Hytera Communications Corporation Ltd v Motorola Solutions Inc

Link copied
Case Copied 81 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Hytera Communications Corporation Ltd v Motorola Solutions Inc [2024] FCAFC 168

Appeal from: Motorola Solutions, Inc. v Hytera Communications Corporation Ltd (Liability) [2022] FCA 1585
File number: NSD 675 of 2023
Judgment of: BEACH, O'BRYAN AND ROFE JJ
Date of judgment: 18 December 2024
Catchwords:

PATENTS –  indirect infringement – appellant found to have infringed respondent’s patent (Australian Patent No 2005275355) relating to digital mobile radios (DMRs) using Time Division Multiple Access (TDMA) technology to divide frequency channel – appeal against finding of infringement – disputed issues of construction – appeal against finding of validity – whether the invention claimed involved an inventive step – whether the invention claimed is useful – whether the invention claimed is a manner of manufacture – appeal dismissed

PATENTS – validity – respondent’s patent (Australian Patent No. 2006276960) relating to DMRs using TDMA technology found to be invalid by reason that the invention claimed did not involve an inventive step – cross-appeal against that finding dismissed – cross-contentions concerning manner of manufacture and infringement also dismissed

COPYRIGHT – indirect infringement - respondent owner of Australian copyright in 11 computer programs in source code – appeal against finding of infringement by the importation into Australia of DMR devices containing firmware in object code, where firmware compiled from appellants’ source code in China and installed into DMR devices in China, and where appellants’ source code developed using respondent’s source code – whether the appellants copied a substantial part of the respondent’s copyright works – whether fact that copied parts of the respondent’s copyright works derived from earlier versions of the respondent’s computer renders them not original for the purposes of infringement, such that the copied parts are not a substantial part – whether appellants otherwise copied a substantial part of the respondent’s copyright works – the correct approach to assessing the copying of a substantial part – where appellants deliberately deleted source code to suppress evidence which might assist in a copyright infringement suit – application of the maxim omnia praesumuntur contra spoliatorem (all things are presumed against the wrongdoer) – primary judge’s approach to assessing the copying of a substantial part shown to be in error

COPYRIGHT – requirement of knowledge for the purposes of ss 37 and 38 of the Copyright Act 1968 (Cth) (Copyright Act) – whether relevant executives who undertook or supervised copying were acting within the scope of their authority – principles concerning attribution of knowledge to a corporation – no error shown

COPYRIGHT – award of additional damages under s 115(4) of the Copyright Act – discretionary decision – no error in the exercise of discretion shown

Legislation:

Copyright Act 1968 (Cth) ss 10, 13(1), 14, 31(1), 32, 36(1), 37, 38, 115(4), 126

Copyright Amendment Bill 1984 (Cth)

Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) ss 81, 136

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) ss 27

Patents Act 1990 (Cth) ss 7(3), 18(1), 117

Cases cited:

Aequitas Ltd v AEFC Leasing Pty…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hytera Communications Corporation Ltd v Motorola Solutions I... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] FCAFC 168
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Hytera Communications Corporation Ltd v Motorola Solutions Inc, the Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia considered an appeal against a decision of the primary judge finding that Hytera infringed Motorola’s patents and copyright. The primary judge found that Hytera had infringed Motorola’s Australian Patent No 2005275355 relating to digital mobile radios using Time Division Multiple Access (TDMA) technology. Hytera appealed against this finding of infringement, arguing that the patent was invalid because it did not involve an inventive step. The Court dismissed the appeal, holding that the patent was valid. The primary judge also found that Hytera infringed Motorola’s copyright in its source code for its DMR devices. Hytera appealed against this finding, arguing that the primary judge’s approach to assessing the copying of a substantial part was in error. The Court dismissed the appeal, holding that the primary judge’s approach was correct. The primary judge also found that Hytera’s executives who undertook or supervised copying were acting within the scope of their authority and that there was no error in the exercise of the discretion to award additional damages. The Court dismissed the appeal and cross-appeal in part and otherwise allowed the cross-appeal.

The legal issues before the Court were whether Hytera infringed Motorola’s patents and copyright, whether the patents were valid, and whether the primary judge’s approach to assessing the copying of a substantial part was in error. The Court considered the technical background to two-way radio communications and relevant technology, including the radio spectrum, frequency bands, and the components of radio devices. The Court held that Hytera infringed Motorola’s patents and copyright and that the patents were valid. The Court also held that the primary judge’s approach to assessing the copying of a substantial part was correct and that there was no error in the exercise of the discretion to award additional damages.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The First and Second Appellants’ Amended Notice of Appeal dated 8 November 2023 be dismissed.

2. The Cross-Appellant’s Amended Notice of Cross-Appeal dated 27 November 2023 be allowed in part, in respect of grounds 2 and 3, and otherwise dismissed.

3. The Cross-Appellant’s Amended Notice of Cross-Appeal dated 27 November 2023 be listed for case management before this Court at 10.15 am on Friday 7 February 2025 for the making of timetabling orders for the further hearing and determination of the copyright infringement claims that arise on the appeal in accordance with the reasons accompanying these orders.

4. Pursuant to ss 37AF(1)(b) and 37AG(1)(a) of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth), until further order of the Court, access to and disclosure (by publication or otherwise) of the unredacted text of the reasons for judgment delivered today be restricted to the legal representatives of the parties and those persons to whom access is allowed under the terms of the confidentiality regimes agreed between the parties on 10 April 2018 and/or the confidentiality regime agreed between the parties on 24 May 2019.

5. Nothing in Order 4 or any other earlier order of the Court prevents any party from publishing the covering pages of these reasons for judgment up to and including these orders and paragraphs 1 to 21 and 918 to 923 of the reasons.

6. By 31 January 2025, the legal representatives for the parties exchange highlighted versions of the reasons for judgment identifying any parts of the reasons that are claimed to contain information confidential to their respective clients for redaction.

7. By 14 February 2025, the legal representatives for the parties confer on the proposed redactions and, if the parties are able to agree on the proposed redactions, provide to chambers an agreed form of the reasons for judgment with the proposed redactions highlighted, together with an agreed redacted form of the reasons for judgment that is suitable for publication.

8. In the event the parties are unable to agree on the proposed redactions, by 21 February 2025 the legal representatives for the parties provide chambers with:

(a) a version of the reasons for judgment which identifies the redactions which have been agreed and those which are in dispute; and

(b) a short written submission addressing the areas of disagreement.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Before dealing with the specific grounds of appeal and cross-appeal, it is necessary to set out some of the technical background.B.2 Background — two-way radio communications and relevant technology To understand the issues which have arisen before us, it is necessary to say something concerning the electronic engineering underpinning two-way radio communications. We have gratefully drawn from aspects of the primary judge’s detailed technical description that are relevant to the grounds of appeal and cross-appeal before us.General Radio is a method of transmitting electromagnetic energy across distance without using a direct, wired connection. The electromagnetic energy takes the form of radio waves which have a certain frequency. Radio waves are generated and sent out through a transmitter and are then received by a radio receiver using antennas. Depending upon their length, radio waves may travel by line of sight, by being reflected off buildings or other objects, in which case the communications will not travel beyond the horizon, and by being reflected off the ionosphere, in which case they can return to earth beyond the horizon. Different radio frequencies (RFs) are used for these different reflective requirements. As stated above, radio communications can be transmissions of audio (analogue transmissions) or of data (digital transmissions). Where a transmission is an analogue transmission, the whole of the voice transmission can be sent and decoded without any additional information being transmitted. Contrastingly, where a digital communication is involved, the decoding of the message requires the use of overheads. Overheads are the bits of digital information that are not associated with the substantive transmission, being the payload. So, digital transmissions are made up of two kinds of information being the overhead and the payload. One of the overheads in a digital communication arises from the need to achieve synchronisation between the devices which is achieved using a synchronisation pattern. Another relates to the scanning of channels which involves the use of information to identify the devices to which a payload is to be delivered. This kind of information is referred to as control information. The more of the radio transmission that is consumed by transmitting control information, the less of it is available to transmit payload.The radio spectrum The radio portion of the electromagnetic spectrum, which radio communications are transmitted on, is divided into three sub-categories known as frequency bands. These bands are the high frequency band (3,000 kHz to 30 MHz), the very high frequency band (30 MHz to 300 MHz) and the ultra-high frequency band (300 MHz to 3 GHz). Each of these bands is further separated into bandwidth channels which radio users use to transmit communications. These channels reflect the frequency range occupied by a carrier signal and are separated by a space known as channel spacing. The size of the bandwidth channel and the size of the channel spacing between each channel is determined in Australia by the Australian Communications and Media Authority. In 1999, ACMA determined that two-way radios would use channel bandwidths of 12.5 kHz, meaning each channel may occupy a range of frequencies in the radio spectrum which are no wider than 12.5 kHz. The size of this bandwidth limits the number of frequencies that can be defined inside a relevant band. Generally, the wider the channel bandwidth, the better the audio fidelity or the higher the data rate will be. The components of radio devices

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

At trial, Hytera did not dispute that Mr GS Kok and certain of the other ex-Motorola engineers brought with them to Hytera, without authorisation from Motorola, Motorola documents and computer code relating to Motorola’s DMR device and made use of some of these materials, including the computer code, in the development of Hytera’s firmware for its DMR device. That in itself is a damning admission, but the primary judge’s ultimate findings were even stronger. His Honour found that the ex-Motorola engineers took with them to Hytera all of the computer source code for Motorola’s DMR device to provide themselves with a resource for the purposes of writing Hytera’s source code for its DMR device. His Honour characterised Hytera’s actions as a “substantial industrial theft” and found that (Motorola Solutions, Inc. v Hytera Communications Corporation Ltd (Liability) [2022] FCA 1585 (the primary judgment or PJ) at [1576]):There is no doubt that Hytera’s software engineers engaged in industrial scale harvesting of Motorola’s source code and that they set out to make this as difficult to detect as possible. The Hytera DMR devices were brought to market in March 2010. The primary judge found that Hytera benefitted from the actions of the ex-Motorola engineers in at least two ways: first, it got to market with devices which were commercially competitive with Motorola’s products where otherwise it would not have done so; and secondly, it got to market by at least 15 months earlier than it otherwise would have. From September 2013, Hytera began distributing its DMRs in Australia. In March 2017, Motorola commenced proceedings against Hytera in the United States alleging patent infringement and breach of confidence. In July 2017, Motorola commenced proceedings (the subject of the primary judgement) in Australia alleging infringement of Australian Patent No 2005275355 (355 patent), Australian Patent No. 2006276960 (960 patent) and Australian Patent No. 2009298764 (764 patent) under the Patents Act 1990 (Cth) (Patents Act). Each of those patents are methods which refine the efficiency of TDMA. Motorola alleged that Hytera infringed the Australian patents by distributing in Australia Hytera’s DMR devices without Motorola’s license. By cross-claim, Hytera challenged the validity of the Australian patents. Following the discovery by Hytera of its source code for its DMR products for the purposes of the patent proceeding, Motorola added a claim for infringement of copyright in its own source code, first in the United States proceeding (in August 2018) and then in the proceeding before the primary judge (in December 2018). Substantially complete particulars of Motorola’s copyright claim were provided to Hytera in June 2019. Motorola alleged that Hytera infringed its Australian copyright in the ‘Release 1’ version of its computer source code for its DMR devices by, first, importing into Australia Hytera DMRs containing firmware which was a reproduction or an adaptation of the whole or a substantial part of Motorola’s source code and, second, making that firmware available for download in Australia from its website portal. Those claims were made under the Copyright Act 1968 (Cth) (Copyright Act).

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In response to Hytera’s second submission, Motorola submitted that the primary judge was correct to recognise (at PJ [1999]) that it was not clear that the “fraud exception” applies to employees or agents simpliciter, or that Mr GS Kok was a fiduciary in the requisite sense. Motorola further submitted that, in any event, the activities of Mr GS Kok were directed towards conferring a technological and commercial benefit on Hytera, and achieved their aim, as found by the primary judge. Motorola argued that the relevant actions for the purposes of the “fraud exception” are the acts or activities of the director concerned (relying on Grimaldi at [282], [285]). In this case, the relevant actions were the acts or activities of Mr GS Kok, being Mr GS Kok’s orchestration and organisation of the DMR development team’s deliberate copying of parts of Motorola’s source code (as found by the primary judge at PJ [964], [1990], [2033]-[2034] and [2037]). Motorola argued that not only was it clear that the key benefits to Hytera outlined by the primary judge (at PJ [2000]) flowed from Mr GS Kok’s acts and activities, but Mr GS Kok was motivated to perform those acts in order to achieve those benefits for Hytera (as found by the primary judge at PJ [1990(f)] and [2033]). Consideration Before addressing the two submissions advanced by Hytera on this ground of appeal, it is necessary to explain the legal framework within which the submissions are advanced. Infringement of copyright under s 37 (importation of articles into Australia for the purpose of sale) and s 38 (sale of articles in Australia) requires proof that the person who imports an article (in the case of s 37) and the person who sells an article (in the case of s 38) knew, or ought reasonably to have known, relevantly, that if the article had been made in Australia, it would have constituted an infringement of copyright. The authorities establish that the relevant knowledge is of the facts from which the finding of infringement would be made (on the hypothetical basis of the article being made in Australia), not knowledge of a contravention of the law: see Albert v S Hoffnung & Co Ltd (1921) 22 SR (NSW) 75 at 81 (Harvey J) as explained in subsequent decisions including Raben Footwear Pty Ltd v Polygram Records Inc (1997) 75 FCR 88 (Raben Footwear) at 91 (Burchett J), 97 (Tamberlin J) and 105-106 (Lehane J). In the present case, the ground of appeal is not concerned with the facts known by the alleged infringer, Hytera, but with the attribution to Hytera, a corporation, of the knowledge of one its employees, Mr GS Kok. As explained by the Privy Council in Meridian Global Funds Management Asia Ltd v Securities Commission [1995] 2 AC 500 (Meridian) at 506-511, the actions and knowledge of a corporation are based upon rules of attribution, as a corporation cannot act or have knowledge other than by virtue of the acts and knowledge of individuals that are attributed to the company. Prior to the decision in Meridian, the common law rules of attribution in England were generally framed by reference to the “directing mind and will” of the corporation: see generally Lennard's Carrying Co. Ltd. v. Asiatic Petroleum Co. Ltd. [1915] AC 705 (Lennard’s case) at 713 (Viscount Haldane LC) and Tesco Supermarkets Ltd v Nattrass [1972] AC 153 at 170 (Lord Reid). In Meridian, however, the Privy Council explained that the applicable rule of attribution in a given case depends upon the proper construction of the relevant rule of responsibility, liability or proscription (at 507); the test of “directing mind and will” adopted in cases such as Lennard’s case was not a universal rule for attributing knowledge to a corporation, but rather a rule determined to be applicable in the circumstances of the case (at 509).