Australian Mud Company Pty Ltd v Coretell Pty Ltd (No 4)

Link copied
Case Copied 78 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Australian Mud Company Pty Ltd v Coretell Pty Ltd (No 4) [2015] FCA 1372

Citation: Australian Mud Company Pty Ltd v Coretell Pty Ltd (No 4) [2015] FCA 1372
Parties: AUSTRALIAN MUD COMPANY PTY LTD ACN 009 283 416 and REFLEX INSTRUMENTS ASIA PACIFIC PTY LTD ACN 124 204 191 v CORETELL PTY LTD ACN 119 188 493, MINCREST HOLDINGS PTY LTD ACN 068 672 471 (TRADING AS CAMTEQ INSTRUMENTS), NICKY KLEYN and KLEYN INVESTMENTS PTY LTD ACN 118 967 687 (TRADING AS CAMTEQ INTERNATIONAL SERVICES)
File number: NSD 2082 of 2011
Judge: MCKERRACHER J
Date of judgment: 4 December 2015
Catchwords:

PATENTS – innovation patents – system and method patents for the orientation of core samples extracted from the ground in connection with geological surveying and other drilling operations – construction of the claims – whether the claims are directed to orientation of core samples in the context of mineral exploration which involves hard rock formations where there is unlikely to be fractured rock or to petroleum exploration which involves soft, fractured or brittle rock – whether the patents are confined in their scope to a system and method carried out by a ‘unitary’ electronic device or embrace a ‘two part’ device – whether the claims require that the recording of time at which the core sample is detached is a separate and discrete action removed in time from the ‘inputting’ of the time – whether an essential integer of the applicants’ tool is that the core sample be ‘held in fixed relation to’ the inner tube at the time of detachment from the body of material – whether the integer ‘indication of the orientation’ in the claims is not present in the respondents’ tool in the ‘real time roll’ method of display

PATENTS – infringement – whether the respondents’ tools include the features of each of the claims of the system and method patent – liability of each of the respondents for infringement – direct infringement – whether the corporate respondents have infringed the patents by making, selling, suppling or otherwise disposing of, or offering for those purposes, the respondents’ tools – indirect infringement – whether the corporate respondents have authorised, procured, induced or joined in a common design with persons to whom the respondents’ tools have been supplied to use the tools, and those persons have so used the respondents’ tools – joint tortfeasorship – whether the second and fourth respondents authorised, procured or induced, or joined in a common design with the first respondent to do the acts alleged to amount to infringement – whether the third respondent authorised, procured or induced or joined in a common design with the corporate respondents to do the acts alleged to amount to infringement – whether the third respondent was directly and personally involved in the corporate respondents’ activities alleged to amount to infringement – innocent infringement – whether the respondents were not aware or had no reason to believe that a patent for the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Mud Company Pty Ltd v Coretell Pty Ltd (No 4) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] FCA 1372
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Australian Mud Company Pty Ltd v Coretell Pty Ltd (No 4) concerns a dispute over the validity and infringement of system and method patents related to the orientation of core samples extracted from the ground, which is crucial for geological surveying and drilling operations. The patents in question pertain to a device and method for indicating the orientation of a core sample relative to the material from which it was extracted. The dispute involves several legal issues, including the construction of the patent claims, the scope of the invention, and whether the claims are novel, involve an innovative step, and are useful. Additionally, the court had to determine if the respondents had directly or indirectly infringed the patents and whether the applicants were entitled to relief for infringement, particularly if the infringing activities occurred outside Australia. The applicants also sought additional damages for infringement.

The court's reasoning was thorough, focusing on the construction of the patent claims and comparing them with the background art and the respondents' tools. The court considered whether the respondents' tools incorporated the features of the claims and whether the applicants' patents were valid. The analysis included an examination of the novelty, innovative step, and utility of the inventions, as well as the potential for prior use or disclosure that could affect the patents' validity. The court also deliberated on the question of direct and indirect infringement, including the liability of the respondents for infringement and whether they were aware of the patents or the potential infringement. Furthermore, the court addressed the applicants' entitlement to relief for infringement activities occurring outside Australia and whether they could claim additional damages.

The court concluded that the applicants' patents were valid and had been infringed by the respondents. The claims were properly construed and the respondents' tools did include the features of the claims. The court found that the applicants were entitled to relief for the infringement activities and that the infringement occurred both directly and indirectly. The court also held that the applicants were entitled to additional damages for patent infringement. Consequently, the court made orders requiring the applicants to file and serve a minute of orders reflecting these reasons, allowing the respondents to file any responsive material, and scheduling a further directions hearing to address the making of orders consequent upon these reasons and to provide directions for the future conduct of the proceeding.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The Applicants file and serve a minute of orders reflecting these reasons within 30 days.

2. The Respondents file any responsive material within a further 21 days.

3. A further directions hearing be scheduled in late February 2016 to make and/or program the making of orders consequent upon these reasons and directions as to the future conduct of the proceeding.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

The System Patent explains that the field of the invention relates to an orientation device, which is used for providing an indication of the orientation of a core sample relative to a body of material from which the core has been extracted, and also to a method of core sample orientation identification.2.1 Background art There is a brief section dealing with ‘Background Art’, which explains the need for core sampling in geological surveying operations and the fact that core samples are obtained through core drilling operations. Those operations, it is said, are typically conducted with a core drill comprising outer and inner tube assemblies. A cutting head is attached to the outer tube assembly so that rotational torque applied to the outer tube assembly is transmitted to the cutting head. A core is generated during the drilling operation, with the core progressively extending along the inner tube assembly as drilling progresses. When a core sample is acquired, the core within the inner tube assembly is fractured. The inner tube assembly and the fractured core sample contained in the inner tube are then retrieved from within the drill hole, typically by way of a retrieval cable lowered down the drill hole. Once the inner tube assembly has been brought to the ground surface, the core sample can be removed and subjected to the necessary analysis. In discussing the background art, the System Patent explains that typically core drilling operations are performed at an angle to the vertical because it is desirable, for analysis purposes, to have an indication of the orientation of the core sample relative to the ground from which it was extracted. It is therefore important there be some means of identifying the orientation of the core sample relative to the ground prior to it having been brought to the surface. So, the System Patent explains that core orientation devices have been used to provide an indication of the orientation of the core sample. The System Patent explains that a common way of obtaining an indication of the orientation of a core sample is through the use of an orientation spear comprising a marker, such as a crayon projecting from one end of a thin steel shank, the other end of which is attached to a wire line (Spear Method). The spear is then lowered down the drill hole prior to the inner tube assembly being introduced. The marker on the orientation spear strikes the facing surface of material from which the core is to be generated, leaving a mark on it. That mark is on the lower side of the drill hole because of the operation of gravity. The inner tube assembly is then introduced into the outer tube assembly in the drill hole. As drilling proceeds, a core sample is generated within the inner tube assembly. The core sample so generated continues to carry the mark which was previously applied. Upon completion of the core drilling run and retrieval of the core sample, the mark gives an indication of the orientation of the core sample at the time it was in the ground. In addition to this method, there are other mechanical core orientation devices for marking a core sample prior to its extraction from the drill hole. Those devices are typically adapted to be incorporated in the inner tube assembly for marking the core. 2.2 Disclosure of the invention

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The specification and claims must be construed in light of the common general knowledge of a worker in the field before the priority date. Traditionally, such a person (or persons) come within the description of a hypothetical, non-inventive worker in the relevant field of technology in Australia, who is equipped with the common general knowledge in the art: Minnesota Mining and Manufacturing Company v Beiersdorf (Australia) Limited (1980) 144 CLR 253. 6. AN OVERVIEW OF THE ORAL EVIDENCE As will be apparent, I will address the applicants’ case first and, secondly, Coretell’s cross-claim. This accords with the order in which the cases were presented. Both cases were put very strenuously. There were, in some instances, strong credit attacks in respect of various witnesses. The respondents, through Coretell, put numerous defence and cross-claim allegations against the applicants’ case or as senior counsel for the applicants described it, ‘every imaginable defence’. The applicants’ case was, by comparison, relatively focused. Many rulings were made in the course of the trial on objections. The rulings did not warrant separate recording in these reasons, with the possible exception only of one ruling, and one anticipated ruling, which I have discussed in Appendix B to these reasons. I propose to say something now of the role played by various witnesses in connection with the issues in the case and the extent to which I regarded the evidence of those witnesses, in a general sense, as assisting the case advanced by the party calling the witness. It should be emphasised that I am presently dealing with general observations on some of the more important witnesses. More detailed attention to the evidence of those and other witnesses appears topic by topic. 6.1 Infringement Insofar as infringement was concerned, the applicants called Dr Kepic as an independent expert. Dr Kepic is an Associate Professor of the Department of Exploration Geophysics at Curtin University, Western Australia. He, along with virtually all witnesses in the case, has provided one or more witness statements or affidavits on which he was examined and cross-examined. Dr Kepic has substantial practical and academic experience in the exploration drilling industry, including direct experience with core sampling operations, although he had not himself been involved in the operation of core orientation tools at an operational drilling rig. Dr Kepic gave evidence relevant to the construction of the claims of the Patents and the features of the respondents’ tools. I accepted the evidence of Dr Kepic, including concessions that he made which were potentially of assistance to the respondents. He has practical and academic experience in the exploration industry, including experience in dealing with core samples. Dr Kepic was well placed to give evidence on the Patents from the perspective of a person skilled in the art. By that expression, I mean a person with a ‘practical interest in the subject matter of the invention’: see, for example, Root Quality Pty Ltd v Root Control Technologies Pty Ltd (2000) 49 IPR 225 per Finkelstein J (at [40] and [46]). The relevant subject matter for present purposes in which a practical interest is required is the subject matter of the techniques and technology used in core sample orientation. Dr Kepic has considerable experience in the hard rock exploration industry. He designed and operated bore hole survey instruments from 1997 to 2002. Although he has not, himself, been an operator of core orientation tools at an operational drilling rig, nevertheless, his knowledge of the technology was substantial. During his professional duties at Australian mining sites, he has been involved in inspecting recovered drill core and making measurements of the core immediately after the drilling sequence. Only qualified drillers are permitted to use core orientation tools and other drilling equipment, so it is unsurprising that Dr Kepic has not operated a drill himself.

Decision

Reasons for decision

These claims by Coretell cannot succeed in light of the conclusion that I have reached in favour of the applicants on infringement. 9. CONCLUSION It has been agreed that the granting of any relief, and it will be in favour of the applicants only, should be deferred until after delivery of these reasons. It should be apparent from the foregoing, however, that I have found that the Patents are valid and that they have been infringed. Obviously, the consequences of those conclusions will require consideration. The cross-claim will be dismissed. Other questions, such as post-expiry injunctions can be the subject of specific submissions. On the basis for the foregoing, I make the following orders:1.The Applicants file and serve a minute of orders reflecting these reasons within 30 days.2.The Respondents file any responsive material within a further 21 days.3.A further directions hearing be scheduled in late February 2016 to make and/or program the making of orders consequent upon these reasons and directions as to the future conduct of the proceeding.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

I note that this approach appears to be consistent with the views expressed by Dowsett J in Grove Hill when considering authorities relevant to the onus of establishing secret use (at [214]-[220]). His Honour concluded in the following terms (at [221]):… Whilst there may have been an evidential onus upon the [patentee] to raise the issue of reasonable trial or experiment, and perhaps even to address that issue in so far as it lay within its knowledge, it did so by calling Mr Mansur to give relevant evidence. In the end, however, the onus remained upon the [party alleging secret use] to satisfy the Court that there had been a disqualifying secret use, having regard to the combined operation of ss 9 and 18. Proof of use which may have been for the purpose of trial or experiment only would not have discharged that onus. It is worth observing that in virtually all cases, the invention in question will have been secretly used for necessary experimental and/or trial purposes. It cannot have been intended that in proceedings for revocation, the inventor should be put to proof of the reasonableness of such use simply because the applicant for revocation alleges disqualifying secret use. Such an outcome, if intended, would surely have been directly addressed.(emphasis added) Importantly, his Honour observed in that passage that proof of use which may have been for the purpose of trial or experiment only by the party alleging secret use would not have discharged the onus of proving secret use. I followed that approach in Bradken (at [366]). It is necessary then to consider the meaning of the matters which are ‘not to be taken as secret use’, including s 9(a) of the Act which is extracted above. In particular, the meaning of the expression ‘… for the purpose of reasonable trial or experiment only’. The principles relevant to what constitutes ‘reasonable trial or experiment only’ were considered in Grove Hill and Bradken. The view taken by Justice Dowsett in Grove Hill (at [229]) was that any collateral commercial advantage from ‘field trials’ was irrelevant if the true purpose of the use was for trial, and the trial was necessary. In Bradken, I took the view (at [359]-[360]) that the word ‘only’ in s 9(a) of the Act did not exclude the anticipation of any ultimate commercial benefit through the use in question, as that could be expected to be theoretically present in any case. The approach taken in Bradken was intended to accord with the approach of Dowsett J in Grove Hill. In my view, the state of the law is that the concept of ‘reasonable trial and experiment’ itself does not preclude that such trial and experiment be conducted in a circumstance which has in mind an ultimate commercial benefit. The word ‘only’ must be read in this light, otherwise almost all trial and experiment would be excluded. To the contrary, it is not intended under the Act that any and all commercial considerations be removed from ‘reasonable trial and experiment’. This would be quite unrealistic and unworkable.