Smith & Nephew Pty Ltd v Wake Forest University Health Sciences

Link copied
Case Copied 23 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Smith & Nephew Pty Ltd v Wake Forest University Health Sciences [2009] FCAFC 142

INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY – product combination claim – whether mere collocation of integers – where integer not part of the combination of the invention is an essential integer of the claim but not as a limitation – not all essential integers fail to interact to produce functional result desired – patent invalid

PRACTICE & PROCEDURE – evidence – objection not taken below to conclusory statement by expert – objection not taken as to expertise of expert – cannot object on appeal

PRACTICE & PROCEDURE – interlocutory appeal – disposition on appeal

Patents Act1990 (Cth)

Australian Broadcasting Corporation v O’Neill (2006) 227 CLR 57 cited
British Celanese Ltd v Courtaulds Ltd (1935) 52 RPC 171 cited
British United Shoe Machinery Company Ltd v Fussell & Sons Ltd (1908) 25 RPC 631 distinguished
Cenefill Pty Ltd v Australian Sheetpiling Pty Ltd and Others (1996) 35 IPR 64 cited
Firebelt Pty Ltd v Brambles Australia Ltd [2002] HCA 21; 188 ALR 280 followed
Firebelt Pty Ltd v Brambles Australia Ltd [2000] FCA 1689; 51 IPR 531 followed
Fisher & Paykel Healthcare Pty Ltd v Avion Engineering Pty Ltd (1991) 103 ALR 239 followed
Kimberly-Clark Australia Pty Ltd v Arico Trading International Pty Ltd (2001) 207 CLR 1 cited
Re Klaber’s Patent (1906) 23 RPC 461 cited
Minnesota Mining and Manufacturing Co v Beiersdorf (Australia) Ltd (1980) 144 CLR 253 followed
Palmer v Dunlop Perdriau Rubber Co Ltd (1937) 59 CLR 30 followed
Pugh v Riley Cycle Co Ltd (1914) 31 RPC 266 distinguished
Wake Forest University Health Sciences v Smith and Nephew Pty Ltd [2009] FCA 630 cited

Bodkin, C.L. Patent Law in Australia (2008)

SMITH & NEPHEW PTY LTD (ACN 000 087 507) v WAKE FOREST UNIVERSITY HEALTH SCIENCES and KCI MEDICAL AUSTRALIA PTY LTD
(ACN 056 073 468)

VID 458 of 2009

FINN, BENNETT AND MIDDLETON JJ
9 OCTOBER 2009
MELBOURNE


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

VID 458 of 2009

ON APPEAL FROM A SINGLE JUDGE OF THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
BETWEEN:

SMITH & NEPHEW PTY LTD (ACN 000 087 507)
Applicant

AND:

WAKE FOREST UNIVERSITY HEALTH SCIENCES
First Respondent

KCI MEDICAL AUSTRALIA PTY LTD (ACN 056 073 468)
Second Respondent

JUDGES:

FINN, BENNETT AND MIDDLETON JJ

DATE OF ORDER:

9 OCTOBER 2009

WHERE MADE:

MELBOURNE

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.        Leave to appeal be granted.

2.        The appeal be allowed.

3.The order of Ryan J made on 15 June 2009 be set aside, and in lieu thereof it be ordered that the application for interlocutory injunction be dismissed.

4.The respondents pay the applicant’s costs of the application for leave to appeal and of the appeal.

5.The parties within 7 days provide to the Full Court written submissions as to the costs of the application before the primary judge.

Note:Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Smith & Nephew Pty Ltd v Wake Forest University Health Scien... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] FCAFC 142
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Smith & Nephew Pty Ltd (Applicant) appealed against an order made by Ryan J in the Federal Court of Australia, which granted an interlocutory injunction to Wake Forest University Health Sciences (Respondent) against the Applicant's launch of an alleged infringing product. The dispute centred on the validity of a patent held by the Respondent and whether the Applicant should be restrained from launching the alleged infringing product. The primary legal issue was whether the primary judge erred in granting the interlocutory injunction without considering the construction of the patent claim put forward by the Respondent, and whether the Respondent demonstrated a serious question to be tried. The Court held that the primary judge should have considered the construction of claim 49 put forward by the Respondent, and that the Respondent failed to demonstrate a serious question to be tried.

The Full Court found that the primary judge erred in not considering, as a separate matter, whether claim 49 comprised a "mere collocation of separate parts" and was therefore invalid. The Court emphasised that a mere collocation of parts, each performing its own separate function, is not patentable, but a claim may validly combine a number of elements which interact with each other to produce a new result or product. The Court concluded that the primary judge should have found, based on the evidence and the construction of claim 49 put forward by the Respondent, that claim 49 was invalid. Consequently, the interlocutory injunction should not have been granted. It was appropriate to grant leave to appeal and allow the appeal. The Court ordered that the application for interlocutory injunction be dismissed and that the Respondent pay the Applicant's costs of the application for leave to appeal and of the appeal. The parties were directed to provide written submissions as to the costs of the application before the primary judge within 7 days.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Leave to appeal be granted.

2. The appeal be allowed.

3. The order of Ryan J made on 15 June 2009 be set aside, and in lieu thereof it be ordered that the application for interlocutory injunction be dismissed.

4. The respondents pay the applicant’s costs of the application for leave to appeal and of the appeal.

5. The parties within 7 days provide to the Full Court written submissions as to the costs of the application before the primary judge.

Note:

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

FINN, BENNETT AND MIDDLETON JJ
We do, however, accept that it would be an error in considering whether the grant of an interlocutory injunction, in the context of an infringement claim, where the validity of the patent is in issue, to impose on a person who seeks to launch an alleged infringing product, an obligation to ‘clear the way’ by revoking the patent. Equally, the fact that a new entrant is prepared to take the risk of being restrained with its eyes wide open, should not be elevated beyond being a factor in the assessment of the many factors relevant to whether to grant an injunction.CONCLUSION For the above reasons, the primary judge should have concluded on the evidence before him and on the basis of the construction of claim 49 put forward by the respondents, that claim 49 was invalid, and that the respondents in these circumstances failed to demonstrate that there was a serious question to be tried. We should stress that we have approached the question of the validity of claim 49 by reference to the evidence and submissions made as to the construction of claim 49 put forward by the respondents. We have not determined the validity of claim 49 finally, this being a matter for the primary judge at trial. We have merely arrived at the conclusion that the primary judge should not have granted the injunction in light of the evidence and the construction of claim 49 put forward by the respondents. It is therefore appropriate to grant leave to appeal and allow the appeal. The respondents indicated that, if the appeal were allowed, it would be prepared to keep all necessary accounts. The Court proposes to order:Upon the respondent undertaking to the Court to keep all necessary accounts:1. Leave to appeal be granted.2. The appeal be allowed.3.The order of Ryan J made on 15 June 2009 be set aside, and in lieu thereof it be ordered that the application for interlocutory injunction be dismissed. 4.The respondents pay the applicant’s costs of the application for leave to appeal and of the appeal.5.The parties within 7 days provide to the Full Court written submissions as to the costs of the application before the primary judge.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: FINN, BENNETT AND MIDDLETON JJ

The primary judge then concluded that the issue of novelty raised difficult questions in the light of a prior publication, the Bagdautinov article, and that in view of the competing arguments on novelty, this contributed significantly to his conclusion that there was a serious question to be tried.CONSIDERATION It seems to us that the primary judge failed to consider, as a separate matter from novelty, the issue of whether claim 49 comprised a ‘mere collocation of separate parts’ and was therefore invalid. A mere collocation of parts, each performing its own separate function, is not patentable. However, a claim may validly combine a number of elements which interact with each other to produce a new result or product. Such a combination may be one constituted by integers each of which are old, or by integers some of which are new, the interaction being the essential element: Minnesota Mining and Manufacturing Co v Beiersdorf (Australia) Ltd (1980) 144 CLR 253 at 266 per Aitkin J, and Firebelt Pty Ltd v Brambles Australia Ltd (2002) 188 ALR 280 at [21]. As we have indicated, it was accepted by all parties that the integers of claim 49, other than the aseptic package, interact with each other to produce a new product and result. However, the respondents submitted the fact that the aseptic bag does not interact with the other integers of claim 49 does not render the claim ‘a mere collocation’. They submitted that the only effect of including an additional integer such as the aseptic bag is to limit the claim, without affecting the invention in the combination claimed, referring to Pugh v Riley Cycle Co Ltd (1914) 31 RPC 266 per Lord Moulton at 283 and British United Shoe Machinery Company Ltd v Fussell & Sons Ltd (1908) 25 RPC 631 at 659 lines 35 to 45. However, the respondents did not support a construction of the claim as a limitation of the scope of the claim. Rather, they supported a construction of a limitation on the apparatus itself. The aseptic bag was contended to be a feature of the apparatus in a kit form. In this case, the respondents’ contention is that, as a matter of construction, the aseptic package is an essential integer of the combination the subject of the claim. They accept that it does not limit the apparatus in its use, the application of negative pressure. They sought to adopt a “fall-back” position that the package is a limitation on the scope of the claimed monopoly, an optional addition. However, the construction advanced was not of an optional addition. Put another way, the invention claimed by the respondents pursuant to s 18(1) of the Act included the package as an essential integer. In putting forward this construction, the respondents must be confined to that construction both for the purpose of applying s 18(1)(a) (manner of manufacture) and s 18(1)(b) (novelty): see Kimberly-Clark Australia Pty Ltd v Arico Trading International Pty Ltd (2001) 207 CLR 1 Gleeson CJ, McHugh, Gummow, Hayne and Callinan JJ at [21] and footnote 37.