MMD Design and Consultancy Limited v Camco Engineering Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 77 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

MMD Design and Consultancy Limited v Camco Engineering Pty Ltd [2023] FCA 827  

File number(s): VID 340 of 2020
Judgment of: ROFE J
Date of judgment: 21 July 2023
Catchwords:

PATENTS – where invention claimed is a tooth construction for a mineral sizer – construction of patent – meaning of “front cover which is weldingly secured to and seated in face to face contact with the front face of the support body” – infringement – where respondents supplied tooth constructions for mineral sizers – whether repair defence applies – no infringement – standing to sue –  additional damages not awarded

PATENTS – validity – manner of manufacture – lack of novelty in light of two prior art documents – lack of inventive step in light of the common general knowledge alone – lack of inventive step in light of common general knowledge in combination with each of the two prior art documents – hindsight bias – clarity and fair basis – patent valid

CONSUMER LAW – misleading and deceptive conduct – whether respondents contravened s 18 of the Australian Consumer Law by failing to warn customers that it had engaged in patent infringement – dismissed

Legislation:

Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth), Sch 2 (Australian Consumer Law) ss 18, 236, 237

Copyright Act 1968 (Cth) s 115(4)

Patents Act 1990 (Cth) ss 7, 13(1), 40, 122(1A)

Trade Marks Act1995 (Cth) s 126(2)

Cases cited:

Advanced Building Systems Pty Ltd v Ramset Fasteners (Aust) Pty Ltd [1995] FCA 236; AIPC 91-129

Airco Fasteners Pty Ltd v Illinois Tool Works Inc [2023] FCAFC 7

Aktiebolaget Hassle v Alphapharm Pty Ltd (2002) 212 CLR 411

Apotex Pty Ltd v Sanofi-Aventis Australia Pty Ltd (No 2) (2012) 204 FCR 494

AstraZeneca AB v Apotex Pty Ltd (2014) 107 IPR 177

AstraZeneca AB v Apotex Pty Ltd (2015) 257 CLR 356

Bristol-Myers Squibb Company v Apotex Pty Ltd (No 5) (2013) 104 IPR 23

Britax Childcare Pty Ltd v Infa-Secure Pty Ltd (No 3) [2012] FCA 1019

Calidad Pty Ltd v Seiko Epson Corporation (2020) 272 CLR 351

Demagogue Pty Ltd v Ramensky (1992) 39 FCR 31

Dynamic Supplies Pty Ltd v Tonnex International Pty Ltd (No 3) (2014) 107 IPR 548

Erickson’s Patent (1923) 40 RPC 477

ESCO Corporation v Ronneby Road Pty Ltd (2018) 131 IPR 1

Facton Ltd v Rifai Fashions Pty Ltd (2012) 95 IPR 95

Firebelt Pty Ltd v Brambles Australia Ltd (2002) 54 IPR 449

Futuretronics.com.au Pty Limited v Graphix Labels Pty Ltd (No 2) (2008) 76 IPR 763

General Tire & Rubber Co v Firestone Tyre & Rubber Co Ltd [1972] RPC 457

Generic Health Pty Ltd v Bayer Pharma Aktiengesellschaft (2014) 106 IPR 381

GlaxoSmithKline Australia Pty Ltd v Reckitt Benckiser Healthcare (UK) Ltd (2016) 120 IPR 406

GlaxoSmithKline Consumer Healthcare Investments (Ireland) (No 2) Limited v Generic Partners Pty Limited (2018) 264 FCR 474

Globaltech Corporation Pty Ltd v Australian Mud Company Pty Ltd (2019) 145 IPR 39

Halal Certification…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read MMD Design and Consultancy Limited v Camco Engineering Pty L... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] FCA 827
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of MMD Design and Consultancy Limited versus Camco Engineering Pty Ltd, the Federal Court of Australia addressed issues concerning patent infringement, validity, and consumer law. MMD Design and Consultancy Limited alleged that Camco Engineering Pty Ltd had supplied tooth constructions for mineral sizers that infringed upon its patent. The court was required to determine whether Camco's actions constituted infringement, assess the validity of MMD's patent, and whether Camco's conduct contravened Section 18 of the Australian Consumer Law by failing to warn customers about the alleged patent infringement.

The court found that the construction of the patent in question was clear, specifically interpreting the term “front cover which is weldingly secured to and seated in face to face contact with the front face of the support body” in a particular manner. The court concluded that Camco’s tooth constructions did not infringe upon the patent, primarily because they did not meet the specific criteria outlined in the patent claims. Furthermore, the court addressed the validity of MMD’s patent, rejecting arguments that the manner of manufacture was unknown or that the invention lacked novelty and inventive step. The court held that the patent was valid, as the claimed invention met all criteria for patentability. Additionally, the court dismissed the claim that Camco contravened consumer law by not warning customers about the patent infringement, finding no evidence to support such a claim.

In summary, the court ruled that Camco Engineering Pty Ltd did not infringe upon MMD Design and Consultancy Limited’s patent, upheld the validity of the patent, and dismissed the consumer law claim. Consequently, no additional damages were awarded. The parties were directed to confer and submit an agreed minute of orders within 21 days or propose their own orders if an agreement could not be reached.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The parties confer and, within 21 days of these orders, submit to the Associate to Justice Rofe an agreed minute of orders giving effect to these reasons, alternatively if no agreement each party submit a proposed minute of order.

2. Orders 1 and 2 made 14 September 2022 be extended until further order of the Court.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Mr de Vos also referred to engineering design standards, such as the Australian Standards and British Standards and to supplier design handbooks and catalogues, such the Ajax Fastener Handbook and bearing catalogues, to obtain information about components that were commercially available. 7. BACKGROUND The following background information is taken from Mr de Vos’ first, third and fourth affidavits.7.1 Mineral sizers Mineral sizers typically consist of two shafts housed within a rectangular enclosure with an open top side and open bottom side. The shafts have rows of teeth affixed to them that rotate in opposite directions to one another. The teeth are designed to crush rocks. The teeth of the mineral sizer do the majority of the work reducing the size of rocks. The teeth break the rocks against other teeth. The teeth are typically shaped to have a pointed front (eg a pick or breaking tip) that allow the teeth to grip the rocks. Depending on the design of the mineral sizer, the teeth may have sacrificial covers. Where a tooth consists of a tooth core (which Mr de Vos described as a “support body”) and sacrificial covers, the covers protect the support body from becoming damaged by the rocks. The covers wear during use and are replaced periodically. The support body may need to be replaced on occasion, but less frequently than the covers. Where a tooth does not include covers, the tooth itself is a sacrificial part, and will be replaced periodically due to wear from the rocks. As a result of the action of the teeth, significant forces are imparted during use to the front, top and rear faces of the teeth. Smaller forces are imparted on the sides of the teeth. The front face of each tooth is subject to the greatest number of forces, though the magnitude of the forces imparted on the front and rear faces of the teeth is similar. Tooth constructions are typically made from steel. Steels tend to be relatively malleable, meaning that it tends to deform, rather than fracture, when force is applied to it. Steel can be hardened to reduce its malleability, making it resistant to plastic deformation when a force is applied to it. Steel is an alloy of iron with a small amount of carbon. A common way of hardening steel is to create an alloy by introducing other elements (such as other metals). For example, manganese steel is a hardened form of steel. The inclusion of manganese makes the steel more resistant to plastic deformation when forces are applied to it. 7.2 Transmission of force According to Mr de Vos, the well-known principle: for every action, there is an equal and opposite reaction, is critical to the operation of a mineral sizer tooth construction. In a mineral sizer, there must be a physical connection between two components (according to Mr de Vos this can be directly or through an intermediary) in order for forces to be transferred between them. When a force is applied to Component A, that force can be transmitted to other components that are physically connected to Component A.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

It is because I consider that the ore fines issue was integral to Mr de Vos’ reasoning on construction and infringement in his affidavit evidence such that it cannot be simply surgically excised, that I have discussed his written evidence at length in a following section. 5. NON-EXPERT EVIDENCE MMD led evidence from three non-expert witnesses employed by MMD, and Andrew Mullane, one of MMD’s solicitors. Each of the MMD non-expert witnesses, other than Mr Mullane was cross-examined. Darren Balmer, Production Director at MMD Australia, made five affidavits dated 27 January 2022, 2 February 2022, 11 May 2022, 10 June 2022 and 24 June 2022. Mr Balmer commenced with MMD Mineral Sizing (Europe) Ltd in 1993, and has been employed by various MMD companies since then, moving to MMD Australia’s Brisbane office in 2009. Starting in about 1995, Mr Balmer began assisting in MMD Mineral Sizing’s service department in the United Kingdom and was involved in the installation of new equipment and the repair and changing of worn components for bolted tooth constructions. According to Mr Balmer, MMD Australia has supplied mineral sizers to mine sites in Australia since the late 1980’s. For the majority of MMD Australia’s mineral sizers, the teeth are composed of a support body clad with covers. The covers are wear parts. In a confidential annexure to his first affidavit, Mr Balmer gave post priority date evidence about the MMD tooth constructions at each of the Yandi, Solomon and Worsley Alumina sites at which MMD contends that Camco supplies infringing tooth constructions. According to Mr Balmer, the MMD intermediate, rear and top covers are made by casting which he describes as a “relatively imprecise fabrication technique”. He observes that there are manufacturing tolerances associated with the cast covers depending on the length of the component. MMD’s cast covers have a manufacturing tolerance of approximately [REDACTED]. The MMD covers also undulate across their inner and outer surfaces (another product of the casting process). As a result, the faces of the covers (both inner and outer) are not perfectly flat. According to Mr Balmer, when fitting the intermediate cover of the MMD tooth construction to the support body [REDACTED] [REDACTED] [REDACTED] [REDACTED] [REDACTED] [REDACTED] [REDACTED] [REDACTED] [REDACTED] [REDACTED] [REDACTED] [REDACTED] [REDACTED] [REDACTED] [REDACTED] [REDACTED] [REDACTED] [REDACTED] [REDACTED] [REDACTED] [REDACTED] [REDACTED] [REDACTED] [REDACTED] [REDACTED]. Mr Balmer gave extensive evidence relating to the ore fines issue. For example:[REDACTED] [REDACTED] [REDACTED] [REDACTED] [REDACTED] [REDACTED] [REDACTED] [REDACTED] [REDACTED] [REDACTED] [REDACTED] [REDACTED] [REDACTED] [REDACTED] [REDACTED] [REDACTED] [REDACTED] [REDACTED] [REDACTED] [REDACTED] [REDACTED] [REDACTED] [REDACTED] [REDACTED] [REDACTED]. [REDACTED] [REDACTED] [REDACTED] [REDACTED] [REDACTED] [REDACTED] [REDACTED] [REDACTED] [REDACTED] [REDACTED] [REDACTED] [REDACTED] [REDACTED] [REDACTED] [REDACTED] [REDACTED] [REDACTED] [REDACTED] [REDACTED] [REDACTED] [REDACTED] [REDACTED] (Emphasis added.)

Decision

Reasons for decision

As Camco appeared to concede in its written submissions, this manner of manufacture argument has an affinity with its novelty and obviousness cases and I consider that it is best dealt with under those grounds of invalidity. As I have found there, certain of the integers of claim 1 of the Patent were not known by persons skilled in the art at the priority date, this aspect of Camco’s manner of manufacture argument cannot succeed.20. CONCLUSION For these reasons, I find the Camco Constructions do not infringe the Asserted Claims. By their supply of the Camco Constructions, Camco has not engaged in conduct that contravenes s 18 of the ACL. I also find the Asserted Claims of the Patent are, and at all material times have been, valid.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.