Hill & Smith Holdings Plc v Safe Barriers Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 31 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Hill & Smith Holdings PLC v Safe Barriers Pty Ltd [2018] FCA 1882

File number: NSD 1212 of 2018
Judge: ROBERTSON J
Date of judgment: 27 November 2018
Catchwords: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – application for discovery – action for infringement of patent – respondent’s cross-claim – allegation of false suggestion – allegation of inutility – whether proposed discovery irrelevant – whether discovery sought oppressive – whether categories too broad
Legislation:

Patents Act 1990 (Cth) ss 18, 138

Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) rr 20.11, 20.14

Cases cited: Halcon International Inc v Shell Transport and Trading Co Ltd [1979] RPC 459
Date of hearing: 27 November 2018
Registry: New South Wales
Division: General Division
National Practice Area: Intellectual Property
Sub-area: Patents and associated Statutes
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 66
Counsel for Hill & Smith Holdings PLC and Hill & Smith Pty Limited: Mr NR Murray SC with Ms F St John
Solicitor for Hill & Smith Holdings PLC and Hill & Smith Pty Limited: Clayton Utz
Counsel for Safe Barriers Pty Ltd: Mr D Logan QC
Solicitor for Safe Barriers Pty Ltd: Dundas Lawyers

ORDERS

NSD 1212 of 2018
BETWEEN:

HILL & SMITH HOLDINGS PLC

First Applicant

HILL & SMITH PTY LIMITED (ACN 153 144 364)

Second Applicant

AND:

SAFE BARRIERS PTY LTD (ACN 609 345 931)

Respondent

AND BETWEEN:

SAFE BARRIERS PTY LTD (ACN 609 345 931)

Cross-Claimant

AND:

HILL & SMITH HOLDINGS PLC (and another named in the Schedule)

First Cross-Respondent

JUDGE:

ROBERTSON J

DATE OF ORDER:

27 NOVEMBER 2018

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.By 15 February 2019, the applicants give general discovery by providing to the respondent electronic copies of the following documents (except documents over which a claim for privilege is made), limited by the concept of reasonable search in rr 20.14(3)(b) and (c) of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth):

Documents supplied by testing laboratories dated before 17 September 2011 that show whether the applicants’ Zoneguard crash barrier beams did or did not operate so that, in the event of a vehicle impact, the gradient of the impact wall and the inwardly and outwardly stepped deflections assisted in redirecting an impacting vehicle wheel back towards the road away from the barrier.

2.The respondent’s interlocutory application filed on 6 November 2018 be otherwise dismissed.

3.Costs reserved.

4.Liberty to apply on three days’ notice.

Note:    Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

ROBERTSON J:

Introduction

  1. These proceedings concern road safety crash barriers the subject of Australian Patent No. 2007323210 (the 210 Patent) entitled “Crash barrier beam”.  The applicants claim an order restraining the respondent from infringing or threatening to infringe the 210 Patent.  It is claimed that the respondent, by its acts in relation to its range of three temporary road safety barrier products (the Defender Barrier Products), threatened to infringe or has infringed each of the essential integers of, at least, claim 1 of the 210 Patent.

  2. Claim…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hill & Smith Holdings Plc v Safe Barriers Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] FCA 1882
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Federal Court of Australia, Hill & Smith Holdings Plc sought an order for discovery of documents from Safe Barriers Pty Ltd in a patent infringement action. The dispute arose from Safe Barriers’ cross-claim that Hill & Smith’s patent was both false in suggestion and inutility. The primary focus of the case was on whether the proposed discovery was relevant to the issues at hand and whether the categories of documents sought were too broad, potentially oppressive, or irrelevant. The court had to determine if the documents requested aligned with the specific issues of inutility and false suggestion as raised by Safe Barriers, and whether they would aid in resolving the proceeding efficiently and cost-effectively.

The central legal issues revolved around the appropriateness of the discovery application, specifically whether the documents sought were relevant to the substantive issues, and if the categories proposed by Safe Barriers were sufficiently narrow and relevant to facilitate the just resolution of the proceeding. The court examined whether the discovery application could be decided without delving into contested substantive issues of patent law, focusing instead on the procedural requirements outlined in the Federal Court Rules. It had to balance the need for discovery with the principles of fairness and efficiency as per the Federal Court Rules.

The court found that the categories proposed by Safe Barriers were too broad and not sufficiently related to the particular issues of inutility and false suggestion. It rejected the overly general categories proposed by Safe Barriers, such as documents related to testing before a certain date, as these did not directly address the specific technical issues at hand. However, the court did order the discovery of a more limited set of documents that could potentially show how the Zoneguard crash barrier beams operated in redirecting an impacting vehicle wheel back towards the road away from the barrier. This decision was made in accordance with the principles of reasonable search and relevance under the Federal Court Rules.

The court ordered that Hill & Smith Holdings Plc provide specific documents from testing laboratories dated before 17 September 2011, showing how the Zoneguard crash barrier beams operated under certain conditions, by 15 February 2019. The court also dismissed the respondent's interlocutory application and reserved costs, allowing liberty to apply for further orders. This decision highlights the importance of tailoring discovery requests to specific and relevant issues to ensure efficiency and fairness in patent litigation proceedings.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. By 15 February 2019, the applicants give general discovery by providing to the respondent electronic copies of the following documents (except documents over which a claim for privilege is made), limited by the concept of reasonable search in rr 20.14(3)(b) and (c) of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth):

Documents supplied by testing laboratories dated before 17 September 2011 that show whether the applicants’ Zoneguard crash barrier beams did or did not operate so that, in the event of a vehicle impact, the gradient of the impact wall and the inwardly and outwardly stepped deflections assisted in redirecting an impacting vehicle wheel back towards the road away from the barrier.

2. The respondent’s interlocutory application filed on 6 November 2018 be otherwise dismissed.

3. Costs reserved.

4. Liberty to apply on three days’ notice.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

As to the applicants’ evidence of oppression, which I take to be similar in concept to making a reasonable search as provided in r 20.14(3), I would permit the applicants to limit their search if it turns out that the number of documents involved and the ease and cost of retrieving a document show that a reasonable search does not extend to any or all of the documents which I propose to order be discovered. I take this course because of the substantial amendments to the respondent’s proposed categories, as handed up this morning, since the applicants’ evidence was filed. Conclusion and orders I therefore propose to order the applicants give general discovery as follows, by 15 February 2019, limited by the concept of reasonable search in rr 20.14(3)(b) and (c):Documents supplied by testing laboratories dated before 17 September 2011 that show whether the applicants’ Zoneguard crash barrier beams did or did not operate so that, in the event of a vehicle impact, the gradient of the impact wall and the inwardly and outwardly stepped deflections assisted in redirecting an impacting vehicle wheel back towards the road away from the barrier. I will hear the counsel on the precise form of the order and on costs. There will be liberty to apply. Counsel should also confer on a timetable for the filing of evidence in the substantive proceeding.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In oral reply, the respondent distinguished the false suggestion case from the inutility cases so far as concern a claim by result, such as Interlego.Consideration In my opinion, it is not appropriate to decide this application for discovery by reference to disputed and contestable issues of substantive law. I seek to avoid as far as possible claim construction as referable to utility. It is appropriate that the application be tested by reference to r 20.14 of the Federal Court Rules, that is, whether the documents sought are documents:(1) … (a)that are directly relevant to the issues raised by the pleadings or in the affidavits; and(b) of which, after a reasonable search, the party is aware; and(c) that are, or have been, in the party’s control.For the purposes of r (1)(a) the documents must meet at least one of the following criteria, by r 20.14(2):(a) the documents are those on which the party intends to rely;(b) the documents adversely affect the party’s own case;(c) the documents support another party’s case;(d) the documents adversely affect another party’s case.And also for the purposes of r (1)(b), by r 20.14(3):… in making a reasonable search, a party may take into account the following:(a) the nature and complexity of the proceeding;(b) the number of documents involved;(c) the ease and cost of retrieving a document;(d) the significance of any document likely to be found;(e) any other relevant matter. In my view, there is a substantial gap between the categories the respondent seeks and whether those categories will facilitate the just resolution of the proceeding as quickly, inexpensively and efficiently as possible: see r 20.11. I am not persuaded that at this stage of the proceeding and against the background of the evidence on behalf of the applicants of the amount of work that would be required to be done that an order in terms of category 1, as amended, is appropriate. Even paring back that category, it proceeds by reference to documents before 8 November 2013 recording or referring to testing, simulations or analysis, by or on behalf of the applicants, of Zoneguard beams. To my mind this category is far too general. Also I am not persuaded what it is that the items by reference to which the category is limited would or might show referable to the particular issues of inutility and false suggestion. For example, I am not persuaded of the relationship between what a video of crash testing of Zoneguard barriers would or might show and those particular issues. As well, the generality of those barriers which were “assessed to pass by the testing laboratory” is not sufficiently related to those particular issues. These are no more than examples of the lack of fit between the particular issues and category 1. In my view it is insufficient as too general that the documents would show what testing was done. For these reasons I decline to order discovery of category 1. In relation to category 2, despite present misgivings as to how the respondent will be able ultimately to prove the particular issues of inutility and false suggestion by reference to a claimed embodiment of the claim rather than the claim itself, but proceeding on the basis of interlocutory or adjectival, albeit direct, relevance rather than ultimate relevance, I am prepared to order discovery of a more limited category. But I would not proceed by reference to emails and attachments “that record any discussion”. I am prepared to order discovery of documents being documents limited by date showing that Zoneguard crash barrier beams did or did not operate so that, in the event of a vehicle impact, the gradient of the impact wall and the inwardly and outwardly stepped deflections assisted in redirecting an impacting vehicle wheel back towards the road away from the barrier: see claim 1 at page 25 lines 17-19. I take into account the reference to Zoneguard at page 9 of the patent and the references there to figures 1a and 1b.