Seven Network (Operations) Ltd v TCN Channel Nine Pty Ltd
Link copied
CaseCopied
72 min read
Full text
FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Seven Network (Operations) Ltd v TCN Channel Nine Pty Ltd [2005] FCAFC 144
COPYRIGHT – cinematograph film – oral agreement between organiser of charitable undertaking and television station under which television station’s camera operator and sound recordist accompanied organiser and troubled youths on trek along Kokoda Track – under agreement, television station to televise short film of trek, on station’s news and current affairs program, and organiser to have raw footage subsequently for use to promote the charity – after program went to air, organiser handed tapes of raw footage as arranged – organiser taking tapes to film producer who makes a one-hour documentary, which is proposed to be televised by competitor television station – original television station seeks injunction on basis of threatened infringement of copyright – whether copyright in original raw footage co-owned by organiser and original television station – whether original television station had contracted to assign to organiser its interest in copyright or to grant him a licence – whether licence assignable – construction of oral contract – admissibility of extraneous circumstances – admissibility of party’s statements of its intention on an earlier occasion.
[14] The appellant contends that the primary judge erred in finding that the respondent had discharged the onus of establishing the matters required under the relevant provision.
[15] It was submitted that his Honour failed to give adequate weight to the evidence of the second witness, and that the findings of fact were not reasonably open on the material before the Court.
[16] The respondent, for its part, submits that no error is disclosed, and that the conclusions reached were well within the range of outcomes available to the primary judge.
Consideration
[17] It is convenient to deal first with the question of construction, as the resolution of that issue informs the remaining grounds advanced by the appellant.
[18] For the reasons that follow, we are of the view that the appeal should be allowed in part and the matter remitted for further determination.
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Seven Network (Operations) Ltd v TCN Channel Nine Pty Ltd and more:
Seven Network (Operations) Ltd, the appellant, sought to restrain TCN Channel Nine Pty Ltd, the respondent, from broadcasting a documentary made by Look Productions, a third party, which was filmed by employees of Seven using Seven's equipment. The dispute centred on whether Mr Murray, who led the Kokoda expedition, had the authority to allow Look Productions to broadcast the documentary based on an agreement reached with Seven's representatives in 2004. The primary judge had found in favour of Seven, but the respondents appealed the decision. The court had to determine the legal implications of the agreement between Seven and Mr Murray regarding the use of the footage from the Kokoda expedition.
The key legal issue was the interpretation of the agreement between Mr Murray and Mr McPherson of Seven. Specifically, the court had to determine whether the agreement allowed Mr Murray to authorise Look Productions to broadcast the documentary. The primary judge had found that the agreement allowed Mr Murray to use the footage for promotional purposes, such as DVDs, but not for broadcasting on a competing network. The appeal focused on the scope of the term "promotional purposes" and whether it extended to broadcasting on a competing television network. The court needed to interpret the agreement in light of the surrounding circumstances and the parties' intentions at the time of the agreement.
The court held that the agreement between Mr Murray and Mr McPherson did not permit Mr Murray to authorise the broadcasting of the documentary on a competing network. The court found that the term "promotional purposes" was limited to uses such as DVDs and did not extend to broadcasting. The court also noted that the context of the agreement, including Mr Murray's previous alignment with Seven and opposition to Nine, supported the conclusion that the broadcasting was outside the terms of the agreement. The court found that Mr Murray did not have the authority to allow Look Productions to broadcast the documentary on Nine.
The appeal was stood over to allow the parties to attempt to agree on the orders to be made. If the parties could not agree, they were required to submit their proposed orders and short submissions by a specified date. The court's decision clarified the scope of the agreement and affirmed Seven's rights regarding the use of the footage from the Kokoda expedition.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. The appeal be stood over to Tuesday, 9 August 2005 at 1.00 pm for the making of orders, including orders as to costs.
2. The parties attempt to agree on the orders to be made consistent with the reasons for judgment published today, and in the event that they have not reached agreement by 9.00 am on Tuesday, 9 August 2005, they submit, by email to each Judge’s Associate, the forms of order for which they will respectively contend and short submissions in support.
Note:
Background
Background to the litigation
The issue on this appeal is whether the third respondent (‘Mr Murray’) was entitled to authorise the fifth and sixth respondents (‘Look Productions’) to make a documentary from cinematograph film footage (‘footage’) taken on a trip to the Kokoda Trail in Papua New Guinea (‘the Kokoda expedition’) to be shown in a television broadcast by the first and second respondents (‘Nine’).BACKGROUND The background to this issue, in particular the events and the participants in those events, is set out in [3] to [50] of the reasons for judgment of the learned primary judge. In summary:(i)In 2003, the first appellant’s (Seven’s) ‘Today Tonight’ program had broadcast a story about a youth camp conducted by Mr Murray, under the banner ‘Camp Dare’, at Ulladulla on the New South Wales South Coast. Chris Simond (‘Mr Simond’), an employee of Seven, had been the reporter on that story. In late 2003, Mr Murray approached Mr Simond seeking to interest Seven in broadcasting a story about an expedition to the Kokoda Trail which Mr Murray, again under the Camp Dare banner, was proposing to arrange for a group of boys from Punchbowl Boys High School.(ii)After some correspondence, a meeting was held at Seven’s premises on 11 February 2004 between representatives of Seven on the one hand and Mr Murray and his Camp Dare supporters on the other. In attendance on the Seven side, were Mr Simond, Craig McPherson (Today Tonight’s executive producer) (‘Mr McPherson’), Stuart Shannon (a cameraman) (‘Mr Shannon’) and Matthew Lynch (sound recorder) (‘Mr Lynch’) who were both under contract to Seven. On the other side were Mr Murray, Ross Townhill (an accountant) (‘Mr Townhill’), Kevin Watt (a corporate consultant) (‘Mr Watt’) and Thomas Aguiler and Iain Cook (both involved in conducting youth camps).(iii)It is not in dispute that at that meeting Mr McPherson, on behalf of Seven, and Mr Murray reached an agreement in relation to their respective contributions, both financial and otherwise, to the Kokoda expedition and the filming of that expedition. The primary judge found that on any view, Mr McPherson committed Seven at that meeting to screening a piece on the Kokoda expedition on Today Tonight, although the length of the piece was undetermined. He also committed to sending Messrs Shannon and Lynch on the basis that all fares, accommodation and expenses including outfitting would be met by Mr Murray. Mr Murray raised the question of a one hour special documentary but Mr McPherson made it clear that that would be a decision for others to make and that it would be made in the light of the footage which came back [31].(iv)It is also not in dispute that at that meeting Mr McPherson, on behalf of Seven, and Mr Murray reached an agreement dealing with their respective rights as to use of the footage. What is disputed are the legal implications of that agreement, in particular and relevantly, ownership of copyright in the footage and the nature and extent, if it be relevant, of any derivative rights of user. (v)The expedition took place between 1 March and 9 March 2005. Mr Shannon recorded about 30 hours of film. Whilst Mr Murray, and no doubt others, contributed to decisions as to what would and would not be filmed, the primary judge was satisfied that Mr Shannon made and executed the decisions. The primary judge was also satisfied that Mr Shannon endeavoured to comply with the brief he had received from Mr Simond [34].(vi)Shortly after return from Kokoda, the ‘Sony’ Mini DV tapes’, which contained the film shot on the expedition, were copied onto ‘DV Pro tapes’ (which, together with certain pre-departure and post-return footage, was referred to below as the ‘Camera Tapes’) and delivered to Mr Simond. Both the Sony Mini DV tapes and the DV Pro tapes had come from Seven’s stock of tapes. The Sony Mini DV tapes were then erased and recycled in accordance with Seven’s practice. Messrs Shannon and Lynch billed Seven for their time and, in Mr Shannon’s case, for the use of a camera. The remaining camera equipment was supplied by Seven.(vii)Mr Simond received the DV Pro tapes on or about 12 March 2004 and then spent approximately five working days playing all of those tapes in order to watch all of the footage. He also watched tapes of footage shot before and after the expedition. He eventually selected approximately 12½ minutes of the footage for the ‘Today Tonight’ story (referred to below as ‘the Selected Footage Film’), and wrote a script for the story, for which he provided the voice over. The program was broadcast on 23 April 2004. Mr Simond was the reporter. On 26 April 2004 a follow up story was broadcast on ‘Today Tonight’ which showed World War II veterans meeting with the school boys who had gone on the Kokoda expedition.(viii)In early May, Mr Murray contacted Mr Simond and there was a discussion about the provision of the tapes. Mr Murray’s version of the discussion was slightly at variance with Mr Simond’s version, however, in substance they were the same.(ix)On or about 21 May 2004 Mr Simond was at Soldiers Point on the Central Coast during filming of a DARE Camp which Mr Murray had invited Mr Simond to come and film. On that occasion, Mr Simond handed to Mr Murray all the existing DV Pro tapes and a number of VHS copies of the ‘Today Tonight’ story that went to air.(x)At some time shortly after 17 May 2004 Mr Murray and Look Productions’ Mr Davies discussed the making of a documentary about the Kokoda expedition from the footage on the DV Pro tapes. Mr Davies suggested an approach to the ABC which failed, and later approaches to Seven and SBS also failed.(xi)In early September 2004 Nine exhibited an interest in the proposed Kokoda documentary. This led to a licence agreement between Look Productions and Nine in late December 2004. The consideration for the licence was $30,000. Mr Davies estimated the cost of production was at least $25,000 and Mr Murray was given a fee of about $2000.(xii)Work on developing the documentary had progressed during late 2004. It was not until February 2005 that Mr Davies converted the DV Pro tapes into a suitable format to be utilised and incorporated into the documentary. It was proposed to broadcast the documentary over the ANZAC weekend of 2005.(xiii)Shortly after Mr Simond and Mr McPherson became aware that Nine was promoting the Look Productions documentary, Seven commenced these proceedings against Nine by application filed on 24 March 2005. On that day Bennett J granted Seven an interlocutory injunction effectively restraining Nine from broadcasting the Look Productions documentary. Mr Murray, D.A.R.E. Operations Pty Limited and Look Productions were joined as respondents and the proceedings continued on the pleadings.THE PLEADINGS AND ARGUMENT
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
LINDGREN, FINKELSTEIN AND EDMONDS JJ
(dissent)
His Honour found that Mr Watt ‘referred to rights as well as the physical tapes’. No doubt his Honour had in mind Mr Watt’s testimony that he said ‘Camp Dare would like the rights to the tape and the footage after [you] have used it on Today Tonight’. Mr Simond denied that anything was said on the topic of ‘ownership of rights in the footage’ and Mr McPherson’s testimony was to the same effect. His Honour may be taken to have preferred the evidence of Mr Watt on this question.Conclusions as to the effect of the conversation at the meeting The finding that Mr McPherson’s response to the request was unequivocal does not necessarily mean that a ‘promotional purpose’ limitation was not part of the bargain reached. If it was, however, it was because of a limitation in the terms of the request to which Mr McPherson was responding. It seems to me that the critical question is how Mr Murray’s initial request is properly to be understood, in the light of all relevant surrounding circumstances. Mr Murray said ‘I want their [Mr Shannon’s and Mr Lynch’s] footage because, you know, we want to be able to [do] promotional stuff for Camp Dare and, you know, DVDs ...’, to which Mr McPherson replied ‘Well, I can’t see a problem with that’. It is possible to regard Mr Murray’s statement of his reason as a gratuitous truthful statement of his intention at the time, but it is also possible to regard it as an integral part of the request. After considerable fluctuation in my view, I have concluded, for the reasons which appear below, that the latter view is the correct one. The sense of the exchange is captured, in my opinion, if we imagine Mr McPherson emphasising the word ‘that’ – ‘well I can’t see a problem with that’. Mr McPherson’s positive response incorporated the notion ‘promotional stuff for Camp Dare, you know, DVDs’. There is a separate, but related, question as to the scope of the notion of ‘promotional purposes’. Mr Murray lacked the skill and equipment required to make anything out of the Camera Tapes, which were in DV Pro format. Clearly, it was envisaged that he be at liberty at least to authorise others to make a copy of parts of the Camera Tapes film in order to produce a film fit to be, at least in some circumstances, seen and heard in public or communicated to the public. It is not necessary, and it is undesirable, for the Court to attempt, to delineate the precise extent, if any, beyond ‘DVDs’, of the meaning of the expression ‘promotional purposes’. It suffices to say that, for the reasons which appear below, I do not think the proposed broadcasting on the competing Nine network was within the terms of Mr Murray’s request – ‘promotional stuff for Camp Dare and you know, DVDs’. The significance of the exchange between Mr Murray and Mr McPherson on 11 February 2004 must be assessed against the following background facts. (1) At least one story on Camp Dare’s ‘boot camp’ for school boys at Ulladulla had previously gone to air on Today Tonight (there was also an unclear reference in the evidence to a ‘follow up’ story). On 16 September 2003, Mr Murray sent an email to Sonia Lear of Seven. In it Mr Murray stated that the Today Tonight reporter involved, Mr Simond, ‘left Ben Fordam [sic] in the dark ...’. Ben Fordham worked for Nine. This was one of several instances of Mr Murray aligning himself with Seven and showing that he regarded Nine as Seven’s, and his own, ‘opposition’.