Insta Image Pty Ltd v KD Kanopy Australasia Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 71 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Insta Image Pty Ltd v KD Kanopy Australasia Pty Ltd [2008] FCAFC 139

PATENTS – obviousness – collapsible canopy framework – introduction of U-shaped mount with non-compressive pin to give stability to frame – claim was for combination of discrete technologies not only for introduction of novel mount with non-compressive pin – history of prior US patents for collapsible canopy frameworks – existence of U-shaped mounts formed part of common general knowledge in Australia.
Held:  the combination was not obvious, having regard to common general knowledge in Australia.

PATENTS – novelty -­ collapsible canopy framework – introduction of U-shaped mount with non-compressive pin to give stability to frame – claim was for combination of discrete technologies not only for introduction of novel mount with non-compressive pin – evidence that earlier collapsible canopy (the Original) was used at motocross and jet-ski races – Original anticipated all claims except one – whether information disclosing the invention had been made “publicly available” as required by s 7(1) of the Patents Act 1990 (Cth) at the race meetings.
Held:  it had.

PATENTS – construction – identifying “the invention, so far as claimed in any claim” for purposes of s 18(1) of the Patents Act 1990 (Cth).

WORDS AND PHRASES – “the invention, so far as claimed in any claim” – “publicly available”.

Patents Act 1990 (Cth) ss 18(1); 7(1), (2), (3); Schedule 1 (“prior art base”, “prior art information”)

Atlantis Corp Pty Ltd v Schindler (1997) 39 IPR 29 cited
Boyce v Morris Motors Ltd (1927) 44 RPC 105 referred to
Re Bristol-Myers Co’s Application [1969] RPC 146 cited
Bristol-Myers Squibb Co v F H Faulding & Co Ltd (2000) 97 FCR 524 cited
British Thomson-Houston Co Ltd v Corona Lamp Works Ltd (1922) 39 RPC 49 cited
Cullen v Welsbach Light Co of Australasia Ltd (1907) 4 CLR 990 cited
Decor Corp Pty Ltd v Dart Industries Inc (1988) 13 IPR 385 cited
Fomento Industrial S.A. v Mentmore Manufacturing Co Ltd [1956] RPC 87 cited
Fresenius Medical Care Australia Pty Ltd v Gambro Pty Ltd (2005) 67 IPR 230 cited
Hill v Evans (1962) 31 LJ CL 456 cited
Humpherson v Syer (1887) 4 RPC 407 cited
Interlego AG v Toltoys Pty Ltd (1973) 130 CLR 461 cited
Jupiters Ltd v Neurizon Pty Ltd (2005) 65 IPR 86 referred to
Kimberly-Clark Australia Pty Ltd v Arico Trading International Pty Ltd (2001) 207 CLR 1 referred to
Lockwood Security Products Pty Ltd v Doric Products Pty Ltd (2005) 68 IPR 459 referred to
Lockwood Security Products Pty Ltd v Doric Products Pty Ltd (No 2) (2007) 72 IPR 447 followed
Merck & Co Inc v Arrow Pharmaceuticals Ltd (2006) 154 FCR 31 cited
Meyers Taylor Pty Ltd v Vicarr Industries Ltd (1997) 137 CLR 228 referred to
Minnesota Mining & Manufacturing Co v Tyco Electronics Pty Ltd (2002) 53 IPR 32 cited Old Digger Pty Ltd v Azuko Pty Ltd (2000) 51 IPR 43 referred to
PLG Research…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Insta Image Pty Ltd v KD Kanopy Australasia Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] FCAFC 139
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Insta Image Pty Ltd v KD Kanopy Australasia Pty Ltd involved an appeal against the findings of patent infringement and validity. The appellants, Insta Image Pty Ltd, challenged the primary judge's decision that their products infringed the patent held by KD Kanopy Australasia Pty Ltd and that the patent was valid. The patent in question was for a "Collapsible Canopy Framework having Captured Scissor Ends with Non-Compressive Pivots." The dispute arose from the appellants' importation and sale of the "Caravan Instant Shelter," which they claimed did not infringe the patent or, if it did, that the respondents were not entitled to damages.

The central legal issues before the court were the questions of novelty and inventive step of the claimed invention. The appellants argued that the invention was not novel, as prior art demonstrated the use of similar structures, and it lacked an inventive step because it was an obvious modification of existing technology. The respondents, KD Kanopy Australasia Pty Ltd, maintained that the invention was both novel and involved an inventive step, and that the appellants' products infringed the patent.

In considering the appeal, the court examined the prior art, including earlier patents and the use of a collapsible canopy by Mr. McKinnon, to determine whether the invention was novel. The court held that the prior art did not anticipate the invention as it did not include all the essential features of the claimed invention, particularly the two-sided socket described in the patent. Regarding the inventive step, the court concluded that the invention, while incorporating known elements, represented a non-obvious combination of discrete technologies in a specific geometrical arrangement, thus involving an inventive step.

The court ultimately allowed the appeal, setting aside the primary judge's findings of infringement and invalidity regarding certain claims of the patent. The patent was revoked in relation to specific claims, but the court left open the possibility of further consideration regarding other claims and the associated legal remedies. The parties were directed to submit further written arguments on these remaining issues, including the potential infringement of a specific patent claim and the allocation of costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal be allowed.

2. The orders made on 3 and 24 April 2007 in proceeding QUD 18 of 2004 be set aside, except order 7 of 24 April 2007.

3. Australian Patent No 656757 be revoked in relation to claims 1, 2, 8-13 and 15-23.

4. The parties provide written submissions as to the appropriate orders to be made:

(a) in relation to allegation of infringement of claim 14 of the Patent; and

(b) as to costs at first instance and on appeal.

by 11 August 2008.

Background

Background to the litigation

The only issues the subject of the appeal were those involved in the appellants’ contention that the claimed invention was not novel and lacked an inventive step.BACKGROUND The title of the Patent was “Collapsible Canopy Framework having Captured Scissor Ends with Non-Compressive Pivots”. The priority date was 4 January 1991. The alleged infringements involved two versions of a product called “Caravan Instant Shelter” which the appellants imported into and sold in Australia. The inventor was James Lynch (deceased). By an assignment agreement dated 19 October 2001 executed by Mr Lynch’s personal representative, the Patent was assigned to K D Canopy Inc. From about September 2000, one or more of the appellants imported and sold the first version of the Caravan Instant Shelter. A later version was imported and sold from about May 2002. The appellants admitted that the earlier version had all of the essential features of, and might infringe, claims of the Patent, but denied that the later version had all of those features. They contended that to the extent that there had been any infringement, there was no liability to the first, second and fourth respondents because those respondents were not exclusive licensees. That aspect of the appellants’ defence depended on the terms of a Distribution Agreement entered into between K D Canopy Australasia, Mr Dand and K D Canopy Inc on 24 December 1997, and was of no concern on the appeal. Other issues at trial that were of no concern on the appeal were the appellants’ contentions that the claims the subject of the proceeding were not fairly based on the specification and lacked clarity.THE PATENT The title of the Patent was as noted at [7] above. Under the heading “Related Patents” the specification states that the “present application” is related to the structure of the inventions disclosed in three “US patents”. In the case of each of them, the inventor was the same James P Lynch. They were:US Patent No 4,641,676 dated 10 February 1987 (the earliest Lynch patent)US Patent No 4,779,635 dated 25 October 1988 (this has been referred to as “Lynch 3”)US Patent No 4,947,884 dated 14 August 1990 (this has been referred to as “Lynch 2”).Elsewhere in the specification there is reference to the following further patent in respect of which Mr Lynch was also the inventor:US Patent No 4,885,891 dated 12 December 1989 (this has been referred to as “Lynch 1”).The nomenclature “Lynch 1”, “Lynch 2” and “Lynch 3” derives from the appellants’ Particulars of Invalidity. It is unfortunate that the nomenclature does not reflect a chronological sequence and that the earliest Lynch patent does not form part of the numbered series (because it was not relied on as an anticipation). Her Honour used the nomenclature above and we will do likewise. The appellants rely heavily on the specification in support of their submission that the primary Judge erred by failing to appreciate that the invention was “a specific improvement to known prior art collapsible canopies, namely “novel mounts” with parallel facing side walls and non-compressive pins”. Her Honour, however, considered that the invention could not be so narrowly defined. She considered that the invention was not simply the introduction of the U-shaped mounts with parallel facing side walls for the purpose of giving increased strength and stability to a known collapsible canopy structure. Rather, she characterised the invention as a total combination of discrete technologies, of which the mounts and pins were but one (or two), in a particular geometrical arrangement.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

LINDGREN, BENNETT AND LOGAN JJ
The Patent was granted under the Act before it was amended by the Patents Amendment Act 2001 (Cth). The amendments relating to inventive step and novelty were contained in Pt 1 of Sch 1 to that Act and commenced on 1 April 2002. They applied in relation to patents for which the complete application was made on or after that date and to the making of complete applications for patents on or after that date. Accordingly, we will refer to the relevant provisions of the Act as they existed prior to the amendments.THE PRIMARY JUDGE’S REASONS FOR JUDGMENT In her reasons, the primary Judge addressed the issue of novelty before that of obviousness. Although we address them in the opposite sequence, we will follow the primary Judge’s sequence for the purpose of giving an account of her Honour’s reasons. Novelty Her Honour noted that the question whether an invention is novel requires comparison with the prior art base, citing ss 18(1) and 7(1) of the Act (at [54]). The appellants pleaded two instances of prior use in Australia before the priority date of 4 January 1991: the use of a collapsible canopy designed by Mr McKinnon (referred to by Mr McKinnon and her Honour as the Original canopy), and the commercial sale and use of collapsible canopies under the trademark “Quikshade” (the Quikshade canopy) by a company with which Mr McKinnon and his father were associated, Summer Craft Blind & Awning Company Pty Ltd. The appellants did not rely on the Quikshade canopy as an anticipation because it did not employ a two-sided socket such as that described in the Patent. The appellants contended before her Honour that the use of the Original included its use by Mr McKinnon at public events such as motocross races and jet-ski races (at [54]). Her Honour observed that s 7(1) provided that prior art information made “publicly available” through the doing of a single act “may be used for the comparison required in connection with novelty” (at [56]). Her Honour continued that in the present case, the information conveyed by Mr McKinnon’s Original must have been made available to any one member of the public in a way that left that person free, in law and equity, to use the information, citing Stanway Oyster Cylinders Pty Ltd v Marks (1996) FCR 577 (Stanway Oyster). The primary Judge discussed the Lynch patents and the “Lyon patent” (being US Patent No 402,755 dated 7 May 1889 issued to G H Lyon and entitled “Expansible Frame”), and concluded, applying the reverse infringement test (see Meyers Taylor Pty Ltd v Vicarr Industries Ltd (1997) 137 CLR 228 at 235), that none of the inventions the subject of them would have infringed the Patent and therefore that they did not anticipate the invention the subject of the Patent (at [57]-[63]). Turning to the Original, her Honour noted that from 1984 Mr McKinnon had made a number of prototypes of a collapsible canopy with four upright metal posts and scissor trusses between adjacent posts, as a shelter for his equipment and tools in connection with his involvement in motocross and jet-ski racing events (at [64]). There were no copies of the Original in existence and the only photographs said to be of it did not show how the scissor assembly was attached to the uprights.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: LINDGREN, BENNETT AND LOGAN JJ

In relation to the disclosure to Mr Soward, the respondents submit that the reference to Mr Forster (at [72]) of her Honour’s reasons) instead of to Mr Soward, does not amount to appealable error. They contend that the appellants suffered no disadvantage by the allegation of disclosure being dealt with as though it applied to Mr Forster rather than Mr Soward because Mr Forster was, on the evidence, more familiar with the Original than Mr Soward was. Moreover, the appellants submit, the finding that obligations of confidence attached to knowledge of the Original must apply to Mr Soward as much as it did to Mr Forster.CONSIDERATIONObviousnessThe provisions of the Act relating to obviousness Section 18(1) of the Act provided, relevantly, that an invention is a patentable invention for the purposes of a standard patent if the invention “so far as claimed in any claim” (our emphasis):(b)when compared with the prior art base as it existed prior to the priority date of that claim:(i) ...(ii) involves an inventive step. The word “invention” was defined in Schedule 1 to mean any manner of new manufacture within s 6 of the Statute of Monopolies, and to include an alleged invention. It will be necessary below to address the question what was the invention so far as claimed in the claims of the present Patent. Neither the expression “inventive step” nor the word “inventive” was defined in the Act. However, s 7(2) and (3) of the Act provided:(2) For the purposes of this Act, an invention is to be taken to involve an inventive step when compared with the prior art base unless the invention would have been obvious to a person skilled in the relevant art in the light of the common general knowledge as it existed in the patent area before the priority date of the relevant claim, whether that knowledge is considered separately or together with either of the kinds of information mentioned in subsection (3), each of which must be considered separately.(3) For the purposes of subsection (2), the kinds of information are:(a)prior art information made publicly available in a single document or through doing a single act; and(b)prior art information made publicly available in 2 or more related documents, or through doing 2 or more related acts, if the relationship between the documents or acts is such that a person skilled in the relevant art in the patent area would treat them as a single source of that information;being information that the skilled person mentioned in subsection (2) could, before the priority date of the relevant claim, be reasonably expected to have ascertained, understood and regarded as relevant to work in the relevant art in the patent area. The expression “prior art information” was defined in Schedule 1 to mean:(a) ...(b)for the purposes of subsection 7(3) – information that is part of the prior art base in relation to deciding whether an invention does or does not involve an inventive step. The expression “prior art base” was defined in Schedule 1 as follows:(a)in relation to deciding whether an invention does or does not involve an inventive step:(i)information in a document, being a document publicly available anywhere in the patent area; and(ii)information made publicly available through doing an act anywhere in the patent area; and(iii)where the invention is the subject of a standard patent or an application for a standard patent – information in a document publicly available outside the patent area; ...The expression “patent area” was also defined in Schedule 1. For convenience, the expression may be understood to refer to “Australia”.