Re: MULTICOIN AMUSEMENTS PTY LTD and BRITISH AMUSEMENTS (NORTH COAST)
CORPORATION PTY LIMITED
And: AVEL PTY LTD
No. Q G67 of 1989
FED No. 830
Copyright
COURT
IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
QUEENSLAND DISTRICT REGISTRY
GENERAL DIVISION
Lockhart(1), Wilcox(1) and Spender(1) JJ.
CATCHWORDS
Copyright - Importation and sale of pinball machines manufactured in America - Copyright in machines vested in United States manufacturer - Respondent Australian distributor of certain models of the machines but limited to machines intended by the manufacturer for sale in Australia - Importation by appellants of used machines of the relevant models, those machines being purchased from companies independent of the manufacturer - Threats by respondent of legal proceedings to restrain appellants with importation and sale - Threats sought to be justified on the basis that respondent was an "exclusive licensee" of the copyright entitled to "publish" the copyright in Australia - Breach of s.37 of Copyright Act alleged - Whether respondent was an "exclusive licensee" of the copyright - Whether respondent had proved that importation was without the consent of the copyright owner.
Copyright Act 1968 ss.10, 31, 37, 115, 119, 202.
HEARING
BRISBANE
#DATE 20:12:1989
Counsel for the Appellants: Mr K T Kilvington
Solicitors for the Appellants: Greg Kelly and Company
Counsel for the Respondent: Mr D Jackson
Solicitors for the Respondent: Chambers McNab Tully & Wilson
ORDER
1. The appeal be allowed.
2. The orders made by the Supreme Court of Queensland on
29 June 1989 be set aside and in lieu thereof it be ordered that:
(a) a declaration be made that the conduct of the defendant in threatening the plaintiffs with an action or proceeding in respect of an infringement of copyright concerning used Williams' pinball machines was unjustifiable;
(b) the defendant by itself, its servants and agents, be restrained from renewing or repeating any threat to institute an action or proceeding against the plaintiffs or either of them in respect of an infringement of copyright concerning used Williams' pinball machines;
(c) judgment be entered for the first plaintiff against the defendant for damages in the sum of eighty-eight thousand five hundred and sixty-five dollars ($88,565);
(d) judgment be entered for the second plaintiff against the defendant for damages in the sum of two thousand three hundred and thirty dollars ($2,330);
(e) the counter-claim be dismissed;
(f) the defendant pay the costs of the plaintiffs, both in respect of the action and counter-claim.
3. The cross-appeal be dismissed.
4. The respondent pay to the appellants their costs of
the appeal and cross-appeal.
Note: Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.
JUDGE1
This case concerns the entitlement of the appellants, Multicoin Amusements Pty Ltd ("Multicoin") and British Amusements (North Coast) Corporation Pty Limited ("British Amusements") to import into, and to sell within, Australia certain models of used pinball machines manufactured by an American company, Williams Electronics Games Inc ("Williams").
The background facts
The respondent, Avel Pty Ltd ("Avel"), which trades as Leisure…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Multicoin Amusements Pty Ltd v Avel Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1989] FCA 830
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court determined that Avel was not an "exclusive licensee" of the copyright, as the machines were purchased from independent companies, not the manufacturer. Therefore, Avel's threats were unjustified. The court further found that Avel had failed to prove that the importation was without the consent of the copyright owner. Consequently, Avel's threats to take legal action against Multicoin for importing and selling used pinball machines were deemed unjustifiable. The court set aside the Supreme Court's orders and substituted them with new orders declaring Avel's threats unjustifiable, restraining Avel from repeating such threats, and awarding damages to the plaintiffs. The counter-claim was dismissed, and Avel was ordered to pay the costs of the proceedings.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. The appeal be allowed.
2. The orders made by the Supreme Court of Queensland on
29 June 1989 be set aside and in lieu thereof it be ordered that:
(a) a declaration be made that the conduct of the defendant in threatening the plaintiffs with an action or proceeding in respect of an infringement of copyright concerning used Williams' pinball machines was unjustifiable;
(b) the defendant by itself, its servants and agents, be restrained from renewing or repeating any threat to institute an action or proceeding against the plaintiffs or either of them in respect of an infringement of copyright concerning used Williams' pinball machines;
(c) judgment be entered for the first plaintiff against the defendant for damages in the sum of eighty-eight thousand five hundred and sixty-five dollars ($88,565);
(d) judgment be entered for the second plaintiff against the defendant for damages in the sum of two thousand three hundred and thirty dollars ($2,330);
(e) the counter-claim be dismissed;
(f) the defendant pay the costs of the plaintiffs, both in respect of the action and counter-claim.
3. The cross-appeal be dismissed.
4. The respondent pay to the appellants their costs of
the appeal and cross-appeal.
Note: Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.
Background
Background to the litigation
The matter initially came before the Supreme Court of Queensland, which found in favour of Avel and against the appellants on several points, including the unjustifiability of the threats made by Avel. The appellants then appealed to the Federal Court of Australia. The Federal Court heard the appeal and also considered a cross-appeal by Avel against the orders made by the Supreme Court. The court examined the evidence and arguments presented by both parties, focusing on whether Avel was indeed an "exclusive licensee" of the copyright and whether the importation of used pinball machines by the appellants was without the consent of the copyright owner, Williams.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether Avel was an "exclusive licensee" of the copyright in the pinball machines.
2. Whether Avel had proved that the importation of used pinball machines by the appellants was without the consent of the copyright owner, Williams.
3. Whether the threats made by Avel to the appellants were justifiable.
Held
1. The court concluded that Avel was not an "exclusive licensee" of the copyright in the pinball machines. The result was that the appeal was allowed on this ground.
2. The court found that Avel had not proved that the importation of used pinball machines by the appellants was without the consent of the copyright owner, Williams. The result was that the orders made by the Supreme Court of Queensland were set aside and replaced with the new orders specified in the judgment.
3. The court held that the threats made by Avel to the appellants were unjustifiable. The result was that Avel was restrained from renewing or repeating any threats to institute an action or proceeding against the appellants in respect of an infringement of copyright concerning used Williams' pinball machines.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Court of Appeal began by examining the nature of Avel's rights as the Australian distributor of the pinball machines. Avel argued that as an "exclusive licensee," it had the right to prevent the importation and sale of used machines, a right which the Court was asked to uphold. The Court found that Avel's rights were limited to the sale of new machines intended for the Australian market, and not extended to used machines. This interpretation of Avel's licensing agreement was grounded in the express terms of the agreement and the absence of any provision that would allow Avel to control used machines. Consequently, Avel was not an "exclusive licensee" in the sense required to justify its threats against the appellants.
Turning to the second issue, the Court considered whether Avel had demonstrated that the appellants' importation of used pinball machines was without Williams' consent. The Court found that Avel had not proved this element of its case. The appellants had purchased the used machines from companies independent of Williams, and there was no evidence that Williams had prohibited the sale or importation of these used machines. The Court held that Avel's argument that it could prevent the sale of used machines by virtue of its exclusive licensing agreement failed, as the agreement did not extend to used machines.
Finally, the Court addressed the issue of the justifiability of Avel's threats. The Court concluded that Avel's threats were unjustifiable as they were not based on any legal right to control the importation and sale of used machines. The Court emphasised that Avel's conduct was not only without basis in law but also constituted an abuse of process. This conclusion was based on the Court's earlier findings that Avel's licensing agreement did not confer the rights Avel claimed and that the importation of used machines did not infringe on those rights. The Court's decision established that exclusive licensing agreements must be strictly interpreted and that threats made without a legal basis are unjustifiable, regardless of the intentions of the party making the threats.