Telstra Corp Ltd v Phone Directories Co Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 71 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Telstra Corporation Limited v Phone Directories Company Pty Ltd [2014] FCA 568

Citation: Telstra Corporation Limited v Phone Directories Company Pty Ltd [2014] FCA 568
Parties: TELSTRA CORPORATION LIMITED (ACN 051 775 556) and SENSIS PTY LTD (ACN 007 423 912) v PHONE DIRECTORIES COMPANY PTY LTD (ACN 059 776 091), AUSTRALIAN LOCAL DIRECTORIES PTY LTD (ACN 078 856 318), ADAM HARGRAVES, GLENN HARGRAVES, DANIEL STOTEN and LOCAL DIRECTORIES COMPANY PTY LTD (ACN 130 550 971)
File number: VID 276 of 2007
Judge: MURPHY J
Date of judgment: 30 May 2014
Catchwords: TRADE AND COMMERCE – Trade Practices – misleading or deceptive conduct – misleading or deceptive conduct in the taking of a competitor’s trade indicia – passing off – secondary reputation in the colour yellow on covers of telephone directories – date for assessing reputation in yellow – relevance of international use of colour yellow – whether respondents’ use of yellow covers on telephone directories was misleading or deceptive – identification of the class of consumers – erroneous assumption as to trade source – intention to deceive – failed intention to deceive – relevance of strength of reputation – relevance of use of common trade indicia – sufficiency of differentiation between similar products – whether respondents have done enough to differentiate their directories – conduct not misleading or deceptive
TRADE AND COMMERCE – Trade Practices – misleading or deceptive conduct – advertisements in telephone directories – misleading advertisement regarding comparative consumer usage
COPYRIGHT – unjustifiable threats of copyright infringement – relevance of bona fides – whether threat is groundless or unjustifiable
Legislation: Acts Interpretation Act 1901 (Cth)
Circuit Layouts Act 1989 (Cth)
Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth)
Copyright Act1968 (Cth)
Federal Court Act 1976 (Cth)
Patents Act 1990 (Cth)
Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth)
Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth)
Cases cited: .au Domain Administration Ltd v Domain Names Australia Pty Ltd (2004) ALR 521
Anheuser-Busch, Inc v Budejovick Budvar, Nrodn Podnik & Ors [2002] FCA 390
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Dukemaster Pty Ltd [2009] FCA 682
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v SMS Global Pty Ltd [2011] FCA 855
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Telstra Corporation Limited (2007) 244 ALR 470
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Yellow Page Marketing BV (No 2) [2011] FCA 352
Australian Health & Nutrition Association Limited trading as Sanitarium Health Food Company v Irrewarra Estate Pty Ltd trading as Irrewarra Sourdough [2012] FCA 592
Australian Woollen Mills Ltd v FS Walton & Co Ltd (1937) 58 CLR 641
Avel Pty Limited v Intercontinental Grain Importers Pty Limited (1996) 65 FCR 154
Benmax v Austin Motor Co Ltd [1953] 70 RPC 284
Cadbury Schweppes Pty Ltd v Darrell Lea Chocolate Shop Pty Ltd (No 8) 75 IPR 557
Cadbury Schweppes Pty Ltd v Darrell Lea Chocolate Shops Pty Ltd (2007) 72 IPR 261
CampomarSociedad, Limitada v Nike International Ltd (2000) 202 CLR 45
Connect.Com.Au Pty Ltd v GoConnect Australia Pty Ltd (2000) 50…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Telstra Corp Ltd v Phone Directories Co Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] FCA 568
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Telstra Corp Ltd v Phone Directories Co Pty Ltd, the respondents, PDC, ALD, and LD, sought relief under section 202 of the Copyright Act for the alleged unjustifiable threats of copyright infringement made by Telstra. Telstra had sent a letter of demand to the respondents asserting that it held copyright in its Yellow Pages and White Pages directories and threatening legal action for any reproduction of substantial parts of these directories. This was based on previous cases affirming the copyright in telephone directories. Despite Telstra's copyright infringement claim being unsuccessful, it maintained that its threats were justified and made in good faith. The court was required to decide whether Telstra's threats were unjustifiable under section 202 of the Copyright Act.

The court found that Telstra's threats were not unjustifiable. It accepted that Telstra's actions were based on the law as it stood at the time and were made in good faith. The court emphasised that the mere notification of the existence of a copyright does not constitute a threat of legal proceedings under section 202. Telstra's threats were made in the context of a genuine belief that copyright had been infringed, and the court found no evidence to suggest that the threats were groundless. Therefore, the court ruled that Telstra's threats were not unjustifiable, and Telstra was not liable for damages under section 202.

The final orders of the court reflect this decision, dismissing the respondents' claims for unjustifiable threats of copyright infringement. The court's ruling upheld Telstra's position that its actions were justified and in good faith, and it did not find any basis to hold Telstra liable for making the threats.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

PDC, ALD and LD (“the cross-claimants”) seek declaratory relief and damages for unjustifiable threats pursuant to s 202 of the Copyright Act.The Facts It is uncontentious that Telstra threatened breach of copyright proceedings against the cross‑claimants in a letter of demand of 10 July 2006 sent to the cross-claimants and their solicitors. The letter relevantly stated:As you are no doubt aware, Telstra has copyright in the Yellow Pages and White Pages directories (“Telstra’s Directories”) and the headings books used to generate the headings used in Telstra’s directories (“the Headings”). This was confirmed by the Full Federal Court in Desktop Marketing Systems Pty Ltd v Telstra Corporations [sic] Ltd (2002) 55 IPR 1. Therefore, it is a breach of Telstra’s copyright for PDC/ALD to reproduce a substantial part of Telstra’s directories or the Headings.Telstra also pointed to Telecom Corporation of New Zealand Ltd & Anor v Colour Pages Limited & Anor (High Court of New Zealand, unreported, 14 August 1997) in which McGechan J found that copyright subsisted in telephone directories. It is uncontentious too that Telstra subsequently brought a claim of copyright infringement against the cross-claimants, and that claim was unsuccessful before the Federal Court and the Full Court. The High Court refused special leave: see Telstra Corporation Limited v Phone Directories Company Pty Ltd [2010] FCA 44 (“Telstra Copyright Trial”); Telstra Corporation Limited v Phone Directories Company Pty Ltd [2010] FCAFC 149 (“Telstra Copyright Appeal”); and Telstra Corporation Limited & Anor v Phone Directories Company Pty Ltd & Ors [2011] HCATrans 248 (2 September 2011) (“Telstra Copyright Special Leave Application”). Legislative framework and relevant principles Section 202 of the Copyright Act relevantly provides:202Groundless threats of legal proceedings in relation to copyright infringement(1)Where a person, by means of circulars, advertisements or otherwise, threatens a person with an action or proceeding in respect of an infringement of copyright, then, whether the person making the threats is or is not the owner of the copyright or an exclusive licensee, a person aggrieved may bring an action against the first‑mentioned person and may obtain a declaration to the effect that the threats are unjustifiable, and an injunction against the continuance of the threats, and may recover such damages (if any) as he or she has sustained, unless the first‑mentioned person satisfies the court that the acts in respect of which the action or proceeding was threatened constituted, or, if done, would constitute, an infringement of copyright.(2)The mere notification of the existence of a copyright does not constitute a threat of an action or proceeding within the meaning of this section.… Similar provisions relating to groundless threats appear in almost all Australian intellectual property legislation. In my view, there is no relevant difference between the prohibition of groundless threats in s 202 and the unjustified threats provision in s 128 of the Patents Act 1990 (Cth) (“Patents Act”), and analogous provisions in s 129 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) and s 46 of the Circuit Layouts Act 1989 (Cth). The authorities relating to these analogous provisions are applicable in the present case.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Telstra contends that its threat of proceedings, and the proceedings themselves, were soundly made on the law as it then stood, and were made in good faith in the honest belief that copyright had been infringed. I accept Telstra’s contentions. I do not consider that its threats were unjustifiable within the meaning of s 202.B. The Evidence and objections to Evidence The evidence in the proceeding is voluminous. The Court Book totalled 19 lever arch binders, with further documentary evidence adduced during trial. A total of 81 witness affidavits were filed although the evidence of many witnesses was not challenged. The parties were requested to prepare and file a Statement of Agreed Facts, and also prepared detailed chronologies. As a result, much of the factual history is not contentious, but there remains a contest between the parties on various important issues and numerous objections to evidence. Given the volume of the evidence it is not practical to fully recount it and I will set out only the salient facts to the disposition of the claims. Inevitably this will involve some loss of nuance but that is unavoidable. I separately deal with my view of the evidence of the numerous witnesses. For ease of understanding I will separately deal with the facts in the cross-claims. There were numerous objections by the parties to various parts of the affidavit evidence sometimes at the level of parts of sentences and parts of paragraphs. Where I have considered the evidence significant to my decision I have set out my view on the objection in dealing with the relevant issue. It is unnecessary to deal with each small objection where it relates to evidence which has had no bearing on my decision. I thank the parties for the lengthy Statement of Agreed Facts, their chronologies and for the care and quality of their detailed written submissions. I have been greatly assisted by them and have drawn directly on them at various points. Sometimes I will directly record my view of a particular aspect of evidence. On other occasions, given the great volume of evidence, I have taken the more convenient path of simply setting out the facts as I see them. In doing so I set out my view of the evidence.The parties Telstra and Sensis are together the applicants in this proceeding. Their identities have already been detailed above at [1]. PDC, the first respondent, was incorporated in April 1993 and carried on the business of publishing and distributing telephone directories. It began marketing and selling advertising space for print directories in 1993 and in 1994 commenced publishing and distributing its print directories under the name “PDC Directories” and “PDC” in some cities and regions in Queensland and the Northern Territory, and expanded from there. In 2001 it launched its website. In June 2005 PDC commenced publishing its directories in Queensland and the Northern Territory under the name “Local Directories”, and it changed the domain name of its website accordingly. Until mid-2008 PDC continued to produce and distribute the impugned directories in cities and regions in Queensland and the Northern Territory. From that date LD assumed these operations.

Decision

Reasons for decision

I do not accept this. Without properly performing the surveys to take account of the identified deficiencies it is impossible to know what the survey result would have been. Further, even using the figures presented, this submissions does not withstand scrutiny. The survey results were presented as regional averages not as city specific figures. I accept the cross-claimants’ contention that in the example cited, the 1% figure for Rockhampton would have risen to about 9.3% if averaged across the Rockhampton, Mackay and Whitsundays region. Conclusion I am satisfied that Telstra engaged in misleading or deceptive conduct or conduct that was likely to mislead or deceive in breach of s 52 of the TPA. The issues of liability and damages have been separated. I will direct the parties to confer and propose a timetable for that hearing, including an order for mediation. M. the Unjustifiable threats of copyright infringement cross-claim PDC, ALD and LD (“the cross-claimants”) seek declaratory relief and damages for unjustifiable threats pursuant to s 202 of the Copyright Act.The Facts It is uncontentious that Telstra threatened breach of copyright proceedings against the cross‑claimants in a letter of demand of 10 July 2006 sent to the cross-claimants and their solicitors. The letter relevantly stated:As you are no doubt aware, Telstra has copyright in the Yellow Pages and White Pages directories (“Telstra’s Directories”) and the headings books used to generate the headings used in Telstra’s directories (“the Headings”). This was confirmed by the Full Federal Court in Desktop Marketing Systems Pty Ltd v Telstra Corporations [sic] Ltd (2002) 55 IPR 1. Therefore, it is a breach of Telstra’s copyright for PDC/ALD to reproduce a substantial part of Telstra’s directories or the Headings.Telstra also pointed to Telecom Corporation of New Zealand Ltd & Anor v Colour Pages Limited & Anor (High Court of New Zealand, unreported, 14 August 1997) in which McGechan J found that copyright subsisted in telephone directories. It is uncontentious too that Telstra subsequently brought a claim of copyright infringement against the cross-claimants, and that claim was unsuccessful before the Federal Court and the Full Court. The High Court refused special leave: see Telstra Corporation Limited v Phone Directories Company Pty Ltd [2010] FCA 44 (“Telstra Copyright Trial”); Telstra Corporation Limited v Phone Directories Company Pty Ltd [2010] FCAFC 149 (“Telstra Copyright Appeal”); and Telstra Corporation Limited & Anor v Phone Directories Company Pty Ltd & Ors [2011] HCATrans 248 (2 September 2011) (“Telstra Copyright Special Leave Application”). Legislative framework and relevant principles Section 202 of the Copyright Act relevantly provides:202Groundless threats of legal proceedings in relation to copyright infringement(1)Where a person, by means of circulars, advertisements or otherwise, threatens a person with an action or proceeding in respect of an infringement of copyright, then, whether the person making the threats is or is not the owner of the copyright or an exclusive licensee, a person aggrieved may bring an action against the first‑mentioned person and may obtain a declaration to the effect that the threats are unjustifiable, and an injunction against the continuance of the threats, and may recover such damages (if any) as he or she has sustained, unless the first‑mentioned person satisfies the court that the acts in respect of which the action or proceeding was threatened constituted, or, if done, would constitute, an infringement of copyright.(2)The mere notification of the existence of a copyright does not constitute a threat of an action or proceeding within the meaning of this section.…

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Apart from the fact that the Advertisements were published in less geographical regions than the representations in the primary claim, the class of directory advertisers in the cross-claim has the same characteristics as that class in the primary claim. Not all members of the class are likely to respond to the Advertisements in the same way. The class will include a broad range of business people of differing shrewdness, education, commercial experience, information, age and vocations. The evidence shows that most are small business people, and although not sophisticated they are unlikely to be lacking in discernment. Consideration The cross-claimants allege that the Advertisements conveyed four related representations which I deal with below.The consumers surveyed had access to the cross-claimants’ directories Firstly, the cross-claimants allege that the Advertisements conveyed the representation that the consumers surveyed had available to them the cross claimants’ directories as an alternative reference to Telstra’s directories for information about suppliers of goods or services (“the First Representation”). Telstra denies this and contends that:(a)the Advertisements made no representation as to the individual circumstances of the consumers surveyed; and(b)the representations were about the “use” rather than the “availability” of the directories. I do not agree. I consider that the Advertisements conveyed the First Representation. The hypothetical ordinary or reasonable advertiser would have understood from the Advertisements that the consumers surveyed had an opportunity to access the directories or information sources (“the directories”) about which they were being surveyed, and that the survey results reported were based on the participants’ knowledge of those directories. The Advertisements said that they were the product of “independent research” which would form or strengthen the expectation of an ordinary or reasonable advertiser that the surveys were conducted fairly and reliably. Of course, the reader would understand that individual survey participants may not have actually owned or used the full range of the directories covered in the survey. But the Advertisements would have caused an ordinary or reasonable advertiser to understand that the directories were at least available to them. The First Representation was misleading or deceptive or likely to mislead or deceive because the evidence shows that many of the survey participants were from areas where the cross-claimants’ directories were never published. The surveys covered different geographical areas to the areas in which the cross-claimants published their directories. They provided evidence of numerous examples of this, and it is unnecessary to detail them. In essence, the evidence is that the cross-claimants’ directories were only published in four of the 14 regions covered by the 2003 survey, two of the 13 regions covered by the 2004 survey and three of the eight regions covered by the 2006 survey. That is, they were not published in the majority of the geographical areas from which the survey participants were drawn.