Austshade Pty Ltd v Boss Shade Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 82 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Austshade Pty Ltd v Boss Shade Pty Ltd [2016] FCA 287

File number: QUD 189 of 2012
Judge: DOWSETT J
Date of judgment: 23 March 2016
Catchwords:

INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY  – where licence to sell goods subject of patent and registered design was terminated – enforceability of registered design

PATENTS – patent exhaustion – restrictive conditions on license to deal with patented property – purchasers title to patented chattels – purchasers knowledge of restrictive conditions on patented property – infringement – sham transaction – patent infringement –modification of infringing product –

COPYRIGHT – copyright in photographs published online – whether photographs published online infringe copyright

Legislation:

Copyright Act 1968 (Cth) s 37, s 38

Designs Act 2003 (Cth) s 10, s 73

Patents Act 1990 (Cth) s 13, 117, s 120(1A)

Patents Act 1952 (Cth)

Sale of Goods Act 1896 (Qld)  s 19, s 20, s 21

Cases cited:

Betts v Willmott (1871) LR 6 Ch 239

Fresenius Medical Care Australia Pty Ltd v Gambro Pty Ltd (2005) 67 IPR 230

Interstate Parcel Express Co Pty Ltd v Time-Life International (Nederlands) BV (1977) 138 CLR 534

National Phonograph Co of Australia Ltd v Menck (1911) 12 CLR 15

Raftland Pty Ltd v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (2008) 238 CLR 516

Secured Income Real Estate (Australia) Ltd v St Martins Investments Pty Ltd (1979) 144 CLR 596

Date of hearing: 23 and 24 March 2015
Registry: Queensland
Division: General Division
National Practice Area: Intellectual Property
Sub-area: Patents and associated Statutes
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 132
Counsel for the Applicants: Mr A Musgrave
Solicitor for the Applicants: Burns & Associates
Solicitor for the Respondents: Mr M Byrne of Lillas & Loel Lawyers
Table of Corrections
2 June 2016 In paragraph 51, “of which 10 were given to Austshade leaving 157 umbrellas” has been replaced with “of which 10 were given to Austshade leaving 166 umbrellas”
2 June 2016 In paragraph 51, “9 December 2011” has been replaced with “9 December 2010”.
2 June 2016 In paragraph 54, “30 November 2011” has been replaced with “30 November 2010”.
2 June 2016 In paragraph 54, “9 December 2011” has been replaced with “9 December 2010”.

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

QUD 189 of 2012
BETWEEN:

AUSTSHADE PTY LTD ACN 066 409 247

First Applicant

EKKEHARD SIEGFRIED HARTMUT KOEHN

Second Applicant

AND:

BOSS SHADE PTY LTD ACN 115 280 272

First Respondent

BAUER INVESTMENTS PTY LTD ACN 010 865 068

Second Respondent

HOLGER BAUER (and others named in the Schedule)

Third Respondent

JUDGE:

DOWSETT J

INTRODUCTION

  1. At all material times the second applicant (“Mr Koehn”), was the sole director of the first applicant (“Austshade”).  Mr Koehn was and is:

    (1)patentee of Australian standard patent 2003204148 (the “2003 Patent”);

    (2)patentee of Australian innovation patent 2012100717 (the “Innovation Patent”); and

    (3)owner of Australian registered design 200717590 (the “Registered Design”).

  2. The third respondent (“Mr Holger Bauer”), was the sole director and company secretary of the first respondent (“Boss Shade”), formerly Revolva Shade Pty Ltd.  He was…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Austshade Pty Ltd v Boss Shade Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] FCA 287
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Austshade Pty Ltd v Boss Shade Pty Ltd involved a dispute between Austshade and Boss Shade over the enforceability of a registered design and patent rights. The dispute centred around a licence agreement that permitted Boss Shade to sell goods that were the subject of a patent and registered design. This licence was terminated, leading to claims by Austshade that Boss Shade had infringed the patent and design by modifying the products and selling them post-termination. The case was heard by the Federal Court of Australia, which had to determine the enforceability of the registered design and patent rights, the impact of the modifications made by Boss Shade, and whether the sale of the modified products constituted infringement.

The court was tasked with resolving several legal issues, including the extent to which the termination of the licence agreement affected the rights of the parties, particularly regarding the sale of products that were already in Boss Shade's possession. The court also had to consider whether the modifications made by Boss Shade to the products constituted infringement of the patent and registered design, and if the purchasers of these modified products could acquire title to the patented goods. Another issue was whether the sale of these products constituted a sham transaction, and if Boss Shade's actions amounted to patent infringement. Additionally, the court needed to address whether the sale of photographs online infringed the copyright held by Austshade.

The court found that the termination of the licence did not affect the rights of the purchasers of the products already in Boss Shade's possession, who could continue to sell the products until the specified date. The court also determined that the modifications made by Boss Shade did not infringe the patent or registered design, as the changes did not materially affect the patented or designed features. The court concluded that the sale of the modified products was not a sham transaction and did not constitute patent infringement. Furthermore, the court found that the sale of photographs online did not infringe the copyright held by Austshade, as the photographs were not published in a manner that constituted an infringement.

The court dismissed Austshade's claims, finding no basis for the infringement allegations. The court also allowed the parties to make submissions on appropriate orders and costs. The court noted that Boss Shade owed royalties to Austshade for the sale of certain umbrellas, but since no claim for these royalties was made, the court invited the parties to make submissions on this matter. The court emphasised that if any party required further findings of fact, they should apply within 14 days of the publication of the reasons. The court granted liberty to apply for further orders.

Background

Background to the litigation

Austshade Pty Ltd, the owner of a patent and registered design for an umbrella, terminated its licence agreement with Boss Shade Pty Ltd, effective from 24 January 2011. The termination allowed Boss Shade to sell the relevant umbrellas until 24 July 2011. Following the termination, Boss Shade modified the design of the umbrellas and continued to sell them. Austshade alleged that these modified umbrellas infringed the 2003 Patent, the Innovation Patent, and the Registered Design. Additionally, Austshade claimed that Boss Shade infringed copyright in photographs published online. Boss Shade argued that the modifications did not infringe the patents or registered design and that the online photographs did not infringe copyright.

This case came before the court as an application for relief regarding the enforceability of the terminated licence and alleged infringements. The matter involved a review of the licence agreement, the modifications made to the umbrellas by Boss Shade, and the alleged copyright infringement. Prior to this hearing, there had been no significant court decisions or proceedings directly addressing the current claims. The court had to determine the enforceability of the registered design and whether the modified umbrellas and online photographs constituted infringements.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The respondents accept that the licence was terminated on 24 January 2011. As a result, Boss Shade could, pursuant to cl 6.4 of the deed, sell the relevant umbrellas until 24 July 2011.APPLICANTS’ EVIDENCE Mr Koehn has sworn two affidavits in this matter:·an affidavit filed on 30 April 2013, found at tab 10 of the trial book; and·an affidavit filed on 13 June 2013, found at tab 11 of the trial book. Much of the material dealt with in his affidavits has been dealt with in the statement of agreed facts. The balance of his evidence is best dealt with in other parts of these reasons. That evidence concerned:·the effect of a certain modification by Boss Shade of the umbrellas which it was permitted to sell;·the number of such umbrellas held by Boss Shade on and after the date of the deed;·the provenance of the copyright photographs;·the question of whether sale of the modified umbrellas infringed the 2003 Patent, the Innovation Patent or the Registered Design; and·the material which is said to infringe the copyright in the copyright photographs. Much of Mr Koehn’s evidence‑in‑chief is otherwise as to formal matters. His cross‑examination focussed on the effect of the modification of the umbrellas and the nature of the payment to him by Mr Holger Bauer or Boss Shade of the sum of $24,850. As I have said, I shall deal with those matters later in these reasons. For present purposes, it is sufficient to say that his evidence concerning those matters was unsatisfactory. To the extent that I have formed any view as to his credibility that view is based on all of the evidence in the case. However those two factors are of particular importance. In the end, his credibility is relevant only in connection with the effect of the modification. The applicants also rely upon two affidavits by Mr Philp, the applicants’ solicitor. Those affidavits are primarily concerned with searches conducted by Mr Philp, the history of proceedings and relevant correspondence. The applicants also rely upon the affidavit of Mr Frank Lee. He is a professional photographer, now retired. He was engaged by Mr Koehn to take photographs of umbrellas, copies of which he annexes to his affidavit. The photographs were taken on 11 June 2008. Mr Lee’s services were billed to Austshade. At some time before October 2008, Mr Lee performed “photo‑shopping” procedures on the relevant photographic files and sent the altered images to Austshade. On 7 December 2011, he sent a letter to Mr and Mrs Koehn in which he stated that he transferred to Austshade ownership of all of the photographs taken on 21 October 2008. He later decided that he had taken the photographs on 11 June 2008 and amended the date accordingly. He also signed a separate document, described as a “confirmation of copyright assignment”. He has no recollection of Mr Holger Bauer, or anybody on his behalf being involved in giving instructions concerning the photographs or any of the other work performed by him in connection with them.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The claim in para 51 depends upon the facts alleged in paras 43‑50. Those paragraphs allege infringement of the 2003 Patent, the Innovation Patent and the Registered Design. I have rejected those claims. It again follows that there is no proper basis for ordering an account.CONCLUSION The statement of claim is quite complex and difficult to follow. I may have overlooked some aspect of it. Should the parties require further findings of fact, they should apply within 14 days after the publication of these reasons. Subject to that possibility, I am presently of the view that the application should be dismissed. However I shall allow the parties to make submissions as to appropriate orders and as to costs. I have expressed the view that Boss Shade owes Mr Koehn or Austshade the royalties payable on the sale of a number of umbrellas. However there is no claim for any such amount. The parties may, if they wish, make submissions concerning that matter. Submissions should be exchanged and forwarded to the Court within 14 days of the publication of these reasons. There will be liberty to apply.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the validity of the termination of the licence agreement, noting that Boss Shade could sell the relevant umbrellas until 24 July 2011 as per clause 6.4 of the deed. The court assessed the evidence provided by Mr Koehn regarding the modifications made by Boss Shade to the umbrellas and concluded that these modifications did not infringe the 2003 Patent, the Innovation Patent, or the Registered Design. The court also found that the sale of the modified umbrellas by Boss Shade did not infringe Austshade's intellectual property rights. Lastly, the court examined the online publication of certain photographs and determined that they did not infringe the copyright owned by Austshade. The court rejected claims regarding infringement of the 2003 Patent, the Innovation Patent, and the Registered Design, and dismissed the application. The ratio decidendi of this decision is that the termination of the licence agreement was enforceable, and the modifications and sales made by Boss Shade did not infringe Austshade's intellectual property rights. The court did not find infringement in the online publication of photographs, and thus dismissed the application.