knowingly concerned" or "involved" in a contravention, a party must have knowledge of the "essential facts" constituting the contravention, but not necessarily knowledge of the legal characterisation of those facts as unconscionable. The Court found that Mr Wills had the necessary knowledge of the essential facts of the College's conduct.

Consequently, the appeals by Productivity Partners Pty Ltd and Mr Wills were dismissed with costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

In each matter:

Appeal dismissed with costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

I write separately on the state of mind that a party must possess to be "involved" or "knowingly concerned" in a principal's contravention of the proscription on engaging in unconscionable conduct in connection with, inter alia, the supply of services found in s 21 of the Australian Consumer Law ("the ACL").[349] Such a party must have knowledge of the "essential facts" that constitute the contravention by the principal but need not know that the principal's conduct constitutes unconscionable conduct or otherwise have knowledge of the legal characterisation or complexion of those essential facts, including that the conduct is contrary to a particular standard that embodies what is meant by unconscionable. What constitutes the "essential facts" of a contravention of which the party must have knowledge will depend on what conduct the principal's contravention consists of in a particular case. The party that is involved or knowingly concerned in the principal's contravention may, but not necessarily will, possess knowledge of a particular matter or have a particular intent that the principal does not. [349]Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth), Sch 2 ("ACL").Background The circumstances of, and issues arising in, these appeals are set out in the judgment of Gageler CJ and Jagot J. I agree with their Honours' reasons for rejecting the first two grounds of Productivity Partners Pty Ltd's ("the College") appeal, which challenged the finding of the majority of the Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia that it had engaged in unconscionable conduct. It follows that I would also reject ground three of Mr Wills' appeal, which contended that, if the College's appeal was successful, then he could not be liable as an accessory. I also agree with that part of Gordon J's judgment that addresses the meaning of "unconscionable conduct" in s 21(1) and the relationship between ss 21 and 22 of the ACL.[350][350]Reasons of Gordon J at [97]-[110]. I also agree with the reasons of Gageler CJ and Jagot J for upholding the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission's ("the ACCC") notice of contention in each appeal, which challenged the finding of the majority of the Full Court that there was "an insufficient basis to infer that Mr Wills had a real appreciation, as at 7 September 2015, of the full consequences of the changes" to the College's enrolment and withdrawal procedures that came into effect on that day.[351] This also disposes of ground two of Mr Wills' appeal. [351]Productivity Partners Pty Ltd v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (2023) 297 FCR 180 at 287 [340]. There remains to be considered ground one of Mr Wills' appeal (and ground three of the College's appeal, which challenges the finding that Site Group International Limited was knowingly concerned in or party to the College's unconscionable conduct through Mr Wills and which depends on ground one of Mr Wills' appeal). With ground one of his appeal, Mr Wills contends that the majority of the Full Court erred in finding that he had the requisite knowledge to be liable as an accessory to a contravention of s 21 of the ACL. As the ACCC's notices of contention should be upheld, the relevant findings about Mr Wills' knowledge that must be considered are those of the primary judge. Accessorial liability under the Australian Consumer Law

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

GAGELER CJ (dissent) BEECH-JONES J
However, the College continued to claim VFH revenue from the Commonwealth, in respect of the persons enrolled between 7 September and 18 December 2015, until September 2016. By the College claiming the VFH revenue, the enrolled person incurred the corresponding debt (plus the 20% loan fee) to the Commonwealth. Unchallenged conclusions below The primary judge concluded that allowing persons who could not be contacted by the College to remain enrolled beyond the first census date so that the College could claim the VFH revenue from the Commonwealth "was to act against conscience; it was a sharp practice that was manifestly unfair to such [persons]; it was driven by avarice without regard to the interests of such [persons]; it preyed on their vulnerability (being their being prey to CA misconduct, their unsuitability or their uncontactability)".[15][15]Australian Competition and Consumer Commission vProductivity Partners Pty Ltd (t/as Captain Cook College) [No 3] (2021) 154 ACSR 472 at 571 [500]. The Full Court rejected the challenge to these conclusions, saying:[16]"We reject the appellants' further submission that the primary judge's findings do not demonstrate that the College took advantage of the risk of agent misconduct. The findings demonstrate precisely that, and that is what the primary judge found (at PJ [500]). The risks and problems associated with the VFH scheme and the College's use of agents to recruit students were known to the College. There could not be a more powerful demonstration of the risks and problems than the fact that, prior to the enrolment process changes, about 50% of enrolled students withdrew or were withdrawn before the first census date. This was not merely a theoretical risk; it was a manifest problem. It was plain that the College's agents had been recruiting large numbers of students who did not understand what they were committing to. The College knew that the outbound QA call enrolment procedure and the campus driven withdrawal procedure provided important safeguards against that problem. The catalyst for the College to change its enrolment process and remove those safeguards was the fact that agents were increasingly referring students to VET providers other than the College because they were unhappy with the College's enrolment process, and the College's revenue was declining as a result. The College changed its enrolment process in consultation with its agents to placate its agents. It removed the two safeguards for students with the result that more students would pass through the first census, incurring a VFH debt, and agents would receive more commission. This gave agents the incentive to refer more students to the College. The result was that the College's revenue experienced an exponential increase, brought about by the combined effect of an increased number of students enrolling and a much higher proportion of those students passing the first census. In changing its enrolment process, the College took advantage of the known risks and problems of the VFH scheme and its recruitment system to gain a financial benefit for itself to the disadvantage of persons who enrolled in circumstances where the person did not do so willingly and with full knowledge of the obligation being incurred (the VFH debt) or where the person was unsuitable for enrolment because they lacked sufficient language, literacy or numeracy skills or technology skills or access."[16]Productivity Partners Pty Ltd v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (2023) 297 FCR 180 at 235 [177].

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: BEECH-JONES J