Dynamic Supplies Pty Ltd v Tonnex International Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 79 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Dynamic Supplies Pty Limited v Tonnex International Pty Limited
[2011] FCA 362

Citation: Dynamic Supplies Pty Limited v Tonnex International Pty Limited [2011] FCA 362
Parties: DYNAMIC SUPPLIES PTY LIMITED (ACN 064 793 862) v TONNEX INTERNATIONAL PTY LIMITED (ACN 085 148 438)
File number(s): NSD 793 of 2009
Judge: YATES J
Date of judgment: 13 April 2011
Catchwords:

COPYRIGHT – subsistence – literary work – compilation – compatibility chart for printer and computer consumables – whether a work of joint authorship

COPYRIGHT – infringement – whether impugned work is a reproduction of a substantial part of the copyright work – indicia of copying – multiple use in impugned work of idiosyncratic expressions used in copyright work

TRADE PRACTICES – consumer protection – representation as to genuineness of products – representation as to reliability of supplier to only supply genuine and not counterfeit products – whether proper basis for making representations – whether conduct misleading or deceptive or likely to mislead or deceive – whether false representations made

TRADE PRACTICES – consumer protection – representation as to tax free status of benefits supplied under a rewards program – whether conduct misleading or deceptive or likely to mislead or deceive – whether false representation made

TRADE PRACTICES – consumer protection – representations as to Australian products – representations as to Australian jobs – whether conduct misleading or deceptive or likely to mislead or deceive – whether false representations made

Legislation: Copyright Act 1968 (Cth) ss 10(1), 32, 35(6)
Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth) ss 21A, 23L(2)
Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) ss 51A, 52, 53(a), 53(c), 53(eb)
Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 2) 2010 (Cth) Sch 7 Subitem 7(1)
Cases cited:

Bookmakers’ Afternoon Greyhound Services Ltd v Wilf Gilbert (Staffordshire) Ltd [1994] FSR 723
Cala Homes (South) Limited v Alfred McAlpine Homes East Limited [1995] FSR 818
Desktop Marketing Systems Pty Ltd v Telstra Corporation Ltd (2002) 119 FCR 491
Ducret v Chaudhary’s Oriental Carpet Palace Pty Ltd (1987) 16 FCR 562
Federal Commissioner of Taxation v Cooke and Sherden (1980) 80 ATC 4140
IceTV Pty Limited v Nine Network Australia Pty Limited (2009) 239 CLR 458
Ladbroke (Football) Ltd v William Hill (Football) Ltd [1964] 1 WLR 273
Levy v Rutley (1871) 6 LRCP 523
Najma Heptulla  v Orient Longman Limited [1989] FSR 598
Netcomm (Australia) Pty Ltd v Dataplex Pty Ltd (1988) 81 ALR 101
Robinson v Sands & McDougall Pty Ltd (1916) 22 CLR 124
Sands & McDougall Pty Ltd v Robinson (1917) 23 CLR 49

Telstra Corporation Ltd v Phone Directories Co Pty Ltd (2010) 264 ALR 617

Date of hearing: 6 - 10 September 2011, 20 September 2011
Place: Sydney
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 236
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr S Burley SC with Mr D Robertson
Solicitor for the Applicant: Unsworth Legal Pty Limited
Counsel for the Respondent: Dr J Bleechmore
Solicitor for the Respondent: Chadwicks - The Law Firm

IN THE FEDERAL…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Dynamic Supplies Pty Ltd v Tonnex International Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] FCA 362
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Dynamic Supplies Pty Ltd (Dynamic) brought an action against Tonnex International Pty Ltd (Tonnex) in the Federal Court of Australia, alleging infringement of copyright, misleading or deceptive conduct under the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth), and false representations about the genuineness of products and the tax-free status of rewards under a loyalty program. The primary dispute centred around the compilation of a compatibility chart for printer and computer consumables, the authenticity of products sold by Tonnex, and the tax implications of rewards provided under a loyalty program.

The court had to determine several legal issues, including whether the compatibility chart constituted a work of joint authorship, whether the impugned work was a reproduction of a substantial part of the copyright work, and whether certain statements made by Tonnex regarding the genuineness of its products and the tax-free status of rewards were misleading or deceptive. Additionally, the court examined whether Tonnex's representations about the Australian-made nature of its products and the Australian jobs it supported were misleading or deceptive.

In its reasoning, the court found that the compatibility chart in question was not a work of joint authorship, but rather an independent creation by Tonnex. It also determined that the impugned work did not constitute a reproduction of a substantial part of the copyright work, as it did not use any idiosyncratic expressions from the original work. Regarding the misleading or deceptive conduct, the court held that Tonnex's representations about the genuineness of its products and the tax-free status of rewards were misleading, as Tonnex could not guarantee the authenticity of all products and the tax treatment of the rewards. The court further found that Tonnex's representations about Australian products and jobs were also misleading, as they could not substantiate these claims.

The court ordered that the proceeding would stand over for a directions hearing to be arranged with the Associate.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The proceeding will stand over for a directions hearing at a time and date to be arranged with my Associate.

Note:

Background

Background to the litigation

Despite having made and subsequently withdrawn the statements in the circumstances I have described, Tonnex has sought to defend them.The tax free representation: background It is common ground between the parties that a taxpayer’s assessable income includes income according to ordinary concepts and that a profit or gain made in the course of a business is income according to ordinary concepts. It is also common ground between the parties that a benefit which is not convertible to cash cannot be income according to ordinary concepts: Federal Commissioner of Taxation v Cooke and Sherden (1980) 80 ATC 4140 at 4150. Rewards under the rewards program could not be converted to cash. However, s 21A of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth) (the ITAA) provides that, in determining a taxpayer’s income, a “non-cash business benefit” is to be treated as if it were convertible to cash. For this purpose, a “non-cash business benefit” is defined as property or services provided after 31 August 1988 wholly or partly in respect of a business relationship or wholly or partly for or in relation directly or indirectly to a business relationship: s 21A(5) of the ITAA. The parties agreed that rewards under the rewards program were property or services for the purposes of this definition. Tonnex accepted that there is a business relationship between it and its resellers. It contended, however, that this relationship is not the relevant relationship for the purposes of the definition of “non-cash business benefit”. It contended that there must be a business relationship between the donor and donee of the rewards (Hewlett Packard and the resellers). That being so, it said that there is no relevant business relationship between Hewlett Packard and the resellers, with the result that s 21A of the ITAA is not engaged. Tonnex also contended that rewards received under the rewards program should properly be seen as a discount from the purchase price of goods, not as income as such. Two further provisions should be noted. First, s 21A(3) of the ITAA determines the amount of income to be brought to account in relation to a “non-cash business benefit”. It provides that a taxpayer’s income does not include the value of a “non-cash business benefit” to the extent that the taxpayer would be entitled to a deduction if it paid for the benefit. Secondly, s 23L(2) of the ITAA provides that where the total amount of “non-cash business benefits” is not more than $300 in any income year, it is exempt income. The issues that divided the parties are:(a)whether the rewards provided under the rewards program are income according to ordinary concepts, that is whether they constitute a profit or gain, and;(b)if so, whether they are a “non-cash business benefit”, within the meaning of s 21A of the ITAA.The tax free representation: consideration In my view rewards received by a reseller under the rewards program are properly to be regarded as a profit or gain made in the course of that reseller’s business. The rewards are received as part of an income earning activity. Those rewards are not properly characterised as a discount on the purchase price for the Hewlett Packard products. The reseller pays the full purchase price demanded by Tonnex for the relevant products. Tonnex does not reduce its purchase price for them. However, in acquiring the products from Tonnex, and provided it meets Hewlett Packard’s other requirements under the rewards program rules, a reseller is entitled to certain rewards. Those rewards are provided by Hewlett Packard, not Tonnex. It follows, in my view, that the rewards are income according to ordinary concepts.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

It is convenient at this stage to turn to Tonnex’s evidence of how Tonnex 2008 came to be compiled. This evidence was given by Mr Rendell. Tonnex’s evidence James Rendell is the National Marketing Manager for Tonnex. In July 2006 he took over responsibility for the production of Tonnex’s price lists. He made three affidavits which were read as part of Tonnex’s evidence in chief. The thrust of Mr Rendell’s evidence in his first affidavit was that the information in Tonnex’s price lists, including the compatibility charts interspersed therein, was obtained through a lengthy process “which involved filtering through the previous product descriptions and product code data which was contained in both our Software Application inventory database and previously created inventory data files as stored on [Tonnex’s] network at the time”. He referred to the “natural evolution of [Tonnex’s] operations” and the engagement of staff employed in the roles of inventory management “who were charged with the duty of adding new products into [Tonnex’s] systems, removing obsolete products, updating product details in accordance with vendor changes and updating product descriptions”. He said that Tonnex gathers information from vendors, customers and the Internet in compiling its price lists and compatibility charts. He said that the information in compatibility charts for these products would, by and large, be the same because this information is generally available from a variety of sources. He specifically denied that Tonnex’s price lists and compatibility charts had been “formulated or developed by reference to [Dynamic’s] price lists and compatibility charts”. In a subsequent affidavit (made as a consequence of the late service by Dynamic of additional affidavit evidence which I permitted to be read in chief), Mr Rendell elaborated on the process by which Tonnex’s price lists and compatibility charts were created. In this affidavit Mr Rendell recounted the history of the production of Tonnex’s price lists in PDF form since the first price list of that kind came to be produced in September 2006. This price list included various OEM-produced compatibility charts which were stored in various file formats in electronic form. Although Mr Rendell considered this price list to be well-designed and laid out, he found that it could not be updated quickly because of the fact that the file was created in Adobe Illustrator format. He also found the file size to be unduly large for email transmission to customers. The next price list that was produced by Tonnex was in October 2007. This price list was produced in electronic form in Microsoft Excel format, making it easier to email to customers. The file contained hyperlinks to various documents and webpages. Mr Rendell estimated that he spent approximately 100 hours in re-designing and reformatting the structure of this price list. This work, however, was largely spent in designing a graphical interface which included images and buttons. After testing the file, Mr Rendell decided to omit the OEM-produced compatibility charts because of their file size. However, after receiving feedback from employees in Tonnex’s sales department in the months following the publication of this price list, he came to the realisation that it would be of benefit to provide a CSV version of the price list, containing a user-friendly compatibility chart. Mr Rendell’s evidence was that it then became necessary to source information to compile such a chart. It was this work that led to the compilation of Tonnex 2008.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the compatibility chart created by Tonnex International Pty Ltd constitutes a reproduction of a substantial part of the copyright work of Dynamic Supplies Pty Ltd, thus constituting an infringement of copyright.
2. Whether Tonnex International Pty Ltd engaged in misleading or deceptive conduct under the Australian Consumer Law by making certain representations to consumers.
3. Whether the rewards provided under the HP Supplies Rewards program are income according to ordinary concepts and constitute a "non-cash business benefit" under the Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth).

Held
1. The court found that the compatibility chart created by Tonnex International Pty Ltd did not constitute a reproduction of a substantial part of the copyright work of Dynamic Supplies Pty Ltd, thus it did not constitute an infringement of copyright.
2. The court held that Tonnex International Pty Ltd engaged in misleading or deceptive conduct under the Australian Consumer Law by making certain representations to consumers, specifically regarding the genuineness of the products and the tax-free status of benefits from the HP Supplies Rewards program.
3. The court determined that the rewards provided under the HP Supplies Rewards program are income according to ordinary concepts and constitute a "non-cash business benefit" under the Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth).

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

It follows that Dynamic has not made good its case in respect of the first reliability representation.The second reliability representation: consideration Once again, the first issue that arises is whether the specific statement relied upon by Dynamic conveys the second reliability representation, namely that customers can rely upon Tonnex and not its competitors to offer for sale or sell genuine and not counterfeit printer and computer consumables. In my view the impugned statement does not convey that representation to its full extent. It simply does not represent that customers cannot rely upon any of Tonnex’s competitors to supply genuine and not counterfeit products. However, the statement, as a matter of substance, is indistinguishable from the statement conveying the genuineness representation. In that connection the statement represents precisely what it says: customers can rely upon Tonnex to only ever sell 100% genuine OEM parts. However, because Tonnex cannot be certain that all printer and computer consumables offered for sale or sold by it are genuine and not counterfeit, its customers cannot rely upon it “to only ever sell 100% genuine OEM products”. The misleading nature of the statement is reinforced by the exhortation: “Don’t risk counterfeits – choose genuine – choose Tonnex”. As I have found, Tonnex’s own evidence speaks of the existence of such a risk when products are purchased from a trader who is not an authorised distributor. Thus the conclusions to which I have come in relation to the genuineness representation apply equally to this statement, save that, in my view, s 51A of the Trade Practices Act does apply to the statement as a representation about a future matter. However, with or without the application of that provision, I am satisfied that, by making the statement, Tonnex has engaged in conduct that is misleading or deceptive or likely to mislead or deceive in contravention of s 52 of the Trade Practices Act.The tax free representation: introduction Between 4 August 2008 and 1 May 2009, Hewlett Packard administered a loyalty program known as HP Supplies Rewards (the rewards program). Customers of Tonnex (i.e. resellers) were eligible to participate in the program provided they registered online with Hewlett Packard. These participants earned points by purchasing certain Hewlett Packard products from certain suppliers, including Tonnex. Accumulated points could be redeemed from Hewlett Packard for products selected from its Rewards Catalogue. These products included gift cards from major retailers, movie tickets, and the like. Between August 2008 and August 2009 Tonnex made a number of statements in promotional literature and on its website, including the following:·Get up to 10% back in tax free rewards from HP Supplier Rewards.·Earn up to a massive 10% back in tax-free rewards through HP Supplies Rewards.·10% TAX FREE in selected vouchers from HP Supplies Rewards. Tonnex did not seek or act on any professional advice to inform itself whether rewards under the rewards program were tax free or, indeed, would be tax free to any extent. Mr Kozman said that, nevertheless, he believed the statements to be correct at the time that they were made, based on his personal (but not expert) understanding of the tax treatment of rewards provided under other rewards programs. The reference to 10% appears to have been Tonnex’s own assessment of the value of the rewards under the rewards program. The percentage figure is not prescribed in the relevant tax legislation.