Adelaide Chemical & Fertilizer Co Ltd v Carlyle

Link copied
Case Copied 47 min read
64 CLR 514

ADELAIDE CHEMICAL AND FERTILIZER

COMPANY LIMITED CARLYLE

ON APPEAL FROM THE SUPREME COURT OF Negligence-Dangerous fluid-Sulphuric acid-Supply in earthenware container-

Breakage-Suitability of container-Injury to person taking delivery-Claim under Lord Campbell's Act-Dependants-Widow and child-Claim on behalf of widow only-Wrongs Act 1936 (S.A.) (No. 2267), Part II. Sept. 20, 23,

Evidence-Admissibility-Res gesta. MELBOURNE,

A company which manufactured and supplied sulphuric acid was accustomed to supply the acid in earthenware jars. These jars were manufactured and supplied to the company by a reputable firm of manufacturers and were tested by the manufacturers and by the company. The jars were in general use as containers for sulphuric acid, and the company had used large numbers with few breakages. Experiments showed that the jars, if filled with fluid of approximately the same weight as sulphuric acid, when tilted and allowed to fall some nine inches, invariably broke. The corrosive nature of the contents of the jars made them highly dangerous to persons handling them, if they were broken and the acid escaped. The company was accustomed to supply sulphuric acid in these containers to C.'s employers. As C. was attempting to lift one of the jars in order to move it from the company's delivery platform to his buckboard which was standing nearby, the jar broke. The contents were spilled over C., who immediately hastened inside the com- pany's building and began to wash the acid from his legs. His wife, who had been sitting in the buckboard, followed him and asked what had happened. He replied :-" I took hold of the handle of the jar, tilted it slightly towards me, to get my other hand underneath, and the top of the jar seemed

64 CLR 515

to come away in my hand. It must have been faulty or cracked." Later H C. was treated at a hospital and was advised to report next day to a doctor. He failed to do so, but his wife treated him with a preparation which a chemist advised her was a proper treatment for burns, as in fact it was. Later there were unexpected conditions, and a doctor was immediately called in. Strep- tococcal septicaemia developed, and C. died. His widow brought an action against the company under Part II. of the Wrongs Act 1936 (S.A.) (Lord Campbell's Act) on her own behalf only, proceedings on behalf of the only child of the marriage having been taken under the Workmen's Compensation Act. In the Supreme Court of South Australia it was found that the particular jar from which the damage resulted was defective and also that the jar was of an unsafe and dangerous type and the widow was awarded damages.

(1) That, whether or not the evidence of C.'s statement to his wife was admissible, and whether or not there was evidence to support the finding that the particular jar was defective, there was sufficient evidence to support the finding that the jar was not reasonably safe, and this finding should not…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Adelaide Chemical & Fertilizer Co Ltd v Carlyle and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1940] HCA 44
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case involved an appeal to the High Court of Australia from a decision of the Supreme Court of South Australia. The appellant, Adelaide Chemical & Fertilizer Co Ltd, manufactured and supplied sulphuric acid in earthenware jars. The respondent, the widow of Leslie Morton Carlyle, brought an action under the Wrongs Act 1936 (S.A.) (Lord Campbell's Act) following the death of her husband. Carlyle had been injured when a jar of sulphuric acid he was lifting broke, spilling the contents on him. He subsequently died from streptococcal septicaemia. The Supreme Court had found the company liable in negligence and awarded damages to the widow.

The High Court was required to determine several legal issues. These included whether the company had breached its duty of care to Carlyle, whether the death was a foreseeable consequence of the company's actions or an intervening cause, and whether the action was properly constituted given that the deceased had a child. The court also considered the admissibility of a statement made by Carlyle to his wife shortly after the incident and whether Carlyle had been contributorily negligent.

The High Court, in dismissing the appeal, reasoned that there was sufficient evidence to support the finding that the earthenware jars were not reasonably safe for containing sulphuric acid, even if the particular jar was not defective. The court held that the company owed a duty of care to take precautions against foreseeable risks, and the brittleness of the jars, which invariably broke when tilted and dropped a short distance, indicated a failure to meet this standard. The court found that the subsequent septicaemia was a foreseeable consequence of the burn injury and not a new and independent cause. The court also affirmed that the action was properly constituted and that contributory negligence had not been established.

The High Court upheld the Supreme Court's decision, finding the company liable for negligence. The appeal was dismissed with costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

Leslie Morton Carlyle was an employee of a herd-testing association, an institution subsidized by the Government of South Australia, who required concentrated sulphuric acid for his work. This sulphuric acid was supplied to the association under an arrangement with the South-Australian Department of Agriculture. The supplier of the acid was the Adelaide Chemical and Fertilizer Co. Ltd. The company supplied the sulphuric acid in earthenware jars, each containing approximately three gallons of acid, which, along with the jar, weighed about 75 lbs. The jars were cylindrical in shape, with a handle that formed an integral part of the structure and was united to the jar at its neck and shoulder. The jars were manufactured by a reputable firm and had been in general use as containers for sulphuric acid. However, experiments showed that if a jar filled with a fluid of approximately the same weight as sulphuric acid was tilted and allowed to fall from a height of about nine inches, it invariably broke. The corrosive nature of the acid made the contents highly dangerous if the jars broke and the acid escaped.

On 31 March 1939, Carlyle went to the company's delivery platform to collect two jars of sulphuric acid. As he attempted to lift one of the jars to move it to his buckboard, the jar broke, spilling the acid over him. Carlyle immediately went inside the building to wash the acid from his legs. His wife, who had been sitting in the buckboard, followed him and asked what had happened. Carlyle replied that he believed the jar was faulty or cracked. Carlyle was treated at a hospital and advised to report the next day to a doctor, but he did not follow this advice. His wife treated him with a preparation recommended by a chemist for burns, which was deemed a proper treatment. Later, unexpected conditions developed, and a doctor was called in. Streptococcal septicaemia developed, and Carlyle died.

His widow, on behalf of herself only, and not on behalf of herself and her child, brought an action against the Adelaide Chemical and Fertilizer Co. Ltd in the Supreme Court of South Australia. The widow claimed damages under Part II. of the Wrongs Act 1936 (S.A.), which contained provisions corresponding to Lord Campbell's Act. The court found that the particular jar from which the damage resulted was defective and also that the jars in general use by the defendant company, although not defective in any particular sense, were in a general sense unsafe and dangerous. The widow was awarded damages. The company appealed to the High Court, arguing that there was no negligence on their part, the death was caused by another agency, and the action was not properly constituted. The widow's failure to sue on behalf of the child did not result in the action's being improperly constituted. The appeal was dismissed with costs.

This case came before the High Court of Australia on appeal from the Supreme Court of South Australia. The Supreme Court had found that the Adelaide Chemical and Fertilizer Co. Ltd (appellant) was liable for damages due to the death of Leslie Morton Carlyle, who was injured when a jar of sulphuric acid supplied by the appellant broke, causing him to suffer severe burns. Carlyle's widow (respondent) had brought an action for damages under Part II of the Wrongs Act 1936 (S.A.), corresponding to the English Act known as Lord Campbell's Act. The appellant argued that the trial judge's findings were incorrect and that the action was improperly constituted. The High Court heard the appeal and delivered its judgment, affirming the decision of the Supreme Court. The Court found that the appellant had failed to exercise the required degree of care in supplying the sulphuric acid in jars that were brittle and unsafe, and that this failure had caused Carlyle's death. The Court also rejected the appellant's arguments that the action was improperly constituted and that the widow's failure to sue on behalf of her child resulted in the action being improperly constituted. The appeal was dismissed with costs.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Was the statement made by Carlyle to his wife admissible as part of res gestae?
2. Was there sufficient evidence to support the finding that the jar was not reasonably safe?
3. Did the death result from the intervention of a new and independent cause?
4. Was Carlyle guilty of contributory negligence?
5. Was the action properly constituted on behalf of the widow only, without the child?
6. Did the company breach its duty of care by using an unsafe container for sulphuric acid?

Held
1. The statement made by Carlyle to his wife was not admissible as part of res gestae. The court found it was a mere narrative of a past event and did not form part of the transaction.
2. There was sufficient evidence to support the finding that the jar was not reasonably safe. The court held that the jars were excessively brittle and unsuitable for the purpose of holding sulphuric acid.
3. The death did not result from the intervention of a new and independent cause. The court found that the infection and subsequent septicaemia were a recognized danger to which traumatic injury exposes the sufferer.
4. Carlyle was not guilty of contributory negligence. The court held that he could not be held responsible for the accident, as the jars were brittle and unsafe.
5. The action was properly constituted on behalf of the widow only. The court followed the reasoning in Avery v. London and North Eastern Railway Co., which held that the action could proceed on behalf of the widow alone without including the child.
6. The company breached its duty of care by using an unsafe container for sulphuric acid. The court held that the jars were excessively brittle and unsuitable for the purpose of holding sulphuric acid.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered whether Carlyle's statement to his wife was admissible as part of res gestae, finding it unnecessary to decide as the judgment was upheld on other grounds. The court established that there was sufficient evidence to support the finding that the jar was not reasonably safe. The court held that the death did not result from the intervention of a new and independent cause, as the infection was a recognized danger to which traumatic injury exposes the sufferer. The court found Carlyle not guilty of contributory negligence, as a heavy jar may be allowed to slip occasionally in spite of the most careful handling. The court held that the action was properly constituted on behalf of the widow only, without the child, following the reasoning in Avery v. London and North Eastern Railway Co. Lastly, the court found that the company breached its duty of care by using an unsafe container for sulphuric acid, as it was incumbent upon the company to exercise at least all reasonable care to provide a vessel as durable and free from liability to break in the ordinary course of handling as is compatible with the conditions and exigencies of manufacture and trade.