Bed Bath ‘N' Table Pty Ltd v Global Retail Brands Australia Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 82 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Bed Bath ‘N’ Table Pty Ltd v Global Retail Brands Australia Pty Ltd [2023] FCA 1587   

File number: VID 314 of 2021
Judgment of: ROFE J
Date of judgment: 14 December 2023
Catchwords:

TRADE MARKS — infringement — whether the respondent’s use of the “House BED & BATH” mark infringed the applicant’s registered trade marks comprising the words “BED BATH N’ TABLE” — whether the applicant has an independent reputation in the words “BED BATH” — whether the words “bed” and “bath” are purely descriptive — relevance of alleged confusion evidence — infringement not established.

TRADE MARKS — infringement — defences to infringement — whether the respondent can establish the defence under s 122(1)(b)(i) of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) — in the event of infringement being established, the respondent has not made out the defence.

TRADE PRACTICES — misleading or deceptive conduct — alleged breaches of s 18 and s 29(1)(a), (g) and (h) of the Australian Consumer Law — well-established reputation of the applicant — wilful blindness of the respondent as to whether store name likely to mislead or deceive consumers — elements of claims established — passing off — reputation — elements of claims established.

Legislation:

Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth)

Evidence Act 1995 (Cth)

Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth)

Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth)

Fair Trading Act 1986 (NZ)

Cases cited:

A Nelson & Co Ltd v Martin & PleasancePty Ltd (2021) 157 IPR 376

Adidas AG v Pacific Brands Footwear Pty Ltd (No 3) (2013) 103 IPR 521

Allergan Australia Pty Ltd v Self Care IP Holdings Pty Ltd (2021) 162 IPR 52

Anheuser-Busch Inc v Budejovicky Budvar (2002) 56 IPR 182

Apple Inc v Registrar of Trade Marks (2014) 109 IPR 187

Australian Meat Group Pty Ltd v JBS Australia Pty Ltd (2018) 137 IPR 385

Australian Postal Corp v Digital Post Australia Pty Ltd (2013) 105 IPR 1

Australian Woollen Mills Ltd v FS Walton & Co Ltd (1937) 58 CLR 641

Bohemia Crystal Pty Ltd v Host Corp Pty Ltd (2018) 129 IPR 482

Brands Ltd v Bed Bath ‘N’ Table Pty Ltd (2023) 174 IPR 261

Brick Lane Brewing Co Pty Ltd v Torquay Beverage Co Pty Ltd (2023) 170 IPR 195

CA Henscke & Co v Rosemount Estates Pty Ltd (2000) 52 IPR 42

Cadbury Schweppes Pty Ltd v Darrell Lea Chocolate Shops Pty Ltd (2007) 72 IPR 261

Campaign Master (UK) Ltd v Forty Two International Pty Ltd (No 3) (2009) 181 FCR 152

Cantarella Bros Pty Ltd v Lavazza Australia Pty Ltd (No 3) [2023] FCA 1258

Cat Media Pty Ltd v Opti-Healthcare Pty Ltd [2003] FCA 133

Caterpillar Inc v Puma SE (2021) 162 IPR 430

Champagne Heidsieck et Cie Monopole Societe Anonyme v Buxton [1930] 1 Ch 330

Chocolaterie Guylian NV v Registrar of Trade Marks (2009) 82 IPR 13

ConAgra Inc v McCain Foods (Aust) Pty Ltd (1992) 23 IPR 193

Conde Nast Publications Pty Ltd v Taylor

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bed Bath ‘N' Table Pty Ltd v Global Retail Brands Australia... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] FCA 1587
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Bed Bath ‘N' Table Pty Ltd (BBNT) commenced proceedings against Global Retail Brands Australia Pty Ltd (GRBA) in the Federal Court of Australia, seeking relief for alleged trade mark infringement, misleading and deceptive conduct, and passing off. BBNT, a dominant player in the Australian speciality soft homewares market, claimed that GRBA's use of the "House BED & BATH" mark for its new soft homewares stores infringed BBNT's registered trade marks "BED BATH N’ TABLE" and constituted misleading and deceptive conduct and passing off. The court was required to determine whether GRBA's use of the "House BED & BATH" mark constituted trade mark infringement and whether GRBA engaged in misleading and deceptive conduct and passing off. The court found that the words "bed" and "bath" in both marks were not purely descriptive but rather allusive, and GRBA's adoption of the "House BED & BATH" mark was not similar enough to BBNT's marks to constitute infringement. The court also found that GRBA engaged in misleading and deceptive conduct by being wilfully blind to the prospect of consumer confusion and passing off by borrowing BBNT's brand elements to attract BBNT's customers. The court ordered that if the parties could not agree on the appropriate orders, they were to file and serve proposed orders and outlines of submissions by a specified date, with a hearing set if necessary.

The final orders of the court will depend on the outcome of negotiations between the parties regarding the appropriate relief and costs. If the parties reach an agreement, they are to file a minute of the proposed orders by the specified date. If they cannot agree, they must file and serve their proposed orders and outlines of submissions by the specified date, with a hearing set for the following week. The specific details of the relief and costs will be determined during these negotiations or at the hearing, if necessary.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. If the parties agree on the appropriate orders to be made by the Court reflecting these reasons for judgment, including as to relief and costs, the parties file a minute of proposed orders by 4.00 pm on 9 February 2024.

2. If the parties are unable to agree on the orders which should be made, each of the parties file and serve by 4.00 pm on 9 February 2024:

(a) A minute of the orders that the party proposes; and

(b) Any outline of submissions in support of the proposed orders (not exceeding five pages in length).

3. In the event the parties are unable to agree on the orders which should be made, the matter be listed for hearing at 10.15 am on 15 February 2024.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

The experts prepared a joint expert report and gave evidence in person by way of a concurrent evidence session.3. CORE FACTS3.1 Soft homewares The term “soft homewares” encompasses textile goods, such as bedding and bed linen (for example, sheet sets, pillowcases and quilt covers), bathroom products (bath linen, such as towels, and bathroom accessories, such as soap dishes and shower caddies), household linen (for example, table cloths, table runners, napkins, teas towels and place mats), kitchenware (for example, cutlery, plates and bowls, serving ware and glasses, cups and mugs) and other homewares (for example, cushions, throws, vases and candles). The parties adopted the term “soft homewares” to refer to bedroom and bathroom products as described above, to be contrasted with “hard homewares” such as pots, pans, plates, knives and cutlery. I have adopted that definition in these reasons. 3.2 Bed Bath N’ Table BBNT has continuously traded in Australia under, and in respect of, the trade mark comprising the words “BED BATH N’ TABLE” since 1976. The BBNT business operates throughout Australia and retails soft homewares in both physical stores and online. It has retailed a vast range of soft homewares products, including textile goods, such as bedding and bed linen, bathroom products, household linen, kitchenware, and other homewares. BBNT does not sell beds, baths or tables. BBNT has approximately 30% of the Australian market share of the speciality homewares and allied products market based on store numbers. Mr Dempsey considered that BBNT’s main specialty competitors (that is, businesses that specialise in bed linen, bathroom products and household linen) were Adairs, MyHouse, Pillow Talk, Linen House and Sheridan. Other notable competitors selling bed linen and bathroom products are Myer, Kmart, Target, Domayne, Canningvale (online only), Spotlight, Westelm, Pottery Barn, Big W, Best & Less, Freedom, Temple & Webster (online only), Harris Scarfe and David Jones. As at December 2021, Adairs operated about 159 physical stores, and Sheridan operated around 57. BBNT operated 167 physical stores at that time. Mr Dempsey stated in his first affidavit that “Adairs is our closest competitor, in my opinion, both in terms of market share and look and feel”. Confidential sales data showed that as at 2021, BBNT had annual sales in the hundreds of millions of Australian dollars. BBNT is evidently a significant business and occupies a dominant position in the speciality soft homewares sector. On the basis of BBNT loyalty and customer information, Mr Dempsey’s evidence was that the main BBNT customer demographic is predominantly female and in the 25–65 age bracket. BBNT’s branding is carefully managed through regimented “brand guidelines” and has consistently, since at least the mid-1990s, been presented in block capital letters on a plain background, as shown below: Store signage typically appears with illuminated white letters, with green on the inside of the letters and no background, and also in frosted white writing on the front glass of the store.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

On 13 October 2021, GRBA was advised by IP Australia that its trade mark application for House B&B was accepted. Mr Lew agreed that he knew that acceptance of a trade mark did not equate to registration of the mark.4.1 Mr Lew’s evidence Mr Lew has extensive business experience, including in retailing hard homewares. He publicly promotes himself as the founder and executive chairman of GRBA, Australia’s number one largest specialty kitchen retailer. The businesses under Mr Lew’s control have very significant annual revenue. Mr Lew gave evidence that “brand” is very important to his business and in the home furnishing sector. The second point is that Flick J was not dealing with a situation where the infringer’s conduct constituted wilful blindness. Ultimately, even if I accept that Mr Lew and Ms McGann genuinely held the subjective belief that there was no similarity between the House B&B mark and the BBNT marks, and therefore no confusion would arise from the adoption of the House B&B mark, that is not sufficient to establish good faith for the purposes of s 122(1)(b). As Beach J observed at [118] in Flexopack: If good faith were to be construed as merely being satisfied on the basis of a stated subjective belief that one did not know of the other, it could lead to a situation where one could justify trade mark use with one’s ignorance. The failure to make proper inquiries should not place a respondent in a better position than if such inquiries had been made. As such, GRBA’s conduct in adopting the mark, discussed above at [234]–[241], does not constitute what I consider in the circumstances of this case to be proper enquiries or reasonable diligence to ascertain that its chosen name did not conflict with a registered trade mark: see Flexopack at [110] (per Beach J). Therefore, GRBA did not act in good faith in adopting the House B&B mark and, if I am wrong on infringement, GRBA cannot rely upon the defence in s 122(1)(b). Finally, GRBA’s actions after receiving BBNT’s letter of demand on 25 May 2021, and thereby being formally put on notice of BBNT rights, are inconsistent with a party acting in good faith. GRBA contends that BBNT is wrong to allege that the conduct of GRBA cannot cease to be use in good faith upon being put on notice of BBNT’s allegations. GRBA relies on the Full Court’s finding in Digital Post at [52], [56], [90] and [93] (per North, Middleton and Barker JJ) that the respondent was acting in good faith pursuant to s 122(1)(a) of the Act even though it was aware of potential confusion and the applicant’s reputation in the registered mark. However, as their Honours stated in Digital Post at [94] “[t]his is not a situation like Anheuser-Busch where there was wilful blindness to the potential for confusion”. This comment suggests that their Honours considered that good faith could not be established where wilful blindness is established. That recognition makes it easy to reconcile the approach in Digital Post with Beach J’s far stricter approach in Flexopack. Although not described as such, Beach J in Flexopack was clearly dealing with a situation of wilful blindness as evinced by his Honour’s comment at [150] that any ignorance of the applicant’s trade mark was “only due to [the respondent’s] own indifference and his failure to make the inquiries that an honest and reasonable person would have made in his position”. This characterisation of Flexopack also disposes of GRBA’s reliance on Halal Certification Authority Pty Ltd v Flujo Sanguineo Holdings Pty Ltd (2021) 163 IPR 433 at [52], [67], [123], [132], [135] and [141]–[142] (per Bromwich J). In Halal Certification, Bromwich J described the infringer’s conduct as “honest” and “no more than an oversight” (at [67] and [141]) which clearly takes their conduct outside the realm of wilful blindness. These findings were not challenged on appeal in Halal Certification Authority Pty Ltd v Flujo Sanguineo Holdings Pty Ltd [2023] FCAFC 175 at [112]­­­–[117] (per Nicholas, Burley and Cheeseman JJ).

Decision

Reasons for decision

Following the conclusion of the hearing, I made orders permitting the parties to provide short supplementary submissions on the relevance of Brands Ltd v Bed Bath ‘N’ Table Pty Ltd (2023) 174 IPR 261. This recent decision of the New Zealand High Court concerned an application by Brands Ltd, who trades as BED BATH & BEYOND, which alleged that BBNT had engaged in trade mark infringement, passing off and breach of the Fair Trading Act 1986 (NZ) by its use of BED BATH ‘N TABLE. I do not consider that this case is relevant to the current matter because, among other things, it concerned different facts, evidence, and statutory contexts. As such, it is unnecessary to further address the case or those submissions of the parties.11. CONCLUSION BBNT was ultimately only partially successful. For the reasons given above, I am not satisfied that GRBA engaged in trade mark infringement. However, a different conclusion follows with respect to misleading and deceptive conduct and passing off. It is the reputation of BBNT, which could not be considered in assessing trade mark infringement, that is crucial in leading to a conclusion that GRBA engaged in misleading and deceptive conduct in circumstances where the House B&B mark was not found to be deceptively similar to the BBNT mark. Further, although GRBA may have not set out with an intention to deceive or confuse consumers, it was wilfully blind as to the prospect of confusion arising from the adoption of a name that appropriated two words from one of its largest competitors. GRBA was simply unable to undermine the obvious inference that was open that GRBA borrowed the words “bed” and “bath” from BBNT’s name in order to attract customers from BBNT, and that such borrowing was “fitted for [that] purpose and therefore likely to deceive or confuse” consumers: Australian Woollen Mills at 657 (per Dixon and McTiernan JJ); Sydneywide at [117] (per Weinberg and Dowsett JJ). BBNT sought to be heard separately on the issue of relief. Accordingly, I will make orders for the provision of a further hearing on relief if the parties cannot agree on orders to reflect these reasons. The issue of costs of the proceeding should also be dealt with at that stage if no agreement can be reached. 12. FINAL NOTE Before I finish, I note that we lost three much loved fathers/fathers-in-law/grandfathers during the trial. I again extend my condolences to the lawyers and appreciate the resilience of the legal teams that enabled the evidentiary part of the trial to continue and be completed in December 2022. It was for this reason that closing submissions were adjourned until late March 2023.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

As I observed above, I consider the words “bed” and “bath” in both marks in this case to be more allusive than purely descriptive. Neither mark is directly or “eloquently” descriptive in the manner of the corporate names in Hornsby or any of the other cases relied upon by GRBA.8.5 Consideration8.5.1The conduct The relevant conduct is GRBA’s use of House B&B as the name of its new soft homewares stores, first launched at Doncaster shopping centre on 14 May 2021, including the use of the House B&B mark on the external signage over the entrance to its store and the use of the House B&B mark on the House website. According to BBNT, at the time of the hearing, there were at least 17 House B&B stores displaying signage which improperly indicates a connection with BBNT. BBNT also contends that GRBA wrongfully used the House B&B name on its website, store receipts, social media, shopping centre directories, advertising and promotional materials including store opening flyers, gift cards and employee name badges. 8.5.2Trade and commerce GRBA’s use of House B&B as the name of its new soft homewares store and its use of the House B&B mark on external shop signage on its retail stores, and all of the other relevant conduct out set out above, is clearly use of the House B&B mark in trade and commerce.8.5.3Whether conduct misleading or deceptive or likely to mislead or deceive On 14 May 2021, a new soft homewares store opened in the homewares precinct of Doncaster shopping centre, up one floor from the existing BBNT store and across from Adairs. Externally, it was much like other soft homewares stores: the store had large glass windows through which made up beds could be seen. Across the entrance to the store was the House B&B sign: The question to determine is what meaning does GRBA’s use of the House B&B mark on a shopfront at the launch of the House B&B store in Doncaster on 14 May 2021, assessed in all the context (both broad and immediate), convey to the reasonable consumer as I have described them above? The relevant broader context in which the conduct is to be judged includes the following (as at May 2021):(a)BBNT had acquired an extensive reputation in the BBNT marks in Australia which had been accumulated over 40 years of use in the soft homewares market.(b)The BBNT mark, despite containing ordinary English words, had become factually distinctive of BBNT as a result of over 40 years of use in Australia.(c)BBNT had around 167 stores in Australia.(d)The BBNT stores commonly had large front windows through which could be seen one or two made up beds in “Hamptons style” and frosted glass window decals with the BBNT mark. This style was similar to stores of other soft homewares retailers such as Adairs.(e)Soft homewares retailers are often co-located in close proximity in shopping centres.(f)GRBA had, over 40 years, acquired an extensive reputation in the brand House and its hard homewares stores in Australia.(g)House stores had a particular “discount” look, unlike the style of the soft homewares retailers (described above) and sold kitchenware products.(h)GRBA had around 140 House stores in Australia.(i)No retailers in Australia other than BBNT used the words “bed” and “bath” in their store name or external signage. BBNT therefore has had over 40 years of “unique” use.(j)Soft homewares retailers use “bed” and “bath” as category descriptors inside their retail stores (as opposed to on external signage), particularly department stores.(k)Soft homewares products range in price from a few dollars (face washer or coaster) to a few hundred dollars (quilt covers).