ICI Chemicals & Polymers Ltd v Lubrizol Corp Inc

Link copied
Case Copied 75 min read

ICI Chemicals & Polymers Ltd v The Lubrizol Corporation Inc
No. NG 190 of 1997
The Lubrizol Corporation Inc v Woolworths Ltd, Austral Refrigeration Pty Limited, Woolworths (Victoria) Pty Limited and Lawrence Refrigeration Pty Limited
No. NG 552 of 1997
[1999] FCA 345
Number of pages - 39
Patent

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

EMMETT J

Patent - revocation - s18(1)(b)(i) Patents Act 1990 - whether claimed invention "novel" - whether anticipation by document published in Australia before priority date - whether general description in prior document exposes elements of invention in the patent - whether anticipation by prior document incorporating another prior document by cross-reference - s18(1)(b)(ii) Patents Act 1990 - whether claimed invention involves "inventive step" - whether notional skilled worker in the field a team - whether claimed invention merely proposal "worth trying" - relevance of attempts by competitors to solve the problem - whether claimed invention merely result of routine trial and error - relevance of commercial success - s18(1)(a) Patents Act 1990 - whether claimed invention a "manner of manufacture" - s40(3) Patents Act 1990 - adequacy of specification - abandonment of some claims - whether specification requires amendment to achieve conformity with remaining claims - s138(3)(d) Patents Act 1990 - false suggestion - infringement

Patents Act 1990 (Cth)

Patents Act 1952 (Cth)

Minnesota Mining & Manufacturing Co. v Beiersdorf (Australia) Pty Ltd (1980) 144 CLR 253, cited

General Tire & Rubber Co v The Firestone Tyre & Rubber Co Ltd [1972] RPC 457, cited

Coopers Animal Health Australia Ltd v Western Stock Distributors Ltd (1986) 6 IPR 545, cited

Wellcome Foundation v VR Laboratories (Aust) Pty Ltd (1981) 148 CLR 262, cited

Advanced Building Systems Pty Ltd v Ramset Fasteners (Aust) Pty Ltd [1998] 19, cited

Weiss v Lufft (1941) 65 CLR 528, considered

SYDNEY, 8-19 February 1999 (hearing), 31 March 1999 (decision)

#DATE 31:3:1999

Appearances

Counsel for ICI Chemicals & Polymers Ltd,

Woolworths Ltd, Austral Refrigeration Pty Ltd,

Woolworths (Vic) Pty Ltd, Lawrence Refrigeration Pty Ltd: D.K. Catterns QC

Solicitor for the above: Blake Dawson Waldron

Counsel for Lubrizol: R.V. Gyles QC; J.T. Gleeson

Solicitor for Lubrizol: Norton Smith & Co

EMMETT J

  1. The Lubrizol Corporation Inc. ("Lubrizol") is the registered proprietor of Australian patent number 638710 ("the Patent"). A copy of the Patent is attached as Schedule 1 to these reasons. The invention which is the subject of the Patent relates to "liquid compositions" said to be useful as refrigeration liquids. ICI Chemicals & Polymers Ltd ("ICI") has brought proceedings under sections 128 and 138 of the Patents Act 1990 ("the 1990 Act") seeking revocation of the Patent and a declaration that threats by Lubrizol of infringement proceedings were unjustified.

2. Lubrizol, on the other hand, has brought proceedings under section 120 of the 1990 Act for injunctions restraining Woolworths Limited ("Woolworths"), Austral Refrigeration Pty Limited ("Austral"), Woolworths (Victoria) Pty Limited ("Woolworths Victoria") and Lawrence Refrigeration Pty Limited…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read ICI Chemicals & Polymers Ltd v Lubrizol Corp Inc and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1999] FCA 345
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Federal Court of Australia dismissed proceedings brought by ICI Chemicals & Polymers Ltd against Lubrizol Corporation Inc seeking revocation of an Australian patent (Patent No. 638710) on the grounds of invalidity. The patent related to "liquid compositions" said to be useful as refrigeration liquids. Lubrizol brought cross-claims against Woolworths Ltd, Austral Refrigeration Pty Limited, Woolworths (Victoria) Pty Limited, and Lawrence Refrigeration Pty Limited for infringement of the patent. The court found that the patent was not anticipated by prior art, involved an inventive step, and met the criteria for a "manner of manufacture" under the Patents Act 1990. However, the court found that the patent did not comply with the requirements of section 40 of the Act, specifically the need for the claims to be fairly based on the matter described in the specification. The court also found that the patent was not obtained by fraud, false suggestion, or misrepresentation. The court concluded that if the patent was valid, there had been infringement by Woolworths, Austral, Woolworths Victoria, and Lawrence. The court directed the parties to consider the outcome and indicate further steps for finalising the proceedings.

Background

Background to the litigation

The Lubrizol Corporation Inc. ("Lubrizol") holds an Australian patent for a liquid composition suitable for use as a refrigeration liquid, specifically with hydrofluorocarbon (HFC) refrigerants like R-134a, in combination with certain synthetic ester lubricants. The invention was developed in response to the need for ozone-friendly refrigerants due to the harmful effects of chlorofluorocarbons (CFCs) and hydrochlorofluorocarbons (HCFCs) on the ozone layer. ICI Chemicals & Polymers Ltd ("ICI") brought proceedings seeking revocation of Lubrizol's patent on several grounds, including lack of novelty, lack of inventive step, and non-compliance with the patent specification. Lubrizol, in turn, sought injunctions against Woolworths Ltd, Austral Refrigeration Pty Limited, Woolworths (Victoria) Pty Limited, and Lawrence Refrigeration Pty Limited for alleged infringement of the patent by using a liquid composition of KLEA refrigerant and EMKARATE lubricant in their refrigeration systems.

The case was heard in the Federal Court of Australia, New South Wales District Registry, General Division. The proceedings were conducted in two parts: the revocation action by ICI against Lubrizol and the infringement action by Lubrizol against Woolworths, Austral, Woolworths Victoria, and Lawrence. The matter was heard over several days in February 1999, with reasons for judgment delivered on March 31, 1999.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the claimed invention in Lubrizol's patent is novel under section 18(1)(b)(i) of the Patents Act 1990.
2. Whether the claimed invention involves an inventive step under section 18(1)(b)(ii) of the Patents Act 1990.
3. Whether the claimed invention is a "manner of manufacture" under section 18(1)(a) of the Patents Act 1990.
4. Whether the complete specification for the patent complies with the requirements of sections 40(2) and 40(3) of the Patents Act 1990.
5. Whether the patent was obtained on a false suggestion or representation under section 138(3)(d) of the Patents Act 1990.

Held
1. The court dismissed ICI Chemicals & Polymers Ltd's application for revocation of the patent on the grounds of novelty, obviousness, usefulness, and false suggestion or representation.
2. The court found that the patent's claims 1 and 4 to 9 were not novel due to the disclosure in the Williamitis Patent, but the remaining claims were found to be novel.
3. The court held that the alleged invention involved an inventive step as it satisfied a long-felt need and was not obvious to a person skilled in the relevant art.
4. The court found that the alleged invention was useful as it improved a vendible product.
5. The court held that the patent did not comply with the requirements of section 40(3) of the Patents Act 1990, as the claims were not fairly based on the matter described in the specification.
6. The court found that there was no false suggestion or representation made in the patent application.
7. The court concluded that if the patent was valid, there had been infringement by Woolworths, Austral, Woolworths Victoria, and Lawrence.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court assessed the validity of the patent by examining each of the grounds for revocation raised by ICI Chemicals & Polymers Ltd. The court found that the alleged invention was not anticipated by the Williamitis Patent, as it only disclosed the use of HCFCs with the described lubricants, not HFCs like R-134a. The court held that the alleged invention involved an inventive step as it satisfied a long-felt need and was not obvious to a person skilled in the relevant art. The court found that the alleged invention was useful as it improved a vendible product. However, the court held that the patent did not comply with the requirements of section 40(3) of the Patents Act 1990, as the claims were not fairly based on the matter described in the specification. The court found that there was no false suggestion or representation made in the patent application. Finally, the court concluded that if the patent was valid, there had been infringement by Woolworths, Austral, Woolworths Victoria, and Lawrence.