FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
The NOCO Company v Brown and Watson International Pty Ltd [2025] FCA 887
File number: VID 264 of 2023 Judgment of: MOSHINSKY J Date of judgment: 7 August 2025 Catchwords: PATENTS – jump starter device for jump starting a depleted or discharged battery (eg in a vehicle) – priority date – where the patents in suit claimed an earliest priority date based on the filing date of a PCT application – where the cross-claimant contended that the patents were not entitled to the asserted priority date – whether, for each asserted claim, the invention in the claim was disclosed in the PCT application
PATENTS – jump starter device for jump starting a depleted or discharged battery (eg in a vehicle) – novelty and inventive step –whether the claims in the patents in suit were anticipated by one or other of two documents – whether the claims in the patents in suit would have been obvious to the person skilled in the art in light of the common general knowledge (CGK) alone, or in light of the CGK together with one or other of two documents
PATENTS – jump starter device for jump starting a depleted or discharged battery (eg in a vehicle) – best method – where the cross-claimant contended that the patentee had not disclosed the best method known to the patentee for performing the invention – whether the knowledge element was to be determined as at the international filing date or as at the filing date for the patents in suit
PATENTS – jump starter device for jump starting a depleted or discharged battery (eg in a vehicle) – infringement – whether the impugned products infringed the claims in the patents in suit – construction issues – whether the claims required that the device automatically start upon satisfaction of preconditions – whether a product that is capable of operating in manual mode falls outside the scope of the claims – whether references to “USB” in the claims encompass USB-C, which had not been released as at the asserted priority date
Legislation: Evidence Act 1995 (Cth), s 136
Intellectual Property Laws Amendment (Productivity Commission Response Part 2 and Other Measures) Act 2020 (Cth)
Patents Act 1990 (Cth), ss 7, 18, 29A, 40, 43, 79B
Patents Regulations 1991 (Cth), regs 3.12, 3.13A, 3.13D
Cases cited: Aktiebolaget Hässle v Alphapharm Pty Ltd [2002] HCA 59; 212 CLR 411
Allied Pumps Pty Ltd v LAA Industries Pty Ltd [2023] FCA 1457; 179 IPR 1
Arbitron Inc v Telecontrol Aktiengesellschaft [2010] FCA 302; 86 IPR 110
AstraZeneca AB v Apotex Pty Ltd [2014] FCAFC 99; 226 FCR 324
AstraZeneca AB v Apotex Pty Ltd [2015] HCA 30; 257 CLR 356
Austal Ships Sales Pty Ltd v Stena Rederi Aktiebolag [2008] FCAFC 121; 77 IPR 229
Bristol-Myers Squibb Company v FH Faulding & Company Ltd [2000] FCA 316; 97 FCR 524
Brugger v Medic-Aid Ltd [1996] RPC 635
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read The NOCO Company v Brown and Watson International Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2025] FCA 887
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court found that the asserted claims in the patents were not entitled to the priority dates they claimed. This conclusion was based on the fact that the invention as disclosed in the PCT application did not sufficiently support the claims. The court also determined that the claims lacked novelty and inventive step as they were anticipated by prior art and would have been obvious to a person skilled in the art. Additionally, the court found that the patentee had not disclosed the best method known for performing the invention as at the international filing date. Regarding infringement, the court concluded that the defendant's products did not infringe the patents, mainly due to construction issues regarding the operation and features of the jump-starting device. The court found that the claims required automatic operation upon satisfaction of preconditions and encompassed USB-C in references to "USB".
Consequently, the Federal Court of Australia declared all the asserted claims of the patents invalid. The court also made orders to revoke specific claims in each patent and dismissed the applicant's claim. Certain parts of the judgment concerning the best method ground were redacted and kept confidential for an initial period. The court invited the parties to make submissions on costs.
Orders
Orders of the court
4. Claims 1 to 8, 11 to 14 and 16 to 21 of Australian Patent 2020201223 be revoked.
5. Claims 1 to 4, 6 to 12 and 14 to 24 of Australian Patent 2021258059 be revoked.
6. Claims 1 to 8, 10 to 14, 16 to 26 and 29 to 36 of Australian Patent 2022201338 be revoked.
7. The applicant’s claim be dismissed.
8. Pursuant to s 37AI(1) of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth), [371] (third and fourth sentences) and [392]-[395] of the reasons for judgment of the Court dated today be published only to the parties and be kept confidential and not otherwise be disclosed for a period of 30 days. [THIS ORDER HAS SUBSEQUENTLY BEEN VACATED]
9. If any party seeks suppression or non-disclosure orders in respect of those paragraphs, the party may within 10 days file and serve an interlocutory application supported by an affidavit and an outline of submissions. The other party may within a further seven days file any responding material, and the party seeking the order may within a further two business days file any material in reply. The application will then be determined on the papers.
10. In relation to costs:
(a) within 14 days, the parties submit any agreed proposed orders as to costs;
(b) if the parties cannot agree, then within 21 days, each party file and serve a short written submission on costs, and within 28 days each party file and serve a short responding written submission. The issue of costs will then be determined on the papers.
11. Paragraphs 1 to 6 above be stayed:
(a) for a period of 28 days; or
(b) if the applicant files a notice of appeal within 28 days, until the hearing and determination of the appeal.
Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Introduction
[1]
Patents
[21]
223 Patent
[21]
059 Patent
[47]
338 Patent
[51]
The hearing and the evidence
[54]
Person skilled in the art
[73]
Common general knowledge
[78]
Power electronics – basic electrical concepts
[81]
Power electronics – components and protective features
[85]
Lithium batteries
[88]
Construction issues
[89]
Applicable principles
[89]
Consideration
[99]
Construction issue 1: sensor to detect polarity
[101]
Construction issue 2: Operation before switch closure
[108]
Construction issues 3 and 4: Automatic Start issue
[110]
Construction issue 5(i): Manual Mode issue
[132]
Construction issue 5(ii): Operation across the voltage range
[148]
Construction issues 6 and 7: USB issue
[149]
Construction issue 8: Power switch etc
[171]
Construction issue 9: Output controlling the power switch
[172]
Construction issue 10: USB charging circuit including DC-DC converter
[173]
Construction issue 11: DC-DC converter controlled by microcontroller
[190]
Construction issue 12: Charging to at least 11.1V or 12.4V
[191]
Construction issue 13: Voltage measurement circuit
[192]
Further construction issue: two sensors
[193]
Priority Date issue
[196]
Relevant provisions
[198]
Applicable principles
[208]
PCT434
[216]
Expert evidence
[225]
The parties’ submissions
[233]
Consideration
[239]
Other invalidity issues
[255]
Lack of novelty
[256]
Applicable principles
[259]
HP Manual
[264]
QTC Brochure
[283]
Lack of inventive step
[306]
Applicable principles
[311]
Common general knowledge
[317]
Evidence
[321]
Parties’ submissions
[337]
Consideration – CGK alone
[347]
Consideration – CGK and HP Manual
[355]
Consideration – CGK and QTC Brochure
[362]
Best method
[369]
Other invalidity grounds
[399]
Infringement issues
[400]
Conclusion
[413]
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In Multigate Medical Devices Pty Ltd v B Braun Melsungen AG [2016] FCAFC 21; 117 IPR 1 at [23]-[28], Bennett, Yates and Beach JJ made a series of related observations about the role of expert evidence in patent cases on issues of construction.Consideration I will now consider, in turn, each of the construction issues identified in NOCO’s opening submissions on infringement. The issues are relevant to infringement or invalidity or both. Some of the issues have fallen away in light of the narrowing of the parties’ cases during the hearing. This will be indicated below. I will approach the construction issues as at the asserted priority date. That is, I will approach the issues on the basis of how the skilled addressee would have understood the Patents as at that date.Construction issue 1: sensor to detect polarity Construction issue 1 (as identified by NOCO) relates to integer 1.6.2 in Claim 1 of the 223 Patent (and comparable wording in other asserted claims). That integer requires the control system or circuit to be configured “to detect polarity of the depleted or discharged battery when connected between the positive and negative battery connectors”. In B&W’s opening submissions on infringement (which deal with construction issues) this construction issue is discussed in terms that relate to integer 1.6.1 as well as 1.6.2. Integer 1.6.1 requires the control system or circuit to be configured “to detect presence of the depleted or discharged battery when connected between the positive and negative battery connectors”. There is a lack of clarity in the parties’ submissions as to the identification of this issue. NOCO’s submissions are directed to whether detection of polarity is to occur regardless of whether the connectors are connected. B&W submits that “when connected” is a temporal limitation that requires the control system, circuit or sensors (depending on the particular claim) to be configured to make the specific detections (i.e. present or not, correct polarity or not) at the time specified in the asserted claims. However, B&W submits, the asserted claims do not assume battery presence. B&W submits that: the asserted claims are directed to an apparatus, not a method; the control system, circuit or sensors of that apparatus must be “configured” to make the specified detections; the asserted claims encompass such an apparatus, irrespective of whether it is, in fact, connected to a vehicle battery. In B&W’s closing propositions (at [8]) and in its closing oral submissions (at T881) it seemed to be making a different point, namely that a reasonable construction of “when connected” is “upon and while connected”, thus including the time after switch closure. In relation to whether the vehicle battery needs to be connected at the time of detection for the purposes of integer 1.6.2, in my view, the answer is Yes. This is clear from the words “when connected” in integer 1.6.2. Further, as a matter of practicality, detection of polarity can only occur when the vehicle battery is connected. This conclusion is supported by the opinion of both experts expressed in the Joint Expert Report, Section A, page 3, lines 86 to 88, where they state:All claims that refer to “configured for detection” or “detection of”, “polarity”, “correct polarity”, “proper polarity” and “improper polarity”, require the vehicle battery to be connected to the jumpstarter connectors to make the polarity determination.