Lockwood Security Products Pty Ltd v Doric Products Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 69 min read

HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA

GLEESON CJ,
McHUGH, GUMMOW, HAYNE AND HEYDON JJ

LOCKWOOD SECURITY PRODUCTS PTY LTD  APPELLANT

AND

DORIC PRODUCTS PTY LTD  RESPONDENT

Lockwood Security Products Pty Ltd v Doric Products Pty Ltd

[2004] HCA 58

18 November 2004
S628/2003

ORDER

UPON the appellant by its counsel undertaking to the Court in writing forthwith to proffer to the Federal Court of Australia, for the period of the continuation of the stay provided in order 5 of these orders, the following undertakings:

(a)to prosecute the proceedings in the Federal Court expeditiously;

(b)forthwith to serve on the Commissioner of Patents a copy of this order with a request that particulars of this order be registered in accordance with s 187 of the Patents Act 1990 (Cth);

(c)not to threaten any person with proceedings for infringement of claims 1-32 of Patent No 702534 ("the Patent");

(d)not to seek to amend any claims of the Patent otherwise than in the course of or in connection with the proceedings in the Federal Court;

THE COURT ORDERS THAT

1.The appeal is allowed with costs.

2.Orders 1 and 2 made by the Full Court of the Federal Court on 7 March 2003 are set aside.

3.It is declared that claims 1-32 of the Patent are fairly based on matters described in the complete specification.

4.The matter is remitted to a Full Court of the Federal Court for the determination of the remaining issues on the appeal to that Court and to make such further orders as are necessary and appropriate, including orders disposing of the costs of the appeal to that Court and the proceedings before Hely J and disposing of any application to amend the Patent.

5.The stay the subject of the orders of the Court made on 27 March 2003 and 23 December 2003 continue until the determination of the proceedings remitted to the Full Court of the Federal Court or further order of the Federal Court.

On appeal from the Federal Court of Australia

Representation:

A J L Bannon SC with C Dimitriadis for the appellant (instructed by Phillips Ormonde & Fitzpatrick)

D K Catterns QC with S J Goddard for the respondent (instructed by Spruson & Ferguson)

Notice:  This copy of the Court's Reasons for Judgment is subject to formal revision prior to publication in the Commonwealth Law Reports.

CATCHWORDS

Lockwood Security Products Pty Ltd v Doric Products Pty Ltd

Patents – Validity – Fair basing of claims – Patent for a door lock – Specification included a consistory clause and described a preferred embodiment – Central claim essentially repeated consistory clause – Whether claim was "fairly based" on the matter described in the specification within s 40(3) of the Patents Act 1990 (Cth) or travelled beyond it – Whether test of fair basing involves consideration of "merit", "inventive step", "technical contribution to the art" or general "fairness" – Whether grounds of invalidity under Patents Act must be kept distinct.

Words and phrases – "consistory clause", "fairly based", "fair basing", "inventive step",…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Lockwood Security Products Pty Ltd v Doric Products Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2004] HCA 58
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The High Court of Australia considered an appeal concerning a patent for a door lock. The parties were Lockwood Security Products Pty Ltd (the patentee) and Doric Products Pty Ltd. Doric had commenced proceedings alleging unjustified threats of patent infringement, and Lockwood cross-claimed for infringement. Doric also sought revocation of the patent on several grounds, including that the claims were not fairly based on the specification.

The central legal issue before the High Court was whether claims 1-32 of the patent were "fairly based" on the matter described in the complete specification, as required by s 40(3) of the Patents Act 1990 (Cth). This involved determining the correct test for "fair basing" and whether it should incorporate considerations of novelty, inventive step, or technical contribution to the art, or if it was a distinct ground of invalidity.

The High Court held that the grounds of invalidity under s 18 of the Act (relating to novelty and inventive step) are conceptually distinct from the requirements of s 40 (relating to the specification and claims). The Court reasoned that s 40 deals with the form and content of the specification and claims, rather than the inherent patentability of the invention. Therefore, considerations of inventiveness or technical merit are not relevant to the question of fair basing. The Court concluded that the trial judge had erred in finding that the claims were not fairly based on the specification.

The appeal was allowed, and it was declared that claims 1-32 of the patent were fairly based on the matters described in the complete specification. The matter was remitted to the Federal Court for determination of the remaining issues on appeal, including costs and any application to amend the patent.

Orders

Orders of the court

UPON the appellant by its counsel undertaking to the Court in writing forthwith to proffer to the Federal Court of Australia, for the period of the continuation of the stay provided in order 5 of these orders, the following undertakings:

(a) to prosecute the proceedings in the Federal Court expeditiously;

(b) forthwith to serve on the Commissioner of Patents a copy of this order with a request that particulars of this order be registered in accordance with s 187 of the Patents Act 1990 (Cth);

(c) not to threaten any person with proceedings for infringement of claims 1-32 of Patent No 702534 ("the Patent");

(d) not to seek to amend any claims of the Patent otherwise than in the course of or in connection with the proceedings in the Federal Court;

THE COURT ORDERS THAT

1. The appeal is allowed with costs.

2. Orders 1 and 2 made by the Full Court of the Federal Court on 7 March 2003 are set aside.

3. It is declared that claims 1-32 of the Patent are fairly based on matters described in the complete specification.

4. The matter is remitted to a Full Court of the Federal Court for the determination of the remaining issues on the appeal to that Court and to make such further orders as are necessary and appropriate, including orders disposing of the costs of the appeal to that Court and the proceedings before Hely J and disposing of any application to amend the Patent.

5. The stay the subject of the orders of the Court made on 27 March 2003 and 23 December 2003 continue until the determination of the proceedings remitted to the Full Court of the Federal Court or further order of the Federal Court.

Background

Background to the litigation

The crucial difference between the parties was that while the Patentee said that the invention was described in the consistory clause, Doric said that it was described by reference to the drawings thus:"Lock release means is provided to enable the lever 31 to be moved out of blocking engagement with the cam projection 40. In the particular arrangement shown, the lock release means 17 is arranged to have direct influence on the cam retainer means, and it is preferred that such influence is achieved through a rotatable camming member 42 which forms part of the release means 17 and is connected to the outside lock 10 so as to rotate in response to rotation of the lock barrel 12. As shown by Figure 11, that connection may include a drive bar 43 of non-circular cross-sectional shape which engages at one end within a slot 44 in an end of the barrel 10, and engages at its other end in a rectangular aperture 45 formed through the camming member 42.As best seen in Figures 4, 6 and 8, the camming member 42 is arranged to overlie the lever 31 at the side of that lever remote from the cam 22. A camming lug 46 provided on the member 42 has a sloping cam face 47 which is adapted to engage against an upstanding portion 48 of the lever 31 which projects above the plate 36, as shown in Figures 4, 6 and 8, when the lever 31 is in the cam retaining position. Rotation of the member 42 caused through operation of the lock 10, results in coaction between the cam face 47 and the lever portion 48 such that the lever 31 is progressively forced downwards against the action of the spring 41 towards the position shown in Figure 8." (Emphasis added.)Below, that passage will be referred to as "the invention urged by Doric". Doric contended that while claim 1 claimed any form of lock release means, the specification described only one form. The background of the appeal Commencement of proceedings. Doric commenced proceedings in the Federal Court of Australia pursuant to s 128 of the Act. It alleged that the Patentee had made unjustified threats of proceedings for infringement of the Patent against it and its two distributors. The Patentee cross-claimed for infringement of claims 1-8, 12-15, 17, 20, 22, 23 and 30-32. Doric in turn cross-claimed against the Patentee seeking revocation of the Patent on various grounds. These were that the alleged invention was not novel, contrary to s 18(1)(b)(i) of the Act; that the alleged invention was obvious and involved no inventive step, contrary to s 18(1)(b)(ii) of the Act; that the alleged invention was not useful, contrary to s 18(1)(c) of the Act; that the specification did not fully describe the invention claimed, contrary to s 40(2)(a) of the Act; that certain of the claims were not clear, or not clear and succinct, contrary to s 40(3) of the Act; and that none of the claims were fairly based on the matter described in the specification, contrary to s 40(3) of the Act. The conclusions of the trial judge. After a 10 day trial, Hely J dealt with the many issues arising out of these complex controversies in a chiselled, economical and speedily delivered judgment. He found that the manufacture and sale of Doric's products had infringed claims 1-6, 12-15, 20 and 30-32[4], but not claims 7, 8, 17, 22 and 23[5]. He rejected all of Doric's attacks on validity save two: he found that claims 1-32 were not fairly based on the matter described in the specification[6], and he found that claims 1-6, 12, 31 and 32 were not novel[7]. He made an order revoking claims 1-32 of the Patent. [4]Doric Products Pty Ltd v Lockwood Security Products Pty Ltd (2001) 192 ALR 306 at 317 [41], 325 [92], 326 [100] and 327 [107].[5]Doric Products Pty Ltd v Lockwood Security Products Pty Ltd (2001) 192 ALR 306 at 324 [84], 325 [86], 326 [98] and [103], and 327 [105]. [6]Doric Products Pty Ltd v Lockwood Security Products Pty Ltd (2001) 192 ALR 306 at 348 [236].[7]Doric Products Pty Ltd v Lockwood Security Products Pty Ltd (2001) 192 ALR 306 at 329 [124] and 330 [128]-[129].

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the central claim of the patent is "fairly based" on the matter described in the specification within the meaning of s 40(3) of the Patents Act 1990 (Cth).
2. If the test for "fair basing" involves consideration of the "merit", "inventive step", "technical contribution to the art" or general "fairness".
3. Whether the grounds of invalidity under the Patents Act must be kept distinct, and if reasoning relevant to one ground of invalidity can be employed in considering another.
4. Whether the consistory clause alone, or the consistory clause in conjunction with the drawings, fully describes the invention as required by s 40(2)(a) of the Patents Act 1990 (Cth).
5. Whether the specification fully describes the invention claimed, particularly in relation to the form of the lock release means.
6. Whether the central claim of the patent essentially repeats the consistory clause, and if so, whether this impacts the "fair basing" of the claim.

Held
1. The court concluded that the central claim of the patent is "fairly based" on the matter described in the specification within the meaning of s 40(3) of the Patents Act 1990 (Cth), and thus allowed the appeal on this point.
2. The court concluded that the test for "fair basing" does not involve consideration of the "merit", "inventive step", "technical contribution to the art" or general "fairness".
3. The court concluded that the grounds of invalidity under the Patents Act must be kept distinct, and that reasoning relevant to one ground of invalidity cannot be employed in considering another.
4. The court concluded that the consistory clause alone, in conjunction with the drawings, fully describes the invention as required by s 40(2)(a) of the Patents Act 1990 (Cth).
5. The court concluded that the specification does not fully describe the invention claimed, particularly in relation to the form of the lock release means.
6. The court concluded that the central claim of the patent essentially repeats the consistory clause, but this does not impact the "fair basing" of the claim.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

It is convenient first to discuss some aspects of s 40(3), then to analyse the reasoning of the courts below, and then to examine the reasons why Doric's arguments, so far as they differ from that reasoning, must be rejected. The construction of s 40(3): separate consideration of each ground of invalidity The language of the legislation suggests that it is wrong to employ reasoning relevant to one ground of invalidity in considering another. Section 18 compared with s 40. Section 18 of the Act is in Ch 2, headed "Patent rights, ownership and validity". Section 18 sets out requirements which go to the nature and subject-matter of patents. In contrast, s 40 appears in Ch 3, which is headed "From application to acceptance", and which deals with the filing, examination and acceptance of patent applications. Section 40 sets out requirements that are certainly important: in the specification, patentees give the public directions about how the advantages of the invention may be obtained after the patent expires, while in the claims, patentees warn their rivals what they must not do before the patent expires[21]. The requirements of s 40, however, unlike those of s 18, say nothing about the nature or subject-matter of patents, and go more to the form that specifications must take. Both the differences in the requirements which ss 18 and 40 impose, and their respective locations in the Act, suggest that s 18 issues have no relevance to s 40. So far as s 18 refers to "patentable inventions" and s 40 to "inventions", that conclusion is also supported by the definition in Sched 1 of the Act of "invention" as including an "alleged invention". [21]Rehm Pty Ltd v Websters Security Systems (International) Pty Ltd (1988) 81 ALR 79 at 94-95 per Gummow J; CCOM Pty Ltd v Jiejing Pty Ltd (1994) 51 FCR 260 at 277 per Spender, Gummow and Heerey JJ. Separation of matters going to and grounds of invalidity. That conclusion is also supported by the fact that the s 45(1) matters which an applicant can ask the Commissioner to conduct an examination into, the s 59 grounds on which a patent application may be opposed and the s 138(3) grounds for revoking a patent are separately stated in the paragraphs of each section. The distinctness of the grounds of invalidity. It is common in patent infringement litigation for invalidity to be alleged, and for more than one ground of invalidity to be relied on. Certain matters of fact and construction may be relevant to more than one issue. Thus common general knowledge is relevant not only to issues of construction by the skilled addressee, which underlie the infringement inquiry and interact with issues of validity[22], but also to obviousness[23]. Other factual matters may be relevant to more than one ground of invalidity[24]. The issues may "intersect and overlap"[25]. However, as Doric conceded in this Court, the grounds of invalidity themselves are, and must be kept, conceptually distinct. In particular, as Doric also conceded, a lack of fair basing is a distinct ground for revocation. Hence the "inventiveness" or "meritoriousness" of, or the technical contribution made by, the specification are issues to be examined if there is an objection under s 18(1)(b) of the Act for want of novelty or absence of an inventive step (ie obviousness). There is no reason to introduce them into the fair basing question.[22]Welch Perrin & Co Pty Ltd v Worrel (1961) 106 CLR 588 at 610 per Dixon CJ, Kitto and Windeyer JJ. [23]Section 7(2) of the Act and Firebelt Pty Ltd v Brambles Australia Ltd (2002) 76 ALJR 816 at 821-823 [31]-[36] per Gleeson CJ, McHugh, Gummow, Hayne and Callinan JJ; 188 ALR 280 at 287-289. [24]Sunbeam Corporation v Morphy-Richards (Aust) Pty Ltd (1961) 180 CLR 98 at 111-112 per Windeyer J. [25]Kimberly-Clark Australia Pty Ltd v Arico Trading International Pty Ltd (2001) 207 CLR 1 at 19 [34].