Chhabra v McPherson as Trustee for the McPherson Practice Trust

Link copied
Case Copied 55 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Chhabra v McPherson as Trustee for the McPherson Practice Trust
[2019] FCAFC 228

Appeal from: Chhabra v McPherson as Trustee for the McPherson Practice Trust [2018] FCA 1755; (2018) 138 IPR 1
File numbers: NSD 2266 of 2018
Judges: GREENWOOD, CHARLESWORTH AND BURLEY JJ
Date of judgment: 13 December 2019
Catchwords: INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY – copyright – appeal from orders dismissing an application for damages for infringement of copyright subsisting in a logo – whether first appellant was the sole owner of the copyright – whether, as co-owner, the first appellant could revoke a licence previously granted jointly by the co-owners to the respondents – whether the licence was revocable at will – whether licence previously granted to the respondents was revoked on the facts – no appealable error – appeal dismissed
Legislation:

Copyright Act 1968 (Cth) ss 10, 30, 35, 196, 197

Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988 (UK) s 91

Copyright (International Protection) Regulations 1969 (Cth) reg 4

Electronic Transactions Act 1999 (Cth) s 10

Cases cited:

Acorn Computers Ltd v MCS Microcomputer Systems Pty Ltd (1984) 6 FCR 277

Chhabra v McPherson as Trustee for the McPherson Practice Trust [2018] FCA 1755; (2018) 138 IPR 1

Computermate Products (Aust) Pty Ltd v Ozi-Soft Pty Ltd (1988) 20 FCR 46

Patten v Thomas Motors Pty Ltd (1965) 66 SR (NSW) 458

Prior v Lansdowne Press Pty Ltd (1975) 29 FLR 59

Robert J Zupanovich Pty Ltd v B & N Beale Nominees Pty Ltd (1995) 59 FCR 49

Seven Network (Operations) Ltd v TCN Channel Nine Pty Ltd (2005) 146 FCR 183

Trumpet Software Pty Ltd v Ozemail Pty Ltd (1996) 34 IPR 481

Waltons Stores (Interstate) Ltd v Maher (1988) 164 CLR 387

Davies G, Caddick N, Harbottle G, Copinger and Skone James on Copyright (17th ed Sweet & Maxwell 2016) Vol 1

The Laws of Australia (Thomson Reuters subscription service)

Date of hearing: 29 May 2019
Date of last submissions: 29 May 2019
Registry: New South Wales
Division: General Division
National Practice Area: Intellectual Property
Sub-area: Copyright and Industrial Designs
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 107
Counsel for the Appellants: Mr M Green SC with Ms R White
Solicitor for the Appellants: MinterEllison
Counsel for the Respondents: Mr A Crowe QC with Mr B Gardiner
Solicitor for the Respondents: DWF

ORDERS

NSD 2266 of 2018
BETWEEN:

SUNIL LAL CHHABRA

First Appellant

KIRAN CHANDRA RAMRAKHA

Second Appellant

AND:

JAMIE ANGUS JOHN MCPHERSON AS TRUSTEE FOR THE MCPHERSON PRACTICE TRUST

First Respondent

DAMIEN IGNATIUS ARNOLD LAMBERT VAN BRUNSCHOT AS TRUSTEE FOR THE VB PRACTICE TRUST

Second Respondent

JUDGES:

GREENWOOD, CHARLESWORTH AND BURLEY JJ

DATE OF ORDER:

13 December 2019

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The appeal is dismissed.

2.The appellants pay the respondents’ costs of the appeal.

Note:   Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

THE COURT:

  1. The two respondents, Jamie McPherson and Damien van Brunschot are partners in a law firm…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Chhabra v McPherson as Trustee for the McPherson Practice Tr... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] FCAFC 228
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Chhabra v McPherson as Trustee for the McPherson Practice Trust involves a dispute over the ownership and licensing of copyright subsisting in a logo. The appellants, Sunil Lal and Hemant Batra, sought damages for infringement of copyright against the respondents, including McPherson and associated entities. The central issue was whether the first appellant, Sunil Lal, was the sole owner of the copyright in the Kaden Boriss logo and whether he could revoke a licence previously granted by both co-owners to the respondents. Another issue was whether the licence was revocable at will and if it was indeed revoked on the facts presented.

The court found that the primary judge's determination that the email from Hemant Batra to Sunil Lal on 4 August 2010 did not constitute an effective assignment of future copyright, as required by sections 196 and 197 of the Copyright Act, was correct. The email did not explicitly assign the copyright to Sunil Lal, and there was insufficient evidence to conclude that an assignment was intended. Furthermore, the court upheld the finding that the licence granted to the respondents was irrevocable, as it was considered a contractual obligation that bound successors in title. The appeal was dismissed as there was no appealable error found in the primary judge's reasoning and conclusions.

The final orders of the court were that the appeal be dismissed and that the appellants pay the respondents’ costs of the appeal. This outcome underscores the importance of clear and unequivocal language in agreements concerning the assignment of intellectual property rights, as well as the enforceability of irrevocable licences.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal is dismissed.

2. The appellants pay the respondents’ costs of the appeal.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

It follows that the appeal must be dismissed.FACTS The findings of fact bearing on the outcome of the appeal are for the most part unchallenged. The critical events are as follows.2010 discussions In 2010 Mr Lal commenced discussions with Hemant Batra, the managing partner of a law firm in Delhi trading under the name Kaden Boriss Legal LLP. The discussions related to the creation of an international network of law firms. Mr Lal was then a partner of the Sydney law firm LBR Legal together with Mr Ramrakha. The discussions between Mr Lal and Mr Batra took place with Mr Ramrakha’s knowledge and consent. Mr Lal and Mr Batra approached the managing partner of a law firm based in Singapore, Chee Chun Woei (Mr Chee). Discussions then continued between Mr Lal, Mr Batra and Mr Chee to establish an alliance of firms. It appears that their initial discussions anticipated the involvement of a Kuwaiti firm of which Fayez Al Dosari (Mr Al Dosari) was a partner. On 24 July 2010 Mr Lal, Mr Chee and Mr Batra held a meeting in Singapore to discuss the network. The minutes of that meeting state that the attendees had the “unanimous” view that:a.That final aim/object should be to bring all the alliance members under one brand name.b.All the member firms should eventually be known by same common name.c.Using/adopting ‘Kaden Boriss’ brand name should be explored in light of the fact that it’s already part of top prestigious legal directories/law firm rating associations.d.If ‘Kaden Boriss’ brand name will be adopted, Hemant K Batra will have to transfer the brand to the alliance entity.e.Though, the brand name will be the property of the alliance entity; however its founder members i.e. Chee Chun Woei, Sunil Lal and Hemant K Batra (and Fayez Al Dosari, subject to confirmation) will have exclusive legal right/ownership/veto re: Singapore, Australia, India and Kuwait, respectively.f.The alliance entity will offer the following in lieu of membership subscription – brand name franchise, marketing, research assistance, IT-Connectivity and Auditing. The minutes go on to record 13 decisions said to have been made unanimously, namely:1.The alliance founder members shall be Chee Chun Woei, Hemant K Batra, Sunil Lal and (Fayez Al Dosari subject to confirmation).2.The alliance members shall agree upon a name for the proposed alliance by 3rd August 2010; all shall be free to suggest any name(s) by 1st August 2010; ‘Kaden Boriss’ shall be one of the name options.3.The alliance shall be established as a Singapore company by 7th August 2010 with Chee Chun Woei, Hemant K Batra, Sunil Lal and (Fayez Al Dosari subject to confirmation) as founder members/shareholders/promoters in equal proportion. Initially, each one will subscribe/pay for 1000 shares @ [US] $1 each.4.The first board of the alliance company shall comprise of Sunil Lal as Chairman & MD, Chee Chun Woei as Vice Chairman & Director, Hemant K Batra and (Fayez Al Dosari subject to confirmation) as Directors. Their term shall be initially for 1 year. Each founder/promoter will become CMD by rotation.5.The constitution and rules for the alliance and its membership shall be finalized by 7th August 2010. Hemant K Batra will circulate the existing draft of Orb Legal and any other relevant document in that respect.6.The initial budget for the alliance shall be worked out by Chee Chun Woei by 25th August 2010.7.Domain name(s) of the alliance name as finalized shall be registered by 7th August 2010.8.All the web sites maintained by the member law firms including those of founders shall become part of the alliance website.9.A road map and timeline shall be worked out soon to replace the names of the founder law firms with the name of the alliance.10.The membership fee for the alliance shall be as follows: US$2000 at the time of joining (US$1000 at the time of making application and US$1000 on admission) + US$500 per month. The founders shall pay only monthly fee of US$500. The said fee shall be for the principal office and in case of any additional office; the fee shall be US$250 per month additionally for each additional office.11.The alliance name shall be exclusive to the founders in their respective countries meaning thereby that no additional member can either be inducted or permitted to use the alliance name.12.Conference Call was scheduled for 30th July at Australia Time 6:PM; Hemant K Batra to provide for one common India no. for conference call.13. Draft Minutes to be prepared by Hemant K Batra.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

By [3] of their amended notice of appeal the appellants contend that the email from Mr Batra to Mr Lal of 4 August 2010, together with the Confirmatory Deed “meant that Mr Batra assigned his ownership of copyright to Mr Lal effective 29 September 2011”. It is alleged that, when read in conjunction with the minutes of the meeting dated 24 July 2010, “Mr Batra’s intention as to ownership of the Australian copyright is wholly apparent” and that the subsequent emails between Mr Batra and Mr Lal confirmed their respective intentions. The case as put in submissions is that his Honour erred by failing to determine in the appellants favour that by virtue of the 4 August 2010 email, and s 197 of the Copyright Act, the future copyright in the Kaden Boriss logos was placed by Mr Batra in the hands of Mr Lal. Upon the entry into the Confirmatory Deed on 12 January 2017 the automatic effect of the earlier agreement was that Mr Batra assigned his interest in the copyright to Mr Lal. The appellants submitted that the primary judge erred in determining that the 4 August 2010 email did not meet the requirements of s 196 or s 197 of the Copyright Act so as to constitute an effective assignment of future copyright vesting sole ownership in Mr Lal. Sole ownership in Mr Lal is said to have vested as and from 29 September 2011, the date on which the Confirmatory Deed took retrospective effect.Consideration Section 197 of the Copyright Act provides:197 Prospective ownership of copyright(1)Where, by an agreement made in relation to a future copyright and signed by or on behalf of the person who would, apart from this section, be the owner of the copyright on its coming into existence, that person purports to assign the future copyright (wholly or partially) to another person (in this subsection referred to as the assignee), then if, on the coming into existence of the copyright, the assignee or a person claiming under him or her would, apart from this subsection, be entitled as against all other persons to have the copyright vested in him or her (wholly or partially, as the case may be), the copyright, on its coming into existence, vests in the assignee or his or her successor in title by force of this subsection.(2)Where, at the time when a copyright comes into existence, the person who, if he or she were then living, would be entitled to the copyright is dead, the copyright devolves as if it had subsisted immediately before his or her death and he or she had then been the owner of the copyright.(3)A licence granted in respect of a future copyright by the prospective owner of the copyright binds every successor in title to the prospective interest in the copyright of the grantor of the licence to the same extent as the licence was binding on the grantor. The phrase “future copyright” in s 197(1) is defined in s 10(1) to mean “copyright to come into existence at a future time or upon the happening of a future event”. The primary judge rejected the appellants’ argument on two principal bases, each of which was sufficient. The first was that the 4 August 2010 email upon which the appellants relied did not on its terms purport to effect an assignment of copyright. The email, his Honour said, contained general assertions about the right to use a “brand” but said little about the ownership of copyright in an artistic work.