Sydney Cellulose Pty Ltd v Ceil Comfort Home Insulation Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 57 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Sydney Cellulose Pty Ltd v Ceil Comfort Home Insulation Pty Ltd
[2001] FCA 1350

PATENTS – proceedings to restrain threats of infringement proceedings made by holder of Australian patent – holder of patent and alleged infringer being business competitors – alleged infringer commenced proceedings to enjoin further threats of infringement proceedings by holder of patent – onus of proof of infringement cast by statute upon holder of patent making such threats – holder of patent failed to invoke facility of O 17 r 1 – holder of patent making threats relied essentially upon dictionary meanings of words used in patent and of alleged infringer’s terminologies for purpose of establishing infringement – principles governing interpretation of patent – doctrine of “pith and marrow” – applicants’ process possessed variants which had a material effect upon way invention works – no infringement established – injunction granted against holder of patent making threats.

TRADE PRACTICES – misleading statements made to consumers of goods or services by trade competitor.

WORDS AND PRASES – ‘unjustifiable threats’ – ‘person aggrieved’.

Patents Act 1990 (Cth) ss 40, 128, 129
Patents Act 1952 (Cth) s 40
Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) ss 52, 53(g)
Federal Court Rules O 17 r 1

Catnic Components Ltd v Hill & Smith Ltd [1982] RPC 183 followed
Clark v Adie (1875) LR 10 Ch App 667 followed
Décor Corporation Pty Ltd v Dart Industries Inc (1989) 13 IPR 385 followed
Hornsby Building Information Centre Pty Ltd v Sydney Building Information Centre Ltd
(1978) 140 CLR 216 referred to
Improva Corp v Remington Consumer Products Ltd [1990] FSR 181 followed
Interlego AG v Toltoys Pty Ltd (1973) 130 CLR 461 referred to
Kastner v Rizla Ltd [1995] RPC 585 referred to
Mechanical Services (Trailer Engineers) Ltd v Avon Rubber Co Ltd [1977] RPC 66 followed
Meth v Norbent Steinhardt & Son Ltd (1962) 107 CLR 187 followed
Minnesota Mining & Manufacturing Co v Beiersdorf (Australia) Ltd (1980) 144 CLR 253 followed
Nesbit Evans Group Australia Pty Ltd v Impro Ltd (1998) 39 IPR 56 referred to
Olin Corporation v Super Cartridge Co Pty Ltd (1977) 180 CLR 236 referred to
Populin v H B Nominees Pty Ltd (1982) 41 ALR 471 referred to
Radiation Ltd v Galliers & Klaerr Pty Ltd (1938) 60 CLR 36 followed
Rhone-Poulenc Agrochimie SA v UIM Chemical ServicesPty Ltd (1985) 10 FCR 567 followed
Rodi & Wienenberger AG v Henry Showell Ltd [1969] RPC 367 followed
Skinner & Co v Perry (1893) 10 RPC 1 referred to
Sunbeam Corporation v Morphy-Richards (Aust) Pty Ltd (1961) 180 CLR 98 referred to
U & I Global Trading (Australia) Pty Ltd v Tasman-Warajay Pty Ltd (1995) 32 IPR 494 followed

Halsbury’s Laws of England (4th ed) vol 35 p 375
Lahore, Patents, Trade Marks and Related Rights pp 18,140-18,161

SYDNEY CELLULOSE PTY LIMITED v CEIL COMFORT HOME INSULATION PTY LIMITED

N 513 OF 2000

CONTI J
20 SEPTEMBER 2001
SYDNEY


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Sydney Cellulose Pty Ltd v Ceil Comfort Home Insulation Pty... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2001] FCA 1350
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Sydney Cellulose Pty Ltd v Ceil Comfort Home Insulation Pty Ltd, the applicants sought relief from the court due to threats of patent infringement proceedings made by the respondents. The applicants, Sydney Cellulose and Aussie Fluff, were involved in the installation of cellulose insulation material in buildings, using a cellulose fire retardant spray (CFRS). The respondents, Ceil Comfort Home Insulation Pty Ltd and its directors, claimed that the applicants' use of CFRS infringed upon their patent, Australian Patent No 526490. The applicants sought relief under sections 128 and 129 of the Patents Act 1990 (Cth), as well as relief in respect of alleged contraventions of sections 52 and 53(g) of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth). The court was required to decide whether the applicants' use of CFRS constituted an infringement of the respondents' patent and whether the threats made by the respondents were justified.

The court examined the language of the patent claim and specification, as well as the principles enunciated by Lord Diplock in Catnic and Hoffman J in Improva Corp v Remington Consumer Products Ltd. The court considered whether the applicants' process of using CFRS fell within the language of the patent claim and specification, and whether the respondents' interpretation of the term "adhesive" was correct. The court concluded that the applicants' use of CFRS did not infringe upon the respondents' patent, as the application of CFRS did not involve the steps of applying a coating of liquid glue or adhesive to the surface of the insulating material and allowing it to dry or set, as required by the patent. The court found that the respondents' threats of patent infringement proceedings were unjustified, and granted the applicants relief under sections 128 and 129 of the Patents Act 1990 (Cth), as well as relief in respect of the alleged contraventions of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth).

In conclusion, the court restrained the respondents and each of them from continuing to threaten the applicants with proceedings for infringement of Australian Patent No 526490, and from making representations to any person or entity that the applicants' use of CFRS constituted infringement of the patent. The court also ordered the respondents to pay the applicants' costs of the proceedings and stood the proceedings over for directions as to the hearing of the applicants' claims for damages.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The Respondents and each of them be restrained pursuant to s 128(1)(b) of the Patents Act 1990 (Cth) from continuing to threaten the Applicants, or either of them, with proceedings for infringement of Australian Patent No 526490 relating to the application by the Applicants or either of them of their cellulose fire retardant spray (CFRS) in connection with the process of installation by the Applicants or either of them of cellulose insulation material in buildings.

2. The Respondents and each of them be restrained pursuant to s 80 of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) from making representations to any person or entity, including Brombal & O’Brien Builders Pty Limited and the New South Wales Department of Housing, to the effect that the application by the Applicants or either of them of their cellulose fire retardant spray (CFRS) in connection with the process of installation by the Applicants or either of them of cellulose insulation material in buildings, constitutes infringement of Australian Patent No 526490.

3. Orders 1 and 2 to continue until further order.

4. The parties or any one or more of them to have liberty to apply, including any application as to the terms of the foregoing injunctions.

5. The Respondents pay the Applicants’ costs of the proceedings, other than in relation to such matters for which orders for costs have already been made in the proceedings.

6. The proceedings be stood over for directions as to the hearing of the Applicants’ claims for damages.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

CONTI J
The principles enunciated by Lord Diplock in Catnic above have been the subject of further analysis by Hoffman J (as he then was) in Improva Corp v Remington Consumer Products Ltd [1990] FSR 181 at 189:“If the issue was whether a feature embodied in an alleged infringement which fell outside the primary, literal or a contextual meaning of a descriptive word or phrase in the claim (‘a variant’) was nevertheless within its language as properly interpreted, the Court should ask itself the following three questions:(i)Does the variant have a material effect upon the way the invention works? If yes, the variant is outside the claim. If no –(ii)Would this (ie that the variant had no material effect) have been obvious at the date of the publication of the patent to a reader skilled in the art. If no, the variant is outside the claim. If yes –(iii)Would the reader skilled in the art nevertheless have understood from the language of the claim that the patentee intended that strict compliance where the primary meaning was an essential requirement of the invention [?] If yes, the variant is outside the claim.”This purposive approach to construction enunciated by Lord Diplock in Catnic, and the above restatement of his Lordship’s observations in Improva, have been more recently followed by the English Court of Appeal in Kastner v Rizla Ltd [1995] RPC 585, and by the Full Federal Court in Nesbit Evans Group Australia Pty Ltd v Impro Ltd (1998) 39 IPR 56 at 81-2 per Lindgren J (with whom Hill J agreed). The respective contentions of the parties and my conclusions in relation thereto It is mutually accepted between the Applicants and Respondents that the essential integers of the claim and specification of Patent No 526490 comprise the following:(i)insulating the ceiling of a building having ceiling lining, comprising the steps of :(ii)placing loose fill insulating material directly above the ceiling lining material to a desired thickness;(iii)applying a coating of liquid glue or adhesive to the surface of the insulating material remote from the lining material; and(iv)allowing the glue or adhesive to dry or set forming a cohesive skin on the surface of the insulating material. It follows that the Applicants’ process of using and applying its CFRS product must be such that it takes each of such four integers (see the authorities cited in [38] above). It is common ground that the Applicants’ said process takes the first and second integers. The essential issue remaining therefore is whether the Applicants’ process takes the third and fourth of such integers. As to the third integer described in [44] above, the Respondents have contended that the Applicants’ description of the method of spraying its CFRS to the surface of cellulose insulation fibre in the ceiling of buildings represents a mere colourable evasion of the language of Patent No 526490 by companies skilled in the art of cellulose fibre. The components of the CFRS, comprising mono-ammonium phosphate and water as earlier explained in [18] above, are said by the Respondents to constitute an “adhesive” within the meaning of that word appearing in both the claim and specification segments of the Patent, as extracted wholly in [10] and partly in [13] above respectively. Although the claim refers to “liquid glue or adhesive”, the Respondents contended that the words “glue or adhesive” should not be read synonymously, and that the word “adhesive” provides the patent with a broader scope of operation, such as to include liquids which, when applied to the insulation material, would cause both substances to join together. The Respondents accept that the Applicants’ CFRS product is not a glue. Consequently, so the Respondents’ submission continues, the Applicants’ method of spraying its CFRS product onto the insulation material, thereby causing the surface of the insulation material to “dry or set”, to further adopt the language of the Patent specification, constitutes an infringement of the Patent, given that the application by the Applicants of their CFRS product is also made “to the surface of the insulating material remote from (ceiling) lining material”, as stipulated by the Patent.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: CONTI J

The Applicants (individually referred to as “Sydney Cellulose” and “Aussie Fluff” respectively) have sought relief from the Court pursuant to s 128(1) of the Patents Act 1990 (Cth) (“the Act”) in respect of threats made by or on behalf of the Respondents to bring certain patent infringement proceedings against the Applicants, and also against Brombal & O’Brien Builders Pty Limited (“Brombal & O’Brien”), a building operator unrelated to the Applicants and for whom the Applicants have been undertaking installation work. The full text of ss 128 and 129 of the Act reads as follows:“128 Application for relief from unjustified threats(1)Where a person, by means of circulars, advertisements or otherwise, threatens a person with infringement proceedings, or other similar proceedings, a person aggrieved may apply to a prescribed court, or to another court having jurisdiction to hear and determine the application, for:(a)a declaration that the threats are unjustifiable; and(b)an injunction against the continuance of the threats; and(c)the recovery of any damages sustained by the applicant as a result of the threats.(2)Subsection (1) applies whether or not the person who made the threats is entitled to, or interested in, the patent or a patent application.129 Court’s power to grant reliefThe court may grant an applicant under section 128 the relief applied for unless the respondent satisfies the court that the acts about which the threats were made infringed, or would infringe:(a)a claim that is not shown by the applicant to be invalid; or(b)rights under section 57 in respect of a claim that is not shown by the applicant to be a claim that would be invalid if a patent had been granted.”Each of the Applicants are in my opinion “a person aggrieved” within s 128(1) of the Act, notwithstanding that the letter of demand extracted in [29] below was addressed only to the First Applicant (see Meth v Norbert Steinhardt and Son Ltd (1962) 107 CLR 187 at 200), and the Respondents did not contend to the contrary. The Applicants also seek relief in respect of conduct of the Respondents, arising out of the same circumstances, in contravention of ss 52 and 53(g) of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth). The relief which I am presently required to consider is confined to that of declarations and injunctions.The First Respondent’s business operations and its acquisition of patent rights The First Respondent Ceil Comfort Home Insulation Pty Limited (“Ceil Comfort”) is a company incorporated and operating at least partly in the State of New South Wales. The remaining Respondents are directors of Ceil Comfort. Ceil Comfort forms part of a consolidated group of companies which carry on business under the trade name of “Cool or Cosy Home Insulation”, or “Cool and Cosy”. Ceil Comfort and its related companies are involved in manufacturing, marketing, and installing cellulose fibre insulation material for buildings, being mainly residential premises. The Ceil Comfort group of companies employs some four hundred employees and subcontractors in activities conducted throughout Australia, and claims to have insulated about twenty to twenty-five thousand homes in Australia. The Cool and Cosy group of companies claim to be the largest cellulose fibre manufacturer in Australia.