Dreamstreet Lending Pty Ltd v Weiss (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 80 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Dreamstreet Lending Pty Ltd v Weiss (No 2) [2023] FCA 684 

File number(s): VID 638 of 2020
Judgment of: BUTTON J
Date of judgment: 23 June 2023
Catchwords:

CONTRACT – contractual interpretation – breach of contract – services agreement between consultant and mortgage broking business – where applicant claimed consultant breached notice period clause – where applicant claimed consultant breached an exclusive service obligation – where applicant claimed consultant breached confidentiality obligations – where consultant made and retained various downloads of customer-related information from the business’s customer relationship management (CRM) system – applicant waived compliance with notice period – applicant not ready and willing to perform its obligations – first respondent breached exclusive service obligation by signing employment contract with another mortgage broking business during term of services agreement – first respondent breached confidentiality obligations by making one of the downloads of confidential information from CRM system – first respondent breached confidentiality obligations by using some other customer information – no loss or damage suffered by applicant – nominal damages awarded

CONTRACT – services agreement – restraint of trade clause – where first respondent prohibited from soliciting, canvassing or approaching a client, customer or patron of the company or any group company – where first respondent prohibited from interfering directly or indirectly with the relationship between the company or any group company and its clients – whether restraint clause was reasonable – whether restraint clause was severable – whether restraint clause included leads generated by the company and the consultant – restraint clause found to be unreasonable and unenforceable

CONTRACT – where services agreement provides for clawback of commission payments made to consultant by mortgage broking business when the lender requires repayment of the corresponding commission – whether business is entitled to clawback certain commission payments – whether there was evidence that the lender in fact demanded repayment of the corresponding commission – applicant entitled to clawback in respect of some customers only

CONTRACT – contractual interpretation – cross-claim for commissions owed under a services agreement – cross-claim for repayment of improper deductions under a services agreement – whether payment of commissions under services agreement depended on amounts being agreed by parties to the contract – cross-applicant entitled to payment of some trail commissions – cross-respondent made improper deductions under services agreement

TORT – economic torts – tort of inducement or procurement of breach of contract – failure to satisfy all elements of the tort – second and third respondents not found to have had the requisite knowledge and intention to procure breach of contract – no loss or damage suffered by the applicant

COPYRIGHT – alleged infringement of copyright in compilations of records in CRM – whether copyright subsisted in the compilation of records in the CRM – whether test for originality is met – whether respondents infringed copyright – whether there was a license to use the copyright in relation to a services agreement – whether an employee’s conduct that was alleged…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Dreamstreet Lending Pty Ltd v Weiss (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] FCA 684
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Dreamstreet Lending Pty Ltd v Weiss (No 2) involved a dispute between a mortgage broking business, Dreamstreet, and a consultant, Mr Weiss. Dreamstreet brought claims against Mr Weiss for breach of contract, inducement of breach of contract by third parties, copyright infringement, and an economic tort. Mr Weiss made a cross-claim for unpaid commissions and the repayment of improper deductions. The case was heard in the Federal Court of Australia.

The court was required to determine whether Mr Weiss breached the notice period clause, the exclusive service obligation, and the confidentiality obligations in his services agreement with Dreamstreet. The court also had to decide whether the restraint of trade clause in the agreement was reasonable and enforceable. Additionally, the court had to assess whether Financepath and another individual, who were alleged to have induced Mr Weiss to breach his contract with Dreamstreet, had the requisite knowledge and intention to do so. Furthermore, the court needed to establish whether copyright subsisted in the compilations of records in Dreamstreet's customer relationship management system and whether any infringement occurred.

The court found that Mr Weiss breached the notice period clause by not providing the required notice before leaving Dreamstreet. However, Dreamstreet waived compliance with the notice period as it was not ready and willing to perform its obligations under the contract. Mr Weiss also breached the exclusive service obligation by signing an employment contract with another mortgage broking business during the term of his services agreement with Dreamstreet. Furthermore, Mr Weiss breached confidentiality obligations by making and retaining various downloads of customer-related information from Dreamstreet's customer relationship management system. However, Dreamstreet did not suffer any loss or damage as a result of these breaches. The court found that the restraint of trade clause in the services agreement was unreasonable and unenforceable.

In relation to the claims against Financepath, the court determined that the respondents did not have the requisite knowledge and intention to procure a breach of contract by Mr Weiss. Therefore, the claim for inducement of breach of contract failed. The court also found no copyright subsisted in the compilations of records in Dreamstreet's customer relationship management system, and no infringement occurred. Regarding Mr Weiss's cross-claim, the court found that he was entitled to payment of some trail commissions and that Dreamstreet made improper deductions under the services agreement.

The court awarded nominal damages for the breaches of contract, ordered Mr Weiss to delete and make unavailable any copies of the downloads he made, and restrained him from using the information contained in the downloads for certain purposes. The court also granted Mr Weiss's entitlement to unpaid commissions and ordered Dreamstreet to repay the improperly deducted amounts. The court dismissed the remaining claims and ordered the parties to confer and reach an agreement on the form of orders, including the costs.

The final orders included a requirement for the parties to submit a form of order that provides for declaratory relief and nominal damages, clawback in relation to certain commissions, payment of unpaid commissions, repayment of improperly deducted amounts, and specific obligations for Mr Weiss regarding the downloads he made. The court also addressed costs, inviting the parties to reach a negotiated position and to make written submissions on the matter. If the parties could not agree on the orders, the court scheduled a case management hearing to resolve the orders.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. By 4:00pm on 7 July 2023, the parties are to confer and provide any agreed minutes of orders giving effect to the reasons of the Court (accompanied by a note that explains the approach taken to any GST and interest), or in default of agreement, provide separate minutes of orders and file and serve short written submissions (not exceeding five pages), in which case the matter will be listed at 2:15pm on 14 July 2023 for submissions to be made on final orders.

2. By 4:00pm on 30 June 2023, the parties notify each other of their respective positions as to costs.

3. By 4:00pm on 7 July 2023, the parties each file and serve written submissions (not exceeding five pages) as to costs and advise the Court whether the party seeks to make oral submissions on costs.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

TABLE OF CONTENTS

INTRODUCTION

[1]

WITNESSES: CREDIT ISSUES

[12]

BREACH OF CONTRACT CLAIMS

[24]

Alleged breach of the notice period: cl 5(d) of the Weiss SA

[24]

Alleged breach of exclusive service obligation: cl 2(c)(i) of the Weiss SA

[43]

Alleged breach of confidentiality obligations arising from the downloads: cll 5 and 7 of the Weiss SA

[49]

The Second Download

[53]

The Third Download

[57]

The First Download

[60]

Dreamstreet’s claims and Mr Weiss’s response

[64]

Mr Weiss’s evidence about making the downloads

[75]

Relevant clauses of the Weiss SA

[85]

Making and retaining the First Download

[96]

Retaining the Second and Third Downloads after 11 June 2020

[100]

Mr Weiss emailing the Third Download to himself on 11 June 2020

[109]

Opening the Second Download on 17 September 2020

[111]

Whether Dreamstreet suffered any loss or damage

[112]

Retention and use of other customer information

[114]

Pleaded case in relation to notepads retained by Mr Weiss, and calendar invitations and a loan serviceability document saved on Mr Weiss’s Financepath computer

[119]

Alleged breach of contractual restraints: cl 13 of the Weiss SA

[123]

Clause 13 of the Weiss SA

[123]

The parties’ contentions

[132]

Principles concerning the enforceability of restraints of trade

[138]

Consideration

[147]

Proper construction of cl 13

[147]

The enforceability of cl 13

[162]

Whether Mr Weiss breached cl 13

[174]

CLAIMS AGAINST FINANCEPATH FOR INDUCING BREACH OF CONTRACT

[188]

Extent of the claims against Financepath

[188]

Elements of the tort of inducing breach of contract

[195]

Consideration

[207]

The fifth element: whether the breach caused loss or damage to Dreamstreet

[207]

First element: existence of a contract

[216]

Second element: knowledge of such a contract

[217]

Third and fourth elements: knowledge the actions would be in breach of contract, and intention to procure the breach

[218]

Knowledge and intention from the start of Mr Weiss’s employment with Financepath on 1 June 2020

[222]

Knowledge and intention from mid-July 2020

[228]

Knowledge and intention from early September 2020

[233]

Knowledge and intention from 25 September 2020

[239]

Exemplary damages claim

[243]

THE CLAWBACK CLAIMS

[245]

COPYRIGHT CLAIMS

[263]

Dreamstreet’s claims

[263]

Facts

[269]

The parties’ arguments on whether the Dreamstreet Compilations are copyright works

[278]

Consideration

[283]

Whether the Dreamstreet Compilations are copyright works

[285]

Person Records

[294]

Opportunity Records

[295]

The compilation of data in the CRM

[298]

Additional matters

[299]

Whether Mr Weiss and Financepath infringed Dreamstreet’s copyright

[302]

Mr Weiss’s conduct in making the Second and Third Downloads

[305]

Financepath’s conduct by Mr Weiss’s actions

[314]

Damages

[321]

MR WEISS’S CROSS-CLAIM

[322]

Restraint claims

[323]

Unpaid commissions and improper deductions

[325]

Unpaid upfront commissions

[326]

Unpaid trail commissions

[327]

Contractual entitlement to trail commissions

[334]

Whether there was any agreement that Mr Weiss would receive no trail commission in relation to the loans of AA and RA, CL and YL, and ML and EL

[344]

The loans of AM and BM and Mr Weiss’s conduct in relation to them

[349]

CONCLUSION

[358]

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Mr Weiss’s submissions as to his purpose in making and retaining the three downloads were consistent with the evidence he gave.Mr Weiss’s evidence about making the downloads After an initial period during which Mr Weiss was paid a refundable retainer, he was paid commissions monthly in arrears, usually around the 12th day of the month. Once on the monthly commission-based arrangement, Mr Weiss would be sent an RCTI by Dreamstreet itemising the payments being made to him, and (in some instances) deductions made by Dreamstreet. In around April 2020, Mr Weiss received a phone call from a recruiter, who told him there was an opportunity to work for Financepath. Mr Weiss’s evidence was that he was dissatisfied with the work he was doing for Dreamstreet, and that this dissatisfaction stemmed from Dreamstreet withholding commissions Mr Weiss considered he was owed and wrongly deducting money from payments made to him. When he started considering leaving Dreamstreet, Mr Weiss was concerned that he did not have a clear record of the commissions he was entitled to and the work that he had done. He understood, rightly or wrongly, that others who had left Dreamstreet did not receive the commissions they were entitled to after they told Dreamstreet they were leaving. Mr Weiss was conscious that the records of the work he had done for Dreamstreet were contained in the CRM and he did not have a separate record. Mr Weiss wanted to retain a record so that he would be able to determine what amounts were owing to him. Mr Weiss noted that there was an option to “export” records in the CRM system and used that option to make the Second Download, containing records of the 96 customers with settled loans. At the time that he made the Second Download, Mr Weiss thought that he would be able to use that list, together with his recollection of the payments he had received, to determine what commissions were still outstanding. He did not want to tell Dreamstreet he was leaving until he received his May commission payment. After he signed the employment agreement with Financepath, Mr Weiss took a two week break from work with Dreamstreet and did not take any new leads from Dreamstreet during that time, but continued to assist customers that had made loan applications to get to settlement. In the days before and on 11 June 2020, Mr Weiss began to draft his resignation email to Dreamstreet. In the morning of 11 June 2020, Mr Weiss received his payment from Dreamstreet in respect of May 2020 and also received an RCTI for that month. Once he had received his May commission payment, Mr Weiss proceeded to finalise the draft email he had prepared to Dreamstreet advising of his resignation and detailing the monies he claimed were owed to him. The Second and Third Downloads did not include loans settled in May 2020 and loans that had not yet settled. Mr Weiss said he wanted that information to prepare his resignation email, so he made the First Download on 11 June 2020. He intended to capture all customers whose loans he had worked on, which information he also wanted as he was also of the view that he might end up in a dispute with Dreamstreet about commissions owed to him and he wanted to have a record of the full list of customers he had had dealings with during his time at Dreamstreet so that he had a record of the number of appointments and work he had taken on. Mr Weiss thought he might need to rely on such records if his request for payment of his commissions was ignored.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Finally, I note that cl 6(f) refers to the withholding of money due to Mr Weiss “during any period while the Company considers that …” and goes on to refer to various circumstances. Dreamstreet did not, by its evidence, seek to justify the withholding of amounts to which Mr Weiss was entitled on the basis that Dreamstreet held the necessary state of mind. CONCLUSION The parties are to submit a form of order that provides for declaratory relief and nominal damages in respect of the breaches of the Weiss SA that have been established, clawback in relation to the commissions associated with the MG and DC and JC loans, Mr Weiss’s entitlements to unpaid commissions, and repayment of the amounts improperly deducted in respect of AM and BM, in accordance with these reasons and which:(a)oblige Mr Weiss to delete any copies of the First Download from his computer devices;(b)oblige Mr Weiss, if requested by Dreamstreet, to make any of his computer devices containing copies of the First Download available to any third-party computer expert retained by Dreamstreet, at Dreamstreet’s cost, to forensically delete any copy of the First Download; (c)restrain Mr Weiss from using any copies of customer-related documentation stored on his devices in connection with assessing the ability of any such customer to service any loan, or to apply for loan finance or refinance; (d)address GST in relation to any payments (if necessary); (e)address any pre-judgment interest; and(f)otherwise dismisses the originating application and the cross-claim. If the parties cannot agree orders, I will convene a case management hearing to resolve the orders. Any agreed form of order should be accompanied by a note that explains the approach taken to any GST and interest. The parties are invited to reach a negotiated position on costs. I will otherwise permit the parties to make written submissions on costs and to indicate whether they are content for costs to be determined on the papers, or wish to make oral submissions.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.