QAD Inc v Shepparton Partners Collective Operations Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 72 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

QAD Inc v Shepparton Partners Collective Operations Pty Ltd [2021] FCA 615  

File number: NSD 85 of 2020
Judgment of: THAWLEY J
Date of judgment: 8 June 2021
Catchwords:

INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY – infringement of copyright in enterprise resource planning software by new business owner – licensor of software required fee as condition of consent to transfer licence agreement to new business owner – fee not paid – whether implied licence to use software – applicants gave respondent permission to use software whilst respondent considered software upgrade options – infringement of copyright established from date respondent indicated it would not pay the transfer fee to the applicant – respondent continued using software throughout the course of proceedings and during hearing – non-pecuniary relief and compensatory and additional damages ordered

INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY – cross-claim against previous business owners – alleged failure to use “best endeavours” to secure transfer of licence agreement and alleged failure to comply with obligations under business purchase agreement to secure benefit of and rights under licence agreement  – business seller’s indemnity against loss suffered as a result of failure to comply with obligations under business purchase agreement and licence agreement – seller guarantor’s indemnity against loss and damage suffered as a result of seller’s breach of business purchase agreement – principles of construction of contracts – cross-claim dismissed

Legislation:

Copyright Act 1968 (Cth) ss 10, 14, 31, 36, 37, 115

Explanatory Memorandum, US Free Trade Agreement Implementation Bill 2004 (Cth)

Cases cited:

Acohs Pty Ltd v Ucorp Pty Ltd (2012) 201 FCR 173

Amalgamated Mining Services Pty Ltd v Warman International Ltd (1992) 111 ALR 269

Australian Blue Metal Ltd v Hughes [1963] AC 74

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Leahy Petroleum Pty Ltd (No 2) (2005) 215 ALR 281

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Pacific National Pty Ltd (2020) 277 FCR 49

Autodesk Australia Pty Ltd v Cheung (1990) 94 ALR 472

Autodesk Inc v Yee (1996) 68 FCR 39

Bailey v Namol Pty Ltd (1994) 53 FCR 102

Chhabra v McPherson (as trustee for the McPherson Practice Trust) (2018) 138 IPR 1

Chhabra v McPherson (as trustee for the McPherson Practice Trust) (2019) 147 IPR 399

Coles v Dormer (No 2) (2016) 330 ALR 151

Commissioner of Probate Duties (Vic) v Stocks (1976) 135 CLR 247

Computermate Products (Aust) Pty Ltd v Ozi-Soft Pty Ltd (1988) 20 FCR 46

Crawford Fitting Co v Sydney Valve and Fittings Pty Ltd (1988) 14 NSWLR 438

Devefi Pty Ltd v Mateffy Perl Nagy Pty Ltd (1993) 113 ALR 225

Director of Consumer Affairs v Srinivasan [2014] VSC 271

Dynamic Supplies Pty Ltd v Tonnex International Pty Ltd (No 3) (2014) 312 ALR 705

Electricity Generation Corporation v Woodside Energy Ltd (2014) 251 CLR 640

Facton Ltd v Rifai Fashions Pty Ltd (2012) 199 FCR 569

Futuretronics.com.au Pty Limited v Graphix Labels Pty Ltd (No 2) (2008) 76 IPR 763

Generic Health Pty Ltd v Bayer Pharma Aktiengesellschaft (2018) 267 FCR 428

Halal Certification…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read QAD Inc v Shepparton Partners Collective Operations Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] FCA 615
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Federal Court recently handed down a decision in QAD Inc v Shepparton Partners Collective Operations Pty Ltd. The case concerned copyright infringement in enterprise resource planning software and a cross-claim against previous business owners. QAD Inc, the owner of copyright in the QAD Software, claimed that SPC, the new business owner, infringed its copyright by using the software without a valid licence. The court found that QAD was entitled to a fee as a condition of consent to transfer the licence agreement to SPC, and since SPC did not pay the fee, there was no implied licence to use the software. SPC continued to use the software throughout the proceedings, leading the court to order non-pecuniary relief and compensatory and additional damages. The cross-claim against the previous business owners, which included allegations of failure to use best endeavours to secure the transfer of the licence agreement and failure to comply with the business purchase agreement, was dismissed.

The legal issues in this case included whether QAD was entitled to a fee as a condition of consent to transfer the licence agreement to SPC, whether there was an implied licence to use the software, and whether the previous business owners breached their obligations under the business purchase agreement. The court found that QAD was entitled to a fee and that there was no implied licence to use the software. The court also found that the previous business owners did not breach their obligations under the business purchase agreement. The decision highlights the importance of obtaining the necessary licences and permissions when transferring software licences and the consequences of using software without a valid licence. The case also underscores the importance of understanding the terms and conditions of business purchase agreements and the potential consequences of breaching those agreements.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The applicants and respondent confer with a view to providing to the Court within 7 days agreed orders to give effect to the conclusions reached by the Court and any agreed position as to costs.

2. The cross-claim be dismissed.

3. Subject to a party to the cross-claim applying within 7 days for a different order as to costs, the cross-claimant pay the cross-respondents’ costs.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

For the reasons which follow, QAD’s claim has been made out and SPC’s cross-claim has not.THE FACTS QAD creates and licenses enterprise resource planning (ERP) software (QAD Software). The software has been marketed under different names. QAD Inc is the only applicant which seeks relief. In 1991, SPC Ardmona Operations Ltd (then named SPC Ltd and later named Sale Proprietary Co 2 Limited (SaleCo 2)) acquired a perpetual and, from the licensee’s perspective, non-transferable licence for the QAD Software from QAD.Australia Pty Ltd (QAPL) (the Licence Agreement). The Licence Agreement was assigned by QAPL to QAD Australia Pty Limited (QAD Australia) in around 1998 and was subsequently amended and updated. The Licence Agreement has remained non-transferable so far as the licensee is concerned. At times relevant to the issues in these proceedings, SaleCo 2 was using QAD Enterprise Applications 2008 Standard Edition (QAD 2008 SE) as its ERP software. SaleCo 2 was also paying QAD for maintenance and support services and had so paid up until 31 July 2019. There was ultimately no dispute that QAD Inc is the owner of copyright in the object code and source code of the QAD 2008 SE software. The cross-respondents, which include Coca-Cola Amatil Ltd, and which are referred to collectively in these reasons as CCA, conducted a business involving the processing and selling of agricultural food products under brands including “SPC” and “Goulburn Valley” (SPC Business). The SPC Business produces canned fruit, vegetables and other food products in regional Victoria. It was acquired by CCA in 2005. CCA held all the shares in SPC Ardmona Limited (which changed its name to Sale Co 1 Limited (SaleCo)). SaleCo owned the SPC Business. SaleCo owned all the shares in SaleCo 2 which held the QAD licence. In May 2018, QAD made a recommendation to CCA that it upgrade the QAD Software to the 2017 Enterprise Edition. The recommended upgrade was “signed off” by SaleCo’s Head of IT, Mr Llewellyn, but needed to be approved by Amatil’s Chief Financial Officer (CFO). That approval was not forthcoming because consideration was being given by Amatil to selling the SPC Business. On 4 September 2018, Mr Read (according to his email, QAD’s Executive General Manager for Australia and Japan) emailed Ms Watkins at Amatil, referring to the “aged ERP infrastructure” and stating that QAD had “found significant platform risks plus opportunity to make financial and labour savings” that would improve profit and “build stability for the future”. In cross-examination, Mr Read agreed that he was wanting to sell to Amatil, at an early stage of its consideration of the sale of the SPC Business, the proposal to upgrade SaleCo’s ERP infrastructure and that this might be achieved before the SPC Business went to market and would make the business more attractive. In response, Ms Watkins indicated that the Amatil CFO (Mr Martyn Roberts) was aware of the issues and would follow up if he considered it was warranted. Mr Read emailed Mr Roberts on 12 September 2018, forwarding the emails between him (Mr Read) and Ms Watkins, and stating that he wanted to meet. Amatil was not evidently interested because it did not respond.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Given the conclusion that SaleCo did not breach cl 10.3, Amatil has nothing to indemnify.CONCLUSION QAD’s claim against SPC is made out. SPC’s cross-claim is not. QAD and SPC should confer with a view to agreeing orders to give effect to these reasons. The cross-claim should be dismissed with costs.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

On 27 November 2019, Mr Rifai wrote to QAD, by email to Mr Read, stating:Dear Mr Read,Arrangements between Shepparton Partners Collective Operations Pty Ltd and QAD Australia Pty LtdWe refer to our recent discussions with you to transfer your existing licence agreement with Sale Proprietary Co 2 Limited, formerly SPC Limited (ACN 004 077 105) (Seller) [SaleCo 2] from the [SaleCo 2] to Shepparton Partners Collective Operations Pty Limited (SPC OpCo) [SPC], being the recent purchaser of the SPC business.We have reviewed your Software Licensing Agreement, dated 27 August 1991, and the Customer Support Software Agreement, dated 20 August 1998, (together the Agreements) with [SaleCo 2]. The Agreements do not allow [SaleCo 2] to assign or transfer the benefit of the Agreements to a third party, nor do they allow QAD Australia Pty Ltd (QAD) to require payment to transfer the software license to a third party.Whilst we are willing to discuss a suitable customer support arrangement with you, [SPC] is not required to pay, nor is it willing to pay, any amounts to effect a transfer of the Agreements from [SaleCo 2] to [SPC]. [SPC] is not contractually obliged with QAD to pay any such amounts (as a contract does not exist between these two entities).Further, under the business sale agreement between (amongst others) [SaleCo 2] and [SPC], [SPC] is specifically not contractually obliged to pay any amounts to any third party when transferring/assigning a contract. To the extent that a contractual obligation exists for [SaleCo 2] to pay any such amounts to QAD, we suggest that you direct this discussion to [SaleCo 2].For the reasons set out above, we will not discuss the payment of a fee to QAD to effect an assignment/transfer of the Agreements/relevant licence(s). However, as already mentioned, we are willing to discuss a suitable customer support arrangement with you over the coming weeks. Mr Rifai stated that he wrote the letter without being aware of the content of Mr Read’s email of 4 November. Mr Read responded to Mr Rifai’s letter later that day indicating that “QAD Legal” refuted SPC’s position, forwarding an email from QAD Legal which included the comment that SPC’s “unlicensed use … constitutes infringement of QAD intellectual property rights”. On 3 December 2019, Mr Zarb made a presentation to the SPC board which the board accepted. The presentation recommended Fusion 5’s Microsoft Dynamics 365 solution. It recorded: “600k QAD Claim needs to be accounted for”. On 10 December 2019, QAD’s lawyers, King & Wood Mallesons, sent a letter to SPC referring to Mr Rifai’s letter of 27 November 2019 and SPC’s “unlicensed use” of QAD’s software. The letter stated that “since the purchase [SPC] has been using the software without a licence” and that “[SPC] requires a licence to use the Software”. The letter set out, under the heading “Options for resolution”, the following:As discussed on our call, there are a number of options available to resolve this issue. These are detailed below. For your information, QAD prices its software and services on a “per user” (sometimes called a “per seat”) arrangement, depending on the number of users. We understand that [SPC] has approximately 220 users, and the figures below are calculated on that basis. If there are more or less than 220 users, then the numbers below will change.•Option 1: Purchase of a new licence for the Software to allow [SPC] to continue to use the Software. QAD is prepared to backdate this licence to 1 July 2019 at no additional charge. QAD requires that [SPC] enter into a maintenance contract with QAD for the period from 1 July 2019 to 30 June 2020, and this arrangement can be renewed each year if [SPC] so wishes. For this option, QAD would charge [SPC] the regular list price that is charged to other customers in Australia as if [SPC] was a new customer. Cost: A$1,147,041.50, per the enclosed QAD quote.•Option 2: The same arrangement as option 1, except that QAD is prepared to recognise that [SPC] acquired the business from [SaleCo 2], and is therefore willing to make a special deal for licence and maintenance which takes advantage of the fact [SaleCo 2] was a prior customer. Cost: A$680,210.19, per the enclosed QAD quote. This option is open for acceptance until 20 December 2019 only.•Option 3: The same arrangement as option 2, but QAD is willing to apply the licence fee and prepaid and unused maintenance fee as a credit against a qualifying cloud arrangement that it entered into between QAD and [SPC] on or before 31 January 2020. A “qualifying cloud arrangement” is one that has a minimum initial term of two years, a 220-user subscription level at QAD list price, and is covered by a standard QAD Cloud Services Agreement. We recommend contacting QAD’s commercial team to discuss this option in greater detail The pricing above includes GST.