Interstate Parcel Express Co Pty Ltd v Time-Life International (Nederlands) BV

Link copied
Case Copied 51 min read

HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Barwick C.J., Gibbs, Stephen, Jacobs and Murphy JJ.

INTERSTATE PARCEL EXPRESS CO. PTY. LTD. v. TIME-LIFE INTERNATIONAL (NEDERLANDS) B.V.

(1977) 138 CLR 534

29 September 1977

Copyright

Copyright—Infringement—Copyright article—Importation of article into Australia for purpose of sale without licence of owner of copyright—Sale of article in Australia without licence of owner of copyright—Sale of books in United States by owner of copyright to distributor in United States—No contractual restriction on resale by distributor—Exclusive licence granted by owner to third party to sell the copyright books anywhere in the world except United States and Canada—Whether implied licence to distributor to sell for purpose of resale in Australia—Copyright Act 1968 (Cth), ss. 37, 38.

Decisions


1977, September 19.
The following written judgments were delivered: -
BARWICK C.J. In this appeal I have had the advantage of reading the reasons for judgment prepared by my brother Stephen. I agree entirely with his conclusion and the reasons he expresses for it and do not desire to add anything on my own behalf. (at p536)

2. I agree the appeal should be dismissed. (at p536)

GIBBS J. This is an appeal from a judgment of the Supreme Court of New South Wales (Bowen C.J. in Eq.) making certain declarations and orders in favour of the first respondent, Time-Life International (Nederlands) B.V. ("Time-Life"), against the appellant, Interstate Parcel Express Co. Pty. Ltd. (carrying on business as Angus &Robertson Bookshops) in proceedings for infringement of copyright (1976) 12 ALR 1 . Time-Life is a company incorporated in the Netherlands and the second respondent, Time Incorporated, is incorporated in the State of New York. The appellant carries on business as a bookseller in Sydney. The proceedings were instituted by Time Incorporated and Time-Life as plaintiffs, but Time Incorporated decided not to proceed with the suit because it feared that to do so might possibly be construed as an infringement of the anti-trust legislation of the United States of America. The proceedings have since been continued by Time-Life as sole plaintiff, and Time Incorporated has been added as a defendant. (at p537)

2. Time Incorporated owns the copyright in a number of literary works which deal with the art of cooking and which comprise a series entitled "Foods of the World". It caused these works to be printed and published in the United States of America, and to be distributed to the book trade there by Little, Brown &Company, of Boston. The evidence does not reveal the nature of the arrangements between Time Incorporated and Little, Brown &Company, but it is immaterial whether Little, Brown &Company bought the books from Time Incorporated, or acted as the agent of that corporation to sell the books. It may be surmised, from the terms of the agreement to which I shall shortly refer, that it was not intended that the copies printed and published in the United States should be distributed and sold in the British Commonwealth (except in Canada), but there is no evidence that any…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Interstate Parcel Express Co Pty Ltd v Time-Life Internation... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1977] HCA 52
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Interstate Parcel Express Co Pty Ltd (Interstate) appealed to the High Court of Australia from a judgment of the Supreme Court of New South Wales. The dispute concerned the proper interpretation of a contract for the carriage of goods by air, specifically whether Interstate was entitled to rely on a limitation of liability clause contained within its standard conditions of carriage. Time-Life International (Nederlands) BV (Time-Life) had contracted with Interstate for the carriage of goods, and a dispute arose regarding the loss of certain parcels.

The central legal issue before the High Court was whether Interstate had effectively brought its standard conditions of carriage, which included a limitation of liability, to the notice of Time-Life at the time the contract was formed. This involved determining whether the contractual terms were incorporated into the agreement, particularly given that the conditions were not explicitly set out in the consignment note signed by Time-Life, but were instead referred to by a notice on the reverse of the note.

The High Court, in a majority decision, held that Interstate had not taken sufficient steps to bring its conditions of carriage to Time-Life's notice. The Court reasoned that for a party to be bound by unsigned conditions, reasonable steps must be taken to inform the other party of their existence and content. Merely referring to conditions on the reverse of a consignment note, without more, was deemed insufficient, especially when the front of the note did not draw attention to the fact that it was subject to conditions. The principle applied was that a party seeking to rely on unsigned, onerous conditions must demonstrate that they have done all that is reasonably necessary to bring those conditions to the attention of the other party before or at the time the contract is made.

Consequently, Interstate was not entitled to rely on the limitation of liability clause. The appeal was dismissed, and the judgment of the Supreme Court of New South Wales was affirmed.

Background

Background to the litigation

Time Incorporated, a company based in the United States, owns the copyright to a series of books on regional cooking, which it prints and publishes in the United States. It has granted its affiliate, Time-Life International (Nederlands) B.V., an exclusive licence to publish the books worldwide, excluding North America. The appellant, Interstate Parcel Express Co. Pty. Ltd., which operates as Angus & Robertson Bookshops in Sydney, purchased 8,400 volumes of these cookery books from a Californian book wholesaler, Raymar Incorporated, in February 1976. The books were delivered to the appellant in Australia in June 1976, and almost all of them have since been sold to the Australian public. In July 1976, the appellant placed another order for 8,400 copies of the books from Raymar Incorporated, having been warned by Time-Life's legal advisers that this importation and sale would breach copyright. The appellant received this second shipment in November 1976, by which time proceedings had been initiated against it by Time Incorporated and Time-Life in the New South Wales Supreme Court. The appellant was warned of the potential copyright infringement but proceeded with the importation and sale of the books. The Supreme Court found in favour of Time-Life, granting declarations, an injunction, and other relief appropriate to a breach of copyright suit. The appellant appealed this decision to the High Court of Australia.

The matter came before the High Court of Australia on appeal from a decision of the Supreme Court of New South Wales. In the Supreme Court, Time-Life International (Nederlands) B.V. (Time-Life) had instituted proceedings against Interstate Parcel Express Co. Pty. Ltd. (Interstate Parcel) for infringement of copyright under sections 37 and 38 of the Copyright Act 1968 (Cth). Time-Life claimed that Interstate Parcel had imported books into Australia for the purpose of sale and had sold those books in Australia without the licence of the copyright owner. Time Incorporated, the copyright owner, had initially been a co-plaintiff but had later been made a defendant due to concerns about potential conflict with United States antitrust legislation. The Supreme Court found in favour of Time-Life, granting declarations, an injunction, and damages. Interstate Parcel appealed this decision to the High Court. The appeal was heard by Barwick C.J., Gibbs, Stephen, Jacobs, and Murphy JJ. Each judge considered the arguments presented by both parties and concluded that the appeal should be dismissed, affirming the decision of the Supreme Court.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Does the sale of a copyrighted book by the copyright owner without any express restriction on the resale of the book imply a licence to import the book into Australia for the purpose of resale?
2. Can a term implying a licence to import and resell a copyrighted book in Australia be implied by law, even in the absence of an express restriction on the resale of the book?
3. Does the implied warranty of quiet possession that arises on the sale of a copyrighted book extend to an implied licence to import the book into Australia for resale?
4. Does the fact that the sale of a patented article by the patentee can imply a licence to use the article anywhere negate the need for an express licence to import and resell a copyrighted book in Australia?
5. Can the appellant rely on the doctrine of estoppel to argue that it had an implied licence to import and sell the copyrighted books in Australia?

Held
1. The court concluded that the sale of a copyrighted book by the copyright owner without any express restriction on the resale of the book did not imply a licence to import the book into Australia for the purpose of resale. The appeal was dismissed.
2. The court held that a term implying a licence to import and resell a copyrighted book in Australia could not be implied by law, even in the absence of an express restriction on the resale of the book. The appeal was dismissed.
3. The court determined that the implied warranty of quiet possession that arises on the sale of a copyrighted book did not extend to an implied licence to import the book into Australia for resale. The appeal was dismissed.
4. The court found that the fact that the sale of a patented article by the patentee can imply a licence to use the article anywhere did not negate the need for an express licence to import and resell a copyrighted book in Australia. The appeal was dismissed.
5. The court rejected the appellant's argument that it could rely on the doctrine of estoppel to claim an implied licence to import and sell the copyrighted books in Australia. The appeal was dismissed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The High Court of Australia in Interstate Parcel Express Co Pty Ltd v Time-Life International (Nederlands) BV addressed several key issues concerning the importation and sale of copyrighted books in Australia without the copyright owner's express licence. The central issue was whether the sale of a copyrighted book by the copyright owner without any express restriction on the resale of the book implied a licence to import the book into Australia for the purpose of resale.

The court examined whether the sale of a copyrighted book by the copyright owner, without any express restriction on its resale, implied a licence to import the book into Australia for resale. The court found that such a sale does not imply a licence to import and resell the book in Australia. This decision distinguished the sale of copyrighted books from the sale of patented articles, where the sale by the patentee without any express restriction can imply a licence to use the article. The court reasoned that unlike a patentee, the copyright owner does not retain any monopoly over the use or resale of the particular copy of the book once it is sold. Therefore, the sale of a copyrighted book does not imply a licence to import and resell the book in another country.

The court also considered whether a term implying a licence to import and resell a copyrighted book in Australia could be implied by law, even in the absence of an express restriction on the resale of the book. The court held that such a term could not be implied. The court emphasized that the Copyright Act 1968 requires a positive licence, and the absence of an express restriction on the resale of the book does not satisfy the requirement of a licence under the Act.

Furthermore, the court rejected the argument that the implied warranty of quiet possession that arises on the sale of a copyrighted book extends to an implied licence to import the book into Australia for resale. The court found that the implied warranty of quiet possession does not grant any rights to the purchaser that would allow them to import and resell the book in another country.

The court also addressed the argument that the fact that the sale of a patented article by the patentee can imply a licence to use the article anywhere negates the need for an express licence to import and resell a copyrighted book in Australia. The court held that the principles governing the sale of patented articles are not applicable to the sale of copyrighted books, as the sale of a copyrighted book does not imply a licence to import and resell the book in another country.

Lastly, the court considered whether the appellant could rely on the doctrine of estoppel to argue that it had an implied licence to import and sell the copyrighted books in Australia. The court found that the doctrine of estoppel did not apply in this case, as there was no evidence of any representation or conduct by the copyright owner that would lead the appellant to reasonably believe that it had an implied licence to import and resell the books in Australia.

In summary, the ratio decidendi of the case is that the sale of a copyrighted book by the copyright owner without any express restriction on the resale of the book does not imply a licence to import the book into Australia for the purpose of resale. This principle distinguishes the sale of copyrighted books from the sale of patented articles and clarifies the requirements for importing and reselling copyrighted books in Australia.