R v FAULKNER
[2002] SASC 286
Court of Criminal Appeal : Nyland, Williams and Gray JJ
NYLAND J: This is an appeal against conviction. The appellant was charged on information with two counts of indecent assault, one count of serious criminal trespass in a place of residence and one count of attempting to abduct a child under 16.
The appellant pleaded guilty to Count 2 which was a charge of indecent assault committed at Port Adelaide between 1 November and 30 November 2000. The appellant elected to be tried by judge alone as to the remaining counts and was found guilty of each of them by a District Court judge on 22 February 2002. The victim with respect to each of these offences was a 12 year old boy (J). J resided with his father but at the time of the alleged offences was staying with his mother (R) and her partner Jack in their unit (Unit 3) at Glanville. The appellant resided in the adjoining unit (Unit 2). J met the appellant not long after his mother moved into Unit 3 which was in about October 2000. Jack is a fisherman and is often away from home. Occasionally the appellant visited Unit 3 and J’s mother visited Unit 2.
The first count of indecent assault is alleged to have occurred in the lounge room of Unit 3 at a time when J’s mother was present. J was sitting on a chair watching TV and the appellant was seated on a nearby lounge. J’s mother had previously caught him smoking cigarettes. On this particular night she encouraged J to smoke excessively, thereby hoping to dissuade him from continuing to smoke. J was wearing shorts and underpants. After smoking about 10 cigarettes he felt ill. According to J, the appellant then moved from the lounge to the chair next to him. J said:
“[the appellant] ‘moved on to my chair, but he picked me up and put me on his lap, on the same chair that I was sitting on’. The accused, he said, was ‘touching where my pulse is... Between my legs like, in the gap thing and like up on my neck and under my arms... he had his hand up the leg of my shorts, but on the top of my underpants’. That touching continued for about five minutes. The [appellant] also ‘touched my penis with this thumb... He just sort of rubbed his thumb along my penis... Once or twice’.”
J thought that he was seated on the appellant’s lap for about 15-20 minutes and that his penis was touched for about 10 minutes.
J said that his mother was tired and he subsequently went next door to the appellant’s unit where he remained for “three, four, five hours” during which time he drank alcoholic liquor and the appellant pulled out the elastic of his “pants” and looked down his “pants”.
J described other occasions on which he visited the appellant’s unit in the course of which…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Faulkner No. Sccrm-02-73 and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2002] SASC 286
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
In relation to the first ground, the Court found that the trial judge had properly applied the doctrine of res gestae in admitting the victim's statements as part of the events themselves. The Court held that the statements were made spontaneously and contemporaneously with the events, and the possibility of concoction or distortion was excluded. The second ground of appeal, concerning the evaluation of inconsistencies in the evidence, was also rejected. The Court held that the trial judge had carefully considered the evidence and found the witnesses credible, despite the inconsistencies. The third ground of appeal, regarding the assessment of the appellant's police interview, was dismissed as the Court found that the trial judge had appropriately considered the impact of the appellant's lies on his credibility.
Lastly, the Court dismissed the fourth ground of appeal, which challenged the overall assessment of the evidence. The Court found that the trial judge had carefully evaluated the evidence and was entitled to rely on the victim's testimony to find the appellant guilty beyond reasonable doubt. The Court of Criminal Appeal unanimously dismissed the appeal against conviction.
Background
Background to the litigation
The first count of indecent assault is alleged to have happened in J's unit while J's mother was present. J was sitting on a chair watching TV when Faulkner, who was seated on a nearby lounge, moved to the chair next to him. According to J, Faulkner then picked him up, put him on his lap, and touched him inappropriately for about five minutes. J also stated that Faulkner touched his penis with his thumb. J further described other occasions when he visited Faulkner's unit, during which Faulkner showed him pornography and touched his penis.
The second count of indecent assault occurred during a fishing trip. The day before, Faulkner and J went to the Semaphore jetty to fish for bait. The following morning, Faulkner drove J to fish under the Jervois Bridge. While in the car, Faulkner picked J up and put him on his lap, rocking him from side to side. J felt Faulkner's erection on his leg and saw Faulkner's erect penis when they were urinating at a nearby pole.
Counts 3 and 4 pertain to events that occurred between 25 and 26 January 2001. That evening, Faulkner drove J and Jack to Semaphore to buy pizza and then returned to J's unit. Later that night, J heard a tapping noise on his window, got scared, and went to sleep in the lounge room near his mother and Jack. J locked his bedroom window and put a piece of wood in the window runner to prevent it from being opened from the outside. Later, J saw Faulkner enter J's unit through the open front door and unlocked screen door. After being denied permission by Jack to take J to his unit, Faulkner left. Later that night, J saw Faulkner again in his unit when he was awoken. Faulkner carried J through the hallway, and J yelled out to his mother, who came running into his bedroom after Faulkner dropped him on the floor. J believed that Faulkner attempted to abduct him through the bedroom window, which was fully open with the fly screen removed.
The case of R v Faulkner is an appeal against conviction brought before the South Australian Court of Criminal Appeal. The appellant, who was convicted by a judge alone in the District Court, was found guilty of two counts of indecent assault, one count of serious criminal trespass in a place of residence, and one count of attempting to abduct a child under 16. The appellant pleaded guilty to one count of indecent assault, while the remaining counts were determined by a judge without a jury. The appeal against the conviction raises four grounds, including the trial judge's application of the principle of res gestae, the significance of inconsistencies and discrepancies in the evidence, the impact of the appellant's record of interview with the police on the assessment of his evidence, and the reasonableness of the verdicts. The Court of Criminal Appeal dismissed the appeal against conviction, finding that the trial judge had adequately considered the evidence and applied the appropriate legal principles.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Did the trial judge properly apply the principle of res gestae in admitting the statements made by J to his mother and Jack after the events of Count 4?
2. Did the trial judge err in determining that the inconsistencies and discrepancies in the evidence of J, R, and Jack were of "little moment"?
3. Did the trial judge properly consider the impact of the appellant's record of interview with the police on the assessment of his evidence on oath?
4. Were the verdicts unreasonable or unsupported by the evidence, particularly considering the appellant's admission of sexual behaviour towards J after previously lying about it to the police?
Held
1. The court concluded that the trial judge properly applied the principle of res gestae in admitting the statements made by J to his mother and Jack after the events of Count 4. The statements were deemed spontaneous and contemporaneous, and therefore admissible as part of the res gestae. This ground of appeal fails.
2. The court determined that the trial judge did not err in finding that the inconsistencies and discrepancies in the evidence of J, R, and Jack were of "little moment." The judge carefully considered the evidence, found the witnesses credible, and concluded that the inconsistencies did not undermine their reliability. This ground of appeal fails.
3. The court held that the trial judge properly considered the impact of the appellant's record of interview with the police on the assessment of his evidence on oath. The lies told by the appellant impacted adversely on his credibility, and the judge appropriately took this into account. This ground of appeal fails.
4. The court found that the verdicts were not unreasonable or unsupported by the evidence. The trial judge carefully assessed the evidence, found the witnesses credible, and concluded that the appellant's guilt was established beyond reasonable doubt. This ground of appeal fails.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court considered four main issues in the appeal against the appellant's conviction. Firstly, it assessed whether the trial judge properly applied the principle of res gestae in admitting the statements made by J to his mother and Jack after the events of Count 4. The court held that the trial judge was correct in finding that J's statements were sufficiently spontaneous and contemporaneous to the acts for them to be regarded as an integral part of those acts and thus part of the res gestae. The short passage of time between the events and the acts, along with the appellant's improbable explanation, supported the trial judge's decision.
Secondly, the court examined whether the trial judge erred in determining that the inconsistencies and discrepancies in the evidence of J, R, and Jack were of "little moment." The court found that the trial judge had carefully considered the evidence, weighed the credibility of the witnesses, and concluded that despite any inconsistencies or discrepancies, the witnesses were credible and reliable. The trial judge was entitled to act on their evidence in determining the guilt of the appellant.
Thirdly, the court looked at whether the trial judge properly considered the impact of the appellant's record of interview with the police on the assessment of his evidence on oath. The court concluded that the trial judge had given adequate consideration to the appellant's lies during the interview and found that they adversely affected the appellant's credibility as a witness. The court did not find it necessary for the trial judge to provide detailed reasons as to the circumstances of the police interview.
Lastly, the court evaluated whether the verdicts were unreasonable or unsupported by the evidence, particularly considering the appellant's admission of sexual behaviour towards J after previously lying about it to the police. The court found that the trial judge had given careful consideration to the assessment of the evidence of the witnesses, taking into account inconsistencies arising out of their evidence. Ultimately, the trial judge was satisfied that he was able to rely on the evidence of J to reach a finding as to proof of guilt beyond reasonable doubt as to each of the charges before him.
In conclusion, the court found that the trial judge had properly applied legal principles and authorities in reaching his decisions, and that the ratio decidendi established or applied by the decision was that the trial judge's assessment of evidence and credibility was sound and appropriate. The court dismissed the appeal against conviction.