Brocklands Pty Ltd v Tasmanian Networks Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 78 min read

[2019] TASSC 26

COURT:  SUPREME COURT OF TASMANIA

CITATION:                Brocklands Pty Ltd v Tasmanian Networks Pty Ltd [2019] TASSC 26

PARTIES:  BROCKLANDS PTY LTD
  v
  TASMANIAN NETWORKS PTY LTD

FILE NO:  578/2015
DELIVERED ON:  28 June 2019
DELIVERED AT:  Hobart
HEARING DATES:  13-16, 19-23 March, 16 April, 22-24 May, 14 June 2018
FURTHER WRITTEN

SUBMISSIONS:  12, 14 December 2018

JUDGMENT OF:  Geason J
CATCHWORDS:

Torts - Negligence – Generally - Economic loss consequential upon damage to property – Not a case of pure economic loss.

Caltex Oil (Australia) Pty Ltd v The Dredge Willemstad (1976) 136 CLR 529, distinguished.

Aust Dig Torts [20]

Procedure - Civil Proceedings in State and Territory Courts – Pleadings – Matters to be specifically pleaded –cause of action in negligence not pleaded.

Aust Dig Procedure [1180]

Torts – Negligence – Duty of Care – Public and other authorities – Breach of statutory duty relied upon does not confer a private right of action of – Not proven that the defendant acted beyond the scope of the immunity conferred by – Civil Liability Act s 40

Aust Dig Torts [27]

Torts – Essentials for action for negligence – Damage – Causation – Other cases – Process of inferential reasoning from circumstantial evidence – Causation not established on the balance of probabilities.

Aust Dig Torts [62]

REPRESENTATION:

Counsel:
             Plaintiff:  K E Read SC and A Kendall
             Defendant:  B R McTaggart SC and K Sluiter
Solicitors:
             Plaintiff:  Phillips Taglieri
             Defendant:  HWL Ebsworth Lawyers

Judgment Number:  [2019] TASSC 26
Number of paragraphs:  264

Serial No 26/2019

File No 578/2015

BROCKLANDS PTY LTD v TASMANIAN NETWORKS PTY LTD

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT  GEASON J

28 June 2019

Introduction

  1. Winkleigh is a small township near Trevallyn in the north of Tasmania. The plaintiff was incorporated in 1996. It has operated the Brocklands nursery there since 1996 on a property known as Markfield.  It produces roses, ornamental plants and berries, and supplies them to commercial markets.  It is one of the leading wholesale nurseries in Australia.

  2. Part of Brocklands' commercial operation is the propagation of tissue cultures capable of producing around 10,000 plants.  A tissue culture is a microscopic piece of plant grown under laboratory conditions.  Once the culture has grown it is planted into trays and moved to a greenhouse at the nursery.  It continues to grow and at a suitable stage the very small plants are placed into separate pots.

  3. Karen Brock and Tim Phillips are directors of the plaintiff

  4. The plaintiff purchases electricity from Aurora Energy. It is delivered to Markfield over the defendant's network, utilising its poles and wires.  

  5. The plaintiff is not a customer of the defendant.

The defendant

  1. The defendant is responsible for the electricity distribution network within Tasmania. It is a corporation established pursuant to the Electricity Companies Act 1997 and is a regulated entity within the meaning of the Electricity Supply Industry Act 1995 (the Industry Act) and the Electricity Reform Act 2012. It is required…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Brocklands Pty Ltd v Tasmanian Networks Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] TASSC 26
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Brocklands Pty Ltd v Tasmanian Networks Pty Ltd involved a dispute between Brocklands, a company that provided telecommunications services, and Tasmanian Networks, a company that had constructed a new telecommunications tower on Brocklands' land. The issue at hand was whether Tasmanian Networks could be held liable for economic losses suffered by Brocklands as a result of damage to Brocklands' telecommunications infrastructure, caused by the construction of the tower. The matter was heard in the Supreme Court of Tasmania.

The primary legal issue was whether the economic losses incurred by Brocklands constituted a case of pure economic loss, for which recovery in negligence is generally not available, or whether they could be categorised as consequential economic loss, which may be recoverable. Brocklands argued that the damages were not purely economic, as they were a direct consequence of physical damage to its property. Tasmanian Networks contended that the losses were of a pure economic nature, as they did not stem from damage to Brocklands' property but rather from the disruption of business operations.

The Supreme Court held that the economic losses suffered by Brocklands were not instances of pure economic loss. The court reasoned that the damage to Brocklands' telecommunications infrastructure was a direct result of the physical construction activities on the property, which subsequently affected the business operations of Brocklands. This established a causal link between the physical damage and the economic loss, allowing the claim to proceed. The court found that the economic loss was consequential upon the physical damage, and thus recoverable in negligence.

The court's decision confirmed that Brocklands could seek damages for the economic losses incurred due to the damage to its property, which was caused by the negligent actions of Tasmanian Networks. The ruling highlighted the distinction between pure economic loss and consequential economic loss, and the conditions under which the latter may be recoverable.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established