Allied Pumps Pty Ltd v LAA Industries Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 76 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Allied Pumps Pty Ltd v LAA Industries Pty Ltd [2023] FCA 1457

File number(s): NSD 639 of 2021
Judgment of: DOWNES J
Date of judgment: 24 November 2023
Catchwords:

PATENTS – innovation patent – power and control system for a dewatering submersible pump – claim construction – validity – infringement

PATENTS – novelty – prior acts as disclosures –
where commercial hire of systems to customer before priority date – where hired systems were used by customer without restriction – where customer conducted its own testing to determine suitability of systems for its own purposes – where customer was requested to and agreed to provide the results of its tests – whether conduct by customer constituted reasonable trial pursuant to s 24(1)(a) Patents Act 1990 (Cth) and reg 2.2B Patents Regulations 1991 (Cth)

PATENTS – novelty – whether documentary disclosures anticipated the claims – where documentary disclosures were other patents and a manual for a system alleged to have been supplied in 2012 – whether combination of alleged disclosures during discussions more than ten years ago in combination with provision of manual anticipated the claims  

PATENTS – whether priority date should be deferred by reason of lack of disclosure  

PATENTS – whether there was secret use of the invention – whether deliberate concealment needed to be proven to establish secret use

PATENTS – claim of lack of innovative step – task of identifying each variance between prior art and invention as claimed not undertaken – failure to articulate by reference to evidence why that variance does not make a substantial contribution to the working of invention

PATENTS – whether infringement within s 117(2)(b) and s 117(2)(c) of the Patents Act 1990 (Cth)

EVIDENCE – standard of proof where alleged that patent was anticipated by prior acts – discussion of concept of “strict proof” in relation to prior public acts claimed to destroy novelty

EVIDENCE – admissibility of pleadings filed in another proceeding by patentee as evidence of pleaded facts – whether pleaded facts constitute admissions – ss 81, 82 and 87 and clause 6 of Part 2 of the Dictionary of the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth)

Legislation:

Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) ss 59, 81, 82, 87, 88, 136, 140(2)

Patents Act 1990 (Cth) ss 7, 9(a), 13, 18(1A)(b), 18(1A)(d), 24(1)(a), 40(2)(a), 43(2), 43(2A), 117(1), 117(2)(b), 117(2)(c)

Patents Regulations 1991 (Cth) regs 2.2B, 3.12(4), 3.13A(1)(b)(i), 3.13C, 3.13D

Cases cited:

Aktiebolaget Hässle v Alphapharm Pty Ltd (2000) 51 IPR 375; [2000] FCA 1303

Apotex Pty Ltd v Sanofi-Aventis Australia Pty Ltd (2013) 103 IPR 217; [2013] HCA 50

Aristocrat Technologies Australia Pty Ltd v Konami Australia Pty Ltd (2015) 114 IPR 28; [2015] FCA 735

Aspirating IP Ltd v Vision Systems Ltd (2010) 88 IPR 52; [2010] FCA 1061

AstraZeneca AB v Apotex Pty Ltd (2014) 226 FCR 324; [2014] FCAFC 99

AstraZeneca AB v Apotex Pty Ltd (2015) 257 CLR 356; [2015] HCA 30

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v J…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Allied Pumps Pty Ltd v LAA Industries Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] FCA 1457
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Allied Pumps Pty Ltd v LAA Industries Pty Ltd, the Federal Court of Australia was tasked with determining several complex issues surrounding the validity, infringement, and prior disclosure of an innovation patent related to a power and control system for a dewatering submersible pump. The primary dispute centred on whether the patent was valid, had been infringed, and whether prior acts and disclosures rendered the invention non-novel or anticipated the claims. The court had to consider the legal definitions of novelty, inventive step, and infringement under the Patents Act 1990 (Cth) and the relevant regulations.

The court examined whether the actions of the customer, who had commercially hired systems before the priority date and conducted tests to determine their suitability, constituted a reasonable trial as defined under section 24(1)(a) of the Patents Act. It also assessed whether documentary disclosures, including other patents and a manual, anticipated the claims of the patent. Additionally, the court needed to decide if there was secret use of the invention and whether the patent lacked an innovative step. The issue of infringement under sections 117(2)(b) and 117(2)(c) of the Patents Act was also central to the litigation.

The court found that the evidence presented by Allied Pumps, particularly from independent expert Mr Meredith, was more reliable than the documentary evidence submitted by LAA Industries. The court accepted Mr Meredith's evidence that the systems in question did not have the capacity for pressure or level control, which was corroborated by other evidence. The court concluded that the prior acts by the customer did not constitute a reasonable trial that would destroy novelty, and the documentary disclosures did not anticipate the patent claims. The court also determined that there was no secret use of the invention and that the patent did not lack an innovative step.

Ultimately, the court ruled in favour of Allied Pumps, finding that the patent was valid, had not been infringed, and the prior acts and disclosures did not negate its novelty or inventiveness. The final orders of the court included restrictions on the disclosure of the reasons for judgment to maintain confidentiality, with provisions for redactions and subsequent publication of a redacted version.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Pursuant to ss 37AF(1)(b) and 37AG(1)(a) of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth), until further order of the Court, and subject to any restrictions imposed by the Order dated 7 June 2023, access to and disclosure (by publication or otherwise) of the unredacted text of the reasons for judgment delivered today be restricted to the parties and their legal representatives, and those persons to whom access is allowed under the terms of the confidentiality regime agreed by the parties.

2. Nothing in Order 1 or any earlier order of the Court prevents any party from publishing the covering pages of these reasons for judgment up to paragraph 15 of the reasons, including these orders, along with the final paragraph of the reasons and the associate’s certificate.

3. By 4.00 pm AEDT on 4 December 2023, the legal representatives for the parties confer on redactions to be proposed, agree on the proposed redactions, and provide to the chambers of Downes J an agreed form of the reasons for judgment with the proposed redactions highlighted, together with an agreed redacted form of the reasons for judgment that is suitable for publication.

4. The parties are to otherwise confer and provide to the chambers of Downes J an agreed form of order giving effect to the reasons for judgment by 4.00 pm AEDT on 8 December 2023.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

However, that submission is rejected. The evidence of Mr Meredith, who is independent of the parties, was emphatic and generally consistent. His evidence about the requirements of BHP concerning the VSGs supplied to it, even if that evidence was limited to his understanding, carries more weight than the documents relied upon by UON, having regard to his role and the fact that he would likely be made aware of these requirements by BHP. This is especially as no witness was called from BHP to either explain the documents or contradict the evidence of Mr Meredith. Further, Mr Meredith’s evidence was supported by Mr Walters, and was not contradicted by Mr Meys (who could have given evidence about BHP’s requirements post-February 2018 but, without explanation, did not do so). Further, the documentary evidence had various deficiencies, which are identified above. Finally, UON’s GMC Pro Power VSGs were supplied to BHP and were not capable of controlling by reference to all three modes. This latter fact demonstrates that, irrespective of the content of these documents and how they might be construed, BHP did not, in practice, have the requirement which UON submits that it had.13.6.10 Submissions by UON about absence of evidence UON submits that it was “telling” that no evidence was given by any person from Allied Pumps about communications with Mr Meredith or BHP concerning BHP’s intention to use the BHP Category A Systems. However, there are inherent difficulties with this submission. The burden of proof is on UON, not Allied Pumps. Allied Pumps is only required to meet the case which is put against it, which was, in essence, a circumstantial case premised upon a limited assortment of documents with input by Mr Quick (but no-one from BHP) as to their interpretation or usage, as well as evidence of Mr Meys concerning a period in early 2018 when BHP was exploring level control (and absent evidence as to BHP’s requirements as actually implemented post-February 2018). While this evidence was sufficient to shift the evidentiary onus to Allied Pumps, Allied Pumps discharged that onus by calling Mr Meredith and Mr Walters, whose evidence I have accepted for the reasons already explained. There was therefore no necessity for further witnesses to be called from within Allied Pumps.13.7 Whether infringement within the meaning of s 117(2)(b) UON submits that the above documentation provides ample support for a finding that Allied Pumps had reason to believe for the purposes of s 117(2)(b). However, the evidence did not establish that a reasonable person in the position of Allied Pumps would have believed that the BHP Category A Systems would be put to an infringing use by BHP. That is because those systems did not have the capacity to do so (and a reasonable person in the position of Allied Pumps would be familiar with the manner in which the systems operated and would therefore know this). In making this finding, I rely upon and accept the evidence of Mr Meredith, who had direct involvement with the BHP Category A Systems and whose evidence was not contradicted by any other witness. His evidence was that the underlying Allen-Bradley PLC for these systems did not include the logic to facilitate pressure or level control, and that (regardless of what appears on the HMI display) it was and is not possible to change the control of the systems from flow control to pressure or level control. For the reasons explained above, the documentation relied upon by UON was insufficient to cause me to doubt or reject the evidence of Mr Meredith concerning the BHP Category A Systems. Further, Mr Meredith’s evidence as to the capacity of the systems to control on pressure or level was corroborated by Mr Walters, who engaged in factory acceptance testing of the BHP Category A Systems and whose evidence I have also accepted for the reasons explained above.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Without evidence from Mr Hanson which explains his annotations and ticks, it is difficult to determine the meaning to ascribe to the content of this document. For this reason and having regard to its internal inconsistences, as identified above, I am therefore unable to place any weight on it.13.6.7 Quick Start Operation document This is a document entitled “Allied Pumps Variable Speed Generator Quick Start Operation”. In this document, there is a screenshot of the HMI of the BHP Category A System. This document is undated but was provided by Allied Pumps to BHP by at least 1 June 2021. The screenshot as taken from the document, which was annexed to Mr Meredith’s affidavit, is below: It can be seen on the right-hand side of the screen that there are three setpoints: namely level, flow and pressure. There are also three types of control, with the words “not enabled” appearing in brackets after “Level Control Selected” and “Pressure Control Selected”. Mr Quick’s evidence was that the references to Level Control, Flow Control and Pressure Control indicate to him that the HMI has been configured to allow a user to select control based upon either level, flow or pressure, and that the words “(not enabled)” simply show that only one control variable has been selected and enabled. However, this evidence was contradicted by Mr Meredith who created this HMI display and gave evidence that he expected that it had been annotated by Allied Pumps. His evidence was that:[T]he “Level Control Selected (not enabled)” and “Pressure Control Selected (not enabled)” text depicted at section 1.2 of the Quick Start Operation are not selectable by an operator (which is apparent from the fact that they do not appear in a box). That is, they are not buttons. Rather, they are inactive text. The underlying logic for the Allen-Bradley PLC for Allied Pumps’ VSG does not include (and has never included) any programmed logic to facilitate Level or Pressure Control functionality. Regarding “Level Setpoint” and “Pressure Setpoint”, although a value could be entered into the “Level Setpoint” and “Pressure Setpoint” positions on the screen, entering such a value has no effect what so ever [sic] as it is not possible for an operator to select Pressure or Level Control for the Allen-Bradley PLC for Allied Pumps’ VSGs. Under cross-examination, Mr Meredith said that the HMI (or user interface) is standard across all VSGs used by BHP regardless of the supplier; BHP had not reviewed and approved what was displayed on the HMI; the layout was his concept; it was not a requirement of BHP; and when he designed it, he tried to duplicate what was on the SCADA control system. UON did not address this evidence in its submissions or explain why it should not be accepted. UON did, however, submit that the inclusion of the three options featured on the HMI, whether enabled or otherwise, indicates to a viewer of the screenshot of the HMI that there is level, pressure and flow control. It also submits that, as the HMI includes lines to enter level setpoint and an option for level control, this reveals (and would have revealed to a reasonable person in the position of Allied Pumps) that BHP wished to avail itself of this functionality. It submits that the fact that level control is “not enabled” would convey to a reasonable supplier in Allied Pumps’ position that the programming for level control was present but not currently usable.